Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | callc's commentslogin

Hey Pavel! Thank you so much to you and Chris for writing this book. I really mean it! It's started me on a fun journey (and hopefully career change soon) into working on really hard problems in browsers.

I finished going through this in July this year. Here are my thoughts at the time: https://calvinlc.com/p/2026/07/23/browser.html

No questions, just gratitude!


Great write up, thanks for sharing!

Curious what people here think as digital technology makes it easier to spot indicators that someone may commit a crime.

I’m thinking about how it used to be extremely impractical to track most of the population, the the enforcement comes after the crime, and there is no pressure to have detected it before it happened and stop it.

How should society/law change in response? Is it purely a give and take between surveillance/right-to-not-be-watch and trying to prevent all bad things from happened before they happen?


>I’m thinking about how it used to be extremely impractical to track most of the population, the the enforcement comes after the crime, and there is no pressure to have detected it before it happened and stop it.

Privacy, unfortunately, is largely the result of it being impractical to violate it.

I see zero reason to believe that states wont read your thoughts if they can easily manage to.


There is a popular movie starring Tom Cruise that explores the consequences of this question.

In Minority Report (spoilers), the precrime department is shut down because of a single error proving the system is fallible, thus making the plot preposterous in the age of AI.

Psycho Pass is perhaps a better depiction of what could happen to a society where the system is broadly accepted.

If we're wading into this medium, then Shimoneta ought be mentioned too, albeit in an absurdist manner filtered through a comedic lens.

We literally have executed innocent people with our current system and not only is there little will to change this system but even stopping executions in response is still up for debate. It was actually preposterous when the film came out!

Dick's original story is actually much darker and more realistic in that the main character's motivation is as much about preserving the appearance of infallibility in the precrime system in the face of it's flaws as it is about proving his innocence.


Haha. In the real world, it's closer to "one success justifies the program's existence" than "one failure closes it down."

Boy, is that ever true. Vide for example the gangsterism of the deportation campaigns under this administration. Somewhere, somehow, they managed to arrest some actually bad guys, and this apparently vindicates mass roundups, wanton thuggery and performative cruelty toward the other 99%.

Philip K. Dick: In my book I invented the Precrime Division as a cautionary tale.

Tech Company: At long last, we have created the Precrime Division from classic sci-fi novelette The Minority Report.


If everyone had a spine like you we’d all be much better off for it

The sad thing is that it's really a lot easier than everyone seems to think it is.

Our masters keep us desperate so we can't

Let me try to pitch you:

The value of general computing freedom is like any other freedom: it is needed when it people are trying to express you.

And not just you. Anyone! So evaluating whether a freedom is necessary turns into a much more nebulous question of “would anyone really need this at one point now or in the future? Is this a thing we should protect in general, even if it does seem like we need it exactly now?”

For example, could Apple/Google at one point be strong armed (by any government) into including spyware onto all devices? And listeners to make sure no one ever says bad things about $DEAR_LEADER?

If the probability of yes is anywhere around 10% over the next decade, maybe it’s a good freedom to have.


No one cares about all that stuff. They just want to do fun/useful things on their phone.


You are correct in the implication not many people at all care.

Just like most people don’t care about freedom of speech, since they don’t “utilize” it. It’s only utilized when you get sued, and then you can exercise that freedom in court.

IMO we, the techy people, have a responsibility to society to argue for this freedom. Since no one else cares or understands it. But without it it’s too easy for history (in this aspect) to go down a not so good path.


Your pesky morals are no match for my capitalism!

/s


Don’t forget about emotions.

There’s something here about the journey not just the destination.

Press a button and problem solved is not too fun


Same here.

IME on the lock screen I’ll be interacting with the media controls and the screen will just turn off, like I’m not doing any interaction.

It’s funny how that basic of functionality is broken.


I really appreciate that I'm not the only one. Using Apple software is increasingly an experience in navigating a minefield of bizarre UX mistakes.

The big concern for me is if I ever find myself in an emergency situation and I need to use my phone to contact someone. Apple's iPhone is so inconsistent and unreliable even in the best of conditions.


my ipad does that, no interaction with anything on the lockscreen will reset the timeout timer


Less things that can go wrong.

Sometimes just having a local machine that you can do everything on is what you need


It’s so easy to generate a pile of crap now that it “just works” as you say.

Quality, maintainability, simplicity, understandability, flexibility etc all still matter at $DAY_JOB, where you’ve got paying customers. We’ve got a responsibility to write good software that adds to people’s lives.

I’d recommend to try to raise the bar. Commit messages written by humans, no PRs above a certain size, any PR needs an introduction / explanation by author first for the reviewers.


> restricting things without any good reason

A feature, not a bug!

You need to be super up to date to be involved! Have all the devices!


I agree, it's just freaking ironic how it was Jobs who said that "if you don't cannibalize your own products, others will"... and then you have such restrictions for eg on iPadOS software that really push you to a Mac for any "proper" compute...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: