Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | driverdan's commentslogin

Still requires using a 3rd party service, sending your data to them, and their app. They could sell your data or include ads too.

I recommend everyone try the example search for themselves (best german bank account for foreigners) and look at everything in the first SERP.

On DDG I get All About Berlin as #6. All the sites above it appear to be LLM generated. Everything is affiliate slop.

On Google I get All About Berlin #2, below Reddit. It only gives me 7 standard search results and a lot of other garbage. Everything besides Reddit is affiliate slop.

On Kagi I get All About Berlin #1. Out of the other 25 results one is Reddit, one is Facebook, and the rest seem to be all the same list style as All About Berlin with a mix of clearly LLM generated content and some that may have been but isn't clear. It's all SEOed.

This is a case where all the results are bad. I don't ever want to be recommended something from an affiliate site. It's just another form of advertising. I also don't want to see any LLM generated sites. None of this is organic content. It's all SEO sites to sell you stuff.


This article is nice but CF does not commit to doing anything in it. They say they are opposed to this and vaguely imply they might have to do something if they lose their appeal.

Stop being vague. CF, will you commit to also withdrawing from impacted countries if the ruling goes against you?


> does not commit to doing anything in it

Right. But of all companies it seems that Cloudflare has the best track record of fighting the governments for this exact reason, so I feel they're not going to let us down here as well.


I agree. Historically they've been a champion of causes like this. This could be an inflection point though which is why I'm asking if they will commit. Since they haven't I'm guessing they will comply and it will be downhill from here.

They can't do shit. You're making it seem like there's an option besides complying or leaving, when there's obviously not.

Well you can also not comply. There may or may not be consequences.

Making your enemy take the first action can be strategic for optics. Consider "Google bans Italy" vs "Italy bans Google", who looks better in each scenario?


CF will stay and enjoy their new anticompetitive protection.

Isnt it ironic that Cloudflare wrote that post?

I have questions! Does it really require all that hardware? I've spent the last week working on a P25 scanner with 2 RTL-SDRs on a Pi and transcription running on a Ryzen AI laptop. The Pi keeps up with recording fine but it is only 4-5Mhz bandwidth instead of the ~11Mhz you're monitoring. For me transcription only lags by a few seconds but if I ran it on my desktop with a 2080ti it wouldn't even be that much.

What STT model are you using? In my tests I've gotten the best WER with whisper v3 large but it's still not that good.


I would expect that the hardware involved is massive overkill.

The Ettus SDRs are very nice and are marked up enormously over the BOM cost. You’re paying for an integrated, supported system, with good engineering, not for the parts. These days, for this particular use, you could probably build your own direct (no downconversion) receiver with a decent filter and, say, a 400MSPS DAC. (This was not a thing at any reasonable price point 15 years ago when I last played with this stuff.) Or you can buy or build a little mixer and choose an appropriate LO frequency and use a much cheaper DAC. Or you can buy a cheaper SDR.

~15 years ago I amused myself for about an hour using a USRP (older Ettus gear) and MATLAB to do more or less this but for regular FM radio, one channel at a time, on a decent laptop of the era. The processing power needed to channelize and demodulate a few channels from I/Q data is very, very low. Even coming up with some kind of optimal demodulation scheme wouldn’t use many cycles. (Although I suspect that there is more space to try to jointly optimize demodulation and transcription with FM than with AM.)

It would be a fun project to try to kludge up an ESP32 of some sort to do this. The tricky bit would be that the WiFi/BT hardware doesn’t go to DC.


Is P25 not encrypted?

It can be. My local network has a few encrypted talkgroups for more sensitive stuff but most is not.

That's not true. Zigbee and Zwave are local only, private, and inexpensive. Home Assistant is great free open source software.

It's not always that simple. I have a bunch of devices in my home that have WiFi IoT: bedroom AC, dehumidifier, refrigerator, and washer/dryer. I bought all of them regardless because they work fine without WiFi and I've never connected them. I'd love it if I could connect them to Home Assistant without data leaving my network. Reverse engineering them is on my list of future projects.

In the meantime they continue to function as "dumb" devices just fine.


I've often though this is part the reason that the Apple IoT space has fewer products than the general market.

Apple's HomeKit allows you to firewall your IoT devices, if you have a Wifi router that supports it.

Since that kind of privacy cuts into the profits of shady IoT companies, they don't support HomeKit.

I'm not interested in trading my privacy for the pithy convenience of moving the dishwasher start button from the machine to my phone.


I'm not sure that this ability to be firewalled is what keeps Homekit down. Inexpensive Matter devices abound that can also be firewalled from the internet, and never connected to it even once[1].

[1]: Yes, I know. There exists Matter-upgradeable widgets that must be connected to the Internet before becoming usable as Matter devices; send those back. I'm also aware that there's Matter devices that require Internet in order to be useful[2], but every instance I've seen of that is just something that was designed by a moron, imbecile, or idiot; send those back, too. Returns cost these companies money.

[2]: https://www.reddit.com/r/TrySwitchBot/comments/1j8ogt8/matte...


You want a router that will not let those wifi devices reach the internet or contact any other device on your network except allowed devices.

For any device that needs to connect to the internet, you want to be able to use dns and ip block lists at the very least.

These changes are on my todo list. Tvs especially need to be quarantined. They scan your network to datamine and try to report your conversations to the tv manufacturer.

The next step is root the tvs and clean off as much junk as possible.


What I want to do is replace their firmware with one that never tries to leave my network. But that's getting a bit ahead of myself since I haven't looked into them at all yet.

Take a look at OpnSense.

> I genuinely don't understand why someone would want to work like this. There's obviously no practical use in having a 26-year-old novelty webcam work at 5fps.

So? Why does everything have to be practical? It can be fun to get something working like this, even if you use an LLM to do it.


> I do feel for Jensen

Why? He caused this. He chose to have affairs with a spy and a subordinate. Now he has to deal with the consequences.


It remains possible to feel sympathy for people who have done wrong. He's one of the richest men on the planet, he's acted with hubris and ignominy, he's betrayed his loved ones, and he's also probably feeling pretty terrible right now.

Why would I have sympathy for him? Sounds like he got what he deserved

Because its the human thing to do.

The human thing to also do is not pushing AI everywhere for the benefit of themselves and their stakeholders, to the detriment of literally the rest of humanity

Have you never been in a situation where you made mistakes, felt guilty, and appreciated the empathy and sympathy from fellow humans in light of all the shame and vitriol you received counter-wise?

Yeah but I'm not also a multi-billionaire who ran a company that is going to crash our economy

And do you only judge whether people deserve your humanity by how rich or poor they are?


probably feeling pretty terrible that he finally got caught?

based on the reporting about the second affair, it's possible his security has had to shut down similar witnesses in the past.


> It remains possible to feel sympathy for people who have done wrong.

It does remain possible; he's a parasite and someone who's just had an affair. He wouldn't value the sympathy given, Neither himself or Nvidia would return the gesture.

They give null shit about you.

> He's one of the richest men on the planet, he's acted with hubris and ignominy, he's betrayed his loved ones, and he's also probably feeling pretty terrible right now.

He chose to have the affair and as having my father do the same to my mother; you get no sympathy for cheating. Let them feel pretty terrible, maybe they will find what it's like to be human for a change.

Nothing more than a parasite in the corporate playground. His actions caught up with him; woe is me. What will I ever do with so much money.


Sympathy isn't absolution. Do you not have mistakes you live with? I hope he's okay in the same way I hope everyone is okay.

No, I don't. I've been working on my mistakes from the bottom of the barrel for the past twelve years of my life.

Changing everything to get out from rock bottom.

Some billionaire cheats on their wife and I am suppose to mourn for them?

You want me to be empathetic for a sociopath? Blow me.


Congrats on the work. I wasn't trying to accuse.

I think you have misunderstood me. I'm not telling you to feel anything and I'm not going to sleep tonight feeling sad for Jensen Huang either.


It’s possible to have empathy for sinners. We’re all human.

I agree. I think the biggest issue is to not have empathy for sinners and you think you are a saint…

> I think the biggest issue is to not have empathy for sinners and you think you are a saint…

At least that's only hypocrisy (assuming you are not, in fact, actually a saint--you might have developed habits and values that mean you are not likely to sin in that way.) At some level it's not even a problem: you want to aspire to be a better person than you are right now, which means you will hold values that you do not currently measure up to.

But thinking you are a saint because you have empathy is perniciously self-righteous. You can see something similar to this in the progressive movement right now, for instance.


I'm not religious. I do agree though.

But you shouldn't have empathy because you like him or anything.

You should have empathy when he proves he's changed. You can make mistakes, we all do. You don't deserve empathy.

He sells GPUs, he's not a rockstar.


It's like if, after a shooting, you were worried about the shooter having to go to jail instead of wondering about the people shot.

Indeed, except, not at all like that

spending your empathy on billionaires rather than people being screwed over by billionaires is a choice.

I don’t have finite zero sum empathy.

Something you might be excited to learn is that empathy is not a finite resource! You can spend as much of it as you want and never actually run out - try it!

Choosing who deserves empathy based on their bank account is also a choice.

Genghis Khan probably had bunions and I could have some empathy for the pain endured, but I don't because spending a second feeling anything for him is a second I'm not invested in empathizing with, and better yet, helping people that actually need it.

DO you feel for how depressed that WW2 dictator was before he took his own life? How sad and lonely the big "H" was? That stirs empathy in you? Not me. I make choices about who I spend my mental and emotional efforts on.


I think a lot of people might also disagree with the consequences. Something along the lines of - if it’s all consensual then why does it matter. Disclosing trade secrets (wittingly or otherwise) or skirting export ban is a separate matter that does have real legal consequences if proven true.

This is his identity. Sure, he’s made some poor choices. Imagine Jobs resigning at the height of iPhone phenomenon or Gates at the very peak of Windows. Not sure if Jensen can bounce back from this psychologically. He’ll be broken for awhile.

"with a spy" where is the proof that she is a spy? It seems to be perfectly ok for CEOs to profess blind allegiance to a terrorist state, like Larry Ellison does, seems like a double standard.

Let's not forget him most likely knowingly breaking US export laws. Some might even call that treason.

Most likely based on?

You mean he knew she was a spy?

Exactly. I don't feel bad for a billionaire who operates in an extremely unethical fashion.

[flagged]


It will be the end of this species

I have some simple but strict rules:

1. Commercial devices must use offline only protocols, Zigbee or Zwave. If it's WiFi only I will not buy it unless the firmware is open source or easily replaced with an open source, local only alternative.

2. Non-sensor devices must fully function without their IoT features. I must be able to control my thermostat, fridge, stove, etc without any external interface.

Never use a WiFi IoT device that isn't open source. Even if you can control it locally it could be a spy device that's exfiltrating your data. Yes, you could setup VLANs or a separate network but it's not worth it. Vote with your wallet.


I don't know how this fits into your list, but I also require an open, local API, so I am free to chose which dashboard/automation I want to use - my own (Home Assistant or any locally programmed orchestrator) vs. the official App vs. some third-party dashboard/website. This was my main criteria for buying a Marstek Venus E Battery. I was able to automate it fully locally, isolated in a separate VLAN, via ModbusTCP/RS485 and my custom Home Assistant Automation. Works wonderfully, even on Internet disconnects. [1]

[1]: https://du.nkel.dev/blog/2026-07-26_dual_battery_automation/


What devices do you use and/or recommend?

I've only tinkered around the edges of home automation, but so far most everything I've looked into is either proprietary and $ or open source and $$$. The sweet spot seems to be proprietary devices that are hackable and/or re-flashable to open source firmware. But there aren't many of those, they come and go constantly.

A large part of my goal for automation is energy efficiency, if I have to dump multiple hundreds of dollars into hubs, switches, plus, lights, and sensors, then I've only added work for myself and saved no money.


Most of my devices are Zigbee. They're inexpensive, easy, and have been pretty reliable. They operate on 2.4Ghz which may have a lot of interference in some places like dense apartment buildings.

