Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | devrob's commentslogin

i lol'd - "it was always knowing what to measure not what to count"

"You're absolutely right I shouldn't have refactored the database schema as a clean up item. Do you want me to revert the git commits or move ahead with feat/foobar-bizz-buzz?"

I was trying to build a version control system at one point. Basically an Ableton project is actually just a massive XML file that you could dump into a repo. I was trying to think of what a "git like" abstraction would work on top of it, but one of the challenges or problems I imagined would be all the VSTs/plugins and compatibility across units. In theory, the actual idea of freezing your XML and pushing to a git repo isn't so bad; it's similar to what Zepplin did with sketch ages ago, the fear was always - what happens when "figma" comes along and kills it but I didn't invest too much time into it.

The other challenge is media file management. Specifically, multiple MB & GB of media file storage means $$$ and git was magical because of free hosting. Then there was clip splicing and diffs - a wav file isn't exactly like a piece of code you can read directly and I don't have enough knowledge of the internals to make it work.

I was also worried Ableton would just take the idea and integrate it anyway and then it would be a wasted effort me


Years ago there was a startup called Splice here in NYC where the original product was basically just that -- version control and collaboration for Ableton (and maybe other DAWs?). I remember having an interview at Union Square Ventures for a role there and a couple of the partners asked me about them as they were an investment, and I really couldn't see a viable business in it the same way GitHub was for git. I brought up the storage costs as well.

I just looked them up and it seems like they're still around and pivoted to a learning DAW and a plugin marketplace.


You mean these guys? https://splice.com/ They're absolutely massive in the music scene.

They're the de-facto sample library for 90% of any commercial track you've listened to on the radio/spotify/tv. There are a few Fred Again and Sabrina Carpenter songs that are basically just one straight sample taken wholesale from them.

Had no idea they started as a version control system.


I was working on exactly the same idea - mobile app to record stems, cloud-based projects - and I remember the sinking feeling when I read the TechCrunch article covering Splice's launch.

Surprised that 10 years later on there's still no industry juggernaut owning collab music production.


I asked claude to 1 shot it and this is what it made: https://github.com/aquaflamingo/ableton-stem-vcs

You should mention that in the README.

Historically, I've been using Recordly and Finalcut to generate product videos for things. Some examples: https://matchcutfcp.aquaflamingolabs.com/


I'm building a couple of things:

1. Creating a MacOS native personal finance tracking + networth dashboard, inspired by Gnucash but no complex business stuff (e.g., Tax invoices)

2. Creating a vision / journey board that tracks your life milestones and displays them in a personal mandala / spiral :)

3. Trying to build an visual story telling tool that lets me convert my medium to long form essays into visual animated companions for youtube. e.g.,

Press 'ENTER' to Feel_ // A Techno Phenomenology https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lq5tlsX8uIM


Wasn't that what the first iterations of cursor were?


Out of curiosity, what real economic terms would you have to see to be convinced?

Do you mean more earnings per share for corporations or real utility impacts on social systems (e.g., more new drugs)

When I ask Claude about the AI ROI, it seems to cite that ~95% of AI PoC's are negative ROI but the 5% that do have ROI tend to have decent return -- my guess is mostly back office clean up to reduce expenses and increase revenue/profit.

IIRC Uber claim their 1.5k/mo budget lead to no new value creation.

FWIW, I look at the situation with similar skepticism. One argument you could make was what Marc Andreesen said with the hypothesis that "all the big companies get nuked", so no new valued gets created but the large market cap companies get eaten by thousands of little pirañas. Obviously, so far, that doesn't seem to be the case.


> Do you mean more earnings per share for corporations or real utility impacts on social systems (e.g., more new drugs)

I mean real utility impacts. More reliable and efficient software, better features, etc. So far we've seen none of that. In fact, it seems like the opposite--more volume but a much lower quality product.


Ah yes, sloponomics.


I used to have a rolling product satire I called "Claude Handshake" which basically explained how cold-email is dead today as people feed email contents into Claude and Claude responds with a draft, that usually comes from another person doing the same thing.

The idea was to just avoid sending email altogether and just simulate the interaction entirely using Claude.


missed opportunity to do book.google :(


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: