Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | TrainedMonkey's commentslogin

Not sure, but since we are comparing the costs, I am also curious about the costs of maintaining infra required for and performing the executions.

Edit: after reading the article seems like a no-brainer, CA is not executing anyone anyway, so why maintain the fiction:

> The decision to spare death row inmates is largely symbolic in a state that has not executed an inmate since 2006, though experts say it could save millions of dollars in court costs each year. Only 13 inmates have been executed since voters reinstated the death penalty in 1978.


Taking a step back wouldn't this be exactly the expected outcome for an emergent technology in a capitalist framework?

1. Execs with no understanding how business operates on the low level are pushing buzzwords.

2. People who want to get promoted deliver on buzzwords and get promoted. Note that the goal is to deliver the buzzword, not use the buzzword to make the business better.

3. Buzzwords do not help vast majority of companies because the incentives and needs are misaligned.

4. Eventually buzzwords settle, some find niches, some die off, and some take over the world.

Last two decades alone - big data, blockchain, crypto, web 3.0, gamification, VR, and now AI. TL:DR - we should expect vast majority of early AI adopters to have net negative to neutral experience. Assuming that AI is like electricity and automobiles more than blockchain we should expect that eventually companies that find a way to apply the tech correctly will eat those who do not.


You are not wrong that secret ingredient is crime, but I think the single largest use of crypto out there is tax evasion. When traveling Asia in 2025 I've met several people who worked for western companies and got paid in tether. Western companies pay flat consulting that avoids payroll taxes / etc and employees skip taxation from whatever country they are in. On the trading side we have ETH wrapping everything and enabling trading of most financial assets.


Not familiar with the issue, but that has to be $1m minimum order, correct? And you would get a production run in 1-10k. How many revs does that include?

My understanding is that Shenzhen dominance so far is from 3 pillars - low minimum order size, low per-part price, and fast response. They can do that because they have lot of highly trained labor that work mad hours. So to compete you would need to leverage a lot of automation... which would be a lot less flexible and very rocky at the start. Would love to get a correction from someone more familiar with the situation.


Biggest issue with my M3 Max is apple mandatory fun bloatware. I think it's the same playbook as phones long term. The hardware is still powerful but the software is optimized for the latest CPU, so older models run hot, take a fraction of the second longer to load the resources, etc. That stacks up over 5-6 years of releases to make older models feel slower.


I've held back an OS update or two, specifically because I'm worried about performance dropoff on the old chip

But with all of the AI-discovered exploits I think it'll become more important to keep everything up to date


Apple makes security updates available for the last few major OS versions, and even backports really bad ones further back on a case by case basis.


> Why not hold your cards until afterwards?

It's a public company that is beholden to the shareholders. They have to explain what they are doing. But I agree with you, seems sus. Even if you can make more money by scaling the old tech today, that does not justify dropping the future innovation. Especially because by all accounts they are swimming in cash... Unless they are telling the truth and 4f extra complexity does not justify extra cost. I really have no context to evaluate that.


Sounds like innovator's dilemma to me. Their current production lines might be too profitable[0], so diverting expansion capacity to a yet unproven technology (to Micron's to-date profit margin requirements) might be too big of a financial hit. Since they're the ones who came up with 4F design, they must hold a ton of patents on the various incremental improvements. At which point, from a purely cynical and utilitarian view, it would make financial sense to let other players polish the remaining 20% and use patent portfolio as a wedge for mid-term technology transfers.

Or in short: "let others figure out the technical complexities and surrounding economics." - Which would make sense from a company that believes they can catch up once the expensive leg of the manufacturing/scaling research has been completed. Whether that bet is good or not, we'll see.

0: Didn't we read a few days ago here that all of 2027 production capacity has been sold out already?


Given that the stated plan of Micron is to focus on 3D scaling, keeping per-mm^2 production costs low makes perfect sense. When Samsung introduced their first volume V-NAND flash, the 2D feature sizes were larger than leading edge NAND flash because of the tolerances inherent in producing 90 layer flash (aspect ratio matters!) as well as the cost of production equipment. That trend has continued as it is cheaper to produce flash with more layers than to compensate for difficulties arising from decreasing amounts of charge kept in ever smaller cells.

In layperson DRAM-speak this translates to the following: rowhammer attacks are mitigated at the hardware level by increasing the size of and spacing between adjacent cells. At some point further feature size scaling makes it no longer be possible to produce 4F cells that are sufficiently robust against rowhammer type attacks to meet Micron's internal reliability targets. This would be akin to when Intel hit the power wall with the Pentium 4 in the early '00s forcing a change in engineering direction away from merely scaling clock speed.

With Micron's insight into the DRAM order pipeline, management likely has to factor in the chance of oversupply in the next couple of years as significant, which makes the shift in direction even more sensible. DRAM price crashes are a regular occurrence in the industry which lead to anti-dumping tariffs and legal battle in the 1990s (as well as Intel's shift away from DRAM towards complex logic devices in 1985). I'm pretty sure Micron's management is consciously working to avoid a repeat of that protracted legal battle.

I'd rather have an engineering problem over a legal problem any day of the week.


> Which would make sense from a company that believes they can catch up once the expensive leg of the manufacturing/scaling research has been completed. Whether that bet is good or not, we'll see.

The article mentions CXMT has committed to 4F^2 server RDIMMs by end of 2026, and a linked article mentions that CXMT has halved the fab build time from the industry-standard 2 years to just 1. How would Micron catch up with that?

The memory triopoly is in the midst of a slow motion wreck because pumping the brakes will reduce profits; the incumbents are going to have their butts handed to them by CXMT in 2-5 years, and they'll all act like they didn't see it coming as they are bailed-out by the US or SK government, for "National Security."


> They have to explain what they are doing.

They really don't. A public company doesn't even have to provide forward-looking earnings guidance, though many choose to do so for strategic reasons. The only reason to make announcements is if there's some strategic benefit to doing so.


Well, yes, but wouldn't this fall under Regulation S-K, Item 303? They don't have to provide forward revenue guidance, but if they're exiting a line of business don't they have to disclose future trends and risks leading to that decision in their 10Q/10K?


> that does not justify dropping the future innovation

Looks like they have mapped the possible paths and consider it a dead end. The density increase is low compared to the effort to process cost, so they just opted for a simpler process with a similar density at a much lower cost per wafer. They might come back to it at some point - they invented it and have substantial IP investment on it.

Also, there might be some cost of opportunity - the AI bubble is now, so anything that diverts from current extremely profitable product lines is a terrible idea. It’s a bubble and they have the fiduciary duty to suck it until it’s dry.


Wouldn't be the first once hot memory tech that ended up in the scrapheap. See: RDRAM.


Market fit beats best technology 100% of the time. Everyone should remember Betamax.


On the surface that seems like a responsible thing to do


I concur that this is probably a good thing, but UTC without leap seconds already exists. That is TAI and some applications that care about long term persistent and self-consistent telemetry use that.


I agree, except that TAI is off from UTC by 37 seconds.

That's a pretty big smear if you want to convert an existing clock from one to the other.


Some, maybe most, humans outperform AI. I've had some calls where I would have preferred an AI that could not understand me to an agent whom I could not understand AND who could barely understand me.


I do not care for Withings software or subscriptions, but their hardware is so nice.


AH, you clearly haven't had the "5 different chargers breaking and begging support to send a different production batch". (And paying for every charger.)

My scanwatch is beautiful, and the battery life is great. But to this day, on my 5th charger, it either charges to full in 20m, or 3 hours. Same charger, same wall outlet. Probably not great for the watches hardware.


Unfortunately I've had. I've had two different scanwatch models and ended up buying ~3 chargers each for of them. Just thinking abut USB-C and how much less different chargers types I have makes me really happy.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: