Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | BarryGuff's commentslogin

I've been using this app for a couple of years. Not being open-source is fine by me; I've never had any security issues or concerns with it. It's got a good reputation as noted by its testimonials and lifespan. Anything dodgy would've been called out by now.

Not sure what you mean by "send my passwords"? It can type any keys that you give it, if that's what you mean. And you can prevent passwords being stored in its clipboard history in the Settings.


Thanks for your feedback ! I'm fine with closed source generally.

What I meant by "send my passwords" is nonetheless that it sends data copied from my clipboard from time to time to some obscure server that parses all clipboard histories in order to retrieve credentials. Maybe I'm just too paranoid.

But except from this point, I find this tool full of good ideas and I can see myself adopting it in the future.

Thanks for sharing it.


It doesn't send (clipboard) data anywhere. Why do you think that? It stores all data locally in its own folder (in a sub-folder called "Toolbox Data"). That's one of the reasons I love it. Your clips are in there. Not sent or retrieved online.

You'll find he is a whiz of a Wiz, if ever a Wiz there was.

> I remember DivX fondly

Now THAT'S a name I haven't heard in a long time. Yes, DivX was the sh*t back in the day. So good!


With emphasis on shit. Really. I can relate to the rose-tinted memories, but DivX and XviD both encode to MPEG-4 ASP which has a lot of shortcomings that manifestly result in the infamous sludgy green-purple banding artefacts of the time, no matter how good the chosen encoder is. XviD is the better of those two MPEG-4 ASP encoders, but it simply does not look good in an absolute sense, just in a relative sense compared to the alternatives of the era.


> just in a relative sense compared to the alternatives of the era

This is common sense. Nobody thinks the original iPhone is revolutionary today, but they do think it was revolutionary for the time.


There's no such thing as a codec that looks good or bad in an absolute sense. Codecs boil down to a quality versus bitrate curve. And starving them always looks bad.

While the most common kind of artifact will shift between standards, significant artifacts are fundamentally bitrate issues or encoder bugs.

If you gave DVD levels of bits-per-pixel to MPEG-4 ASP you could get something that looks nearly perfect.


> There's no such thing as a codec that looks good or bad in an absolute sense.

There are plenty of examples of both awful codecs (software; encoders) and of digital audio/video standards (e.g. Vorbis and MPEG-4 ASP) suffering from material limitations.

> If you gave DVD levels of bits-per-pixel to MPEG-4 ASP you could get something that looks nearly perfect.

No. Not even if the source is encoded by XviD. Not all problems can be solved by throwing higher bitrate at it. The ASP only supports 4:2:0 chroma subsampling, which is the largest of several shortcomings contributing to the limited quality you can achieve with ASP video material.

People on at least an intermediate knowledge level of digital video know what a damning problem 4:2:0 subsampling is and how heavy a penalty it incurs on color and clarity. Your comments mostly hold a suggestion that you kinda have some rough idea about digital video. And that's OK.

MPEG-4 SSTP is a very different matter, but that's not what DivX and XviD encodes.


I should have added "general purpose". I know there are restrained encoders for specific situations. Can you list a few of your examples for video? And I don't understand the other example you did mention, isn't vorbis more than enough at high bitrate?

4:2:0 is just fine for video. It is not a heavy penalty. It's OK for you to be rough about this. More seriously, if it's good enough for bluray and UHD bluray then it's fine.


Yeah sure, a few example that spring to mind would be...

Poor encoder: FAAC/FAAC2, the first open-source encoder for AAC audio, produce terrible audio no matter how much bitrate you let it work with. The AAC standard itself facilitates crisp audio quality at low bitrates, as heard with e.g. Apple's Core Audio AAC encoder or Nero AAC.

Poor encoder: Xing, a popular MP3 encoder of the early 2000s, was similarly infamous for producing chirpy and slurry audio even at or above 192 kbps, while bona fide MP3 encoders like LAME do far better on less.

Poor encoder: NVENC, Nvidia's on-GPU hardware video encoder, produce very poor H.264 video even at 8-10 mbps, even on the current 8th and 9th generation (RTX 40/50 series). Good H.264 encoders like x264 is capable of producing excellent FullHD video at just 2-3 mbps.

Poor standard: Vorbis is a good example of a spec whose limits/mistakes make it impossible to preserve certain combinations of frequencies, resulting in brief passages where parts of the reproduced spectrum deflates, making some music sound as if it lost its breath, so to speak. When fed certain "triggering" audio content designed to expose problems in the spec, Xiph's reference Vorbis encoder will produce ringing sounds. Interestingly also the MP3 spec has similar limitations where certain frequency combinations (usually towards the lower and upper ends) will reproduce with quantized amplitude, even when encoded with LAME, though the outcome is nowhere near as pronounced as it can be with Vorbis.

Poor standard: MPEG-4 ASP, being limited to 4:2:0 chroma subsampling and PAL/NTSC resolutions. My beef with 4:2:0 is because of how harsh it is on low-resolution content. MPEG-4 ASP being limited to a maximum of 720x576, and the 4:2:0 chroma coverage being only a quarter of that, is the reason why DivX/XviD content is smudgy even with reproduction filters.

On FullHD content a 4:2:0 grid has almost three times higher resolution, which I agree works out on both still scenes and slow panning (the two scenarios where low chroma resolution makes itself most reminded).


Oh I didn't mean to waste your time on poor encoders. I'm sure there's many of those. I mean actual codecs that have a problem, that make it impossible to do good quality.

> Vorbis is a good example of a spec whose limits/mistakes make it impossible to preserve certain combinations of frequencies, resulting in brief passages where parts of the reproduced spectrum deflates, making some music sound as if it lost its breath, so to speak.

So the people that talk about bitrates where it's transparent are basically delusional?

> Poor standard: MPEG-4 ASP, being limited to 4:2:0 chroma subsampling and PAL/NTSC resolutions.

That makes a lot of sense, I had no idea it was limited to those resolutions.

Thanks for the time explaining those.


> So the people that talk about bitrates where it's transparent are basically delusional?

In my opinion they are not. A lot of people won't pick up on differences unless something is pretty off, even if they were intimately familiar with the audio beforehand. Some people are barely able to tell the difference between one and the same piece of music being played to them first in stereo and then in mono. A fundamental problem with blind listening tests, such as those often cited from the venerable Hydrogen Audio forums, is that they provide subjective instead of objective truths - besides everyone's hearing being different, an individual's perception of music also changes by the day as it's affected by their current mood, state of health, emotional state, whether they are rested or not, and so on. Applying a scientific method (e.g. PSNR or spectral analysis) reveals an objective truth of how close a lossy product is to the original, which is where Vorbis has been shown to fall short. But subjectively a lot of users may never notice, nor even care.


> A lot of people won't pick up on differences unless something is pretty off, even if they were intimately familiar with the audio beforehand. Some people are barely able to tell the difference between one and the same piece of music being played to them first in stereo and then in mono.

Well anyone that declares something is transparent without "to me" attached, based on only their own testing, is in the flippant "delusional" category.

I'm talking about people that get the best listeners they can find to seek out differences, and combine their knowledge together while hunting for flaws. If they can't even find one or two people that can pick out a distortion, then that's a pretty trustworthy standard, even if that only gives you a 99.9th or 99.99th percentile listener. Are these people aware of the specific problem you're stating? Do they agree or disagree?

> Applying a scientific method (e.g. PSNR or spectral analysis)

But that kind of truth is far from what you actually want, a measurement of how imperfect the compression is to human ears. You can use a complicated mathematical model for how listening works, but you're stuck calibrating that model with humans, punting the problem up a level. Bulk semi-subjective data is the best foundation we can get our hands on.


It was amazing being able to fit a full length movie on a CD-ROM though.


Didn't VCDs do the same thing? IIRC the Sega Saturn could play them.


I recall that full length movies on VCD were usually two discs to get decent quality.

Not needing to get up and switch discs because you could use divx or xvid instead was a real life improvement.


And thats another reason why you had two CD drives in tower cases. My 667mhz AMD-K7 had two CD drives, insert both VCDs and nearly seamless watch a movie.

There was the part where you had to double click the media player to make it full screen again however pretty wholesome for its time.

Nowadays, it's just not the same and Ai isn't nostalgic at all.


The stock Saturn needed a VCD expansion card to play them, but some of the Japanese-only models like the Hitachi HiSaturn had it built in.


Agreed!


"DivX and XviD both encode to MPEG-4 ASP which has a lot of shortcomings that manifestly result in the infamous sludgy green-purple banding artefacts of the time, no matter how good the chosen encoder is."

That's the fault of your decoder; I never had that problem playing DivX or XviD videos in VLC.


If anything it would be an issue with the encoder, but it's not. Both DivX and XviD are prime pieces of software but they live within unbridgeable limitations of the MPEG-4 ASP profile. This or that individual may not care about the outcome, and they may use various post-processing to smooth out the creases, but the limitations are all the same real and inherently visible.


It would be with the decoder, as the issue will happen in Windows Media Player but not VLC (which has its own implementation of XviD/DivX.)


It's just that you have different (or no) post-processing filters running between those two video players. MPEG cannot be arbitrarily decoded, only arbitrarily encoded.


At 1024x768, compared to my Nokia 14" CRT TV it looked good enough.


It was absolutely a good enough solution compared to the long wait for DVD releases and shelling out tons of money.


I had to use Google Translate to read it. An interesting concept to prevent taskbar burn-in on Windows.


How come Meta's glasses are still a thing when Google's glasses got shut down for privacy reasons? What's the difference?


Great article!


Light mode for me. Dark is just weird, IMO. I don't get more eye strain from light like so many other people do. I also don't wear sunglasses when outside, ever. Maybe I've got strong eyes.


This proposal is so wrong. One person (a judge) should not hold the power of a decision due to personal biases.


Exactly. Jury trials are a fundamental component of a democratic system of law.

I have been very critical of the UK lately, but now I’m actually starting to get worried for the people there.


And regular people can circumvent it? An judge usually has to explain his/her reasons for an verdict, an jury doesn't have to. The costs of inviting candidates, screening them and getting both sides to agree to the jury also has costs attached to it.


Well if rights have a cost then by all means just scrap them.


I want to know how they understand how cats and dogs see. They say certain colors, but how do they know for sure?


The eye has "rods" and "cones". Rods see in B&W (grayscale), and "cones" see in color. We have three types of "cones". Each see only one color: blue, green, red (it's actually more complicated, but they are defectively three types) When the green and red cones activate, your brain interpret yellow. And the other colors are also combinations. Take a look at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cone_cell

Dogs have "rods" and only two types of "cones": blue and yellow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dog#Senses They also interpret combinations, like us, but have less info to combine.


Wish the stereo images were cross-eyed mode. They're easier to see that way.


Aren't they already in that mode in the linked page ?

I was able to merge them fine by looking through them.

Maybe cross eyed mode is different.


> Wish the stereo images were cross-eyed mode.

Me too, but mostly because it would mean we had a way to do interstellar travel. I'm pretty sure you'd need a very long baseline between the images for the angles to work properly


Knocked a couple into cross-eyed mode [1]. Don't hurt yourself.

[1] https://imgur.com/a/t4RYc04


Perhaps an enterprising soul can convert them to wiggle-grams?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: