That may be a factor, but there are other, very rational complaints. They are enormous, noisy eyesores. They result in raised electrical rates for anyone living in the region. They are another user of water in areas that may already be stressed for water. They are also setting us up for massive e-waste in 5 years. Those are real problems that you can't just hand-wave away.
You can't hand wave them away, but you can dissolve them with even a modicum of grounded research. All industry is big noisy buildings, DCs aren't particularly loud either (and don't need to be), electric rates come mostly from distribution costs, not generation costs, DCs use about 2 golf courses of water a year, so ask the farmers to water one less day (and save the ag runoff from hitting the streams too), inference is currently being served on 5 year old hardware and 10 year old cards are even hard and expensive to get.
And last of all, it's like 3 datacenters that keep coming up as "DCs are bad" despite their being thousands in the country (and hundreds of hyperscale sized ones).
The whole thing is public panic rather than academic honesty.
You are telling me I'm wrong, not because any of these impacts are wrong, but that they shouldn't count. That's hand-waving.
> All industry is big noisy buildings
But they produce jobs, goods, and social value. If people don't see the value of AI (or even see it as a job risk), then why would they be inclined to put up with the noise and land use?
> electric rates come mostly from distribution costs
Which are costs that result in higher residential rates. Go ask someone who recently looked at their ComEd bill.
> DCs use about 2 golf courses of water a year, so ask the farmers to water one less day
Except you can't ask farmers to do that. We need food, and water is finite. That's not anti-AI panic, it's a cold fact.
Except AI isnt saving lives. It isnt even usually improving lives. For the most part it is being used to justify laying people off, to heap more responsibility on those that remain, to destroy the livelihood of artists, and to flood public spaces with slop. Even if the capabilities are incredible, the average lived experience of it is awful.
Inference will keep getting cheaper and cheaper though. Perhaps model releases will be fewer and farther between because these groups can't affording paying out a billion or more in training each generation
Yeah, but Wright's law (cost of making the n^th something (like a token) being exponentially less than the cost of making the first) strongly suggests that post-bubble inference will be significantly cheaper the longer the bubble lasts.
Whether that's a good thing considering the other things those dollars could be going towards...
I mean I'm happy for better but it might start grounding the industry where 1.6% better on some benchmarks doesn't justify hundred million investments.
Yes! At first there free, yes free, ISPs. Then remember when news sites didn't have pay walls? When every site wasnt loaded with ads and trackers? When Facebook, Twitter, or linkedin provided open data apis or rss? The enshittification came for it all because the bills were due.
I have to wonder in this: how much of the revenue per worker boost in tech due to massive layoffs and coasting on momentum? Most tech workers I know do not describe a sustainable new environment with AI, but rather over-worked skeleton teams
Totally fair, I did heavily edit and spent a lot of time refining the step through to try to make the process interesting and understandable but I should have done the writing myself.
I came across this line yesterday, I copied the text but not a link to the source unfortunately. It was in reference to PRs but it seems like a good standard to hold ourselves to.
“Don't let the AI write prose or any text another human (or the reviewer) will read. Here, the whole intention is that the text comes from a human and reflects the humans thoughts exactly. Also, as long as AI written prose is detectable, you show care for the reader by writing it well yourself. Try to have empathy for the reader as you write!”
reply