Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | boosturpud's commentslogin

> Redistribution can only get you so far.

That "so far" being a middle class the envy of the rest of the world which the US threw away to create a new class of oligarch.

"Back at the tail-end of that era, in the early 1960s, America’s richest faced a 91 percent tax rate on income in the top tax bracket."

https://inequality.org/article/tax-the-rich-we-did-that-once...


Perhaps they realised it’s not a good policy? Like literally everywhere else in the world?

No other country has 91% taxes and all those who tried dialled it back. India tried it and it was hilariously bad.


> Perhaps they realised it’s not a good policy?

Citation needed that it's not a good policy. Parent comment explained why it was good, and your reply is "or perhaps it was actually bad".

There's a simpler explanation as to why it was rolled back: the people with the most money and power didn't like it and wanted it gone, and worked over time to accomplish this.


so it could be two reasons

1. 90% tax is a net good for society but big bad capitalists colluded to reduce it in every country independently

or

2. 90% is actually a bad policy and every country independently adopted against it including Nordic countries, China, India, USA

you decide which one is more likely.


It's not "90% tax" it's 90% or similar tax rate at the highest band, which most people will never reach.

Despite you showing your bias by phrasing option 1 to look childish, I think it's more or less what happened, actually. It doesn't take much "collusion", just greed and short-sighted self-interest from greedy, short-sighted self-interested people with influence to wield.

And you till haven't cited how that 1) this definitely didn't happen and 2) high tax rates in the highest band is a bad idea.


Exactly.

Stop trying to foist your "P" into my "AI".


You genaPi boosters are insufferable.

This is like blaming people for crashing when they buy a new car and the brake lines have yet to be installed. "Any mechanic would know to first install the brake lines before driving the car."

You spout this victim blaming billionaire taintlicking from one side of your mouth, and then from the other you proclaim how these tools "allow anyone to code".

If the deliverable is a virtual machine then they should be delivering a virtual machine.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: