There's no way that it hasn't existed for infinity, for the value where universe = literally everything. It can't come from nothing, so it has always existed. I am obviously not aware of the formal definition of universe, considering there are theories of our universe being one of many bubbling in the cosmic foam.
> There's no way that it hasn't existed for infinity
I'm not disagreeing, but this is _slightly_ shifting the goal posts. When scientists in this field talk about the 'age of the universe', it's nearly always the short form of 'the time distance from now back to the big bang, beyond which there is no way to see beyond'.
Sure, I explicitly shifted them from formal physics definitions, where "nothing" is actually "something", e.g. in the case of your cited book, the "nothing" is still a set of quantum laws and fields. How did those arise?
IIUC, There is no good reason to believe that they 'arose' at all, or inversely no good reason believe that they did not. It is likely unknowable. We don't know that there ever _could_ be a 'nothing' void of fields, etc. No one has demonstrated either that such a situation could arise, and no one has demonstrated that such a situation is necessary.
I'm not sure I understand the question. Let me try to fill in a longer form of your question because I suspect it's a tautology in longer form. Please correct me if I'm misrepresenting your question:
[A 'nothing' void of fields] would [by] definition be necessary if there was a [event where the universe spontaneously emerged from a 'nothing' void of fields] (which is NOT the same thing as the big bang).
Assuming that's a reasonable statement, then sure, but only because you've sort of defined the situation into existence for no good reason, with no explanatory power, with no supporting evidence, etc. Again, there doesn't seem to be any good reason to think such a state can/would ever exist.
It's always worth remembering that our sample size of universes is 1, and our understanding of that single sample has pretty severe limits on our ability to see past the big bang. Can a universe emerge from 'nothing' (in the non-krauss sense)? I'm not sure such a state even makes sense to talk about, and I think that is generally the consensus, that there is either _something_ (which doesn't necessarily involve matter, but does involve our understanding of physics and potentially allows for a universe to pop into existence), and to speak of 'nothing' that is truly devoid of anything, doesn't make sense to speak about since without physics and fields and whatnot, I'm not sure you have the concept of casuality, so I'm not sure we could _ever_ talk about that 'nothing' as being anything that something emerged _from_. It cannot be a state in chain of events (nothing -> something) unless you have physics/fields/whatnot, and so now you're back to Krauss's nothing.
It's an interesting concept that I read a few years ago on HN. Basically, if you add 1 to a number, you get a bigger number. You never get to infinity. You can keep doing this until the heat death of the universe, and you still won't get to infinity. So why do we think infinities exist? We know the universe started, it's reasonable to conclude it will also end, and is therefore not infinite. And if the universe is not infinite, it cannot contain infinities, by definition. Which matches our observations; we don't see any infinities in the universe.
Time is part of spacetime, and spacetime is a property of this universe. So there's no "when" or "where" outside the universe. So it doesn't make any sense to talk about "before" the universe. Time started when the universe started. Causality is a property of time; one thing follows from another because of time. If there's no time, there can't be any causality.
> How could it start from absolutely nothing?
So this question doesn't really make any sense. There's no other way it could have started, because the very concept of "nothing" and "started" didn't apply outside of the thing we're saying started (sorry, it gets very difficult to talk about this using a language so firmly grounded in time). It doesn't make any sense to ask what caused the universe because causality itself is a property of the universe.
Like I said, interesting concept and thought. I have no idea if it actually describes reality.
What always confuses me about Anthropic is them insisting that they need more compute.
This feels wrong in several ways:
a) they're certainly not addressing their customers like they're compute-limited. One must ask, what would that look like? For one, I think it'd look like a wait list to sign up. It'd look like prices going _higher_, and not lower
b) IIUC, their revenues don't cover their _current_ compute costs. So, let's pretend coreweave magics up a new dc and hands it over to anthropic, which means presumably anthropic needs to start paying for it. How does that affect anthropic's revenue? AFAICT, it just adds costs, it doesn't make their revenue go up.
The only interpretation I can find is if Anthropic is _convinced_ that they need to train faster/harder, and that doing so would somehow significantly shift their TAM or costs, for example by coming up with a model that was simply 10+ years ahead of anyone else that costs the same as opus 5.5 to run, and they instantly nab the entirety of openai's market share. Seems pretty unlikely.
Anthropic’s unit economics are really good, so I don’t think (b) is true. Point (a) may be valid, but they’ve also grown consistently, and even their slower growth rate in Q3 of this year is still very strong. To keep up growth, they likely need to procure compute months ahead of time as well, so it makes sense for them to do this before they are actually limited.
I assume some of this is the escalating cost of training, indeed, and that being faster means abandoning efficiency.
But you’re right. I have often wondered why it is that such a small amount of extra compute (300MW) from SpaceX was entirely enough for them to uncap so many customers.
I think the (in-house) data centre burdens of ever-more complex models may be considerable, but I think the data centre businesses expecting to serve inference tasks are probably heading into a Chinese real estate bubble.
I'd be quite worried about your name being too similar to Symantec (now part of broadcom, but the brand is apparently being preserved to some degree): https://sep.securitycloud.symantec.com/v2/landing
Firmware validation isn't particularly close to symantec's products from my perspective, but I'm sure a lawyer would be happy to disagree for the right retainer.
Thank you! We will have to look into that, but theres actually an even closer to our name that we get auto-corrected to. if you really want to see how crowded naming is... just google "simantic". Our SEO goals truly need to peak to get through
we have thought about it, but its a name we came up ourselves, fits the bill and we have the domain for it. Can't ask for much more. its pretty rare for google to be our inbound and when we get to that point we would probably overtake that in SEO anyway
So I see an interesting side effect of all of this in your comment. The groupthink seems to conclude that the root of GH's issues are:
- A dramatic increase in its traffic due to vibecoding
- Azure just generally not being very reliable
Now, if you're not a paying customer, maybe you just ignore this and chalk it up to "I'm getting what I paid for". And if you're a paying customer, you migrate away. What happens to GH then? Well, you (and other paying customers) are probably only a small part of the first of the identified causes, and not at all a contributor to the second. So it's not like you moving away will make GH more reliable, but it does lessen MS's motivations for fixing things: GH as a business unit works by having a free tier and a premium tier and that's fine as long as the profit from the premium tier exceeds the cost of the free tier.
THat's long winded way of saying: I wonder if you/other paying customers leaving is the real start of a GH death spiral. Less paying customers == less MS investment == less paying customers == less MS investment, etc.
For us it's not just about reliability, but risk exposure. The last couple of years really changed what our security model looks like. And it's not in public clouds, on SaaS products. LLMs are killing SaaS for sure, not by replacing them but making them a concentrated risk.
> A human proof won't just be logically correct, it will be cognitively distilled and coherent. It may still take years to understand it, but the logical flow will be straightforward, not obfuscated.
Not a counterpoint, actually case in point, because:
>Mochizuki and a few other mathematicians claim that the theory indeed yields such a proof but this has so far not been accepted by the mathematical community.
Man, I wonder how many facebook marketplace sales will be something like "In order to make sure you're a real person, before we can meet up so I can hand over this brand new macbook for $500 I need you to send me $10 electronically. It's really just to verify your commitment". With the right prompting, I'd be entirely unsurprised if Muse will just send over the $10, and of course the seller ghosts the buyer -_-
I've sold a few things on marketplace and have got some strange requests from buyers that i think are AI. I was selling a piece of exercise equipment that has a screen attached to it (rowing machine) and got a request to take a picture with a tape measure to verify the screen dimensions. The product is only sold with one screen size and it was plainly visible in the listing pictures too.
That could be either lazy buyer or someone who's had a seller tell them wrong dimensions or wrong model for the item. Someone I know from college told me a couple years about how they lied to a buyer about the cheap wayfair furniture was actually part of a sample sale from a big name brand. I usually ask the seller for any info thats make or break for me, but I also reverse google image search the listing photos to make it easier for myself though.
My version of this theory is that we already have AGI, but Altman/Amodei/Zuck keep asking it for an infinite money glitch and it keeps (correctly!) saying "no money, humanity is fucked given the trajectory, and you in particular will be fucked once the general public decides that you're the scapegoat". A/A/Z decides the AGI is wrong of course, so obviously dumping another billion into training or reinforcement or tagging or whatever is the next step.
Not any reputable ones. The consensus on the estimated age of the universe has shifted only slightly in the last several decades.
reply