Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Defitio's commentslogin

Personality traits are not mentioned in your references wiki article.

There are plenty of counter examples of other people who are born in the same month than me who are totally different.

There is also a huge difference how people handle sickness like the ones mentioned in the wik article.

The origin of those signs are also totally different and are pure fiction


>There are plenty of counter examples of other people who are born in the same month than me who are totally different.

That's irrelevant though. He didn't say it is a law of nature that forces development in the same exact way. Just that it's a factor.

What is the concern is how a statistically significant part of those born at X months are affected, compared to those being born at Y months.

Not whether there are exceptions. Of course there will be. People being the same in both groups might even be the majority. But one group (say "born in spring-summer ) having 17% more of something compared to the other is a big thing, and that's whats considered here - even if the rest 83% are the same on that aspect.


There are statistics for these things. Counter examples just means they’re somewhere else in the distribution.


He doesn't have a statistics for what he claims as the wiki article is making a different point.


They didn't claim that these things were true, they said that they're "endlessly fascinated by the effect your birth month may have on you"


That implies things which I countered.

What's the problem?


In my opinion plenty of people just use kids as a scapegoat for meaning of life.

My question would be why you value your kids time more than bouldern?

Because you made them? Because they consume so much time with them?

Or because you are just better in being a parent and biological getting satisfaction out of it?

Unfortunately for me I'm not sure if I would end like you or the other poster who regrets it sometimes.

Also I'm not sure if I want to force another/new human through my experiences like going to school etc.

In dune the king new/realized that he can't do what is necessary but has to prepare his son to do so.

I have the opposite though: perhaps I need to not to have kids to stop the cycle of creating meaning through procreation.

Yes I overthink stuff and one way or the other I still think becoming a parent would be a life changing experience but besides all of the normal thoughts climate change comes on top of it.


> Or because you are just better in being a parent and biological getting satisfaction out of it?

It is totally this. We are biological creatures and we cannot escape that.

Love, sex, friendships, relationships, parenting, happiness, and so forth are all aspects of our biology. We are not automatons living a purely rational life. Satisfaction in life depends on those biological mechanisms and shouldn't be seen through a purely rational lens.

Kids aren't a scapegoat for a meaningful life. They do absolutely make life meaningful. Much in the same way eating a delicious meal brings pleasure. We depend on our biological wiring to feel such things.


Thank you for this poignant reminder.


Yes but is it fair to the new human?

Oversimplified: would you be okay to create a new human if you know they have only 100 days to life? 5 years? 20? Suffering in school, sleep problems etc etc?

Just because it's evolutionary pre programmed?


Not everyone who struggles in life would rather not live. I think it's quite arrogant to contemplate whether living is worth it for another human being.


I find it arrogant to force a human being to life, especially at this time. I question everyday the fact that somebody else decided for me that life is somewhat worth living.


When I'm the maker of another human it's definitely worth considering before if it will be worth to do so


Even so, that person will not be you. Even if they will go through exactly the same things you've been through they may not have the same experience. You cannot know if it was worth it for them.

I think it's fine if people don't have kids, I just find the reasoning "what if they suffer, etc" a cop-out. You cannot know that beforehand and even if they suffer, they may still find meaning in life.


Last several replies you gave are such high quality. I hate it when people overintellectualize such obvious things like having a kid. I would have flipped out at the other poster, but you stuck in there and gave some really good points. Awesome.


Having kids is everything but obvious.

Don't dismiss critical thinking with an attack on you just because it feels obvious to you.


Regret emotions etc. are only possible when you are alive.

Missery etc also can only be felt when you are alive.

You clearly don't take any responsibility at all otherwise I'm lost on how easy you just dismiss concerns.


So is joy, happiness and pleasure. I feel sorry for you if your life is only filled with regret and misery. For most people there are ways out of misery but it all starts with the realization that it's not a necessity. When you're depressed it's difficult to imagine ever being able to feel anything else again but knowing that it is possible can put you on the right track.

Maybe your need to pass judgement on my character based on two posts should tell you something about yourself. It really takes an inflated ego to, as a non-parent, talk about responsibility with a parent. Paraphrasing: "Responsibility as a parent is heavy as a mountain, deciding not to have children is light as a feather".


Well, if you believe that life is worth being experienced as it's pretty unique as far as experiences goes, it's normal to expect to be okay with giving that to your child isn't it? I think most people think of life as a net positive.

There's a song where I'm from with a funny line about that - Life is short, but it's long in small stretches.


When I was a teenager I thought kids were a pyramid scheme. If your life isn't worthwhile, then what point is there in creating another life whose worth will be equally questionable? This sounds like your "scapegoat for meaning of life" idea.

What I eventually gradually realized was that the kid might just be another person, but you're not just creating a person, you're also creating a relationship with that person. And it's a unique kind of relationship, in some ways more intimate than any relationship you can have with anyone else including your romantic partner. (Which adult runs with beaming face to hug you whenever they see you come home from work and you know it's all totally genuine?) I'm not an expert on what has objective meaning in life, but I'm pretty sure that deep relationships like this are one of the stronger candidates.


If you can edit this. Edit out the “you” to “people”. It doesn’t look like an attack then. I see your comment is greying out so it’s getting downvotes.

Having diff perspectives is cool so it would be unfortunate for yours to get flagged because it seems too aggressive.


I think your concern (will I be one who is fulfilled, or one who regrets?) is reasonable, but in fact for many people the answer is “yes”. You’ll often feel fulfilled. Occasionally you’ll regret.

Also, “escape goat”, while an amazing phrase, should be “scapegoat”.


Escape goat is such a better term haha. I wish it was a legit synonym


>I have the opposite though: perhaps I need to not to have kids to stop the cycle of creating meaning through procreation.

You won't stop the cycle though, others who do actually have kids will simply continue it, and the single biggest way in which you could have had and influence on the future of the world and the human race will have been eliminated.

And that's before you get into any religious implications of having and raising children.


Being wealthy or powerful probably has more influence on the world and humans than having kids.


Nonsense, on a long enough timescale your descendents will intermarry with other people, and the wealthy and powerful of future generations will be your descendents. Dave Thomas may have had a major influence on the US with his restaurants and charitable foundations, but if he had never been born in the first place he wouldn't have been able to accomplish any of that. I chose Thomas as an example because he's a literal orphan and his adoptive family wasn't particularly wealthy either as far as I can tell.


I agree maybe that’ll happen. Maybe it won’t. OTOH, as society is now, being rich and/or powerful can definitely influence things and almost all influences of society happen by the rich and powerful.

In my pov, saying having kids is the most important way to influence the world unfortunately provides an excuse to prop up the status quo of incredibly imbalanced power and wealth structures.

It also seems a bit mean to posit having children is the way to most influence society. Not every one can responsibly and properly raise children. Or have the financial foundation


At least I would stop it for my gen pool.

I'm not responsible for potential suffering of others.


Depressing though very depressing and concerning.

Normally modern companies are also sometimes a safe space for all the discrimination happening because of religion.

Like the campus of Aramco were you can be more lax. Or were homophobia is not tolerated etc.

COVID also showed how problematic it is if people just accept some believe system without expecting any logic.

If people don't question basic and stupid religios beliefs they also tend not to question real issues in society.


I think anyone still a catholic after all of the news stories about priests either has fully questioned their religion and come to their own conclusions or has decided to never question their religion at all.


The rampant sexual abuse perpetrated by Catholic priests is a function of a couple things, but chiefly among them was the cultural moment and who, exactly, was entering Seminary at that time. You can trace back the overwhelming majority of abusers to specific cohorts. Not trying to get conspiratorial about it, it’s just a fact that this was something boomer priests did and they all joined the Church during the sexual revolution in the 1970s.

Not really sure I have a point other than to say modern Catholics are quite aware of what people think about the Church and waffle between being dismissive (because critics genuinely don’t understand it) or reactionary.


Well, personally, I'm not concerned as much about the actual low level priests. You'll get a few bad guys no matter what you're doing in an organization that big. It's the shuffling them around after being caught and not going to the police when they knew. If the middle and the top also have the bad guys you have to start questioning what the organization is really about. And I struggle to believe that it's just one generation of priests that was bad while all the other ones were perfect celibates, to be honest. This was just the generation that ran into media that couldn't be silenced.


Why are you reading hn?

Shouldn't all the stories here should lead you to a different path?

Questioning rationally your beliefs?


The presumption of these questions is astonishing. You know nothing about me, and certainly not the extent to which I’ve “rationally questioned” my beliefs. (Of course, I recognize the laughably invidious premise of your question, which is that, had I truly and “rationally” done so, I would cease to be a Christian. Give me a break.)

A recommendation: Try practicing a little intellectual humility. It will get you farther with people. Have a good one.


Suck is not on a mission to connect people. He is just a dude who got tremendously rich by fucking over people with the first social Media platform.

If aliens have the same evolution, Facebook would have just be called something else.

This his idiotic plan to pivot fb into the future because after WhatsApp and Instagram suddenly TikTok came.

And if you believe in a future with VR and in the one platform paradigm than this investment is worth a lot but it's in my opinion a very big gamble while suck believe in it's being a smaller gamble.

/shrug imagine suck actually believing in something worthwhile he actually could have used this by making a real working social media platform or start doing something for people like planting trees...


I rethought my reaction to Google IO conference: I found it boring because they showed things which do not have an impact on me.

Like 'taking better pictures when you a person of non white color's but that's the wrong attitude. They solve great issues like this and I'm probably more underwhelmed that we even had to fix something like this because it wasn't really solved before.

Let's see if/when we get a more stable timeframe back. With COVID and the Russians it's shitty and climate change might already be a regular constant.


Climate Change has been a regular constant since there was a climate


Could you please stop posting unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments? You've been doing repeatedly, unfortunately. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for, so we have to ban such accounts.

If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.


You should be intelligent enough to make the right assumption of what I'm referencing.

If you don't believe in human made climate change pls say so directly so I can ignore you


Could you please stop posting unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments? You've been doing it a lot already, unfortunately. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for, so we have to ban such accounts.

If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.


There are a lot easier targets someone can attack for undefined terror than this pipeline.

The motivation should make sense, Russia makes sense, it was probably Russia.

And in regards to past Russian behavior even more realistic.


Plus Ukraine being found out by their lifeline countries (NATO) is wayyyyy too big of a chance to take. This was 99.9% likely to be the russians.


While similar also totally different: it also contains political messages and less security focused but technical talks also.

Food hacking or 3D printing also.


I'm German too and at least here in Munich you still have to wear masks in lots of settings.

Public transport, doctors office, in my work office etc.

And the discussion around Oktoberfest was quite often in the media.

I'm not sure what you mean by 'no one cares about COVID anymore'.


Masks might be mandated in specific settings, but revealed preference makes it clear: Everybody goes to events, bars, clubs, has private gatherings, there are conventions with tens or hundreds of thousands of people in Germany as we speak. That's what I meant: Most people have moved on from being overly concerned with it.

I finally got covid last month. It wasn't fun, but I had worse colds. I think many people experienced the same thing, and so covid morphed from a looming, unknown horror to a known quantity.


Mask usage has gone down to... I'd say 20-30% in the supermarkets I frequent, but I don't think it's completely wrong with the implied exaggeration for effect.


I sometimes forget it with the superttoo but I do t want to be counted as not caring.

I'm not sure this exaggeration paints the right picture.

At least in public transport is very visible


It's much harder to get COVID through eyes than the nose


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: