Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Folcon's commentslogin

This is fascinating, I never even considered this need.

Could you say more about this? What kind of setups work well? Is this really straightforward or are there any subtleties?


There are shitloads of such projects, and you can buy those from Alibaba en masse.

The general search term is: "fake battery circuit" and "fake battery software".

Example:

https://yaky.dev/2022-09-06-smartphone-without-battery/

You can find numerous videos on yt too how does it look in practice on the large scale by watching some police raid videos


Are you sure this is still a viable path? They suggest the BMS is an issue: https://www.reddit.com/r/androidafterlife/comments/1au1x7z/d...

Different use cases, if the apps don't offer what you need because it's uncommon or custom, then the call is superior, apps can't offer every option, so you default back to messaging and a back and forth, at which point you do want realtime communication


I am not sure what kind of restaurant you're thinking about where it is impossible to put every food option into an app.

If you think about the logistics of running a decent kitchen, the set is quite limited in the first place.


So you need to know exactly what you want to order? People rarely order food like that in my opinion. The majority of the time people like to browse menus and consider the options. In that scenario the voice chat interface is absolutely terrible. “Remind me again of the option you presented to me 3 minutes ago? No not that one, list them again. No I don’t need to know the full item description with all ingredients, just be brief!” and so on. It’s just not an efficient way to relay that type of data.


This might be key, I think Grant Sanderson of 3blue1brown fame gave the example of the Turing machine being this small lemma that was introduced in a paper about computability, and if no one actually spent any time thinking about what it was and what it meant, we have solved the paper and thought there wasn't any interesting or useful application of this math.

Thankfully the machine was built, I do wonder if how we're going to solve the understanding part of this, there's a lot coming out, drinking from the firehose is not something I can reconcile with my experience that a lot of good ideas need serious contemplation time to bear fruit.


It seems like Nintendo is the only one I've heard of routinely doing it?

And I'm not sure why? I would have thought producing and refining new IP would be good to do now and again, at least releasing something novel once every few years?

Or perhaps they prefer just buying external IP.


> It's also rare you have a game that is allowed to improve the way Minecraft, Factorio, or Stardew Valley have

Honestly I think this is the hardest thing, I've spent a bit of time now trying to look at how indie works, including building out a small team to put something together and you either need to get funding, or it's pretty gruelling.

You can build something small slow and steady, but you've got to luck out and hit the zeitgeist if you don't want your project to collapse for a lack of money.

Or you have to have someone support you, I mean Stardew Valley famously was building for 4 years before they released, with his partner supporting him, that's a huge survivorship bias.

Project Zomboid is another game that comes to mind that's been being built for a long time for a dedicated community. However they managed to get a paid prototype out early, even though they had cash issues and a fair bit of bad luck.

Not sure what the story behind Factorio is come to think about it.


Factorio was a pretty good early access success story as well. They were developing for a long time before full release and had lots of time to polish it. I think it helped that it was the kind of game that the devs could keep playing a lot without getting tired of it, and so they had a lot of opportunity to iterate on the design as they went. I think it's also the kind of game where good quality code has a lot of benefits for the game itself, given the scale of what they want players to be able to build and the need for reliable simulation for multiplayer. They also had a good principle of developing the core game design as a 'mod' itself, which made the modding interface pretty powerful.


Every one of my examples was also extremely lucky to hit pay dirt at just the right time (3D dwarf fortress mining simulator had a number of contemporaries that could have just as easily been "the big one"; the idea of "Harvest Moon for PC" was clearly long overdue but hadn't caught on; and Factorio hit the perfect polish (heh) needed to really capture that group (similar games existed and still exist)).

None of them can you build a successful business strategy around, really, because the vast majority of games like that do NOT succeed.


For sure, this is the nature of the indie video game market. I would say factorio was a lot more unique (though not totally) at the time: The closest gameplay that really existed was the minecraft modpacks that inspired factorio but these were a little limited in exposure by their nature of being mods. The explosion in automation games as a genre was largely as a result of factorio's success.


> and if you think you are the 'good' guy

I honestly never got why the belief that if you used this line of reasoning in practice, you were just a bad guy, that thought they were a good one, never seems to be a more common belief

I mean it pops up in media a lot, either as misguided, or deceptive characters


The point is you can justify almost anything on the basis of defining yourself as the 'good guy'.

Take the US recent assassinations of Iranian leadership. Objectively unilaterally assassinating other countries leaders is wrong - but somehow it's fine if you have a good guy/bad guy lense.

One of the problems here is huge swathes of material that the AI will have ingested includes this kind of exceptionalism thinking - it's particularly deeply rooted in Western culture generally and US culture in particular.

The problem isn't so much whether the good guy/bad guy allocation is corrrect - rather that it's very existence in the training set is deeply dangerous - as all it takes is one single classification to happen and suddenly everything is for the greater good.


> Objectively unilaterally assassinating other countries leaders is wrong

Why? If the leader is responsible for atrocities, then why would it be wrong to kill them? Especially if their removal would result in a more liberal leader replacing them, and not just chaos or more bloodshed.

In the case of Iran, there was no evidence of that, but as a general rule leaders should not be a protected class.


As someone who spent a lot of time supporting users and understanding their challenges with these tools, there's a lot of can you do X vs how can I do X, at least a 10x if not 100x difference.

IE: Model do this for me vs teach me.

Enough that I know people who have built businesses purely training people.


I do wonder whether you're comparing two different versions of chinese products?

IE, you're seeing and buying things they're selling directly, so they need to manage quality control, vs what is being sold on amazon, potentially a 3rd party seller who's cutting corners to make a nicer margin?


Hongdian's primary retail front in the west is through Amazon.


The problem with "it's hard to believe" is that this is an area where I'm not even sure how to effectively estimate the counterposition, I've seen things that I thought were interesting get cancelled or have no follow up all the time, and it makes sense, no idea if it will matter, or even work, and even if it does, how much will it cost to realise any value?

Who knows how often really impactful tech is gated behind some non-obvious thing which we never follow up on.

I mean Douglas Engelbart basically bet his entire career behind the Mother of All Demos[0], if it had flopped, modern computing as we know it would be fundamentally different, same with Hiroo Kinoshita and Extreme Ultraviolet Lithography[1][2], we just would have had Moore's law falling off a cliff.

-[0]: [The Mother of All Demos, presented by Douglas Engelbart (1968)](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY)

-[1]: https://spie.org/news/photonics-focus/mayjune-2023/developin...

-[2]: [The Closest Thing We Have to Alien Technology by Veritasium](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MiUHjLxm3V0)


To add to what you're saying, that's also ignoring that having the time or ability to build really complex things in assembly is harder, higher level languages making things easier also enables people to do more complex things


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: