Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | bariumbitmap's commentslogin

Theremin did invent the Thing (a.k.a. the Great Seal bug) that worked as a passive RF cavity. However, he later invented a completely different device called the buran eavesdropping system:

> Apparently happy with ‘the thing’, Beria called on Theremin’s services again and he was enlisted for further eavesdropping operations. In 1947 or earlier, when Theremin probably served in the Kuchino sharashka outside Moscow, he was called upon to create another device for wireless surveillance, but this time it should operate fully remotely without any device planted at the target site. The project received the code name buran (snowstorm). To solve this difficult task, Theremin paid attention to the resonators already present in a building, such as windows. A conversation in a room may cause window panes to vibrate slightly, and Theremin devised a method to detect these vibrations from a distance, using an infrared beam directed at the window pane, and then to interpret them and convert them to discernible speech (Glinsky, 2005, p.261).

>

> The buran was able to detect speech from as far away as 500 metres, making detection very difficult. Interception would have to disrupt the infrared beam and jamming would require optical overpowering. Both were unlikely. However, it could be used only when weather permitted and was not effective in rain, fog or smog (Glinsky, 2005, p.261). Buran is often considered a predecessor of the laser microphone, although it employed an infrared beam rather than laser.

https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2307/48828289


The Thing uses a radio signal at 330 MHz (or perhaps a second or third harmonic). These radio waves have a wavelength of about a meter, which is about 6 orders of magnitude longer than an optical wavelength. It's a fundamentally different mechanism than laser Doppler vibrometry.

> These radio waves have a wavelength of about a meter, which is about 6 orders of magnitude longer than an optical wavelength.

Radio waves are light. By definition, they are optical wavelengths.


Radio waves and visible light are both electromagnetic waves, but the frequency/wavelength are different by several orders of magnitude.

Right, but "optical wavelengths" are not limited to the visible!

For example, the company I work for manufactures DUV optics for the semiconductor industry and IR optics for the defense industry.


Given these common-use definitions:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optics "Optics usually describes the behaviour of visible, ultraviolet, and infrared light."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio_wave "Radio waves are a type of electromagnetic radiation with the lowest frequencies and the longest wavelengths in the electromagnetic spectrum, typically with frequencies below 300 GHz and wavelengths greater than 1 mm"

I see no problem with using the term 'optical wavelength' to distinguish between a wavelength of ~1 micrometer and 'radio waves' at ~1 meter.


The next sentence from the linked Optics article:

> The study of optics extends to other forms of electromagnetic radiation, including radio waves, microwaves, and X-rays.

I have no problem with this usage if the distinction helps understanding, but we seem to be discussing terms with potentially conflicting definitions without defining them: laser, light, radio, optics. All of these can reasonably apply to MHz radiation!


And the next sentence is "The term optics is also applied to technology for manipulating beams of elementary charged particles."

No one disputes that 'optics' can refer to more than visible light. But, in the context of a discussion about lasers and 1950's radio devices operating at VHF, we can still use terms like 'optical wavelength', 'radio wave', 'light', etc to distinguish the phenomena.

Language is a two-way street. Words are imprecise tools for people who want to communicate together, even in engineering and physics. Being pedantic without a deeper point to make isn't a useful contribution.


I'm trying to address a misconception I see happening in this very thread:

> Yes, he invented the technique of monitoring audio through light. How was I wrong there?

> These radio waves have a wavelength of about a meter, which is about 6 orders of magnitude longer than an optical wavelength.

> The point was light being used for audio, not specifically laser as a light source.

> You seem to keep responding to multiple people defend your point, but he used 1320 MHz in the thing which is not light.

These comments disagree on important definitions. I don't think it's pedantic to point this out.


The context is a plausible energy source for illuminating a passive modulating reflector (a window pane or a custom cavity resonator) in 1945 Moscow.

There are three approximate frequency bands being discussed. The bands are separated by a factor of about 1 million. The width of each band is a factor of 3-8.

Human voice audio - 500 Hz to 4 kHz (the modulating signal)

VHF-UHF radio - 330 MHz and 1320 MHz

"Light" - 300 to 800 THz


> "Light" - 300 to 800 THz

This restriction to the visible is what I'm pointing out. (Note that the first person to mention the word "visible" was you!)

ClikeX clearly included radio waves in their intent, and that is an accepted definition! It's the definition I use in practice as an optical engineer.


If you actually have any new information about the wavelengths Leon Theremin was using, please share it.

ClikeX originally claimed that the USSR had lasers in 1945 (untrue) and that Leon Theremin invented the detection of sound vibrations or audio reproduction of via light (also untrue).

The confusion here is between the two different eavesdropping systems developed by Theremin: The Buran eavesdropping system (which used likely-near infrared on windowpanes) and "The Thing" (which used VHF-UHF radio on a custom device).

Your repeated insistence on the unrelated point that "light" and "radio" are technically both electromagnetic waves isn't clarifying anything.


Mate, I'm really not trying to argue with you. I'm not suggesting anyone here is wrong!

> If you actually have any new information about the wavelengths Leon Theremin was using, please share it.

I'm quite confident it was an optical wavelength! ;)

> ClikeX originally claimed that the USSR had lasers in 1945 (untrue) and that Leon Theremin invented the detection of sound vibrations or audio reproduction of via light (also untrue).

> The confusion here is between the two different eavesdropping systems developed by Theremin: The Buran eavesdropping system (which used likely-near infrared on windowpanes) and "The Thing" (which used VHF-UHF radio on a custom device).

Great summary!

> Your repeated insistence on the unrelated point that "light" and "radio" are technically both electromagnetic waves isn't clarifying anything.

I hope this has helped clarify that, of the terms used here, only "radio" is clearly distinct, since "light" and "electromagnetic waves" are often used interchangeably.


No worries, it's all good

I can't find a way to read the article, anyone have a gift link?

(Edit: archive.today and wallhop.io don't work)



Thanks, but I'm getting this error:

> This gift link has expired. Register to access this article



This is a really good hack. This is peak HN. Thank you.

That was courtesy of Bypass Paywalls Clean https://gitflic.ru/project/magnolia1234/bpc_uploads which is quite helpful with this stuff

archive.is has it

archive.is is having a screenshot of the error for this article

Is this a joke?

The New York Post links to the Economic Times:

> The Comprehensive Study on Single-Use Straws, commissioned by South Korea’s Ministry of Climate, Energy and Environment, was revealed on Wednesday by Kim Wi-sang, an opposition People Power Party lawmaker, according to The Korea Herald.

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/new-updates/paper-...

which cites the Korea Herald:

> The report, commissioned by the Ministry of Climate, Energy and Environment and disclosed Wednesday by Rep. Kim Wi-sang of the People Power Party, assessed the environmental impacts of four types of straws — conventional plastic straws, paper, biodegradable plastic and bio-based polyethylene (bio-PE).

https://www.koreaherald.com/article/10911494

I wasn't able to find the original report, it's not in the ministry's press releases:

https://www.mcee.go.kr/eng/web/index.do?menuId=461


It looks like the details of the report are not published, but there's a call to do so: http://www.ikld.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=342710



Backblaze drive stats used to be very useful when purchasing consumer drive stats for my laptops, e.g. in 2015:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10387962

https://www.backblaze.com/blog/hard-drive-reliability-q3-201...

For various reasons I don't consult Backblaze stats much nowadays, but I wish this kind of reliability and failure rate information were more available for other products, especially LED light bulbs.


No kidding! About twelve years ago, I outfitted a house with LED bulbs for about $5 a pop (a bargain at the time!) and those lasted for six years, until I moved. In the new house, LEDs were all less expensive but now they also fail quickly. I'd HAPPILY pay $5 for eternal bulbs again.


LED light bulbs really seem to be a market for lemons.


I still use Backblaze drive stats and lifetime annual failure rates to help me decide which make and models of drive I might want to buy for my NAS upgrades.

Why did you stop using them?

Outside of drives, I rely on Consumer Reports for reliability reports. They’ve got the longest history of any organization I know of that gathers data like this, across the widest array of product types.

I don’t necessarily trust their reviews on what is the best product in a given field of technology equipment, but I do trust their longitudinal reliability statistics. I try to take both sets of factors into consideration any time I am looking at buying products.


> I still use Backblaze drive stats and lifetime annual failure rates to help me decide which make and models of drive I might want to buy for my NAS upgrades. > > Why did you stop using them?

I guess the short answer is I don't have a NAS, I have a laptop with M.2 SSDs.

> Outside of drives, I rely on Consumer Reports for reliability reports.

I also use Consumer Reports but they have some limitations, for example they stopped reviewing LED light bulbs in 2017.


I don't know much about sociology, so I found it interesting to read a sociologist critique his own field. This part stood out to me:

> To make a loose statistical analogy, it is a little like continuing to add variables to a regression on the grounds that the explained variance keeps increasing.

Like a statistical model having parameters, a theory should have some nuance, but too much nuance is analogous to overfitting. It reminds me of the maxim that a theory should be as simple as possible but no simpler


> This sort of breathless outrage rhetoric would be a lot easier to take seriously if it spent even a minute acknowledging the very real risk to users that this is meant to mitigate: tech support scams where people are walked through installing an app that takes over their phone and steals their money, private data, and identity.

1. Is requiring developers to submit government ID actually an effective way to prevent tech support scams? Will scammers actually be deterred by a government ID requirement in addition to the existing developer registration process?

2. Is requiring developers to submit government ID the best option to prevent tech support scams? Are there other options that Google could use to make Android user less susceptible to tech support scams?

> You can disagree with the tradeoff, but if you don't acknowledge it you're just doing propaganda.

The tradeoff, such as it is, is acknowledged on keepandroidopen.org under the "But wait, isn't this...just about security?" section:

> The security rationale is a smokescreen. Google Play Protect already scans for malware independent of developer identity. Requiring a government ID doesn't make code safer.

Finally:

> Personally, I think the 24h cooldown is an excellent compromise to allow user freedom while slowing down attackers sufficiently to mitigate the harm.

I don't think this is an excellent compromise. Scammers are persistent. I'm not convinced a 24 hour cooldown is enough to deter them in any meaningful way. I, on the other hand, am not persistent enough to wait 24 hours to install an Android app from F-Droid just to try it out.



Stargate is military scifi. For starters, all the protagonists work for the US Air Force.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: