Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | _factor's commentslogin

I wonder if this took into account GPU render-time fingerprinting? The minute timing differences in how you render an image are still used to identify you.

Recently did a WebGPU project and noticed Firefox polls GPU status on a 100ms timer, so you can't really use it for such as far as I can tell.

That said, Claude figured out that while Canvas copying of a loaded JPEG was out due to fingerprint resistance, it could copy it via WebGPU, so yeah...


This reminds me of some fucking bullshit about how browsers silently store canvas pixel data as premultiplied and try to transparently convert everything you put in and everything you take out, but silently corrupt color values in the process.

https://github.com/nagadomi/nunif/issues/32#issuecomment-153...


Yea ended up with my own PNG decoder in JS due to such issues.

It does not - there are a lot of these sorts of techniques, but we specifically modeled what commercial fingerprinters do in the wild to provide a realistic number. I have not seen a commercial fingerprinter do those sorts of timing-based fingerprinting techniques. (Doesn't mean there isn't one, just that I've looked at more scripts that your average person and haven't seen it.)

Oracle has a product that does just this commercially.

If you can run compute shader code, the fingerprinting and side channel possibilities become very rich. [1] is one paper among many on this topic.

[1]: https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3634737.3656283


Depends. If it is uranium, the lead will only continue to increase.


holy shit lmao


It is notable in that it’s the first time an open Chinese company openly stated they were reducing intelligence for “safety”.

“Our lock can be picked by the robot.” We ban the robot instead of fixing the lock. It’s shortsighted.


If we had a technique that would defeat almost every lock in the world, we might be prudent to delay releasing that until people have had time to change the locks.

Same general benefit as coordinated disclosure, except it's a big game-theory problem where we're likely to eventually have sufficiently capable defectors.


they're pretty clearly framing it as holding back on the robot and letting is lose slowly to give everyone time to update their locks


They are directly responding to new Chinese export controls on cyber capabilities.


Note the Israeli training data scandal to influence AI responses. AI is not reliable for this purpose.


My kid wasn’t progressing quite as well as their older sibling at a young age. They would trip over things and not be as interested in certain play activities. Dark under eye circles were also more pronounced (straining).

During a checkup, they had the option for an eye screening (basically an iPhone app) that takes pictures and flags possible issues. The concerning part was that the nurse’s default was to offer to “skip” this exam since it wasn’t covered by insurance and many parents chose to for financial reasons.

We didn’t skip it, and it found the need for a correction. The first time with the glasses on still brings tears to my eyes rewatching the video. “I see everything!” as they went to look at everything they were missing. The under eye circles also resolved immediately after.

The developmental delays aren’t even the biggest issue. Your eyes learn to work together at a young age, and skipping the glasses can lead to permanent eye issues if not addressed early. Many children likely have a permanent disease that a checkbox and cheap pair of glasses would have prevented.

This is long overdue and in no world should we be training health care providers that early age eye health is “skippable”.


Did you read the article?


Yes, I read the 5-7 paragraph article :). I'm not sure what part of it you could possibly consider a rebuttal...? It's just talking about one devs decision to keep working on their purist software despite their anxiety; basically no broader points are made at all, and certainly none are made with any sort of rigor. It didn't seem like that was his goal.


The author specifically mentions the compliments on helpful scripts and tools help them feel fulfilled.


Then they should stop selling hardware they don’t plan to support. Me-ish when you spend $1,500 on a piece of hardware is completely acceptable.


Never buy hardware based on expectations of future features, especially if there’s no promise from the vendor.


They also open just as fast! Near instantaneously! Yuck!


Hardware debugging and firmware details lead to thinking/testing loops on all but the frontier here.


I’m fine with that being the default. I know plenty of people who would have emulated the Win malware situation on their phone otherwise.

I’m not ok with it being the only option.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: