Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | alanweber22's commentslogin

There's definitely going to be a Streisand effect from all this. I hadn't heard about KF until a couple months ago too when an Asahi developer I follow was complaining about them on twitter. Now just about the entire tech community knows of them.

I have zero interest in participating with their content, but sent KF a crypto donation to help support forums with less censorship. I'm sure they'll be getting a nice bump in funding from all this.


I don't think it's fair to say that. Individual businesses aren't evaluating KF themselves and independently coming to the same conclusion. Otherwise, it would be highly coincidental that they all randomly reached this conclusion within a few days of each other, when there hasn't been any significant recent shift in content on KF.


> it would be highly coincidental that they all randomly reached this conclusion within a few days of each other

Oh, no doubt that a massive online campaign surfaced the question of whether KF needed to be evaluated.

The fact that they've all come to the same conclusion is because of KF's content, not because individual service providers are not independent. The common thread is the site under evaluation, and the site is that bad.


Ok fair point that their evaluations and conclusions could all still be independent, but simply triggered by the twitter campaign.

But from all that's been written on the topic, there's been very few concrete examples put forward of dangerous content on KF. It seems to me more likely that businesses have simply seen that the twitter campaign reached a critical mass and made the simple decision to cut them off to reduce reputation risk without doing much of an investigation themselves.


Moderation should occur at the lowest level possible: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subsidiarity

Spam that could overload a system would need to handled higher in the tech stack. But some content moderation could at the level of the individual user, who could filter what he wants to see based on his own preferences.


In what ways does maidsafe improve upon freenet?


Far far more advanced — it splits data into chunks, encrypts it end to end, uses a Kademlia DHT which removes the IP addresses after the first hop so no one can find all the nodes, has consensus about the files and their evolution, and uses later cryptographic primitives like BLS keys etc. etc.

https://safenetforum.org/t/maidsafe-vs-freenet-i2p-ipfs/9409


None of the points you note here are advantages of maidsafe over Freenet — except maybe the later crypto primitives (though these aren’t necessarily safer).

But your link has one important point: "Freenet…is more a exchange and communication system instead [of] a data management system as Maidsafe".

The goal of Freenet is censorship resistant communication. That is its focus and the origin of almost all its features.


Why don't you consider them advantages?


I’ll go through them:

- it splits data into chunks, encrypts it end to end → same as Freenet.

- uses a Kademlia DHT which removes the IP addresses after the first hop so no one can find all the nodes → same for Freenet, except that Freenet has many additional privacy protections in the protocol and uses node-locations on a ring like Chord, but with an inferred small word structure that allows efficient routing without the need to be able to connect to anyone but your direct peers.

- has consensus about the files and their evolution → Freenet has signed, user-controlled keyspaces, so no consensus is needed. Lifetime is given by access (what people access is kept alive) without actually having to track accesses, which is much safer for privacy than a consensus algorithm.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: