Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | 4bpp's commentslogin

Well, if they like you, at least:

> 1984 ehf. reserves the full and unconditional right to decide whether to terminate services to the Subscriber, with or without notice, if 1984 ehf. considers the materials stored by the Subscriber to be illegal, unethical or harmful.

> In house we refer to this as the Nazi provision, because even if we are a freedom of speech host, we will not have the fruits of our labor used to spread racism, anti Semitism, instigation of violence or hatred.

This is a broad enough cutout that it could be used for just about anything - in modern discourse, people routinely describe any political stance they disagree with as "harmful" even if it is something as pedestrian as zoning regulations. If some company or individual sues to have my website taken down, prima facie they must have concluded that it is harmful to their interests - how do I reckon whether this hoster will concur?

I miss the era of actual principled free speech advocacy (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Socialist_Party_of_Am...), as opposed to what appears to be plain old political activists cynically wearing the name. Even the CCP wants speech that it agrees with to be free.


I agree with most of your criticisms. But I guess it's economically not worth it to cater to people who might get in trouble in some way. Worst customer group.

So, whoever does it is doing it out of some personal belief and not for the money. So it's going to be some kind of activists anyway. Might as well be these activists. I prefer it this way for things that matter the most to me. Real people with names and opinions instead of big corporations.

Although I most likely don't agree with most of their opinions, I know what their line is. It's a human approach vs corporations / lawyers / ToS.


That's the thing with "free speech". Freedom of speech does not mean freedom of consequences.

Free speech protects you from the government handing you consequences for saying things (and even that has limits, try yelling "fire" in a theater or "bomb" in an airport). But it does not require any private citizen or company to do business with you (well, almost - stuff like regulated public utilities usually are exempted).

And in addition, companies are not living in a vacuum by themselves as the far-right edgelords always try to claim. Companies, even individual people, are all part of society - and stuff that falls under the "Nazi policy" is generally considered to be like a cancer for societal cohesion.


> Freedom of speech does not mean freedom of consequences. Free speech protects you from the government handing you consequences...

If the consequence we are talking about is blocked speech, that is exactly what free speech means. Here it is the host advertising themselves as a free speech platform, that's an empty guarantee if all it refers to is actions taken by a government.

Clearly they want to allow some legal expression and not others. That's fine, but it is not free speech. The basic test is allowing speech that you do not support.


You can diminish any principle you don't like in this fashion. Maybe when I'm feeling particularly cupidous, I can say something like "The right to property protects you from the government taking away your things. It does not require any private citizen or company to not extend their sticky fingers into your pocket when you are not looking".

In my opinion, for free speech to be a meaningful principle at all, it has to be an obligation upon everyone to believe that if someone has something to say and someone else wants to listen, you as a third party ought to not interfere to prevent them from doing so. Regardless, this "free speech host" is actually not even promising free speech in the narrow sense of protection from the government only - after all, they prominently declare their intent to take down illegal (i.e. unwanted by the government) content!

(Yes, I'm aware some people want to draw a distinction between "the government does a thing" and "the government publishes a text saying it will do a thing, and then does the thing". I find this distinction bizarre, especially since if the latter is not considered a violation of your definition of free speech, then almost every sufficiently bureaucratic autocracy is a free speech country.)


> stuff like regulated public utilities usually are exempted

As a matter of fact, domain registrars, like ISPs, are exempted from certain liabilities because they are neutral technical intermediaries. They're not on the hook if someone publishes illegal content through one of the domains they maintain.

Charitably, one might read such a clause as the refusal to host sites like stormfront. However, these might be the same type of people that consider Elon Musk an bona fide Nazi and X a Nazi propaganda site, and then you run the risk that your entire site gets shut out because some persona-non-grata posted a "Hello World" on it and you didn't ban them outright.

I don't know which it is, therefore I'm extra careful with anything that smells of activism.


"There is freedom of speech, but I cannot guarantee freedom after speech." - Idi Amin

Of course, this argument was not very popular here on the post about Meta blocking that protest page...

Obviously not, that argument is and always has been a mantra rather than anything serious.

For what it's worth, I think Meta and the other large "social" networks should be placed under much, much more scrutiny. For many people they have become something similar in importance to utilities, often outright replacing them (i.e. phone calls), and yet, platforms routinely fail to uphold existing laws, engage in arbitrary bans and refuse people support when they get hacked.

The block that was commonly believed to have been done at the request of the current US Federal Government?

Well...yes. That's the problem.

There is no way to have a registrar that can guarantee they will block all actual abuses, while also guaranteeing that they will block nothing else, in a way that can be spelled out in black and white, requiring no human judgement, and no trust in them.

And this is generalisable, too. There is no way to universally specify "good" and "bad", or even "good faith" and "bad faith", in any domain, in a way that does not require human judgement, and thus trust in the ones making the judgements.

That's just part of living in a society. Either we agree, in some measure, to trust each other and work together, or we rapidly come to the conclusion that the only way forward is to code our own DNS system, registrar, and OS from scratch, and then run it only on hardware we have designed and built from scratch with our own hands. And run it only on solar power, so we're not dependent on the grid. And have it directly connected to at least a half-dozen separate ISPs, so you don't have to trust any single one of those. And... And... And...


I bet despite their name they have absolutely no qualms about hosting Communist propaganda.

What's the time cutoff for the question? Based on most current mainstream understanding of physics (ex. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_far_future), and mainstream understanding of "doom", at unbounded time horizons P(doom)=1 (and hence also both conditionals, as long as you accept 0<P(AI)<1).

Presumably, when this generation comes of age they will largely answer this question with "sure, I don't see the problem", which many will consider a big win.

I think the problem here is that a bunch of people in these threads are pursuing different goals (those who want a non-spying TV for themselves, those who want it for their relatives, those who want the entire spying TV ecosystem destroyed), and each of them treats the other groups as if they were misplacing the goalposts from their own preferred location.

> You must realize there are things like 3blue1brown, Veritasium, and Numberphile on YouTube, right?

There are things like "Left: the Bible in Chinese, Right: Mozart's 40th symphony" on YouTube too, but I wouldn't take that as evidence of the existence of a significant contingent of polyglot religious split-brain multitaskers. Conversely, I do in fact know several people who run explainer videos in the background simply because they like the feeling of a reassuring voice making intellectual noises at them.


No, qweqwe and I were discussing the same topic.

Some people think it’s ok to waste their life configuring Linux PCs to do standard non-custom appliance stuff, and some people just buy appliances. The appliance people in this case get to easily use Bluetooth speakers and HDR and the Linux PC people get to spend hours they won’t get back configuring their PCs to do the same thing that the appliance people get out of the box.


> The appliance people in this case get to easily use Bluetooth speakers and HDR and the Linux PC people get to spend hours they won’t get back configuring their PCs to do the same thing that the appliance people get out of the box

> spend hours

Sorry but your knowledge seems to be quite outdated. HDR on Linux has worked for a while now and Bluetooth is just as easy to use as it would be on a TV. Installing the entire OS takes less than an hour.

Not sure what you are on about regarding "configuring Linux PCs", you just install an OS once and forever not have to deal with insert proprietary TV OS bullshit, which is far more annoying and time-wasting than configuring something on a Linux PC. Not to mention the conveniences that you get with a real PC instead of some Android toy OS.

The "appliance" is more "convenient" right until you find something wrong/annoying/inconvenient about it and have to deal with the usual bullshit. I mean, sure, if all you need is watching Netlix it will be fine.

tl;dr your comment might have made sense ~5 years ago, but right now you have no clue what you're talking about and basically just repeating "linux pc hard and bad" propaganda


I have a NUC running LibreElec in my living room, on the input to my TV immediately adjacent to the input used by the Apple TV. I'm speaking from direct personal side-by-side experience.


> Who the fuck knows what can happen with the current US admin

The ratchet of authoritarianism has been turning steadily in the US (and the rest of the world) for at least the past 25 years, and a big part of why no coherent opposition to it managed to manifest is how it was turned into a partisan issue. Republicans and the apathetic centre tune out Democratic complaints about the authoritarianism of a Republican administration just as it happened when the party associations were reversed some 5 years ago, because a group resenting its outgroup wielding power is the most unsurprising dog-bites-man event.

At the same time, neither side is willing to criticise authoritarianism by their own, both because they do not want to "stab their soldiers in the back" in the culture war and because in practical terms more power to wield against the outgroup is too useful to forego. Would you still be happy to support a durable circumscription of the current US admin's ability to regulate local AI, if it also meant that no future Democratic administration could interfere with a cataclysmic AI-driven campaign of right-wing misinformation and propaganda that is threatening everything you hold dear?


Right but one side publicly directs the department of justice to investigate its political enemies and interfere in elections and the other side doesn't.


Lawfare has been an increasing problem for several administrations now. Like the parent poster says, each side is largely blind to their own abuses, but they're still abuses.

And then the other side uses it as justification to escalate further.


What sort of lawfare did the previous regime engage in? Are we at a point where former presidents are immune to prosecution for actual crimes?


> Are we at a point where former presidents are immune to prosecution for actual crimes?

Name the last time a president was prosecuted and you'll have your answer. Trumps lawsuit over presidential acts just forced into the open what was before a gentlemen's agreement about presidential power. Outside of office, I don't think any of the former presidents had a huge drive to commit anything above financial crimes and using their status.

Biden I can not think of anything scaling beyond putting his ego over country when he went for a second term. He clashed with the legal system but challenges in court is typical for the role. And even in that, he choose to comply (example loan repayment) over Trump who rushes to complete his goal before legal can step in (golf course, ballroom, etc).


When did the previous White House do either of those two things? Please be very specific.


Using the word lawfare reveals you are not unbiased.


This must be satire. There's no way you actually think that using the word "lawfare" exposes political bias.


I've mainly seen the word used in suspiciously bot-like GOP-propaganda comments on youtube videos


This is what American discourse has devolved to. "I saw the other side saying it!"

You're just proving my point without realizing it. I'm not even American, and have no horse in your race.


When that user writes "suspiciously bot-like GOP-propaganda", he means "normal American citizens who democratically blew my party out of the last popular election", FYI.


I truly hate party politics and just want politicians cooperating to make the country run as well as possible for as many people as possible. But Republicans reliably cut taxes for the rich, dramatically grow the national deficit, and start stupid wars.


Also, are literally running the most corrupt administration that ever existed, turning the US government into an actual authoritarian dictatorship


Yes, the Trump admin seems to be breaking laws and blatantly lying as a matter of principal.


We're doing an interesting study where we interview folks who were in a coma for 5~ years and only woke up recently.

Would you be interested to join?


When did the previous White House do either of those two things? Please be very specific.


Oh, dear. Well, I hope 882 pages is enough for one example. Somehow, I suspect it will not be, of course.

https://www.justice.gov/opa/media/1436006/dl


This has nothing to do with what was mentioned.


Allegations of misconduct by the DOJ - even if politically motivated - are not relevant to my comment.

Please tell me about the time the Biden White House publicly called on the DOJ to prosecute its political enemies or interfere in elections.

If that happened, it should not be hard to find a reference to a public statement or executive order.


I always got the sense that solutions for significant "unsolved problems in medicine" would be at least 10 years out from the point of total AI dominance in the theoretical sciences. Doing actual experiments is bottlenecked by real-life constraints (organisms are slow to grow and unpredictable, human laws won't let you build a factory to brute-force biology on a million test tube guinea pigs, let alone humans), and the theoretical side of biology is also relatively underdeveloped, to the point that "solve aging" seems as hard to formulate as Navier-Stokes would have been with 15th-century mathematics.


If you are serious about this preference, would you also be okay with a compromise solution where only you (and anyone else who feels the same) die, rather than taking everyone else with you?


You don't have to want to give the policeman status: once he pulls you over after running a red light at 2am and you realise he might let you off the hook if you are nice and deferential, the status gradient almost establishes itself. People knew this, and decided to become policemen for the status. So it was with tech wizards, once you encountered a problem you could not solve without their help.


I think gradual rollout is underrecognised as the utterly devious way of implementing user-hostile changes that it is. It doesn't take a lot of scrolling through the comments here to find instances of people who are unaffected by some change or another being inexplicably hostile towards posters who are, implicitly accusing them of anything from incompetence to drama-mongering and misinformation. In that way, some of those who would complain about a change are worn down early on, and by the time the change is rolled out to more people they have already resigned and moved on, preventing a critical mass of opposition from forming.


Yes, it's a kind of boiling the frog where instead of slowly cranking up the degree of enshittification you do it with the number of affected users instead. In both cases the goal is to avoid a critical mass of user outrage.

A/B tests in general should require informed consent just like any other study on human participants. But then most software developers don't care about ethics so this is nothing new.


That's the magic of A/B testing. You get to send an entire "B" group into paranoia and upset about the change they didn't want/like while everyone in "A" gets to gaslight B that B isn't experiencing what they're getting and that it would never happen to A...


I never understood what are the technical obstacles to building the phone network in such a way that caller numbers can not be spoofed or suppressed. Then, you could just build a system where receiving an unsolicited phone call from a commercial entity entitles you to a compensation in small claims court, to the tune of 50 EUR, unless the caller can prove that you explicitly authorised them.


The problem is not that the originator can be found. The current, existing, legacy, phone system already can find the exact originator.

The problem is that enforcement of breaking the regulation is so non-existent that the criminals just place millions of calls knowing, at most, they might get a minor slap on the wrist that can be budgeted for as a "cost of doing business".

Every single call carried across the phone network is billed, and every hop along the path knows who to bill for their part of carrying the call. The billing system is the method to trace back to the originators, and then apply a fine sufficiently large enough to no longer be a cost of doing business.

But the regulators seem to have no idea that the billing system provides the traceability to find the criminals and then go after them. Instead we get things like stir/shaken that are trying to patch "authenticity" on top of a network never designed with that in mind.


AFAIK, the problem is that the system works like international mail used to.

There are strict barriers at the borders to ensure everybody pays their dues. But once a call is accepted, there's no control at all about where it's going to.


The problem is that it's a network. The hard part of networking isn't the technology - it's the other people. And short of a government regulation or a monopoly, they'll never all agree.

STIR/SHAKEN has an exception for calls passing through TDM trunks, which don't support it. This created a small industry for passing spam calls through TDM trunks. Such calls can trivially have their caller ID spoofed.


> short of a government regulation or a monopoly,

Phone companies used to be monopolies, in Europe they were owned by the government as a public service. But when they become profitable politicians betrayed their citizens and sold them. Nowadays, phone companies are a source of scams, spam and everything wrong with big corporations. And all that profits are now private instead of helping to fund the country.


On this topic, phone lines are so ubiquitous that it is irresponsible for representative governments to continue to let private companies mess around with them. Doubly irresponsible to go from public to private after the increase in popularity.


That was in the 2000s. Phone lines are an anomaly now but cellphones are not. The phone number is more like an ICQ number than an identifier of a physical connection, but is still regulated like the latter.


You don’t get to tell these people you pay they can’t double-dip as telco shareholders!


Do you have more information on this?

Why are those non-STIR/SHAKEN TDM trunks serving as transit trunks (non-terminating), rather than terminal-only trunks? Seems a pretty obvious hole to close.


DEFCON talk "Journey to the center of the phone network"

Slides: https://media.defcon.org/DEF%20CON%2033/DEF%20CON%2033%20pre...

Video recording: somewhere


Thanks!


The only limitation is cold hard cash. The phone companies make big bucks from telemarketers by providing an endless list of new numbers and multiple lines. The whole racket wouldn't work without the companies' greenlight.


Exactly. The same reason the bulk of paper mail is unsolicited garbage. The spammers/scammers are paying customers, without regulation the incentive for the phone company is to keep them flowing.

Compare to how effective spam filters are on email. It's a much harder problem, but the spam costs the provider money, so they address it.


Historically, in a world of analogue phone lines, spoofed phone numbers were a legitimate feature: if my business has more than one phone line, each of those lines is going to have its own distinct number; but I'm going to want outgoing calls from any of those lines to appear to originate from the same number (the one that I put on my promotional material, invoices, etc.).

Much the same as e-mail, identity within the phone system was, historically, entirely built on trust (because only Ma Bell could make configuration changes, and they could verify that what their customer was asking them to do was legit). Those assumptions were carried through deregulation, and are very deeply entrenched in the technical design of the network. Changing them will hopefully become easier over the next few years as analogue service is turned off entirely (e.g., BT/OR in the UK are set to turn off all analogue phone service by the end of January 2027).


I've seen two reasons. 1) Backward compatibility--you would have to add an additional security layer, and some old legacy switching hardware (5% of the network?) wouldn't support this. 2) Phone companies profit from the calls, so they have no incentive to spend the money to upgrade and stop it.


It would work until you need to route an international call.

And there's a lot of telemarketing and scams happening across country lines.

I mean, they should still do it. It's just the first problem they'd face.


In Finland international inbound calls using Finnish caller ID are simply blocked (mandated by regulation since 2023).


That's fine. International calls pay a dollar a minute. If telemarketers had to pay that they'd be out of business.


International calls pay whatever the caller network wants them to pay. You're assuming that the caller network isn't part of the scam.


Incorrect, it's the callee network


Sure but the caller network bills the telemarketer and they could be in cahoots.


Well yeah but that applies to local calls too and no telemarketer will sign up with a provider more expensive than they need.


Yes, but the premise here is that for national calls it becomes harder to spoof the caller id. In fact, here in Italy we're seeing an increase in telemarketing calls from Spain and France, so it's not entirely hypothetical.


I'd love to be able to opt out of receiving any calls originating from out-of-country.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: