Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | dragon96's commentslogin

You can't pull the plug after it kills people. For example see [1], where the DOJ mistargeted a school with AI.

There are scenarios where kill -9 isn't going to happen in time. What if the team that is harming people with AI is different from the one that is monitoring the harm? What if no one is monitoring? What if the user is intentionally malicious?

And wiping out humanity doesn't necessarily mean shooting people either. Every trader involved in the '08 financial crisis was locally acting in their own interests. Those could have easily been AIs optimizing trading strategies too.

[1] https://futurism.com/artificial-intelligence/us-military-pen...


> in the '08 financial crisis ... could have easily been AIs optimizing trading strategies too

??? They were... There are books about the faults in the algorithms that led to the '08 financial crisis.

> pull the plug after it kills people

Are you aware that in this regard "AI" means "all algorithms employed in decision making"?


[flagged]


This is a very ironic statement.

Do you think that AI killing us would not involve us doing stupid shit with AI first? Or do you have some strange idea that this strange AI we're talking about would just pop up out of nowhere like a miracle?


lol precisely. At least you have come around to my argument. Its stupid people doing stupid things, not some amazing AI that spits out text doing it. Stupid people kill people today already. Stupid people have always existed but LLMS are not going to wipe out humanity.

There is no AGI, there is no intellgent text predictor that is scheming to make us do stupid shit to wipe us off the map, its stupid people that evolution will take care of. We have survived this long, we will be ok. We make mistakes along the way but we somehow manage to survive. The only thing I see killing us soon is climate change, but again we can stop it but stupid people seem to want us to keep going down the path we are. We will eventually solve that problem too.

If anyone has any strange ideas, its those parroting the idea that LLMs are AGI and will lead to the death of humanity. Utter nonsense but again thankfully nature and evolution has a way of keeping the smart and strong while eliminating the weak.


No, I have not come to your view at all.


I won't bother arguing, but there's also no need to be rude about it


> Why does it say ‘written by’ and ‘pictures by’, was this made without AI?

That is what those terms mean, yes...


People lie, particularly people who have used AI to generate things. Given the image styling and story I suspect LLM use to generate. A credit would be nice for the little machines.

Also regardless of AI use, I’d expect a credit for the author whose style this is a pastiche of.


I'm sure you took the time to study the works of the artist over the course of their 23 year tenure and their body of work. Right?


Since it’s a ripoff of another artist alongside partially AI written text it’s hard to tell really. But sure, your righteous indignation on their behalf is noted.


Parodies are not rip-offs. There's a reason why we explicitly allow them under copyright law as fair use.


It's not a parody, unless you take parody to mean 'copy of an artist's style'. Parodies are not a tribute but an insult to the person concerned, usually an exaggeration - this is just a copy.


Parody doesn't have to insult the original; the key thing you need is commenting on the original. This piece is on the border between using the setting and style of F&T to make an unrelated point (not parody) and commenting on how the F&T cookies story, despite being written for children, makes a broader point about incentives and control that adults would do well to internalize (parody).


Thank you; it's nice to be appreciated.


> Given the image styling and story I suspect LLM use to generate. A credit would be nice for the little machines.

This is rather passive-aggressive. It would be nice if you're right, but you haven't given any basis other than vague suspicion. You're implying that it's "not nice" because they didn't credit the AI, but you haven't come anywhere close to establishing that AI was actually used. I could just as easily suspect your comment of being AI and claim that it would be nicer if you just admitted it.


AI was used, see the comments above.


I don't see any comment at all that AI was used for the image generation in the way you alleged


Sending an AI response communicates more than just the response itself:

1. "I'm not entirely sure, but this is what it says to save you some time."

2. "You didn't ask the question precisely because you are not an SME, but I reworded it using the jargon that would allow the AI to answer better and here is the response."

3. "This response is AI, but in general my other ones are not"

4. "I trust the AI's response in this scenario."


These are somewhat valid reasons, but I think most of us have seen the use of pasting AI responses that are simply a laziness of communicating.

If you're trying (1), it's easier to say "I don't know, maybe <available ai> can answer". It doesn't save any time to ask an AI that the other party is equally equipped to ask. It just saves the responder time from being genuinely helpful.

If you're (2), at least explain this (or include the prompt so it's self evident and a teaching moment). Of course, if you're a SME, maybe you also have the knowledge to just answer directly - see 4.

For (3), why reply at all: see 1.

For (4), saying this associates your own authority and knowledge, and is valuable, but the omission of such disclaimer makes it indistinguishable from 1.


Sometimes people ask questions on HN off handedly while making some kind of argument where the questions can easily be answered by plugging them into a Google search box. And then I wonder why didn’t they just do that? Usually they don’t do it because it causes whatever argument they are making to implode quickly. I’m guessing they aren’t anti AI they just don’t want to know. It’s not even a “do you trust the AI or not” since the AI is just able to quickly find and present basic data. The fact that their question can be answered quickly and easily is what they find offensive.

At work I’ll use AI to answer colleague questions and then wonder why they just didn’t use it instead. It’s usually just a training issue, the answers are usually right enough to unblock them at least.


If severity is a low cardinality enum, it still seems acceptable


The order returned from the Index Scan is not the ordering requested by the user, so there would still have to be a full (or topk) Sort over the dataset returned from the index scan, which could negate the gains you get from using an Index Scan; PostgreSQL itself does not produce merge join plans that merge a spread of index scans to get suffix-ordered data out of an index.


What does a Spiel game refer to?

If you want the ultimate depth:ruleset ratio, come learn Go :) Every game is so different and exciting


Spiel Des Jahres is a prize they give every year to a bunch of board games. Don't look at very old board games, but some of the modern ones: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spiel_des_Jahres

As for Go, I was tempted, but it's also very abstract, I do like some kind of theme in my board games.

A board game well integrated with the theme gives great vibes.

Some of the games great from there: - Sky Team, discovered right there on the wikipedia page: for 2 players, me and my wife spent countless hours on it. Very simple rules yet so damn fun - Azul up to 4, simple rules and a lot of depths. Place tiles on a board while stealing from others the stuff they want to use - Kingdomino is so simple yet choosing the piece (some form of draft) requires thinking ahead so many turns! - Dominion is still a great game: deck builder with simple rules. Didn't think that was possible? It is!

A lot of the children games are also great (this is for families with kids)

Some nominated are also great, even if they didn't win


Spiel des Jahres (Game of the Year) is a boardgame award that notably favors family-friendly accessibility. If you're seeing the award on the box, you can be confident that even if the strategy can potentially get really deep, you can still break this out to have a fun time with both grandma and your 12 year old cousin.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spiel_des_Jahres


One of the values of doing your own research is it forces you to speak the "language" of what you're trying to do.

It's like the struggle that we've all had when learning our first programming language. If we weren't forced to wrestle with compilation errors, our brains wouldn't have adapted to the mindset that the computer will do whatever you tell it to do and only that.

There's a place for LLMs in learning, and I feel like it satisfies the same niche as pre-synthesized Medium tutorials. It's no replacement for reading documentation or finding answers for yourself though.


This seems like a difference between learning styles. You seem to champion learning by reading. I’d argue using an LLM to build a toy or tool and learning that way is just as valid.


Plus, in-game clocks didn't exist until Remastered came out


Inconvenient truths about the big bad wolf disaster of 2027


I keep comments committed in a separate branch.

The lack of syncing doesn't bother me, because the purpose of taking notes always falls into one of these categories:

1. I read the code to get an idea of how something works. The code is there to make examples/variable names concrete, but I don't need to know the exact implementation.

If the notes need to sit in the code, usually that's because the answer spans multiple methods (eg "what does an e2e request look like?"). A set of comments on outdated code is always good enough for me.

Otherwise, a lot of times the answer can be summarized in one line (eg "where is the state tracked?" -> in FooBarClass). These can go into personal notes.

2. I need to know the implementation and it is complex and hard to follow.

If I need to know the implementation, either it is because I'm actively working on it, or I need to make [complex idea] more concrete in my head.

If it's the former, usually I'll have memorized it by the time I read through it.

If it's the latter, by the end of it I'll have gotten the main idea and it's fine to forget the implantation details.


Next up: Numbers every math person should know


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: