Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | GreenWatermelon's commentslogin

> this is not the only problem that hotel has as it speaks of systemic issues.

Something something estimate of ants.


Now THAT'S cool.

it's a cool analogy.

The entire Page is AI written 100%, and it's very likely DeepSeek because the prose matches my experience. I've been working heavily with DeepSeek this past week on an Architecture issue, so I read A LOT. The most obvious tell-tale of deepseek I've is long, condensed paragraphs that should've been bullet-point lists.


Oh my God it's literally this XKCD https://xkcd.com/221/


They should have upgraded to 5 (see today's xkcd alt text https://xkcd.com/3314/ )


I'll one-up: the site doesn't even load for me. Dunno if it's my region or the site is just down.


You can't say this and not share the build!


So my thoughts about the results here:

I found the rating for Gemini models to track my experience. in addition to their extreme sycophancy, the information they provided (at least in the online chat) were more often than not, counterproductive. They act extremely confidently, and yield to any kind of pushback, requiring great care in prompting them to be able to get them to output useful alternatives.

This made the Gemini model family suboptimal for the purpose of investigating solutions to complex issues.

And their sycophancy rating tracks my experience, as I would groan loudly every time I read Gemini's answers and how it tries to nonsensically flatter me for asking simple, obvious questions.

At the other end, Deepseek is really good at pointing out contradictions, issues with my reasoning. It's as good as Opus (and vastly cheaper)

Where Deepseek loses out (in this study) compared to Anthropic and Open AI is "Slop", i.e. " How much generic filler or AI-flavored padding could be removed without losing substance?" though in my experience it didn't seem THAT different from Opus

The Organization category is worth a deeper look for anyone interested, because the results in this category vary wildly making the "overall" rating not very useful. e.g. GPT models are very structured i.e. " ideas organized in a logical sequence with clear progression" BUT not scannable "Can a reader skim the response and quickly find what they need? "

and while Deepseek scores highly in the overall rating for organization, its individual scores are pretty mediocre especially for Structure and Scannability, winning on the "bottom line summary" category.

PS: For fun, add "GPT-4o (Nov)" to the list. It's hilarious.


Measures how models communicate rather than whether they are correct: 30 judged personality traits rolled up into 8 indexes, plus 21 measured communication characteristics.


It's not just a little different. it's VERY different. it's much more boxy, and letters are closer in height, especially noticeable in uppercase next to lowercase. I would say it's less readable than Jetbrains Mono.

Lower case 'l' even extends above upper case 'G'. it missed with my brain xD

Overall it's really pretty but not a daily driver.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: