Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Scaled's commentslogin

I'm in the paranoid camp. I've always wondered who in their right mind sends profit data upstream when it's exactly what the networks need to push margins down. Maybe Google and the others don't actually use that for ill intent, but they don't exactly have trustworthy reputations. If it came out tomorrow that they were using the data to inflate their margin, no one would be surprised.

Google and Meta have also both been caught in advertising shenanigans -- I forget the details but I recall getting some (tiny) class action settlement check.

Link previews should ideally be fetched server side and then you would get the best of both worlds. I wish synapse would support that.


Great find, I'll be enabling this, thanks!

If you stop logging in regularly to the other ones, people eventually move over when they don't want to wait a day or two for a response. Just make it clear you're only on matrix 24/7, anything else you're just not active on. (Which means uninstall the mobile apps, too.)

Also, Discord's id scan rollout was extremely effective in motivating my friend group. I don't think any of them even got directly hit by it (yet), but we've all had other issues with their faulty AI bans and account flags and losing accounts due to them that it wasn't a tough sell for us.


I know people who switched to whatever app flavor of the day it was when they switched. I just never talked to them anymore. I'm not installing 5 other apps because some person decided to use while the rest of the world is still on the other app.

Depends on what you value more I guess.

The person leaving values the continued communication just as little, so these sorts of problems are usually non consequential.

I have a dozen message apps on my phone, but I run graphene so I don't worry as much with them each being sandboxed. Oddly ElementX is the only one I have notification issues with.

I get a notification from somebody which opens the app and I can read it.


> Quad9 is 100% opposed to piracy, but the DNS is the wrong place to try to attack that problem

Can you elaborate on where you would like to attack the problem? Because Cloudflare (as discussed elsewhere in this thread) is a notorious enabler of major piracy sites (and even profits from providing services to them). Domain registrars favored by pirates usually don't want to get involved, and neither do Internet transit providers.

Essentially, the companies who directly or indirectly facilitate and profit from piracy wants to point the finger at the host -- who is inevitably an internationally located bulletproof provider, who refuses to take any action since that's their entire business model. Everyone else in the chain want to play dumb, as if they're not involved.

It seems to me that every company involved and profiting off piracy should have a duty to take steps to minimize the further harm they cause to content creators when they are properly made aware of illegal content.


To quote Gabe, "Piracy is a service issue"

Stop trying to solve piracy by chasing every link in the chain in ever more frustrating ways demanding they solve your issue.

Accept a few core things

1. 0% piracy is impossible.

2. You can significantly reduce piracy by making your content easy to access for everyone and charging a fair price (see also steam).

3. You cannot demand both no piracy and carve out weird regional or international rules for your content.

Piracy was down globally after streaming became mainstream and cheap, it's only coming back now because of greed and the splintering of content into different platforms.


Exactly. The paid product needs to be better and more convenient than the free.

This is what happens when the opposite starts to again become true


May I add not only accessing content but owning it, and by owning I don't mean licensing. Licensing is cancer and it will spread to something you hold dear, be it gaming, books, audio books, blu ray, whatever. Or rather already has.

But it's not just about piracy, also plenty of other stuff that is illegal.

Product costs too much so it's morally justified to steal it? That's victim blaming. Though it does seem to make pirates feel better about their crimes to do so. It's a common fallacy among pirates.

The reality is the early streaming economics were not sustainable. Netflix was operating at a significant loss due to massive investments in content production. Prices inevitably had to go up. Similarly, fracturing was inevitable as other studios faced the same profitability issues.

Pirates live in this world where they've convinced themselves they somehow know better than the content producers, and simple business realities are reduced to 'greed'. And yet those same pirates would cry foul if their own pay was withheld from them.


> The reality is the early streaming economics were not sustainable. Netflix was operating at a significant loss due to massive investments in content production. Prices inevitably had to go up.

In other words: Netflix was practicing predatory pricing [0] and would never have become a quarter-trillion company without it?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predatory_pricing


Since the losses were on content production, then at most you could say they have predatory pricing on netflix originals, which seems silly to worry about since that's such a small part of the market.

If their revenue covered licensing plus hosting, the price wasn't causing any significant problems.


If buying isn't owning, then piracy isn't stealing

Attack it at the pirates. EU already has KYC laws for hosting companies.

Should we hold the steel industry responsible for gun control since they indirectly profit from gun sales?

A better analogy would be should we hold shipping companies liable if their services are used to ship guns illegally, and yes, there are quite a few rules to deter that.

Edit - an even simpler and more direct analog: if Cloudflare was knowingly providing services to a site that let you order illegal guns, the ATF would absolutely be able to take action against Cloudflare and it's executives.


> A better analogy would be should we hold shipping companies liable if their services are used to ship guns illegally, and yes, there are quite a few rules to deter that.

Poor analogy - DNS providers aren't shipping pirated material to the end-user. They just provide the address. They don't ship anything.


Well, guns are legal though. Even in countries with strict gun regulations you can still buy guns legally.

So is the internet.

Where do you live where DNS is illegal?

> Can you elaborate on where you would like to attack the problem?

Not having an answer to this question does not make the assertion "This is the wrong place to attack the problem" wrong in any way.[1]

So, worst-case scenario, no one has an answer to your question, but that doesn't invalidate the assertion anyway, so why ask the question?

I also find it hilarious that trillion dollar companies can strip-mine all of human creation and sell it back to humanity for a profit while devaluing labour, but the minute someone is copying movies, with almost no negative effect on anyone else, suddenly laws are required.

------------------

[1] After all, we can also attack the problem by requiring everyone get government permission to use their computers, or handover all credentials on their computer to their government, but you wouldn't produce the asinine response "If not on the user's computer, then where do you recommend we attack the problem?" Just because someone points out that an idea is bad does not mean that they also need to provide a better solution. Just saying "This is a bad idea" is sufficient.


Cloudflare continues to shield major piracy sites while directly profiting from them -- including massive piracy sites that directly target small content creators. Cloudflare does this with direct knowledge that they are beyond the reach of the law... for now.

But eventually this behavior is going to backfire for everyone when Section 230 has to be reduced to account for it.


> Cloudflare continues to shield major piracy sites while directly profiting from them -- including massive piracy sites that directly target small content creators. Cloudflare does this with direct knowledge that they are beyond the reach of the law... for now.

Small content providers (a group that I am a member of, but I doubt that you are) already have had their revenue slashed due to LLM training off them, then providing the results to end-users for profit.

> But eventually this behavior is going to backfire for everyone when Section 230 has to be reduced to account for it.

You are very confused; section 230 is for hosters. DNS providers typically don't also host any pirated material. If they do, you can go after them as hosters, not as DNS providers.


> Small content providers (a group that I am a member of, but I doubt that you are) already have had their revenue slashed due to LLM training off them, then providing the results to end-users for profit.

I don't see how this is relevant to the discussion.


Really? You're going to make the (irrelevant/ad hominem) argument, based on zero data, that you're not talking to a small content creator on this site of all places? A social media site that is heavily populated by startup founders? Wild swing.

They're not beyond the reach of the law. You can get an injunction against Cloudflare to shut down one of those sites just like beIN did. In most European countries you'd even get your legal costs refunded by Cloudflare.

In the US, it would be impractical to get court orders for every piracy url as you don't get legal costs refunded. It's cool EU does this though, and is something US should adopt.

Section 230 doesn’t apply to copyright infringement. You’re thinking of DMCA.

Section 230 is section 230 of the DMCA.

You’re confused. Section 230 of the CDA (Communications Decency Act) relates to user-generated content like social media postings that, among other things, protects the website owner (content host) from liability for defamation. DMCA doesn’t have a Section 230.

It is really irritating that organizations have started considering phone plans (voip vs prepaid vs postpaid) as fraud signals. This likely has something to do with information sharing agreements that each of the big wireless providers offer to sell your data. Really feels like yet another way for governments/companies to punish people who value privacy.

> This likely has something to do with [selling your data]

It seems much more likely it has to do with certain phone plans having drastically higher rates of fraud.


Certain neighborhoods have drastically higher rates of crime. That doesn't make it okay to treat everyone from there as a criminal.

(Or in this case, disenfranchise them of access to government services.)


Unlike a private business, who can decide not to do business in the high crime district, the federal government needs to serve every single citizen.

Whether it's OK is mostly unrelated to whether it's the reason it's done.

I uh have some news for you.

Shipping address is absolutely used as a fraud signal.


Yes, but not by USPS. You won’t get your mail undelivered just because you live in a sketchy zip code.

That’s the main difference between government-ran services and the private sector. The government has to service you if that’s their commitment, even if it costs lots of money or is stupid. Otherwise it’s disenfranchisement or even a free speech issue.


You’re making several logic errors.

“Treat everyone from there as a criminal”. You’re not being treated as a criminal you just can’t use a VoIP number.

And for your example, if the neighborhood was known for car thefts, and a major theft happened, it would make sense to assume your suspect is from that neighborhood.


No, it wouldn’t “make sense”, it would be “prejudicial”.

If you were building an ice cream shop and you do market research and discover a neighborhood has a higher than average ice cream intake, is it prejudicial to build your ice cream shop there?

Recognizing that a high rate of fraud comes from VoIP and then refusing VoIP is similar.


What about banning people from visiting your ice cream shop if they live in a certain area?

False equivalence. The more likely scenario is banning people who don’t wear shirt or shoes or who carry themselves in a certain way or behave poorly like a VoIP service

Being against this is like being against spam filters "just because it has all these spammy keywords doesn't mean it's spam". Granted, maybe the government should provide universal service but banning VoIP numbers is not ridiculous.

Well I would say that calling that "prejudicial" is walking into dangerous territory. By all accounts, from a statistical perspective, it only makes sense in this scenario to suspect some more than others.

Not it wouldn’t be, it would be entirely logical.

Well it's a good thing we're not talking about that then.

Those two things are not the same.

They are the same, and both are largely due to decades of redlining and disenfranchisement and convincing people like you that redlining stopped.

Of course they aren't: it's an analogy, as you know. If you'd like to argue the point, you'll need to actually say something.

That may be, but nobody but you and your phone carrier should have access to information about your plan.

  security = 1 / convenience
in this case convenience is not for the "customer"

You are being too optimistic:

That relationship is not true. It might be true at the efficiency frontier. Maybe. I don't know.

But it's very easy to compromise on convenience without gaining any security and vice versa.


As someone who works in security, I disagree! Security often comes at the cost of convenience, but it doesn't have to. My experience is mostly with IT security, but:

* Passkeys are an example of technology that is both more convenient and more secure. In this case security comes at the price of (a bit of) privacy, though.

* Memory-safe languages are much more convenient, and much more secure than unsafe ones. The price usually comes at a price of performance, but does not have to, and modern memory-safe languages are barely slower than C.

* Prepared statements in databases are both more convenient and more secure than joining strings. The price is a bit more complexity.

* OTP codes (google authenticator style) are at least as convenient as SMS codes, while being more secure. The price is... a bigger chance of locking yourself out, I guess.

* Passphrases are easier to remember and more secure than passwords. And a password manager is even more secure.

* Server-side HTML rendering with templates is much more secure and much more convenient than joining strings manually.

* Using managed services (managed k8s, cloud storage, s3, hosted databases) is more convenient than self-hosting. Security depends on your threat model - but you need a proper infrastructure team to manage updates/hardening. For small companies it's not viable.

* SSO with OIDC in corporate environment is more secure and more convenient for users and administrators than having a separate login everywhere.

* Docker containers are more convenient (to work with) and more secure than running things on bare metal on physical servers.

* Exceptions are easier to use and safer than signals, and as secure as return codes (different failure modes).

* Automated updates are much more secure and much more convenient than having to manually trigger system update every time.

* Building and deploying images with CI/CD is more convenient and much more secure than having developers deploy to production from a local machine.

* Traditional banking is more secure and more convenient than cryptocurrencies (lol).

I can go on. You may disagree with some of them, but surely you will agree that "more security = less convenience" is not an universal truth.


In which case the customer's next action should be to divide by zero.

Please let me know how to opt out of the government interactions.

The two traditional methods are getting together a big enough mob to vote out the incumbents, and something similar but with guillotines.

In the interest of technical correctness (the best kind of correctness, I hear), neither of those is a form of opting out. The proper traditional way is to relinquish your nationality through formal channels.

I hear it's about as easy as cancelling with Comcast.


In the interest of technical correctness, that is not a form of opting out because, as you said, it's impossible. That is what they want you to think is the way to opt out, so you'll be steered well away from channels that actually work.

Do you know of any cable companies that aren't trash?

So the solution is to punish everyone who doesn't use that plan to reduce fraud on those who do. Right. Great.

I'm not particularly convinced fraud reduction is the primary motive here.


I work at a large fintech. It’s absolutely fraud. VOIP and portable numbers are a massive fraud correlation. Wish it weren’t so but it is.

Same as PO Boxes. Sadly, because I’ve been in a situation where I legitimately needed to use one as my address. Alas scammers ruin everything


Mechanically, that doesn't make sense. You have to show an ID to the government to open a PO Box, and the opener's info can be gathered through a court process. It creates a clear tie to the fraudster. If anything, a PO Box should have less fraud compared to a regular address that could just be a dead drop or similar.

For honest people, yes. Less honest people get a PO box with someone else’s id. Organized crime is quite organized, and paying some poor sod a few bucks to open a dozen PO boxes doesn’t seem incredibly complicated

If they're using someone else's ID to get a PO box, couldn't they use someone else's ID to get a phone line?

Yes, but nobody said that it’s a perfect correlation. That doesn’t detract from it being a huge fraud indicator.

It's not just an ID, it's other forms required as well. I got one at some point, and it was a pain with the documentation required.

I’m not downvoting or disagreeing with you. I don’t know exactly the exploit mechanisms in terms of id verification. but the result is very clear from arms length - PO Box addresses for accounts have massively higher rates of fraud.

maybe i've been lied to by hollywood but isn't it rather easy to fake an ID in the US?

LE: according to gemini hydrogen it's not easy to open a PO box using a fake ID.


It’s relatively easy (or was, might not be anymore) to make a fake ID that will fool someone who wants to be fooled, so you can get into a bar when you aren’t 21. All the doorman needs is plausible deniability - they showed me an ID, it said they were 21, I let them in.

An ID that will stand up to scrutiny by someone who really cares is not easy to fake. And an actual US Postal Service employee cares.


What's frustrating is that my VoIP number gives me powerful anti-spam tools - that's why I'm reluctant to get rid of it and start giving out my actual cell#!

Pretty much the entire world is VOIP now.

Yes, but in terms of classifying a number, it means something other than "the voice is carried by IP packets at some point in the signal chain"

> massive fraud correlation

Don't care. There the only way you can keep spam away from you. Everyone tries to collect your phone number and force you into their marketing spam.

You pull that crap and block voip numbers, I am no longer a customer of yours.


You say it as if it’s some sort of new information, but it’s not. Everything in life is a trade-off. I and many others would happily make that trade. Everyone that has done this has made the tradeoff. Not all business is worth pursuing.

That’s fine and that’s your choice. However it’s such a small percentage of legitimate customers that want to use voip, that it’s not worth the fraud loss to support them. Ie, it costs more to serve voip customers than they’re worth to the business. It’s our (and other similar services) choice to serve you too.

You missed the part where I said "everyone who doesn't use the plan".

Facial recognition on everyone (something of dubious long-term security value given AI image generation) punishes people who don't use VOIP as well.

Also? Doesn't Google have an API you can query for phone number reputation that gives more fidelity on what is or isn't a trustworthy phone number beyond "VOIP bad"?


Fraud is a fact of life. Credit cards openly encourage fraud and try to mop up the mess after the fact; why can't we apply this to other aspects of life?

? What benefit does a credit card company have to encourage fraud? They're the ones that will be paying out after the fact.

Perhaps a better way of seeing it is: They've found the balance between security and ease-of-use that maximizes revenue for the current point in time.

They could lock it down to requiring TFA + pre-authentication over a phone for every transaction etc etc etc, but the inconvenience to the vendor & customer, and cost to retrofit are probably huge. If it costs $1B to implement a technology that reduces fraud by $500M/yr, and transactions drop by $600M/yr due to the inconvenience, it's probably not worth it.

I'm 100% sure they must have huge fraud / tech departments keeping an eye on emerging fraud methods, counter-measures, etc. I would also bet they work with hardware vendors such as ingenico to keep rolling out new generations of countermeasures at hardware levels, so that when they have enough market penetration, they can start going from "optional" to "mandatory".


Usually fraud is paid for by the merchant. In fact, due to the various fees for everything from 3d secure to charge backs, fraud can be a profit center for the cards and banks (as long as it's not so much fraud the merchant can't pay)

> What benefit does a credit card company have to encourage fraud?

Lesser friction to use credit. Basic security has been an afterthought the entire time. Anyone with your card details can freely use it. Our payments system is a complete joke.

> They could lock it down to requiring TFA + pre-authentication over a phone for every transaction etc etc etc, but the inconvenience to the vendor & customer, and cost to retrofit are probably huge

Yes, security is inconvenient. But they don't even care about trying to come off as securing your money to begin with. There is simply no pro-human option available in the american markets.


I do not clearly understand all that you are implying, but it is a much better framework to state:

-- all of the systems we would be required to use MUST be sensible (acceptable, non-absurd).


that's because by implementing 3d secure too much they lose out on sales and impulse buys, making them less money. the gov has no incentive for this, clearly you have no idea what you're talking about

I've had a bank account for about a decade which forced me to add a phone number. A year or two ago, they insisted on "re-verifying" and then said the current number was invalid for whatever reason, which I assume means I don't have it registered as a postpaid number or have opted out of some data brokers. They still insist on sending 2fa codes to it though. I'm tired of getting stuck with paid, invasive, less convenient, less secure 2fa

Walmart deleted the house phone number I had and told me it was invalid. In actuality it is a home VoIP number that my wife also uses for her separate account and Walmart has decided that although multiple Walmart accounts are allowed per addresses a phone number can only be associated with one of them.

Since I did not desire any interaction with walmart on my cell phone I created a google voice number and gave them that instead which they bizarrely accepted. Then a month later they'd automatically updated the field to have my cell number, probably purchased from my credit card company or whoever!


Oh wow that's pretty bad. Is it possible you or your wife bought something in store and gave them the number, linking it by card number? I've had something similar happen where I bought an item in store, without giving them any extra info, and they sent an email receipt to the online account I had, which I'd most likely used the same card to buy online with before.

Go to your bank branch and say you don't have a phone

And I think some platforms don’t even send SMS login codes to VOYP numbers

No, it’s because it’s a valid and useful fraud signal. It’s just one that has downsides that you personally do not like / are affected by. No model is perfect but some are useful. I assure you that this one is. It’s not for me to say whether or not it’s OK for governments (or the quasi-government entities that a government forces its people to interact with) to use signals that have this particular sort of false positive profile, but you’re being baselessly conspiratorial.

Lots of things are "fraud signals" which are actually just intentional class boundaries.

Your government can use Signal to organize bombings in Yemen, but if you use Signal, you're a potential terrorist.

Sure, a phone plan can be a fraud signal, and that fraud signal will be used as part of a modern digital redlining campaign, denying or restricting access to American citizens who either were born into poverty, value their privacy against the State, or both. It doesn't matter if fraudsters actually fit the profile, but the State appreciates hiding behind the plausible deniability of statistics.


I know a guy on Text-o who could help...

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=nS97AzfKp3U


Valve aren't jerks, but they are stealthily inflating game prices by 30%. That massive fee is being paid by the consumer, even if the consumer doesn't realize it.

> Valve aren't jerks, but they are stealthily inflating game prices by 30%.

Nah.

From what I've heard from folks who used to do bricks and mortar distribution, that 30% is _way_ better than what you'd get cut out in that system. [0] From the perspective of the person publishing a video game, you also get waaaaaaaaaaay more for your cut with Valve than you'd get in a B&M distribution. _So_ much more. The same is true for the purchaser and player of video games.

[0] If for no other reason [1] than the fact Valve will sell your game forever, unless some government or powerful payment processor very strongly demands that it not be sold.

[1] ...and there are many other reasons...


Brick and mortar is an antiquated comparison when most people haven't bought a game on CD/DVD in decades. Sure, it used to cost quite a bit with all the middlemen involved -- these days, we are more efficient and we just don't need them.

> Brick and mortar is an antiquated comparison when...

Nah. It reminds folks how video game devs used to pay _way_ more to get much, much, _much_ less.

If folks don't like what they get for the cut Valve takes, folks are free to distribute on Epic Games Store, Humble Store, itch.io, or -hell- host their own downloads and manually email one-time links to copies after receiving payment.

Hell, unless you're locked into an exclusive distribution agreement (which I'm pretty sure that -unlike Epic- is not a thing Valve does) you can use every available distribution method at the same time.


That's very ignorant perspective on it. 30% is very much standard cut in near any kind of online gaming stores and Steam's on average is lower than that.

Yes, they could drop the price for indies but they do have progressive tiering, at top you pay 20% to them and by revenue split it's much closer to taking 20% cut on average than 30%. But yes, indies are being a bit screwed there.

... if not for the fact every single cheaper platform will still get you massively less sales just because they can't compete on feature, let alone popularity of Steam.

Also the 30% funded ability to play games at all on my Linux box so I'm fine with paying the extra.


I stopped reading at the personal insult. This isn't reddit. If you want to disagree, be respectful.

Summary: Discourse reflects on the shift toward personal AI agents. Reddit's moves to lock down their platform (login requirement, etc) is in conflict with their users wishes, whereas Discourse as an open source forum software is naturally more aligned with both the users and hosters of the community -- as these groups care about the user getting the information they need, not the delivery mechanism.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: