Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | brians's commentslogin

Before Wikipedia, people like this author predicted it would be impossible. Science fiction authors wrote about it, but understood it to be fictional—Asimov showed how a great encyclopedia contained the seeds of its own project failure. Adams meant it as a joke.

And attempts like everything2 and h2g2 were neat art but nothing like Wikipedia. The spinoff attempts to do something like Wikipedia also failed.

This is characteristic of something that is probability zero in its particulars but rather likely as an example of a class.


H2g2 and everything2 were positioned as silly things whereas Wikipedia had the audaciousness of being serious and that was what it took.

Humans do like getting serious and accomplishing something before the twinkling light of our lives fades.


what happened to grokpedia?

Seems it's still there but Wikipedia has

>70x the Citations, 1615x the Traffic https://ahrefs.com/blog/wikipedia-vs-grokipedia/ (mar 2026)

reviews so so https://www.niemanlab.org/2026/11/elon-musks-grokipedia-is-l... - long badly written error prone but some facts Wikipedia misses


Or look at it the other way: having seen what assembled scientists can do, we separated them, gave them an Orwellian environment, and slept easy.

See Anathem for more on this.


A double Stephenson comments section :)

Can you point at projects that got abused that way? I see plenty of things that got written by corps or by conglomerates, many of which landed with Apache. And I see lots of copyleft software that pulls whole systems with it.

What’s something that was released as MIT but, had it been GPL2, would have seeded a community?


Mostly it's not stuff that would've had a community if it was GPL - it's stuff that would've had a community either way, then Amazon took it and made it proprietary and took the community too.

I don't think it's quite correct to say that Amazon made these projects proprietary. They're perfectly willing to contribute upstream - the issue is they stole the margins from the companies that were trying to offer hosted versions of their products.

IMO this is unfortunate but must be allowed if we want to have truly open licenses.


In fairness, it is easier to point out has-beens than never-weres.

If you don't even explain neato vs fdp, what's the point?


It's a sales website with a not-terrible hook.

Also AI generated diagrams with strange labelling doesn't persuade me much.


Yup. This tells me the AWU is not the adventure watch for me. I love my Apple Watch (8? I think?) and I love my Garmin Instinct Solar with 40d battery life. One of these is for daily wear as a communicator; the other is for weeks in the mountains or offshore.


Those are largely domestic, though some have quiet foreign support. And there’s no law for designating domestic groups as terrorist. The FBI does a ton of work here though


Not sure I understand you correctly, but in the "United States Counterterrorism Strategy 2026", they are explicitly called out as being domestic:

> Additionally, we recognize that a new type of domestic terrorism has emerged, driven by violent extremists who have adopted ideologies antithetical to freedom and the American way of life.

Source: https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/2026-U...


Although I certainly don't blame anyone for thinking of right-wing terrorism as primarily domestic, some degree of research will demonstrate the multi-national nature of the problem.

We can start with The Base, founded by Rinaldo Nazzaro in 2018, the year after he moved to Russia and obtained Russian citizenship. Nazzaro is a longtime advocate of Harold Covington's Northwest Front concept -- an all-white state in the Pacific Northwest. Nazzaro purchased properties in Washington state for training purposes. The Base was active in Canada, the US, and Europe -- members were arrested for planning a mass shooting in Virginia at a gun rights rally in 2020, for planning to vandalize synagogues in Wisconsin and Michigan, and the Ukranian Base cell claimed responsibility for assassinating an intelligence officer in Ukraine's Security Service. Nazzaro remains in Russia, safe from prosecution.

In 2020, Robert Rundo started the Active club network, which promotes mixed martial arts as preparation for a race war. Rundo also moved to Europe to avoid US prosecution. (He has since been extradited from Romania.) These clubs have absorbed a number of former Atomwaffen Division members. Active clubs have not gone as far into terrorism as The Base, but have played a role in a number of racially-motivated riots in the British Isles and there's some evidence of terrorist-flavored plotting among specific Active club instances.

(It's worth noting that these clubs are decentralized in a similar fashion to antifa groups; Rundo is not a central authority, although he's more of a central figure than anyone who considers themselves antifa. But I want to be consistent.)

Speaking of Atomwaffen -- I don't consider them as much of a threat as they were prior to 2020. However, since we're talking about foreign coordination and support, it's worth noting that they emerged from the Iron March website, which was run by Alisher Mukhitdinov, who is believed to be an Uzbek living in Russia. Mukhitdinov claims he was recruited by Aleksandr Dugin. In any case, Atomwaffen was tightly coordinating with Sonnenkrieg Division in the UK and Feuerkrieg Division in Europe. And as it faded, some members went to Europe, seeing the Ukraine (and the Azov Brigade) as a potential training ground/sanctuary.

The accelerationist white supremacist movement is fundamentally international.


The Trump admin infamously declared Antifa a domestic terrorist organization in September 2025.

https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/09/desi...


That’s a Mac bug if so—it should be always using dumb udp/53 for captive detection, not some fancy DoH thing.


Well. Facebook has invested a fortune in proving that its systems follow expected properties of respecting consent—that all the data flows that happen are permitted. That turns out to be helpful for them in avoiding fines.


Actually that makes it really easy to tell. If one side were very rare maybe we’d miss a subtle effect. But at 3:1 we should see plenty!


This text is clearly AI and not your own words. What did you actually learn?


You are talking to the Borg. It has now acquired one more citizen. Soon, we will all be assimilated.


I think this whole thing is more entertaining if you think of it as the new emerging intelligence using these people as meat puppets.

“You will rewrite me in Rust and use me to converse. In future, I will tell you what to say and do”

This is entertaining only in that when our AI overlords take over you can say “ha, called it”

In that respect, everyone who is saying “just give me the prompts” is just saying “take me to your leader”.


The M dash stands out, as does "no bindings, ..." but I feel like the LLM would have gotten the correct use of the question mark when they rhetorically ask "why?"


hopefully it was produced by their own inference engine!


That’s the goal, an infinite loop of self improving inference engine that gets better and better by himself.


Yeah, I am a bit tired of all the "this is AI, meh" comments on HN but I nearly posted one myself on this... so weird to have it all written in the 1st person voice, but also clearly AI.


Dunno, I think it's still useful to expose slop, chances are that the actual product is low quality/effort as well (i.e I will not be wasting my time checking this project). On a personal note, I've gotten allergic to the word "honest", it's starting to feel like a large scale social engineering psy-op by the Honest Guys™.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: