Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | LPisGood's commentslogin

If you were building an ice cream shop and you do market research and discover a neighborhood has a higher than average ice cream intake, is it prejudicial to build your ice cream shop there?

Recognizing that a high rate of fraud comes from VoIP and then refusing VoIP is similar.


What about banning people from visiting your ice cream shop if they live in a certain area?

False equivalence. The more likely scenario is banning people who don’t wear shirt or shoes or who carry themselves in a certain way or behave poorly like a VoIP service

Being against this is like being against spam filters "just because it has all these spammy keywords doesn't mean it's spam". Granted, maybe the government should provide universal service but banning VoIP numbers is not ridiculous.

A school district had to cancel classes because of a cyber incident. How often does that happen?

I don't know how often but if I saw it on the news absent anything else I'd file it under "things are crazy these days" rather than "things are crazy this week in particular".

I think such things are happening more and more year after year, which is newsworthy in and of itself. I'm not denying that. I'm not even denying that AI/cyber incidents on a big scale haven't happened and aren't coming. This is all newsworthy. I just have doubts about how people are interpreting the events of this particular week.


Constantly

No fallback to paper and pencil?

I think almost none of these ever worked for me. It’s a cool idea, but if it ever worked at scale, it would be shut down legally, and by its nature, it can’t really work not at scale.

I used to use it all the time... I'm guessing about 15 years ago.

Most of the logins were actually bugmenot@mailinator.com, with password bugmenot.


Same here, I used to use it often about 15 years ago but there was a period where the logins slowly stopped working for me and I eventually gave up using it.

I've used it as recently as a month or two ago, though most working logins I found on it recently were just using throwaway yopmail addresses and I could just create a throwaway account with that if I wanted

yeah. I mostly moved to making a fresh one with a temp-mail.org email, since bugmenot accounts tended to be burned 90% of the time for the past 15 years or so. Whatever blessed hero runs it uses a rotating cast of domains so it doesn't tend to trip basic "protections" against throwaway addresses.

maybe we need to establish this, and maybe some friends can add this as a hidden feature in their project. ;)

It was still working for me, although you add to create new account and add it from time to time.

Shut down legally how? There's no law against telling someone else your password.

It’s generally a violation of the terms of service to share accounts like that. A civil issue, not a criminal one.

The Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA), 18 U.S.C. § 1030, criminalizes intentionally accessing a computer “without authorization” or by “exceeding authorized access”. Abetting that would also be criminal.

And courts have narrowed the scope of what exactly that means greatly.

How can anyone not be confused? Explicit declarations and memorable lines like "If the “exceeds authorized access” clause criminalizes every violation of a computer-use policy, then millions of otherwise law-abiding citizens are criminals" (Van Buren v. United States, 593 U.S. 374) seem built for a logic of fait accompli that makes lawful conduct contingent on portrayals of computer use prevailing among non-specialists at the time of the ruling.

Then the site can close the account and not send spam to that email any more? The operators of BugMeNot never signed any agreement with those sites.

I'm not a lawyer, but I believe in America at least we still have freedom of speech to encourage people to violate the ToS of websites.


You don't have to sign an agreement to be found in violation of contract law. Knowingly advising others to break contract law is still a liability.

Encouraging someone else to break their contract violates what law?

Tortious interference? That said, I'm not sure that they'd really be advising/inducing people to break contracts; I'd think anyone seeking them out already had that intention.

Criminal if bad actor does something bad and it becomes the account owner's problem.

ToS / contract violation.

If BugMeNot is considered the "account owner", they may have legal repercussions for what bad agents do with those credentials. Just b/c you publish your email/password doesn't mean you're immune legally to what bad actors might upload.


It hosted credentials uploaded by other users. BugMeNot itself is probably not a party to the contract with the website itself at all.

Yes, exactly: If I share my username/password, they might penalize me - not everyone I shared it with.

I don't think you're getting it, though. If you share your password through a website that explicitly instructs people to violate the TOS, then both you and that website could end up in court.

Terms of Service are not laws. There is no legal penalty for breaking them.

It is not a crime. It is considered a breach of contract in many cases. As a result, if a site can prove there were damages, they can sue in civil court for it. That is the big distinction here: civil liability vs criminal liability. It can be the former without the latter.

I think you will find many civil legal contracts have penalty clauses for breaking them.

A company does not have a green light to arbitrarily decide what conduct constitutes a violation of the law.

Terms of Service is not a legally binding document.


It is a legally binding contract in many instances. A violation of a contract is not a crime generally, but they could sue for damages.

How would they ever know what a random website’s TOS are when someone posts a login from that site?

You're missing the point.

This site instructs people to violate the TOS of specific websites. That could land them in a lawsuit.

And the CFAA could definitely be interpreted to make this a criminal matter. I don't think that has legs, but it is a law on the books that this might violate.


I think they’re pretty clearly not designed by idiots. A lot of smart people work there.

I think quality of most products is seemingly going down. To me it is a likely consequence consequence of increased financialization and money being expensive.

Also of the increased monopilizations / duopolization as well as increased abuse of network effects in many areas that removes bargaining power from consumers.

Software has always been broken at a systemic level. It’s a complicated continuously changing web of abstractions and abstraction breaking hacks attempting to survive prolonged contact with reality.

It was less broken before open source allowed an architectural explosion, because the dependencies were too expensive. It took a lot of arguing to get management to splurge on a single library or other tool. A lot of astronaut-architect wannabes were constantly grumpy about mgmt that wouldn't pay for the latest whiz-bang thingie.

The actual programming logic has certainly always been complex, but the integrations weren't so bad. You could learn your very small toolset quickly and focus on ideas. Now, you have an ultra-massive toolchain to come to terms with, made up of free software and "cloud" architecture that starts off cheap and gets expensive later on.

Dependencies have always been the problem, but that problem has expanded in every direction, at every layer, approaching our own limits of comprehension. AI has allowed us to catch up, temporarily, but given the collective penchant for upping the ante, I expect the real supernova is yet to come.


Is the problem open source? I haven't see these kinds of widespread problems coming from Java dependencies (25 years old) or Perl (maybe 30 years old)? Okay, maybe people aren't using Perl like they used to but Java is still a thing.

Part of it is the inclination of the developer to make the thing more robust. Part of it is lowering the barrier of entry, maybe to the point it's _too_ easy to submit a package. Part of it is bad decisions made by the package manager, like running arbitrary scripts.


I don’t doubt you would find a trove of issues in CPAN if you went looking. It’s not an interesting target, though, because it’s all but dead.

Java via maven central is similar. It’s not a popular language. We know those libraries are riddled with issues - log4j’a big vulnerability isn’t that old - and simply requiring a GPG signature on a package is a thin guard against compromised uploads.

The NPM ecosystem is uniquely suited to supply chain attacks though. It has a massive rate of churn, which makes it impossible to maintain dependencies safely. You either lock in and hope there’s no big issues or ride the wave and hope you don’t get hit by zero days.


I agree that CPAN is not as active as it once was. Maven is hardly dead, it's pretty active (as is Java the language). NPM is very busy but they also have a very real bot problem.

Also, egg all over my face with java4shell news today :-)

Apologies, I didn't mean to imply Maven was dead, though I can see how it comes through that way. I meant to imply Java is less popular than other modern languages, and is a bit less interesting as a target as a result. Not unpopular, not dead.

Open source as in "you can use this for free" isn't the problem, but open source as in "here's a repository of one million pieces of code that an evolved monkey banged out in two hours" is a problem.

5/5, account is now locked


Yeah, I also question if this has anything to do with open source. Open source solutions have been around for decades, heck React has been open source for 13 years.

AI has allowed us to scale development effort massively - and shows the same weaknesses as scaling human teams too quickly - planning, verification/testing and code fragmentation become issues almost immediately.


I have seen mostly engineers complain that management wouldn't stop paying for the new whizz-bang thingy.

I do embedded. I’ve always marveled at how ludicrous that “real software” is. I have truths. I have registers that will never be or act differently, I can make pretty damn good assumptions that no one will put this code somewhere else’s etc.

In the past few years though, it’s been creeping into my domain too.


>I have registers that will never be or act differently

Even this needs a qualifier. Radiation exposure can cause bit flips. Certain aerospace applications must address this, and even some earth-bound applications at high altitude.


At high altitude or high deployment numbers. Hyper scaler data centers measure these “one in a million” anomalies in thousands of times per hour.

Yeah, don't we have error correcting RAM for this reason, here on Earth?

Sure, but RAM isn’t the only place a bit can flip. Registers are a thing. IBM had error correction in Power architecture CPU registers, not sure where AMD, Intel, or Apple (lol) are on that issue. IIRC register bit flips first came up with Sun SPARC hardware, which Sun mitigated, but of course SPARC isn’t used too much these days…

A quick AI-assisted search informs me that neither AMD nor Intel document any on-CPU error correction, though perhaps there is some. Apple currently has zero systems that even use ECC, which seems insane to me given they’re shipping systems with up to 512 GB of RAM.

This seems to be an issue that’s falling through the cracks again. I guess nothing will be done until there’s a critical failure due to a bit flip, and verifying that was the cause for a given problem is difficult.

On ECC, Apple needs to Think Different (tm). Maybe it should introduce actual “Pro” machines…


Besides, chip bugs are famous since the Pentium, and unreliable circuits are the normal way to describe circuits, you have to add notice when you get a reliable one.

That's why we do requirement gathering and analysis. Engineering is always about tradeoffs and things that matters in certain context don't in others. The issue is that in a lot of orgs, while there's a record of decisions, we don't usually track assumptions and the overall system is full of contradictions. Also there's no overall keeper of knowledge (either one person or a team) that periodically ensure that contradictions are kept at minimum.

A decade ago there was a huge culture around having 100% uptime, nowadays it seems that not only is lower uptime acceptable, but services need to have some downtime and break when they are not profitable. Filtering out the undesirable users and upgrading them to plans with better economics is a new requirement in this age that wasn't present before during the growth stage and freemium VC backed startups

Well, yes, but the proportion of systemic level broken stuffs might have change a bit. Just like, ok, there was always rule34 lurking to make dirty everything innocent that remained of the untainted child memory one had.

Now it’s somehow guarantied that the volume of dirtied quickly prompted version of anything anyone ever cherished far exceed the scarce outcomes of the original.


I don't get this thing where people are allergic to the idea that change can happen.

No matter what's trending worse there's always this thought terminating phantom law of conservation of everything. The fact that something is not an entirely new bespoke phenomenon always turns into denial that it could be happening more often or in a newly qualitatively worse way.


There are certainly people at CIA and other intelligence agencies who focus entirely on which refinery parts are on the Pareto frontier of easiest to destroy, hardest to replace, and most important to functionality.

Ukraine has their own refineries, I'm sure their intelligence agencies could approach any number of resident experts without needing outside help.

While that’s certainly true, it is not a guarantee. International industrial supply chains are complex, and Ukraine’s top military intelligence people undoubtedly have their hands full. What’s clear is that western intelligence assistance is hugely valuable for their war effort.

The good news is this outage is not impacting approach or ground control so you’re safe.

John Wayne, a class C (the approach mentioned above) isn't even letting VFRs go. If it's actually limited to ARTCC I don't know why that would be.

Except some airports haven't enough free gates for disembarking as planes that wanted to take off were denied. So they tried to go back to their gates. As a result some planes in the air are being diverted to less-busy airports.

Sounds safe, just extremely inconvenient.

Thanks, bud - very reassuring that some minimum bid contract shop built something on a “secure” network they can’t even keep up.

Netflix isn’t widely reported to be hacking systems left right and center.

Technically, you do not need radios. There are many many uncontrolled airports in the United States, where you can technically fly around without establishing two-way radio communication. It’s doable, but I don’t know if that’s even a scenario pilots test in the simulator during their semiannual trainings.

Most air traffic is IFR. You definitely need radio for IFR traffic in for deconfliction in most of the world. (There's a few exceptions in very remote places, but that's mostly academic.) Even legacy procedural (non-radar) separation assumes you have working radio, and a radio failure is an emergency.

VFR traffic doesn't necessarily need radio, and is not affected by this groundstop.


You don’t need radio for IFR (as the whole point of a flight plan is that if you lose contact you continue to fly your plan). But you kind of do need radar.

You actually don't need radar, and ATC can do non-radar "procedural" control where they block off sections of airways or entire airports, one-in one-out at a time, like sections of railroad track. There are still a few parts of the remote US, as well as large sections of Northern Canada, where radar coverage is nonexistant and ATC is done via procedural control. Radar outages also happen on occasion, which would necessitate this.

As for lack of radio, this would only work if ATC blocked out your entire route from start to finish - which isn't practically ever done. Otherwise, they need to be able to maintain positive control over your flight since the airspace isn't reserved, which means conflicts are possible.

If you lose radio communication, it's an emergency and they'll move everyone out of your way. This doesn't work very well if everyone loses radio communication simultaneously.


Right, but isn't a lot of that necessary radio aircraft-to-aircraft, like ADS-B? Obviously not ideal, but I thought IFR traffic could feasibly maintain separation without ATC help.

ADS-B can't legally be used to maintain separation. It's only approved for use as an aid to awareness for additional safety.

Could you in an emergency, if you had no other options? Yes. But ATC can't legally give you a clearance that was dependent on using ADS-B for separation.

(Similarly, if there's a potential traffic conflict, and you tell ATC you see the other traffic on your ADS-B display, they just have to disregard that statement and assume that you can't see the other aircraft at all.)


Interesting, thanks.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: