Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | MBCook's commentslogin

The only complaint I’ve seen is that the full disk access dialog is scary.

Well ok? Full disk access is EVERYTHING. Keys to the kingdom. If it’s not encrypted (and some of Apple’s stuff isn’t that should be) then apps that have the permission can anything.

Before that wasn’t the worst thing in the world, most apps didn’t care. But now we have LLMs. And suddenly people are realizing just how creepy full disk access really is.

So I agree. This is a great change.


I think a lot of apps do it just to avoid all the different prompts. It’s probably easier to get the average person to say yes to that than to have to go through each one over time.

Can I see your documents? Your downloads? Your home folder? Your desktop?

And it’s not like they all happen at once. Every time you go to open a file, it randomly asks you if it’s somewhere they haven’t done it before. Maybe because they’re not using the system open save dialogue, which automatically grants access to that one file.

I like that macOS has these facilities. But the existing dichotomy of all or nothing + 30 prompts just didn’t work well.


On my personal Linux machines, the only four (non-hidden) directories in my home directory are `code`, `Downloads`, `dotfiles`, and `Dropbox` (and I'd put the last one somewhere else, except it only lets me pick the directory for where something called `Dropbox` is rather than rename it, and since I kind of hate having capital letter named directories I ended up deciding years ago that I'd just keep it next to Downloads and it would be less annoying).

On the MacBook my work gave me, there are a ton of extra directories that I would vastly prefer to relocate somewhere else in a combined way (Pictures, Videos, Documents, etc.) that I'd have to separately configure a bunch of things to not dump stuff in, which I could do, but then I'd also have to fix all of the half dozen permissions on every app require access to any them. This is all doable (I assume? maybe there's truly no way to stop stuff from going into those directories by default, but I'm assuming that there's probably some esoteric setting somewhere), but my point is that the way they've designed it not only adds a bunch of initial prompts for when you start using stuff on a system across directories that realistically do not have different security concerns, but they haven't bothered to make it any easier if you ever want to change something in the future. I understand that this is a niche concern for power users, but it's absolutely wild to me how MacOS continues to find new ways to get in the way of me compared to Linux as the years go on.


That model is still fairly broken, you can ask for all of the specific perms and there is still a ton of stuff that isn't covered and requires full disk access. So even if you want to use all the prompts when needed at time of action, you still cannot as a dev.

It does not have to be perfect. And really, it cannot be. There will always be corner cases. If it works in most cases, I am happy to enable full access for apps that really need it. I am not going to do it for 100 apps, and I am not going to do it if the app fits one of the cases where it does work, either.

As a developer, it’s another set of hoops to jump through. As a user, I am happy that there are some guardrails (that I can disable).


How much of this is that we even allow these claims in the first place?

Is this a much smaller problem in countries that don’t allow homeopathy or off label/unverified claims?


I’ve never heard of Laetrile before. The Wikipedia article on Amygdalin, which it’s a derivative of, covers it well.

A chemical that metabolizes into cyanide, which people climate is a vitamin and “cures cancer”.

What a mess. So much horrible “alternative medicine” hokum out there.


I have no idea about this one, but isn’t chemotherapy also quite the toxic cocktail? Scientific rigor back then was also a bit hit and miss. I’m not trying to imply anything here, but your condemnation seems a bit strong.

Yes, the way chemo works is by poisoning the cancer, but importantly the poisons specifically attack cancer more aggressively than normal cells. Cyanide doesn't work like that at all, it's untargeted and will just kill you without doing anything about the cancer.

I don't think the poisons necessarily attack cancer more aggressively. Cancer just suffers more aggressively. Subtle difference, but I believe most chemos work by being just poisonous enough to everything (eg by inhibiting cell division) that cancer is the first to die out. Sometimes just barely.

Zidovudine (AZT) might be another useful analogy.

Which, to be fair, will subsequently kill the cancer.


ClF3 best broad-spectrum antiseptic.

subsequently indeed. if i had cancer i would rather it be the other way around.

If that is your target, a 9mm gun would achieve the same result much faster.

It's the same as a fever: raise the temperature until disease cells die off, hopefully before you cook your eyes, or parts of your brain, or your heart. It's a valid tactic, as long as it's properly managed.

I find the condemnation completely appropriate: there's way too many frauds and snake oil salesmen in it, out for profit at the whatever the cost. Antivaxxers, "naturopathic doctors", and so forth. Now everyone's opinion is as valid as a licensed doctor's, or a professional researcher's.


The condemnation needs to be very strong. People fall into the trap of seeing similar things and doing false equivalences like you just did. “I’m not trying to imply” does not disqualify the implication you most definitely made.

Chemo is toxic but it kills the cancer first. That doesn’t land in the same category of things that just kill you.

Evidence-based medicine is the only thing that can split the two and continue to move us away from blood lettings and massaging feet to clear up asthma. It is much newer than science in general so all of the woo needs to be aggressively quashed.


>Evidence..

All evidence (second hand of course) is prone to manipulation and censoring.

So "evidence" is just suggestive, not the last word. Acting like it is would just create the same evil, but in a much larger scale (because there is "evidence" or "no evidence"), that you are trying to prevent.


The practice of science that gives us (or discredits) medicines is the same practice that created the machine you are using to spew this anti-science theory. Smart phones exist as the result of two hundred years of materials SCIENCE progress.

You don’t get from blacksmithing to Moore’s Law without science.

Do you brush your teeth? Have you gotten cavities anyway? Should you stop brushing then? No, because it’s the best thing we know to do. And like a thousand things you do every week without thinking much about, we do our best until we can prove that something else is better. And even then, “better” may be expensive. So it’s still a trade off.


lol..no further comments.

>Do you brush your teeth?

It is great that you bring this up. What does science say about plastics? It is bad for your body?

But what is the first thing that "science" tells us to put in our mouth in the morning? Yea, a plastic brush!

Yea, that is right, all the "progress" that you listed. Science didn't do them. ECONOMICS did. If economy does not allow, then your beloved "science" can't do shit.


> continue to move us away from blood lettings and massaging feet to clear up asthma

saying these in the same sentence is funny to me. even if the massaging of feet doesn't clear up asthma, you at least are nice and relaxed. nothing wrong with that even if it doesn't do the claim.


While bloodletting (with leeches even!) is actually a genuine treatment.

For very specific issues, narrowly applied and supervised with leeches that have been ensured to be disease-free.

That's a far cry from "we don't really know what ails you, probably too much blood", but it's still funny.


Hemochromatosis patients are advised to donate blood routinely to control their symptoms. And you can lower the amount of heavy metals in your body by donating blood. Though I don’t know if the recipient would be happy to know that.

Knocking people out has many advantages, but only in certain well defined scenarios. Bloodletting was used in mostly the wrong ones, which is why it’s a perennial favorite of rationalists.


Opportunity costs.

“Hey it doesn’t cure a heart attack to drink water but at least I’m not thirsty,” is the same sentiment but with more obvious consequences.


You know people can die from asthma attacks, right? Some reflexologist claiming they can cure you so you give up the inhaler and die is what we’re talking about when you pretend alternative medicine is an actual alternative. There is most certainly something “wrong with that”.

> isn’t chemotherapy also quite the toxic cocktail?

Yes. Chemo tries to kill the cancer faster than it kills the host.

Cyanide just kills everything.


That was one of the most absurd dichotomies I encountered. The nurse giving you the infusion walks out with a splash guard, gloved and gowned, carrying basically a hazmat bag that they have to double check and match all the numbers on, and then they just hook it up to your vein and pour it straight in.


While there are/were some Nobel laureates bitten by the quackery bug, laterite origin and promotion has all the requirements of a snake oil being developed by unsuccessful reject with zero credentials and shady biznesses.

What do they call alternative medicine that works?

Medicine.


There's lots of stuff that absolutely does have clear clinical benefit but isn't really 'formalized' as medicine. For instance - ginger. And vice versa, there's examples like aducanumab [1] that's an approved medicine, but also doesn't work, and was known not to work when it was approved.

Extremist takes tend to be wrong on most things. On any issue worth debating, there's always going to be plenty of nuance in the grey zone.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aducanumab#Efficacy


You’re confusing corporate greed with scientific/medical rigor.

That we haven’t been able to control the former is being turned into misplaced distrust of the latter.


Framing these things as distinct doesn't make much sense when the former plays a major role in getting to decide what is studied (via funding) by the latter, and consequently plays a major role in the career success or failure of the latter. They're inextricably intertwined in the current system where medicine is driven largely by a profit motive, and that's a problem.

The right wing wants to disparage real medicine not because alternative medicine is better (or even useful), but because they want people to be ok with reducing spending on real medicine.

No, it's because they peddle Confidently Incorrect, and waging war on anyone who even suspects they might have an objectively correct answer serves that purpose.

Their constituents don't like how complicated the world gets. They want someone to tell them that all of that complexity is an illusion and we can fix it by getting rid of rules and people who don't look like us (diversity = complexity).

Their favorite thing in a debate is to get the other side to say, "it depends".

Which is extra weird because most of their voters are old enough to know for sure that the person at work who says that is the one everybody trusts.


I thought in these trite partisan takes that 'the right wing' was all about big business? And there is scarcely a business bigger than big pharma.

Dataset of one, but ginger is the first thing I reach for if I feel like I'm going to chunder.

Traditionally it's also used for cold/flu type stuff both as a prophylactic and a treatment. Works excellently. Or the next time you have a sore throat try a ginger shot. It knocks it right out. I'm not sure how the extremist types reconcile China now having a life expectancy greater than the US even as huge chunks of Chinese still use traditional Chinese medicine. [1]

I'm certainly not arguing that TCM is universally effective (or even mostly effective), but rather that all medical systems have their pros and cons. Western medicine is driven primarily by profit which can result in promoting ineffective medicines and ignoring effective but unprofitable treatments. The outcomes we 'should' have with the idealization of Western medicine are far away from the ones that we do have. Medicine and a profit motive just really don't work well together.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traditional_Chinese_medicine


Eh, if only. Medicine is inseparable from business incentives. And since it's a highly regulated industry, they can only cover the costs when something generates a lot of revenue. And there are many reasons why something might not generate enough revenue, even if it works.

It's only medicine if a pharmaceutical company invents it. Otherwise, it's an herbal remedy. It's almost like you know nothing about western medicine.

Much like .45 aspirin, it'll fix what ails you. Permanently.

There’s a lot of people who needed to get from A to B.

Without planes, lots of them probably just tried to rush to Amtrak and they received a volume they’ve never seen in a very short order.

I doubt there is anything more complicated than that.


Which is why I started with “while most likely”

To actually answer your question, I would be highly surprised if the amtrack ticket booking system had much technical overlap with what led to the ground stop.

How is there not a second backup network???

Cue that line from DS9 where O’Brien says he’d never be caught without a secondary backup during a fight, and the cardassian is like “you have a second backup?” incredulously. https://youtu.be/o7o9ZtipVyo?is=y3for_WXwISmuqpd

I wouldn’t say anything but this is approximately the only time in my entire life this scene will be relevant.


I remember that scene, but I can’t believe that you had it at the front of your memory like that. That’s awesome.

There are people who literally live for this shit, you know. I have friends who have puns lined up for 1000+ situations.

The more time I spend working in tech, the more I realize that everything important is held together with cardboard and duct tape.

That's because everything really important is not just tech but a socio-technical system of tech+humans operating/building/maintaining that thing. A lot of the things can't/shouldn't be automated with tech (see the Irony of Automations paper) – they are up and running thanks to the resilience (socio-technical quality) which appears as a "cardboard and duct tape" for untrained eye.

True for every industry / field I've worked in, unfortunately (which is more than I'd like to admit).

You had duct tape? Lucky!

Any time people freak out about these kinds of things and assume the absolute worse, I just tell them I’m surprised these things don’t happen more often

Why only “one” network at all!?

The Internet was purpose designed to tolerate disruption as major as a nuclear war, which it achieves through decentralisation.

Private networks exist to make idiot managers feel more confident while actually dramatically reducing availability by putting all their eggs into a single basket.


Many aviation systems predate the internet. Depending on the region, some systems do not use Internet Protocol, let alone TCP.

The FAA Telecommunications Infrastructure (FTI) operated by L3harris was built between 2002 to 2007.

That is already well within the era of IPv6, let alone "the Internet".

There's no excuse.


For something so incredibly critical in real time, I’m not sure I would want to trust the Internet.

When was the last time the Internet "went down" globally?

The last time the internet caused flight outages was September 22nd of this year.

Over what area? Localised, nation-wide, or global?

thats like mandating using I-95 for all ambulance & firefighter traffic

Isn't using a private network like mandating using I-95 (since it might be blocked from a freak accident one day), while using the internet, with redundant paths between hosts, like allowing the traffic to find the best path?

The internet is pretty unreliable as it goes, and the internet in your locality is probably only one network (e.g. Comcast's) - what are you gaining by running critical systems over Comcast internet access, instead of Comcast leased line? Saving a few hundred bucks a month, yes, but that's because you're getting less reliability than you actually need.

Also lower MTTR and more robust SLAs in many cases. Business services will usually result in service credits being issued if the SLO is breached. Residential... not so much.

One network can be a fully redundant design with multiple geographically distinct links and so on.

But it does not make it 100% resilient to cascading failures or possible Layer2/3 loops that might happen during a software upgrade, especially in a country wide deployment.

The FAA will give a root cause at some point of why this happenned.


Think of all those pilots timing out on the tarmac.

Not exactly. They’re not your tokens, they’re the user’s tokens. If those are different people.

Your app uses tokens when it goes to private cloud compute tied to the user’s iCloud account. I don’t think anyone knows what the limit is, we only know that higher iCloud plans bring higher limits.

It’s all very fuzzy right now as this is brand new and I think they’re just trying to incentivize development rather than risk strangling it out of the gate.


I’m not sure I’ve really seen it within the community of programmers. It was certainly more there early on when the models were much worse, but I’ve seen it fading.

I have seen it among “the general public“. I’ve seen normal people complain about things in open-source projects or other contexts where to whatever degree they accepted programming took time before now they think it’s all just a magic wand with Claude, no matter the level of complexity.

I haven’t heard a single person at my company in management at any layer complain that we’re not working fast enough now that we have AI. One of my friends has 100% told me their management is pulling that. The management over there is on the everyone should do four times as many tickets, and use at least X amount of tokens per day. otherwise you’re slacking off train.

It’s all in who you talk to.


I think it's an age thing as well.

Engineers that have only started full time work post 2023 haven't experienced the counterfactual of not having AI.

They see all the mundane business/eng bottlenecks that are pervasive now and don't truly know how much better it is now than before


I think a large part of it is that the programmers that aren’t using AI have already been fired or pushed out of the industry in other ways.

The programmers who are left is an artificial selection of AI boosters.


That’s not the case at my company at all. It’s available to use but they’re not forcing it or firing people who aren’t using it. It’s just a tool we can use.

If you follow various data sources like the StackOverflow developer survey or DORA from 2023 onwards, by this theory about 77% - 90% have been fired or pushed out of the industry.

That’s my immediate thought.

As we’ve seen happening in the open source projects with the piles of bugs being reported to them so much of what’s going on doesn’t seem to be new features, but just longstanding technical debt coming to the fore.

Maybe AI can’t write that new feature for us really fast. Maybe we asked. Maybe the code was complete garbage and it made it clear we really don’t want to keep piling on top of it and need to fix the issues we’ve known about for a long time. Adding new features at the old pace was a problem. We can’t handle the new.

Between that and the fact that some kinds of tech debt are much easier to pay off now that’s where a lot of our “new capacity” is going. Shoring things up.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: