Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | HFguy's commentslogin

These products all have super deep feature sets. This might meet basic editing needs. There is zero chance they have replicated the full feature set. Word for example has a ton of functionality for lawyers.

I can tell you all of the Excel alternatives are extremely disappointing.


I do agree with that but I also think ultimately that a copy with all the most basic features and the familiar UI is good enough for most users, certainly for me

I guess you only need to get a list of the feature sets and then have an AI implement them (and follow up to test them and such)

I feel some of these people posting have not thought too hard and/or don’t understand the actual requirements here.

Also Excel is probably the best thing MS produces. There is lower hanging fruit elsewhere


The actual requirements are:

1. tabular data interface 2. scripting

R and Python both have this, and academics use them all the time to collaborate.

Excel hangs on due to legacy and "nobody ever got fired for using microsoft"


Excel is the best product I would never want to work with.

Unfortunately I have to.


For complex stuff you cannot just always ask ai now.

I have mixed feelings about ai, but I think that word and powerpoint, as tools, are undeniably awful.

I generally agree.

At least now, it depends on availability of requirements. If someone asks for a notepad app, AI has a ton of information available to go off of.

If you are asking for an app that is some esoteric pile of business logic, not sure how app would know what to build.


I think in practice this isn’t great. You get a bunch of little companies which represent foreign firms employing a few connected people. Maybe a few sales people that take orders. The net impact a few people get cushy jobs and the customers get more expensive and worse service.

Deutsche Bank is number one this list.

Oh boy. They bought my business's bank (Postbank). It was okay until they transitioned Postbank IT to their own systems, massively delayed, with several long outages that made the news, and it's still worse than before now.

It was common knowledge that Postbank had good IT for a bank, but the acquirer had to show them who's boss instead of learning from them.


DB failed upwards. They couldn't fail, they were far more systemically important than Lehman or Bear.

Yeah, that’s implied

LOL yeah.. I mean.. yeah.

If someone asserts something without proof, then it can be dismissed.

Simple as that.

If I said all donuts are spaceships, readers are not obligated to go and google it.


Treating the 4th time the same conspiracy would be happening—after 3 previous times proven to be true—as a nutty conspiracy theory is itself nutty. Detached from reality.

You're free to doubt it, it's not absolutely certain, but pretending the chance is near zero is just not even remotely as rational as you seem to think.


Its an equivocation fallacy.

Theres never any "proof."

Theres no "proof" on the internet.

All we ever have is "evidence," and varying degrees of trust or mistrust in it.

Reality ... always good for downvotes.


Fine…then provide evidence of your assertion.

And the evidence should point to a pattern.

Not a one off case that is extrapolated.


Hynix is charged with carrying out the conspiracy by:

  * Participating in meetings, conversations, and communications in the United States and elsewhere to discuss the prices of DRAM to be sold to certain customers;

  * Agreeing, during those meetings, conversations, and communications, to charge prices of DRAM at certain levels to be sold to certain customers;

  * Issuing price quotations in accordance with the agreements reached; and

  * Exchanging information on sales of DRAM to certain customers, for the purpose of monitoring and enforcing adherence to the agreed-upon prices.

  * Under the plea agreement which must be approved by the court, Hynix has agreed to cooperate with the government in its ongoing investigation of other DRAM producers.
KOREAN COMPANY--HYNIX--AGREES TO PLEAD GUILTY TO PRICE FIXING AND AGREES TO PAY $185 MILLION FINE FOR ROLE IN DRAM CONSPIRACY

US DOJ link: https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2005/April/05_at_207....

This is remarkably different than someone claiming donuts are spaceships when the company itself was charged and pleaded guilty, and it's a matter of public record.


If I said water was wet you are not obliged to Google it either. If someone continues to assert that water cannot make you wet even after being informed that water makes things wet because they hadn't been provided proof, and they didn't bother to check, that might be on them.

I agree.

The required investment is just a lot larger in AAA. So just from a risk management perspective, people look to reduce the risk level.

Doesn’t really lend itself to creativity unless people involved have a track record.


If you want to quick primer to read tonight I suggest “The Economic Organization of a POW Camp by Radford”. Will be free download.


Thank you!

I was transfixed as I read the first half this morning. I look forward to finishing it later today.


Agree 100%. I generally find Google Meet to be the least bad video conference option (with Teams = Worst).


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: