Honestly, this is one of those things where historiography swings back and forth and the truth is somewhat in the middle. The swinging back and forth is usually because confidence builds around a certain assumption but time is long and eventually evidence is discovered challenging that, then other assumptions get undermined, the new revelation gets focused on to the expense of all the past evidence and it becomes the new central assumption
It could be argued that Turkish and simplified Chinese succeeded simply because they were supported by, you could even say imposed by, a government that controls > 90% of the population speaking the language. Neither was the case for Arabic: there is no single government spanning that proportion of Arabic speakers, and from how I read the article, it seems no government really supported Unified Arabic to any extent even remotely comparable to Turkish and simplified Chinese.
This is what I think about grammar. Yes, it’s a little arbitrary but it makes you think a little more about your writing. That’s why I try to use correct grammar in text messages. I don’t push this on anyone because most people don’t like to think about word choice, but I am a writer at heart. Still I have to bite my tongue every time someone sends me a text message “hi am here”
I think small children learning language learn in a way similar to LLM's, just saying words that seem appropriate to the situation without any understanding of the meaning. But a key difference in my mind, is they use the reactions to this text prediction to help them construct a picture of the world, which then can interact with their thinking of what words to say.
The irony of the "leave Britney alone" guy is that he was the only person who was correct, and then himself became a target of the brutal attention and ridicule aimed at Britney Spears.
The entertainment business (especially Hollywood) has always been guilty of exploiting artists and then throwing them away when they're no longer bankable.
This is also an option with AI patches, if your AI contribution is good enough, let it get proven in use, and then it can be considered naturally as the developers of the original project look at what's going on with similar projects.
Code that works but is unmaintainable is a burden on a project, that being said with open source, you can always fork the code, add your code, and let people decide
reply