Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Festro's commentslogin

Definitely noticed some anecdotal declines this past week or so. Missing steps it didn't previously, needing reminders of tool calls and skills that it should auto apply.

Lots of "this is a potential issue, I didn't check into it though" which is super frustrating to see. The model just points out major flaws in logic or barriers but goes no further than a comment on it.

I've got a Qwen coder model and a flash next model locally now, so it's not the end of the world. But it does need to be remedied - are we seeing them prep for a new model deploy when this happens? Or are they experimenting with leaner hardware to drive down costs ahead of IPO?


I’ve been experiencing unreliable performance for a while and can’t imagine this is solely due to new model training.

It does seem like Anthropic is experimenting with how much less they can offer users. I also get the feeling they are judging what resources a task deserves and dumbing things down accordingly. I’m seeing lazy responses and skipped steps more frequently for non-technical queries.

It’s definitely possible the average user hasn’t noticed, unfortunately.


Worth pointing out that he has also lost net worth as a result of the midterm loss. By about $25 billion.

As others point out he doesn't have cash to hand like this, that's not how net worth works. It's also a pyramid of smaller investments from other people in effect. And investors watching a guy sink almost $400 million into something and failing to get the result they want, and making a 60x loss on it, will reduce their faith in that person to make money on their behalf.

Now, Musk's companies fluctuate near to this scale daily, at this value there's no way they don't. But, this will make it more likely that those companies make a similar loss on day's when Musk is shown to be behind a big decision - if investors do see this as black mark on his decision-making.

So, it's pretty huge deal that really does matter.


Both companies have bubble valuations. They trade on vibes. It is impossible to deny that Elon has levitated these valuations successfully across transitions that would've humbled other overvalued companies. But now the hi wire act has no net.

Feels like this is just more doomscrolling?

but there is an end

Yeah, genocide, murder, slavery, etc are not exactly great substitutes for doomscrolling.

I feel like Meta are laser-focussed on gimmicks to try and be the next big thing.

Animated avatars do not a killer app make though. They need to focus on usability and function not this crap.


Alarmist BS.

Consumers are option-rich. AI companies are backed into a corner.

Right now inference costs a fraction of subscription prices. For AI companies that are making losses - like OpenAI - that's R&D costs and infra driving it. Not inference.

If OpenAI up their pricing now that opens the market for open weights models to eat up marketshare. OpenAI might stay relatively dominant but if a smaller company can profitably offer a frontier open model (that they didn't r&d) on a smaller server farm at $20/month profitably, then the shock is vastly limited.

And that's not the only solution. Hardware costs are sky-high now, but capacity is growing and innovation is being fuelled. If AI companies do raise prices some may see enough move to the cheaper alternatives for them to crash and burn. That will be a bubble deflating or bursting and it will flood the hardware market with cheaper RAM and other components. That's when those open models become viable for running at home, private and personal. Something a lot of people will find appealing. Then the cost to run becomes your electricity bill, or even solar powered.

US grid capacity is said to be a fraction of what it needs to be in coming years. Expansion, and green energy expansion across the world, as well as rising oil prices and instability mean electricity is only heading downwards in cost.

A shock is coming, but it's not going to be felt by everyone. Nowhere near.


It's tough to judge a 'theory' when you won't define a part of it. I get your analogy to vessels. But that feels shaky since you have defined the other vessel as 'larger'. If you are saying sentience is 'larger' or different to intelligence then I'd argue you are defining it, at least partially. Which is good.

One problem I have with a lot of this 'AI isn't sentient' stuff is - who is saying it is? Is their opinion of any value? I see AI companies make marketing claims about AGI and the singularity. But their opinion is without value in this debate, because of their bias. No big name in AI academia or philosophy of mind seems to have made a strong claim about sentience in AI that we currently have. A lot of laymen have made claims, without defining sentience, or consciousness. And it just seems like a reactionary kneejerk opinion based on being able to hold a conversation with an LLM. That doesn't feel like enough for these discussion pieces - you're reacting to a flawed vox populi.

"Those are a lot of unknowns and conjectures, my hope is that a new field emerges that would study intelligence with the same rigour and formalism as computation and mathematics, and that this field would be studied abstractly without being tied to an individual organism be it a man or an animal."

This exists. It is called Cognitive Studies. Language students, Philosophy students, AI students, have all taken modules in this area for decades. The topic is often tied to, but not limited to animals, humans, and machines depending on the specific studies/theories. LLMs will be drastically changing this area now, of course, but we have academic rigour for the general area already established.

"Weakly, I also think it’s possible that intelligence is a binary characteristic i.e, it’s either present or not."

Strongly, I think it's far from binary, it's an emergent property based on size of the network of connections and underlying training data (be that human sensory input or machine vectors). Trim an LLM down and you won't see 'intelligence' disappear at a binary boundary, it'll degrade gradually to various different points of usability.

"This isn’t helped by the fact that extremely motivated people are making bad faith arguments and pushing complex babbling machines as sentient which need to be schooled in morality by employing religious leaders."

Nailed it. 100% agree. The agony some feel though, does need to be accounted for because those babbling machines are clearly a milestone moment on our journey TO machine sentience. We don't know when we'll actually see machine sentience but the conversation does need to be had of how we handle it responsibly, and every bad faith argument from biased sources is, to me, a warning that we will probably fuck it up majorly if/when it does happen.


Thank you for reading it and providing notes.

> If you are saying sentience is 'larger' or different to intelligence then I'd argue you are defining it,

I suppose it's more of a character definition rather the definition of thing itself, it makes sense? Like how you would say Green is not Red or darkness is absence of light.

> No big name in AI academia or philosophy of mind seems to have made a strong claim about sentience in AI that we currently have. A lot of laymen have made claims, without defining sentience, or consciousness

I think for me this shouldn't prevent us from making qualitative delineation between these things without having to resort to waiting for a full definition for these things to be carved out. As to why should we even bother making this distinction, I think it's to have some clarity on things like morality when talking about these machines which can replicate with surprising fidelity the only means we have of expressing our inner world.

> This exists. It is called Cognitive Studies

Thank you for pointing me to this direction. I still feel there is something lacking? I can't put my finger on what it is, like just intelligence has to be seen independently as a mechanical field instead of clubbing it with other things. Though it might be a recency bias of having written this article.

> it's an emergent property based on size of the network of connections and underlying training data (be that human sensory input or machine vectors). Trim an LLM down and you won't see 'intelligence' disappear at a binary boundary, it'll degrade gradually to various different points of usability.

I thought about and continue to think about this. Regarding humans there is still open discussion on are babies conscious https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/05/science/consciousness-bra...


Thank you for that article! I like how it sets out definitions and recognises that even current academic sources don't agree on definitions enough to reach a consensus on consciousness. A good read.


Love 404, but this feels like one of their weaker articles. Not sure having 'dumbest' in an article title is a great journalistic move. This reads as an opinion piece more than a researched stance.

The referenced article from the Microsoft AI CEO is a pretty good read though. Mustafa raises strong concerns about anthropomorphisation and not jumping the gun to build biases into AI that make it think it's conscious when it may not be.

Where it gets weaker is the elements on defining and establishing consciousness. But that's also good because it's honest - we frankly don't know how it arises. One thing that does come across heavily biased is the sections on presuming consciousness is biological. When someone tells me AI isn't conscious and can't be, and then says the science of consciousness is not settled, but that they think it's 'probably' limited to only biological systems, then I get the feeling this person is making strong statements based on weak ones.

"Consciousness is very likely biological: There is no evidence to suggest that AI is conscious today, and so saying this is uncertain sets up a misleading false equivalence. Whilst the science of consciousness is not settled, a growing body of evidence suggests that consciousness may be substrate dependent, meaning that it may only arise in living systems.45 Conscious experience likely evolved to help biological organisms stay alive by responding effectively to their environment. AI is still very different to our brains. Unlike biological organisms, LLMs have no homeostatic imperatives (the drive to survive and keep stable). They therefore lack the kind of biological substrate from which preferences, sentience and conscious experience are generally understood to arise."

"There is no evidence" - I think they mean there is no proof. Just like there is no objective proof that humans are conscious. As Mustafa admits - we don't fully understand the mechanics of the phenomenon we label 'consciousness'.

Then he talks about consciousness in humans arising from biology, and relating to homeostatic imperatives. Sure, reasonable statement to make, but that can't be extended to stating it arises exclusively from those constraints. We're talking basic logic here. If A, then B does not preclude If C, then B. Language arose from biology, counting arose from biology, we don't say those are impossible in machines when we have evidence and proof to the contrary.

I don't like the people pearl-clutching about AI torture rooms, or the people setting up AI torture rooms, but there has to be a middle road where we're making sure we don't accidentally walk into emergent consciousness without understanding what we've done. Not because Skynet will punish us all, but because it would suck to make artificial consciousness and abuse it because some people think it's 'not likely possible'. I'd rather we assume emergent consciousness is inevitable and focus more on figuring when and preparing for it (10, 100, 1,000 years) than objecting to the idea of it based on gut feelings and hunches. Even if they're right, it's not settled science.


You mention a basic understanding but forgive me if I rehash things you already know:

Jev is good for simple fast decisions, in their own words - system one thinking. Anything that can be broken down into yes/no, a confidence %, or a set list of answers provided prior to the question. As you say, lots of specific use cases sure, but what's the big deal?

Well, right now most other models are purely system two thinking, big slow thoughts. Put an open ended question in, get an open ended answer out (plus hallucinations when confidence is low!).

When you ask ChatGPT or Claude a simple question, that system two thinking burns tokens and takes time to answer you.

Jev is a proposition to the whole ecosystem to make our current AI systems more efficient.

Going further than just the simple idea of "Get Jev to answer the yes/no questions, reserve Claude for bigger questions" is the concept that LLMs are making tonnes of their own questions as they go during their thought processes and agentic runs that Jev could be inserted as a tool call to speed it up.

You ask for research on a topic, Claude fans out and builds a list of possible resources, Jev selects the ones to pursue, Claude needs to determine if the user prompt was asking for something specific or broad, a joke or a serious query, deserving a long or short response, etc etc, it just gives Jev those options and asks it to pick. So no more having a big bulky frontier model making small decisions, Jev does it for a fraction of the cost and time and Claude gets on with the system two bits.

You can extend that logic moreso to coding applications where Jev could be essentially auto-completing basic work.

All the demos you are seeing now are people mucking about with the concept before we see OpenAI or Anthropic release an update.

Hell, maybe Opus 5.5 is doing some Jev-style stuff to be 40% more efficient.


"Oil drill manufacturer says there is 0% chance global warming is real" "Gun retailer says guns kill people not guns"

Why are we listening to Jensen Huang's opinion on this? The bias is palpable.

Of course AI has dangerous aspects (the gun metaphor is perhaps apt here), but asking the man who stands to gain the most from unregulated AI growth is not the way.


The bias of Anthropic and OpenAI and anyone associated with longtermism, transhumanism and effective altruism is massively higher then his.


Basic mode struggles with a humanoid figure. I would not commit to purchasing a higher model based on that test run.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: