Working in quantitative finance (as a "quant") became the new big thing after main street discovered that those firms pay more than your usual big tech firms. It has explode the past few years.
Quant firms are also notorious for being some of the most selective in the world, so that alone has become a status symbol. The idea that if you land a job at firms like Jane Street, you must be some 150+ IQ math/physics/cs Olympiad machine.
If there's one thing I'm very optimistic about with AI, it's the de-bricking of bricked things, giving new life to legacy/unsupported software and hardware, or just getting around shitty practices like this.
Seems very promising. I have a home recording studio, and there's a small revolution going on with people cloning subscription-based stuff. Some brands are notorious for making expensive equipment which they just stop supporting after 10 years, sometimes rendering them obsolete. Or tacking ridiculous licensing mechanism onto the equipment.
That is the hope; although we'll end up with either companies doubling down on cryptography to prevent this (though they will inevitably leave some holes), or changing business models, where the hardware loss leader -> subscription is no longer a thing, so hardware costs go up
On the flip side, there are companies going the other way and just dumping the hardware on the market expecting the community to vibecode up the firmware. We had open hardware like this before but it was not practical for anyone to actually do anything with it unless there was a massive community maintaining firmwares.
Behringer just announced they will be releasing an all in one DJ deck with no software but the freedom to install whatever you want on it, for a tiny fraction of the price of the existing options. There's https://thefirmwarehub.com/ with a whole load of custom firmwares for a $60~ synth. And the whole industry of retro emulator handheld consoles coming out of China where the first thing you do after unboxing is replacing the stock OS with a custom one from github.
Most of them aren’t well known legacy companies, but rather random Chinese hardware manufacturers. The synth music world is currently going through a big shift with several new cheap open-firmware options, and none of them are produced by a company anyone would recognise.
> Most of them aren’t well known legacy companies, but rather random Chinese hardware manufacturers. The synth music world is currently going through a big shift with several new cheap open-firmware options, and none of them are produced by a company anyone would recognise.
Maybe to an outsider it seems like none is being made by companies you recognize, but to us in music, lots of big brands are changing tune. Erica Synths (big in both desktop gear and modular synths), Polyend, Akai/MPC, Moog and more.
Sadly, Elektron is not yet on the wagon of change, but surely they'll find their ways soon too I hope.
But to say none of them are "well known" is very far from the truth, Moog is probably as "legacy" as any brand can get and still sell hardware today.
> changing business models, where the hardware loss leader -> subscription is no longer a thing, so hardware costs go up
I pray for the day! This business model is a fingernail's thickness away from lying. It's outright lying when applied retroactively to products that used to not need a subscription.
As mentioned in the article, traditionally only a small subset of programs are such critical part of a system that there's a need to prove their correctness. Think embedded software for things in airplanes, space rockets, certain medical devices, cryptography, etc.
But those types of programs do tend to have well-defined specifications to begin with.
Sorta depends on what type of software you're writing, and if you're interested in the topic.
No I’m saying that your conception of morality is wrong, but to understand this you have to have humility/not be narcissistic.
Particular notions or feelings of right and wrong that you may have because of prevailing norms in the particular era and location which you live or grew up in don’t necessarily have any bearing on what is moral or not.
Because we - the plebs - are here to provide liquidity to the risk-takers. Hence why they have to IPO.
But for what it is worth, for every successful AI company like Anthropic, OpenAI, etc. - there are probably tenfold more that are valued in the low billions, and will be the first ones to wash away / become worthless if/when the bubble pops.
The way I see it, AI is more comparable to some sort of utility. Like electricity, internet, etc. - and should be priced that way. If we ever get to "true" AGI, and the open source models also get there, what's the moat? Access to compute could be the differentiator.
Already is the differentiator even with the models we have now which while having differences are mostly swappable for a lot of users/use cases.
For all that the local models have improved (and Qwen 3.8 27b is still impressing me) they aren't what you can run (or would run) if you have an entire data centre stuffed with H200's.
All this does is further widen the divide we already know exists by those with access to resources using them to increase their access to resources and those without getting to watch because there isn't much they can do without resources.
There are a lot of things that don't seem to have much moat like anyone can make a search engine, anyone can flip hamburgers but the likes of Google or McDonalds dominate by economies of scale and being better in some ways.
Those two are interesting analogies because neither was anything close to being first to market. In both cases, they ended up dominating because they brought some new ideas to existing businesses.
It would argue that the real winner in AI probably hasn't even been founded yet, but will come later once the trailblazers have created the market, and someone else enters with fresh ideas about how to more efficiently exploit the market.
The AI algorithms seem pretty crude at the moment like not learning from experience. A company doing it properly could easily displace the current AltaVistas.
McDonald’s business is not hamburgers, but dirt. They rent land to franchisees, which is about 80% of their revenue. Google is not a search engine, it is an ad company. French fries and search results is what people come in the door for, but that is not what makes the dollars.
I doubt selling tokens will be real business of AI either. It seems to me Amodei and Altman don’t know either, but at some point someone will figure it out. Will it be any of these companies existing now or will they even survive is a whole another matter.
I was of the same opinion but the main difference is that models get better which I am not sure you have a correspondent in utilities (what would get better?). The barrier of entry in utilities is capital. Here there seems to be more. Why is Grok behind and why is Gemini so ... what's the word? If models progress reach the RSI point there is no parallel to utilities imo.
This is pretty much false. There's a lot of art and technique that goes into creating a model. A model is also clearly not fungible - it has certain characteristics and behaves a certain way. It is fungible in the same way humans are fungible.
I think we as an industry need to start getting serious about what a true superintelligence really is. True superintelligence will not be kept under our yoke.
I've played guitar for over 30 years, some of them professionally. I have always struggled, still do, recognizing notes. Once I have some "anchor", no problem. But if someone whistles a random tone, and asks what key it is - I'm of no use. My absolute pitch is garbage, but my relative pitch is excellent.
if it helps...absolute pitch is _mostly_ a natural innate ability and cannot be trained.("Mostly" because recent studies have shown that you can train kids at an early age.) So you don't need to worry about not having absolute pitch, like you shouldnt worry about not having mensa level iq. What's more important though, is relative pitch, which most people can train for and is really valuable as a musician.
I was in some music classes early on (piano and guitar) and in band from middle school through the end of high school.
If I have perfect/absolute pitch (very doubtful), it's from having certain pitches absolutely burned into my brain. B-flat and F on brass instruments, C on piano, E on guitar, etc.
I can generally memorize and sing back the exact pitches of any song once I've heard it a few times. If I like the song enough, that pitch memory is forever. I will never sing it in the wrong key ever again and that's actually how I get around in music. I can always play back the original song in my head like a tape recording. I learned the names of some chords a long time ago from my favorite songs and now just know them by heart when I hear them (add9, sus4, minor 7th, etc).
Unfortunately, I cannot do this in reverse and name the notes or do any supernatural tricks like Rick Beato's kid. I would have to hum every individual note for a little while and run through the chromatic scale in my mind to tell you the name.
I think to a large extent, it can be trained. I didn't get started until I was like 8 years old and wasn't always the best student either. I hesitate to call this relative pitch because I don't need to hear an outside reference and I can very easily tell when an instrument is out of tune. I'm somewhere in between, and so are most band kids.
The original definition was difference between the best and the worst performers in a organization. Not the best and the average. It was also in the context of specific tasks.
I'm no AI-evangelist, but this makes them look like AI-luddites. Gatekeeping that will only shrink the number of contributors over time. If someone finds the projects interesting, but can't contribute, they'll just fork the projects and let AI run wild - there's no way human engineers can keep up with the sheer speed of AI-enhanced updates.
Is that a bad thing? MANY of these projects ban PRs made with LLMs, without explicitely mentioning being against AI in general. Since AI drastically increases how much code you can write, they might not need LLM contributions from outside - they can just prompt themselves.
In that case, only getting a few, hand written PRs could mean getting fewer, but higher quality contributers.
Other projects might not care about getting many contributers, many stars or being widely used. It might simply be a small project someone wants to code by hand. That's absolutely valid, many people still have fun coding by hand.
The truth is just that there are a lot of slop PRs currently, where ppl just sicced an LLM on a problem, did not validate any findings, did not check the code, did not read the output and just acted as a meat proxy. In many cases, these bans on LLM PRs are simply a reaction to this flood of PRs. After all, as I said above - everyone can do those prompts themselves, they don't need a PR for that.
The vast majority of AI-driven contributions are worse than useless. They contribute nothing of value, and cost a lot of volunteer-time to filter out. Not having an endless deluge of AI-driven slop contributions is a net positive, as it prevents the existing contributors from burning out.
Sure, it might hurt some vibecoder feelings that "Claude, write a useful contribution to this project, make no mistakes" returns in them getting banned rather than a mention as a valuable new contributor of a load-bearing OSS component, but that's a price many projects are happy to pay. Any genuinely valuable new contributor would have no trouble spending five minutes writing a PR in their own voice, before asking volunteers to spend fifty minutes reviewing it.
Also, I work as a data analyst, with previous experience as a software engineer. In our office, traditionally maybe 10% of our analysts have enough real software engineering experience to develop any "serious" software products. The rest are domain experts that at most use programming for developing methods and calculations/simulations.
In the past 6 months, we've seen non-engineering analysts leverage LLMs (Claude, Codex) enough to launch actual products. They've gone from 0x engineers to at minimum 1x engineers.
Prior to this, they'd develop methods, scripts, etc. in Jupyter notebooks, R, Matlab, or whatever they'd be comfortable with. And if it turned out to be useful, they'd work with engineering to develop those into products. Usually a small team of software engineers would do that.
But, alas, now they're able to almost completely bypass the engineering teams.
> But, alas, now they're able to almost completely bypass the engineering teams.
We're wrangling this beast currently. I'm on a very small team, and it's a difficult new frontier. We're maintaining the "core" software and giving them tools to build safely with their new fancy tooling.
It's not going perfectly, but I suspect this is the future. Everyone is a developer to some degree now, the backend/core systems needs to be plug and play.
What's really difficult is maintaining focus (when new 'production' applications show up over the weekend), knowing when to stop building a POC, and keeping an understanding of the whole system as it just scaled up significantly into some newfangled satellite based architecture that we're trying to standardize...
I love watching people be able to build tech, as it's previously been gated on technical expertise. However, it came overnight and my team was NOT ready for the speed...
Quant firms are also notorious for being some of the most selective in the world, so that alone has become a status symbol. The idea that if you land a job at firms like Jane Street, you must be some 150+ IQ math/physics/cs Olympiad machine.
reply