I used both for a long time. i3 for non-terminal work, and tmux in the terminal. Loved it, and am ready to move back to Linux for better OS-tiling management. I also ran it on OpenBSD on my laptop as a daily driver for about ~9 months. Loved the security/simplicity, but made it more difficult or impossible for certain Linux only tools.
It's always been a chore to keep sessions (and tmux windows) at a minimum to avoid context switching and the cognitive drag/fatigue that comes with too many. My goal is 2 active sessions to avoid context switching, but it's so easy to just take on more tasks and try to cycle between all of them, and accomplish less overall. I've had upwards of a dozen, and it is very draining. Even more panes within windows to track subtasks becomes unruly. The other problem is that work keeps ballooning as agents pick up related/unplanned work along the way all the time. I try to reign things in by having the agent create tickets that we will revisit during planning sessions later. By keeping tasks minimal, it feels slower, but then I can think deeply about the problem without the cognitive residue coming from all the other sessions.
GNOME generally seem to have struck a nice balance over the years. Icons has a reasonable amount of skeuomorphism without too much hyperdetailed textures, most icons has distinct shapes (not just a bunch of boxes with rounded corners).
I used to rice my linux desktop, but havefound less reason to do so the last ~5 years, and have been happy using the defaults in Fedora. I spend most of my time in a terminal, the browser and a few select GTK utilities apps, like Switcheroo, Curtail, Netsleuth etc.
Maybe it is the somewhat slower, more iterative pace of GNOME, compared to macOS an Windows, that ends up with a more balanced end result?
I wouldn't say that's better. Now your .config directory contains a github token that can do more than just repo pull/push, and it is trivially exfiltrated. Though similar thing could be said for browser cookies.
I canceled my account recently for the same reason. The two day or same day shipping would never happen even though on the product it was advertised as such.
reply