Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | constantius's commentslogin

Exactly. France also has very few migrants from the countries 'Iran attacked': they're largely from North African and Francophone African countries. A lot of inconsistencies and half facts in that comment.

The socialist party hasn't been well-meaning people for a while. I wouldn't even consider them left. Otherwise agree.


Fair. I’m not even sure what they stand for these days. Either way it’s not working


> violent rioters use the excuse of the peaceful organized protest to infiltrate and wreak havoc

This is not true, and very much the kind of propaganda spewed by the (far-)right, please do not trust it.

The entire crowd chants very explicit chants against the government and police, gathers around fires in the street, shouts at police when they attack the demonstrators or fire gas canisters and flash-bang grenades. The crowds that get out are not getting smaller, despite mainstream media and government equating the protests with violent looters, so it seems everyone marching feels a need to. There are looters, but they're a tiny, insignificant minority.

The protests are violent because the repression is violent, and because they are marching against real suffering.


Someone sees an opportunity to get some internet points, has zero engagement with the discussion, makes an announcement for a half-baked project: this is how your 2 sentences look. I think your 'initiative' is perfectly illustrating what that community is trying to avoid.


I used to think like you, but living in a country where the far right is about to come to power, and seeing fundamental freedoms disappear by the day, I've understood why people believe that parties like Reform and AFD (and many other parties, who resemble each other as much in their ideology as in their links with Russia, a useful signal) have to be stopped in their tracks while there's a chance, and if we find ourselves in a 'first they came for the far-right' type of situation, that's a bridge we'll have time to think about later.

The normalisation of fascism, the criminalisation of resistance or even of protests, all the way to the boot stomping on your face, all those things appear so fast, too fast to react. So I can see why one would prefer to take the rights of far-right politicians away. If Corbyn came to power and witchhunted Reform, I would think much less of Corbyn but I'd still understand why others would cheer on that.

And when it comes to Palestine Action, they did the kind of violent crimes that I hope will be taught to future generations, same as we taught about resistance in WWII. I and everyone else support Palestine Action not because of the old women, but because they did burglary and vandalism against a terrorist state carrying out genocide. Sunshine and rainbows.


> I used to think like you, but living in a country where the far right is about to come to power, and seeing fundamental freedoms disappear by the day, I've understood why people believe that parties like Reform and AFD (and many other parties, who resemble each other as much in their ideology as in their links with Russia, a useful signal) have to be stopped in their tracks while there's a chance, and if we find ourselves in a 'first they came for the far-right' type of situation, that's a bridge we'll have time to think about later.

I am in the UK, and Reform, which isn't far right (they are like UKIP dissaffected conservatives and reactionaries), is not going to come into power. In all likelihood they are going to split the Conservative vote.

> The normalisation of fascism, the criminalisation of resistance or even of protests, all the way to the boot stomping on your face, all those things appear so fast, too fast to react. So I can see why one would prefer to take the rights of far-right politicians away. If Corbyn came to power and witchhunted Reform, I would think much less of Corbyn but I'd still understand why others would cheer on that.

I actually like Corbyn (for all his faults), and I think he is fundamentally a good man and wouldn't stoop as low as persecuting his political opponents.

As for witch hunts, historically they've turned out to be a very bad idea. I shouldn't need to comment any further.

> And when it comes to Palestine Action, they did the kind of violent crimes that I hope will be taught to future generations, same as we taught about resistance in WWII. I and everyone else support Palestine Action not because of the old women, but because they did burglary and vandalism against a terrorist state carrying out genocide. Sunshine and rainbows.

"Violent crimes are okay when people I politically agree with do it."

It doesn't matter to me if a violent gang of thugs is left wing or right; they are violent thugs. I think you need to take a break from online politics because it has you justifying the sort of behaviour that you claim to oppose (fascism).


> Corbyn? [...] wouldn't stoop as low as persecuting his political opponents. [...] I shouldn't need to comment any further.

Weird misreading of my comment. I'm not saying he would, I'm saying even if someone as fundamentally as him did, I would think less of them, but that I still would understand it.

> Violent crimes are okay when people I politically agree with do it.

Violent resistance to genocide is something I fully support, with absolutely zero qualms about what unfortunate drone, military company, or government official gets hurt in the process. I'd expect everyone would support that, no?

> justifying the sort of behaviour that you claim to oppose (fascism).

Mate... are you serious?

An advice for you: stop supporting Russia and Israel, you could hardly have chosen a worse moral alignment.


> Violent resistance to genocide is something I fully support, with absolutely zero qualms about what unfortunate drone, military company, or government official gets hurt in the process. I'd expect everyone would support that, no?

No, I don't agree. I don't want a bunch of violent thugs roaming around the UK who think they are morally righteous committing crimes. This will have perverse side effects that you and I cannot predict.

The fact that you haven't considered this fact or don't care shows how naive you are.

> Mate... are you serious?

Yes. What you are advocating for is similar to fascism.

> An advice for you: stop supporting Russia and Israel, you could hardly have chosen a worse moral alignment.

This is the problem with almost every discussion on the net with people like you. Where did I say I support either Russia or Israel? Nowhere.

I don't care about Russia and Israel. This is full of us-vs-them politics-brained bullshit that I often encounter. I will spell it out to you, I don't care about foreign wars that I have no control over. I suggest you start reading some actual literature.

https://classics.mit.edu/Epictetus/epicench.html


This is getting ridiculous, you've been inventing weird claims this whole discussion and condescendingly arguing against them, and getting personal on top of that. Pathetic.

> I don't care about foreign wars that I have no control over

Talking about a war of invasion by a fascist country on the border of your continent and a genocide. I'm wasting my time.


> This is getting ridiculous, you've been inventing weird claims this whole discussion and condescendingly arguing against them, and getting personal on top of that.

I've quoted what you said and responded to them point by point. You said you understand the need to persecute political opponents (those being Reform, which is a centre-right party) and support thugs that break the law in the UK (where I live).

That is what you said. I have my issues with how the British State is run. I, however, understand that I have literally no ability to change any of this.

> Talking about a war of invasion by a fascist country on the border of your continent and a genocide.

"Everything I don't like is fascism."

The genocide is in the Middle East. I have zero ability to affect events there. Israel isn't fascist either because Zionism is not fascism.

As for the Russo-Ukraine war, not every political ideology that isn't democratic western values is fascist. Ukraine/Russia is a proxy war between the Western Allies and countries outside of that alliance.

> I'm wasting my time.

You are repeating poor arguments that equate to "bash the fash", and having a poor understanding of geopolitics isn't my failing and isn't going to convince anyone that isn't an idiot or mind-raped by propaganda.


[flagged]


I don't know why you're subtly indicating conspiracy theories here. The support of certain parties, in this case far right ones, by Russia, financially/ideologically/politically, and in the other direction the support of Russia (and the apology of their war of invasion) by these parties is not a secret or a theory, it's not hidden by either Russia or those parties...

And yes, getting support from amd making apologies for a country like Russia is a good signal of who not to want anywhere near the halls of power.


It's a load of cobblers made up by parties that lose to explain why they are losing. It's the biggest cope of them all and means they don't have to blame their policies or their candidates.


Not wanting to get involved with foreign wars is not the same as supporting a war.

If any of the parties got any support from Russia directly, they would be arrested. Have they been arrested? If not, then whatever you've been told about them being involved with Russia is bullshit. The government would like to find any excuse to lock up certain individuals in the UK; this includes both those on the left and the right.


> If any of the parties got any support from Russia directly, they would be arrested. Have they been arrested? If not, then whatever you've been told about them being involved with Russia is bullshit.

You're taking "innocent until proven guilty" too literally. Absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence.


No, I am not. I've heard a lot of bullshit in politics over the last decade. You got to show me proof. Otherwise, I am not interested in such claims because they are often unfounded or straight-up propaganda.

You should demand evidence for claims, especially if they are serious as you claim.


The state claims everything they disapprove of to be done by Russia, and these useful idiots keep on believing them.


Thanks for showing your true colours. Having a discussion in one comment and insulting me in another. Pathetic.


I think you are a useful idiot if you believe nonsense like "Russia hacked Brexit" and similar claims. I have friends and family that believe this, unfortunately.

I also have very little respect for people that justify violence because they believe they are morally righteous. Doesn't matter whether they are left/right, Muslim, Christian, Jew, Hindu, Buddist etc.


I think they don't know much about history but think they do, and believe that the Crusades were the West heroically coming to help oppressed people because Arabs. 'They started first', basically.


Actually, it was a response to the Ottomans capturing spain


I think it was a response to 9/11.


That's a naive understanding of academia.

Meeting standards is nothing but a formality, a form to fill. The PhDs and lab staff doing the killing, if they have any qualms about the act itself or just the purpose of the killing, generally justify it away as being what they have to do to keep the job. The "humane" killing methods are learned on the job through trial and error, and such errors keep happening regularly to experienced staff.

Prior to lockdowns, many/most lab animals just got killed: interesting quality of life standard.

What's written in lab policies is not at all how it happens in reality.


that does not sound at all like my lab experience, nobody was doing ad hoc trial and error on basic animal management


Just wanted to thank you for your posts in this thread. I'm not American, but I feel depressed about the memory-holing that has happened, ever since the last election, where people seemed to.forget that the Democrats presided over the first year of the genocide, and said they would continue doing so if they had won, and have in fact continued facilitating it with whatever power they wield since. Seeing the reactions like the one you got, the Democratic party ascending to sainthood in the eyes of its supporters, from the very start of that election, feels surreal to me.


Thanks for posting this, I'll get myself an anthology of his poems. If you have other poetry recs, they'd be very welcome.


It was the language of the educated because of the Roman Empire. The elites used to study how to be Roman elites before the 5th century, and when Rome fell they just continued, as it was the established sign of higher class. The elite has been educated by Cicero for the last 2 millennia, and continues to be so.

A good analogy is French being the language of the elite in Britain, well after the Normans got merged into the general population.


> and when Rome fell they just continued, as it was the established sign of higher class.

Well not in the west where the elite was replaced by uneducated barbarians for several centuries and it took quite a while for the church to teach them how to read and write again.


Nomen usoris rei convenit...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: