Security features like this works, until it doesn't.
When I installed WireGuard on macOS, I was happy to discover that it stores private keys in the system keychain. Accessing the private key requires Touch ID.
Then one day after a system upgrade, the WireGuard app crashed on startup with:
[APP] Unable to open config from keychain: -25300
Then the app deleted all profiles because they are all "orphaned", apparently for "keychain consistency" [0].
From then on, I just use a text editor to edit my WireGuard configuration files, and import them to the app. The bug still exists to this day [1].
Can echo this, I've also fallen foul of keychain behaviour. In my case I found a lookup that passed the account name as raw bytes instead of text didn't match my item. On macOS it matched all items with a blank account (strictly, generic password items), which on my computer meant items from GitHub CLI, Malwarebytes, and Adobe Creative Cloud. The app I was building silently used one of those as its key, and would change whenever one of those apps would update its entry. The fix was to make sure the account is passed as a string and that it has a service name so that lookup either matches exactly my item or none. The API takes a loosely typed dictionary, so wrong types throw no errors, just different behaviour. I now always test against the real keychain and not a mock.
So many of the keychain APIs are "deprecated" (read: marked as "we will nuke this API whenever we want") and have been for a decade or more, but have no replacement either.
A lot of the Security Framework came from Classic, hell, the idea of a keychain came from Classic! Just a mess.
The worst part: the people that work at your bank and at city hall are not security nerds, and don't care to become security nerds. do with that what you will.
This is not a feature built for security nerds. This is a feature built for corporate compliance box tickers, and it works precisely as wanted in corporate environments, where all lost secrets can be easily replaced after visiting the helpdesk room personally.
Security nerd here. I would have expected it. But only in the sense that I have no faith in this industry to write secure software and protect from data loss.
I'm using WireGuard myself. Not on MacOS, but on Windows/Linux/Android.
The reason I went with WireGuard to begin with, is due to how secure it suppsedly was. Having long standing unresolved issues like that is a bit worrying. I'm still most likely safe, but it's not exactly reassuring, either
This is likely just that if someone chooses an OS that requires a special HW just to build a release with no easy cross-compilation possible, and to pay a gatekeeper just to publish it, and that can't even run on an emulated computer properly, they can't expect FOSS maintainers will be bothered with much more than "here's a source code, build it/test it/do QA yourself if you like" for their particular pet platform.
For platforms where development is unhindered by arbitrary obstacles like these and others, wireguard works fine. :)
Just going to reply to your comment here: the choice to use wireguard shouldn't come down to relative security (although I guess it gets a benefit here), but from being fast and simplistic.
All of the traditional components of VPN management are removed from the core code. Wireguard follows the model "do one thing, and do it well." It's also built into the kernel, which inherently can make it faster than userland VPN software.
This is why companies like Tailscale exist--as they're basically selling back the features that you would get in a more traditional IPSEC VPN, but in front of Wireguard instead.
> You linked a commit and a Reddit post. Is there a proper Github issue as well?
It's funny you mentioned that. The GitHub repository is a mirror of https://git.zx2c4.com/wireguard-apple. You cannot create issues there. You're supposed to send a bug report to the mailing list, which is enough friction that none of us did so far.
Its unfortunate no updates for Wireguard macOS have been pushed out for 3 years, App Store is still showing 1.0.16 as the latest version – as also confirmed on the Wireguard website at the latest version.
No doubt macOS APIs have moved on a lot in 3 years and so perhaps bugs that are being seen are simply a reflection of the lack of updates to keep up with API changes ? Just thinking aloud here, I don't know if the concept of OS API changes are applicable to this particular PR / bug.
> I've passed on reporting so many bugs, because I refuse to create a Microsoft account to do it.
99% of the time it's perfectly fine to just email the maintainer with a bug report and maybe a patch.
> In fact, I don't understand how sending an email is high friction.
Judging from the fact that after so many years, such a widespread (as seen in the Reddit post and here) issue still hasn't resulted in a single bug report in the mailing list, I'd say most people (including myself) do indeed consider using a mailing list to be higher friction.
If I'm not mistaken, unless you're already CC'ed by a participant, you'd have to subscribe to the whole mailing list just to receive notifications for a single thread. For an "issue" on a Git forge, participation is usually as easy as upvoting and then clicking the "Subscribe" button.
Assuming you're already using MS Github. Anyway, even if I was, a lot of Github project require filling out an absurd Simon Says form. Or that scene from Indiana Jones where he takes a wrong step and falls through the floor. That's nothing to do with email or Microsoft specifically, it's just another reason I almost never bother reporting bugs. Talk about friction.
Yeah, I hate these forms (issue templates) too. Every time I have to fill such a form, I always feel that they are discouraging me from writing the bug description in a natural, coherent way. I'd spend more effort to make sure the description is clear and contains all necessary information, if there's no issue template requirements.
Yes, but most people won't. Most people will submit a bug report with important information missing that means we have to go back and forth. Also, there is often specific debugging information that people would not even know would be useful.
In the current age, its useful because AI will submit tickets using the CLI that don't use the form, so I can immediately close and lock them and go on living my life.
Edit (March 2025):
Wireguard, to my surprise, has no bug tracking system like Jira or issue tracking area such as GitHub.
If you want to see this fixed, the only way to instigate change is to write team@wireguard.com and jason@zx2c4.com.
Interestingly this is exactly why I have to mess with brightness settings from time to time.
Has anyone else noticed the weird interaction between apps turning the brightness to the max and the system’s auto brightness? I’m not an iOS developer, so I don’t know about the relevant APIs. But every time an app changes the brightness to display a QR code, it seems to do so by retrieving the current brightness, turning it to the max, and when it’s done, setting it back to the old value. The problem is that iOS seems to register the brightness change as user initiated, and changes auto brightness behavior. After a few uses, auto brightness will no longer adjust the display to the minimum brightness, even when you’re in complete darkness.
Fixing this used to be easy. Just go to display settings and toggle auto brightness off and on. Then Apple decided to move the toggle under accessibility. Now it’s Accessibility -> Display & Text Size and scroll all the way to the bottom.
I'm new to Ubiquiti routers, but I had no problem dividing the /60 I got from my ISP and assign /64s to VLANs.
You might be interested in https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KZpJvpm1Ris (title: Does UniFi FINALLY support IPv6 Properly? State of IPv6 with Unifi Network v9). The video is about a year old, but from the looks it's not terribly outdated.
> Every time I login using a Wayland desktop, only my main monitor is detected and it defaults to 60hz. I have to go through a whole process of unplugging the "undetected" monitors and plugging them back in.
Are you using GNOME? mutter has this problem where it does not retry commit on the next CRTC: https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/mutter/-/issues/3833. If this is actually what's happening on your system, switching to KDE should solve it.
> HDR on Wayland is barely functional (in my experience)
This also sounds specific to GNOME, as mutter still doesn't have color management. You'll get a better HDR experience with KDE.
GNOME is typically the worst of all the options if you need feature support. They aggressively nack wayland proposals, and subsequently don't implement those proposals - while almost the entirety of the ecosystem does.
No, having the bare minimum "HDR support" does not mean it works fine. I have a 27-inch 4K 144Hz monitor with P3 wide color gamut and HDR600. This monitor is connected to 2 PCs, one running Arch Linux with GNOME as the DE and one with Windows 11.
Since Windows 11 24H2, with the new color management feature turned on, I can get correct colors on the monitor in both SDR and HDR modes. So it ends up with HDR on at all times, and mpv can play HDR videos with no color or brightness issues.
GNOME, on the other hand, is stuck with sRGB output in SDR mode, so you get oversaturated colors. With HDR on, SDR content will no longer be oversaturated, but if you play HDR videos with mpv, the image looks darkened and wrong. I've tried setting target-peak and target-contrast to match the auto-detected values on Windows, but the video still looks off.
Have you actually contributed to the Go standard library?
Yes, there are people who don't work for Google and can +2 on changes, but you still need 2 Google employees to at least +1 on your change before it can be submitted. This is mentioned in the Contribution Guide [0] and is enforced by Gerrit.
> Finally, to be submitted, a change must have the involvement of two Google employees, either as the uploader of the change or as a reviewer voting at least Code-Review +1. This requirement is for compliance and supply chain security reasons.
I see you use a hard-coded constant ALIGN = 512. Many NVMe drives actually allow you to raise the logical block size to 4096 by re-formatting (nvme-format(1)) the drive.
Just opted to use fixed 512 byte alignment in this library since all decent SSDs I have encountered so far are ok with 512 byte file alignment and 64 byte memory alignment.
This makes the code a bit simpler both in terms of the allocator and the file operations.
It’s really the hardware block size that matters in this case (direct I/O). That value is a property of the hardware and can’t be changed.
In some situations, the “logical” block size can differ. For example, buffered writes use the page cache, which operates in PAGE_SIZE blocks (usually 4K). Or your RAID stripe size might be misconfigured, stuff like that. Otherwise they should be equal for best outcomes.
In general, we want it to be as small as possible!
> It’s really the hardware block size that matters in this case (direct I/O). That value is a property of the hardware and can’t be changed.
NVMe drives have at least three "hardware block sizes". There's the LBA size that determines what size IO transfers the OS must exchange with the drive, and that can be re-configured on some drives, usually 512B and 4kB are the options. There's the underlying page size of the NAND flash, which is more or less the granularity of individual read and write operations, and is usually something like 16kB or more. There's the underlying erase block size of the NAND flash that comes into play when overwriting data or doing wear leveling, and is usually several MB. There's the granularity of the SSD controller's Flash Translation Layer, which determines the smallest size write the SSD can handle without doing a read-modify-write cycle, usually 4kB regardless of the LBA format selected, but on some special-purpose drives can be 32kB or more.
And then there's an assortment of hints the drive can provide to the OS about preferred granularity and alignment for best performance, or requirements for atomic operations. These values will generally be a consequence of the the above values, and possibly also influenced by the stripe and parity choices the SSD vendor made.
Why would you want the block size to be as small as possible? You will only benefit from that for very small files, hence the sweet spot is somewhere between "as small as possible" and "small multiple of the hardware block size".
If you have bigger files, then having bigger blocks means less fixed overhead from syscalls and NVMe/SATA requests.
If your native device block size is 4KiB, and you fetch 512 byte blocks, you need storage side RAM to hold smaller blocks and you have to address each block independently. Meanwhile if you are bigger than the device block size you end up with fewer requests and syscalls. If it turns out that the requested block size is too large for the device, then the OS can split your large request into smaller device appropriate requests to the storage device, since the OS knows the hardware characteristics.
The most difficult to optimize case is the one where you issue many parallel requests to the storage device using asynchronous file IO for latency hiding. In that case, knowing the device's exact block size is important, because you are IOPs bottlenecked and a block size that is closer to what the device supports natively will mean fewer IOPs per request.
Using full-blown VPNs under such environments has the disadvantage of affecting your use of domestic web services. You might want to try something like https://github.com/database64128/shadowsocks-go, which allows you to route traffic based on domain and IP geolocation rules.
> One problem with Go is the lack of fine-grained control over allocation. In particular, no arena allocation support. How does C# compare?
Go has an experimental arena package [0], but the proposal is on hold and the code may be removed in the future.
C# does not support arenas. But it does provide the stackalloc keyword, whereas in Go you kind of need the compiler's blessing for avoiding heap allocations.
> Another problem is relatively high cost of FFI interop with C. It's gotten better, but Go still needs to switch stacks, etc. How is C#?
Async in C# is implemented as stackless coroutines. Calling into FFI is cheap.
> How does C# compilation speed compare?
In my experience, release builds are a bit slower than Go.
> Does the compiler optimize more aggressively than Go (which does very little optimization)? I've heard the C# AOT compiler is lacking, but it's not clear in what way.
>> Can you use LINQ against databases like Postgres on Linux, without having to buy into a lot of Microsoft/.NET stuff?
>Probably not. This is usually done with EF Core and the Postgres provider.
You can use Npgsql[0] alone or with non-EF Core interfaces, since it's just a ADO.NET Data Provider (for others: the common interface for database access in dotnet).
The GP question is interesting because it asks about using LINQ with databases "without having to buy into a lot of Microsoft/.NET stuff". I'm going to assume they mean "without using all-microsoft-sourced libraries and frameworks like Entity Framework" (since LINQ is a .NET library interface thing anways).
A couple of example of alternatives that support utilizing Npgsql for database access:
There are a number of other libraries, some more or less complete/maintained than others. EF and Dapper are by far the most popular libraries folks are using on top of Postgres, but there are alternatives, and using the ADO interface on its own works fine (I've done this in very small projects to limit dependencies).
Shameless plug: I wrote a DDNS service in Go [0] that uses Netlink on Linux and the IP Helper API on Windows to monitor network interface addresses in the most efficient way possible. As a result of working on this project, I sent 3 separate CLs to the x/sys module.
This is one of the many things where Go just takes care of automatically. Since Go 1.19, if you import the os package, on startup, the open file soft limit will be raised to the hard limit: https://github.com/golang/go/commit/8427429c592588af8c49522c...
Seems like a good idea but I do wonder what the cost is as the overhead of allocate the extra resource space (whatever it is) would be added to every Go application.
I doubt the kernel would actually allocate the resource space upfront. Like SO_SNDBUF and SO_RCVBUF, it's probably only allocated when it's actually needed.
When I installed WireGuard on macOS, I was happy to discover that it stores private keys in the system keychain. Accessing the private key requires Touch ID.
Then one day after a system upgrade, the WireGuard app crashed on startup with:
Then the app deleted all profiles because they are all "orphaned", apparently for "keychain consistency" [0].From then on, I just use a text editor to edit my WireGuard configuration files, and import them to the app. The bug still exists to this day [1].
[0] https://github.com/WireGuard/wireguard-apple/commit/dfb685f2...
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/WireGuard/comments/wyt828/osx_wireg...
reply