There are a lot of vendors. I have a decent amount of SONOFF stuff, Schlage Zigbee deadbolts, Ikea Zigbee blinds, etc. No one makes a good Zigbee thermostat so I have a Honeywell Zwave.


Switchbot Smart plugs are cheap, around five dollars in a four pack. You can flash them over the air without needing to open them up. And they have a ESP32C3. So you can easily flash them with Tasmota or ESP home. And they include energy monitor.

Thank you for the tip! I'll look into those.

I recommend SONOFF: they support ZHA as first class citizen (they are very active on raising PR to https://github.com/zigpy/zha-device-handlers) and they are cheap (manufactured in china). I don't even have to download their app to do the initial setup, most of their devices just work out of the box with ZHA.

SONOFF is hit or miss, they have some very buggy devices. For instance I wanted a thermometer in every room to map temps in a 3d floor plan.

The Sonoffs would just drop from the zigbee network never to return without a reset, known issue with these.


What do you think of smart tvs? Like how to properly isolate them, because they don't fit your rules (neither do they fit mine)..

> What do you think of smart tvs?

They should be kept offline and used as monitors only.


Right? I've never quite understood the question. There's no requirement that a smart TV be connected to the internet.

Something like a Roku is cheap, can handle your streaming services (including Jellyfin), and has no spying hardware. DIY HTPCs are of course the best option for control.


Why would something like Roku be any better?! It's proprietary and can do all the same things as a smart TV..

Sure, HTPC would be the best, but they are quite a bit pricier.


> Sure, HTPC would be the best, but they are quite a bit pricier.

Not necessarily. An Apple TV box is now $300. That's enough to buy a far more capable mini-PC. You can run an ordinary Linux distro on it with a "launcher" like Plasma Bigscreen. Alternatively, if you want to put some more work in, build LineageOS for x86_64 with an ARM translation layer and you get the best of both worlds. I recently did just that and I am delighted with the result.


I have my home server in the living room, connected to the TV. But I also have another TV and I wouldn't want to buy and maintain one more device just for that.

Last I checked there were no mics or cameras built into my Roku, but maybe we're concerned about different things. What are the "all the same things" you're talking about?

Scanning your wifi network, and if you have smart devices, they often have lackluster security, so now they may all be vulnerable by a third party.

Guess where all those private IP camera streams that got public come from.


I don't connect TVs to networks. I use external streaming devices. Previously this was Roku with all of their tracking domains DNS blocked but I've switched to Android TV (NVIDIA Shield). I used Claude Code to review all the installed software and remove anything that called external services that wouldn't break core functionality. DNS blocklists handle everything that remains.

There's an app for that: https://github.com/Gathin23/cleanyourtv

( Disclaimer: _ALL_ the usual caveats )

The above intrigues me, I plan to give it a go when I reach it on the TODO list- ideally that would address issues that can't be fixed with network isolation.


I didn't know about those protocols, and also surely they don't really mention them in the title or product description usually. Also are they the most used average protocol? I don't wanna pay premium price for a reasonable offline feature which was always the default.

However, I tried to purchase from EU manufacturers so that, at least, they're GDPR-liable. Quite a few of them even advertise things like "Offline mode only available" or "NO account setup needed!" ... It was a FKN weight measurement device (one of those you put on the floor and step on). Id rather die a horrible death then give them any access to my WiIF or email account. i jsut want a damn number in Kilos and thats it.

And about people saying "OVERWRITE", "CHANGE", "HACK", or whatever. I mean, I used to do those things when I was younger, learned alot, but I simply don't have the time for that anymore and it shouldn't be required.

That's the whole point: these things should be the default, rather than requiring you to waste two weekends fixing a product you just purchased.


You can buy pre-flashed hardware such as Martin Jerry switches with Tasmota on it (OSS). Which is what i recommend for people trying their best to avoid tinkering.

My parents had this problem when I was growing up. We lived in town A but due to being on the border of town B and in the middle of nowhere we got our mail from town B. Anything addressed to town A wouldn't be delivered. They ended up getting a PO box in town A and post office would put all the undeliverable stuff in it.

With a growing population town A decided to start delivering their mail something like 20-25 years ago. I can see it being a bigger problem now with autofill addresses and such.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: