Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | ericmay's commentslogin

> We need multiple providers for rockets.

We have that? SpaceX, ULA, Blue Origin, Rocket Lab to name a few I can think of.

> Since a lot of the rest of the US space world is struggling to successfully launch

Can you walk me through how you are arriving at this conclusion?


SpaceX is retiring the Falcon 9 and not currently selling rides on Starship.

ULA and Blue Origin are recovering from anomalies, and ULA uses Blue Origin engines, so if there is a problem with BE-4 both companies are affected.

Rocket Lab's rocket is small and cannot launch either Leo satellites or the major national security payloads.

No other US launch vehicles are currently operational.


Space X will probably have to keep Falcon 9 around for a while for human spaceflight to ISS, no?

They are contractually obligated to fly up to ISS until 2030 or so. But they are not obligated to sign new contracts nor are they currently selling rides on Falcon 9 to commercial customers (all future flights are booked).

Will they offer launch on Starship to NASA and commercial customers? TBD, but SpaceX is making so much money on Starlink that they have no financial incentive to do so. They make more money launching their own Starlink satellites than anyone else is willing to pay.


Rocket lab will have a new medium sized rocket by end of year / early 2027 fwiw

Ah I stand corrected. Didn't hear about their delay. Don't really follow this too closely

RL can't even successfully make a first stage tank yet for Neutron, and they've already said first launch is now in "2027" without specifying a quarter. It's definitely not going to be ready by the end of the year, that's for sure.

Bullshit. Neutron has so many issues that i would be shocked if they dont have to start over.

Thanks - that makes more sense, but the OP was being quite general which is why I asked the question.

Stoke has a good chance of making 2027. They are the only real competitor IMO in terms of engines and fully reusable design.

Meanwhile, Blue is prepping for their annual layoffs...


At least Stoke is skating to where the puck in going to be.

But I think it's going to take them longer than anyone hopes to make a difference. For starters, their current vehicle is not large enough for major national security payloads and probably not large enough for most LEO constellations.


I think Stoke are planning to be able to do up to ~20 tons which should cover quite a lot of stuff. (https://youtu.be/83WRugdvII4?t=71)

Their current design, called Pathfinder, has yet to reach orbit. It was supposed to launch in 2025 and now has been pushed back to 2027. Pathfinder is designed to launch 3 tons fully reusable and 7 tons expendable (Starship can launch 50 tons fully reusable).

They have plans for Block 2, which can (hopefully) launch 15 tons fully reusable, but their projected first flight is 2029, which likely means 2031 at the earliest.

Like I said, I think Stoke is doing the right things and going the right direction. But even if everything goes right for them, they won't be a factor in launch capacity until the mid 2030s.


I know quite a few folks who joined Stoke and things are looking promising there! Here’s hoping their first launch is a success.

Today's anomaly is just the latest in a series of anomalies for ULA's Vulcan. (previously the solid fueled boosters were losing their nozzles).

Blue Origin blew up a rocket on the pad in May and hasn't launched since.

Rocket Lab's medium lift rocket (Neutron) hasn't launched yet and its Electron is too small for most payloads.


> Blue Origin blew up a rocket on the pad in May and hasn't launched since.

Yeah, it's hard to launch when you blew up your pad. Even if they had another rocket ready to go, you've blown up your pad so it doesn't matter.


They have a booster they've flown twice. Not sure if it got damaged too, but theoretically they could have flown that booster by now if they had a second pad.

SpaceX has carried about 1,787 of the 2,300 tons launched worldwide this year, or 78%.

https://www.flightatlas.org/history/2026/statistics


Why isn't there a backup or a secondary deletion confirmation or something along those lines?

Plenty of people have accidentally deleted such things, so it's not unheard of. Not sure we should be overreacting to stochastic agents being used tens of millions of times per day making a mistake. Eventually they won't make mistakes anyway.


From the article: The files were later recovered via Dropbox

Also, I can’t stand these articles. Oooh “rogue” spooky AI deletes things!


Agreed. There's nothing rogue, just being sloppy. But starting the title with "Sloppy Claude AI..." certainly won't get as many clicks.

> There's nothing rogue, just being sloppy

What's the difference, when you ignore anthropomorphic considerations about what the AI was "thinking" as it did the things?


It's a computer program. "Rogue" implies autonomous intent, and shifts accountability away from the people using tools irresponsibly.

Imagine you pipe /dev/random to your terminal, and it spits out the word "fuck". Should we then write a headline saying "Rogue random number generator curses at tenured professor"?

Or you step out of your car while it's in gear, and it crashes into your house. "Rogue vehicle injures its owner's child"?


Right, so no difference:

  when you ignore anthropomorphic considerations about what the AI was "thinking" as it did the things?

Computers have been anthropomorphized for a very long time. AI is also a kind of anthropomorphism for the use of the word "intelligence". If we wanted to move away from that, perhaps we could say something like "maliciously developed statistical language model", or "malicious statistical language model" to replace rogue. In this case it was merely a "statistical language model", but if the author sees a need to append an adjective, then I think sloppy is more accurate than rogue.

Are you sure??? Because some of the ones I’ve used in Europe and Asia are god awful

We should compare.

Not because I doubt you but Europe is pretty disparate.

Amtrak from NYC to Philadelphia cost as much as a flight to continental Europe, and the experience was abysmal, truly awful I couldn’t even get the tickets for hours and took a bus instead.

Perhaps I’m “spoiled” by UK and Swedish trains but UK is pretty terible


We were talking about the websites, and the OP was saying it’s the “worst example”. Cost and experience weren’t being discussed.

Yes, I meant I had a bad experience with the website, as in, it didn't work at all and I had to go to a service counter.

They acted like I was committing a crime at the service desk too tbh. I’m not sure how they are in business.


Yea and in France when the only train for the day broke down I couldn’t get a refund because “you might come back to France one day”.

Sorry, as an American Amtrack’s website isn’t even in my top 5 of worst train websites.


not getting a refund is a lot different than not even getting a ticket imo.

Fair point about refunds for delays in general, its so awful I normally don’t do it. Not with trains, busses nor airlines.


> Fair point about refunds for delays in general, its so awful I normally don’t do it

That's one thing in which DB - the German rail company - excels: their refund process is easy and often quite smooth. It is unfortunate that this is probably because they have had so much practice running it given than around 70% of their long-distance services are delayed but still, it works and I tend to get my 25% or 50% refund for 1+ and 2+ hour delays within a few weeks, sometimes days.


It depends hugely on when you book--both time in advance and time of year--as well as any sales going on. Which can vary a TON in Europe as well. I almost always take trains within Europe but they're no bargain.

Re: when you book, for the East Coast trains time of day matters greatly.

If you book a train from NYC to Philadelphia on Dec 9, there are four trains leaving before 6am with coach tickets for $10.

NYC to Boston has similar early morning prices.


Right. I'm not going to NYC for now but I saw the end-of-year sale in my inbox recently. Pricing varies a lot. (And I usually don't book Acela on my own dime absent a bargain; the transit time isn't much different from the regional.)

Great if you're in Manhattan. Less great if you're not.

A lot of travel generalizations assume you're going more or less going downtown to downtown. There are some limited suburban stations for both NYC and Boston but, generally speaking, a lot of train transportation advantages over air go away if you're not traveling more or less downtown to downtown and become liabilities.

In my case, there's an out-of the way but otherwise convenient south suburban station outside of Boston and I'm basically always going to Manhattan so I train unless I'm just changing planes in Newark.


Oh you're right. I was actually thinking of the airport. Getting to/from Manhattan isn't so bad, but JFK is in Queens so the path of least resistance is generally to Manhattan and then to Queens even if you're already in Queens.

Getting direct service to the other boroughs would be nice though. Acela (Penn Station to Back Bay) was a bit of a WTF moment for me though.


Logan is actually quite convenient to Boston metro in general. But if you're driving in from the suburbs, RTE 128 works a lot better even if, for me, it's pretty much 100% out of my way to travel to NYC. I could drive to New Haven to avoid driving into the city (which I hate doing) and take Metro North but, then, that's more driving.

Spoiled by UK rail? lol

The year is 2019. I wanted to book a ticket on GWR. Couldn't, site didn't work with iOS. Figured I'd buy a ticket at the station. Couldn't, no staff. Figured I'd use the TVM. Couldn't, most were out of service. After I managed to buy a ticket staff mysteriously came out of hiding.

The trip itself was grand until the train (Class 800) broke down and staff started blaming passengers.

The refund process was quite smooth as soon as I replied to the initial denial and pointed out that yes being stranded for an hour qualified for a full refund under their stated policies.


yeah. thats the joke.

UK train service is abysmal, but Amtrak is worse.


Amtrak's been more reliable for me and I've never had problems booking a ticket. Never had problems with them while they were running Caltrain either. I get the joke but I think Amtrak does quite well with the constraints they're required to operate under. The UK doesn't really have that excuse.

Canadians, like Americans and practically most people in the world would band together to help folks in situations like this and do so with warm and loving hearts.

No, please stop engaging in baseless and pointless speculation. If the US wants to bomb Iran it doesn’t need more reasoning than it has already used to already do what it has done.

If you haven’t noticed the Iran war is universally unpopular. They actually do need to fabricate a reason to continue.

No they don’t - popularity isn’t all that relevant. The president can just order strikes tomorrow.

Besides popularity isn’t the determination of whether something is a good idea or not. The Korean War for example was very unpopular yet it was the right and smart thing to do.


The Korean War was absolutely not the right thing to do. It was a literal terrorist act by the US that killed 2.5 million civilians. I can’t believe you used that as an example.

Well that’s wrong. The Korean War is what stopped authoritarianism from spreading and encompassing the entire Korean Peninsula. The blood of the 2.5 million civilians you’re citing falls on the tyrannical governments of China and the Soviet Union and their evil lapdogs in what is now North Korea.

No, it’s not wrong. The US killed those people, just like in Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan… we (the US) are by far the biggest terrorists in human history, and it’s not even close.

Yes it's wrong. No the US didn't kill those people. Stop engaging in flame bait please.

We don't need EVs. I drive one and like it and want to see more but underlying your comments here is a false assumption that if we don't build EVs we're falling behind or something. That's not correct.

While China has been scaling up it's production of vehicles, it'a also facing a 20% YoY decline in vehicle sales internally and thus has to look to export cars. It's currently shut out of the highly profitable and second largest (by volume, perhaps largest by $$) market and because of these factors and incoming EU action to prevent China from destroying the European auto industry faces companies who have built factories that were geared toward building 100,000s of thousands of vehicle but are only building a few thousand.

> If legacy US auto is not scaling EV production, why are the tariffs still in place?

Because your assumption is wrong. We don't need to scale EV production. Tariffs are in place because the engine and fuel source don't matter as much as having the industry does. While I also am in favor of competition, there's a balance to be had in maintaining good union jobs and preventing entire industries from collapsing due to all sorts of fair and unfair trade practices. It's the same approach the EU has broadly taken with its own products and market. The US is just playing catch up where it can or feels it needs to.


Falling behind in what, is the question. The race to electrify is because we're cooking the planet with fossil fuel usage, and electric cars are the future in which we don't choke ourselves out. Electrify transportation and move the grid to renewal resources. The economy is one thing but we only have one Earth.

See even this is an assumption. We don't need electric cars - we need to walk and bike (i.e. better building patterns). Creating EVs still creates emissions, you still have to mine the resources to make them, and you still use ships to transport then from China which aren't electrified. Using a lot of energy to drive a few miles to get a loaf of bread isn't sustainable no matter whether it's an EV, Hybrid, or ICE vehicle.

But if you think this is a big deal that needs to be solved (and I'm no opponent to saving the planet and reducing emissions or any of those things) my recommendation would first be to get China to release its hold on rare earth mineral processing, and then have them voluntarily give away EV and battery technology to other countries building cars so we can work on this problem together. Unfortunately China lost the trust of the western countries through its action and so we're sort of stuck in this situation because of them. None of the EU, Japan, Korea, or America are going to let their auto industry be destroyed and lose all of those good jobs just for the sake of the environment. It's a non-starter. If you think that's the approach to take you're probably wasting your time.


I'd be a huge supporter of building out more walking, biking and public transit options; besides the environment, those are good for physical health too. However, that boat has long sailed in the US. Current urban and suburban layouts are just way too spread out and can only be traversed by car. It's unfortunate, but if you don't have a car in the US, I feel like you're essentially an invalid.

At this point, even if we could overcome the cultural resistance to deprioritizing cars, we really cannot do so. Hence the only realistic option seems to be optimizing cars to avoid emissions. Even if EV's just move the pollution somewhere else, on the whole they are way better than gas cars.


It hasn’t sailed, that’s a misconception. While in many metropolitan areas the suburbs would be difficult to reconfigure, the core of those same cities are sitting on acres and acres of empty space that can be used for development of housing and businesses and with an expansion of good transportation options can enable a car-free lifestyle or even just minimize the number of trips you take.

We make an impact not with a wholesale big dig style project but piece by piece. When that neighborhood grocery store opens in walking distance you can walk instead of drive. Maybe you still take your car to work everyday but we can still reduce emissions in other areas.

EVs just aren’t the answer to these problems, well, not at the expense of American workers, good union jobs, and our manufacturing capacity.


Oh for sure, I agree there's a lot of space, but reconfiguring all the existing construction to become denser seems like a much longer timeline than transitioning to EVs. I've not really done the numbers on this, but comparing most suburbs with a dense walk/bike/public transit-friendly city like, say, NYC is like a day-and-night difference, which makes a broad reconfiguration seem very far off. Maybe my reference points are too extreme?

Also, to increase density the thing that people would need to give up, in addition to cars, is private backyards. I feel like that is a much bigger cultural hurdle to overcome, since that is like 50% (including the white picket fences!) of the home ownership part of the traditional American Dream.


We don’t need to reconfigure anything, just build. Columbus where I live has 1,000 acres of surface parking lots and empty lots. We can just literally build downtown and reduce emissions and car usage.

We don’t need to give up private back yards. I live in an urban neighborhood and have one. Now some of the building I’ve suggested would be much higher density but not all of it needs to be. I think your reference points are a bit too extreme. I wouldn’t even talk about suburbs or New York in this, they don’t matter.

I drive an EV and I prefer it, but it’s just a non-starter to import Chinese EVs at the expense of union jobs and the American auto industry. Even if that means ongoing negative effects to the environment (overpopulation is another factor too for example).


The world sells 90M units/year of light vehicles, as of this comment. You cannot stop people from buying light vehicles (broadly speaking; several countries have banned combustion vehicle imports already, and hopefully this trend continues). If they will be bought, they should be EVs. If they are not now, they will eventually be, based on current trajectories. 100% within ~10 years I think, maybe a bit longer. Legacy auto and nation states can protect their domestic markets only for so long, and countries without any domestic auto manufacturing are going to consume all of the cheap EVs China will build for them.

Ember Energy: China’s EV exports hit record $9.2 billion in May as ASEAN demand surges - https://ember-energy.org/latest-updates/chinas-ev-exports-hi... - June 24th, 2026

- “China’s electric vehicle exports continue to break records, and the surge in shipments to ASEAN markets is especially striking,” said Euan Graham, a Senior Electricity and Data Analyst (Global) at Ember. “Southeast Asia is fast becoming one of the most dynamic destinations for electric vehicles, and China is supplying that demand at scale and speed.”

- Singapore, 24 June 2026 – China’s electric vehicle exports reached a record $9.2 billion, up 49% year-on-year, in May 2026, according to new data from global energy think tank Ember. The previous record was in April 2026 at $9.1 billion.

- In May 2026, China shipped a record value of electric vehicles abroad, exceeding the previous monthly high set in April and underscoring the country’s dominance in global EV manufacturing. China exported around 448,000 electric passenger cars in May, roughly 279,000 battery-electric vehicles and 169,000 plug-in hybrids. EV exports have closed in on lithium-ion batteries as the largest of the “new three” cleantech export categories, having grown from under $1 billion a month in 2020.

- Exports to Southeast Asia reached an all-time high of $1.2 billion in May 2026, as ASEAN nations accelerated the electrification of their vehicle fleets. The surge was led by Thailand, which took a record of more than 36,000 Chinese electric cars in May, and the Philippines, where shipments climbed above 33,000 vehicles.

https://ourworldindata.org/data-insights/global-sales-of-com...

- "To decarbonize road transport, the world must move away from petrol and diesel cars towards electric vehicles and other forms of low-carbon transport. This transition has already started. In fact, global sales of combustion engine cars are well past their peak and are now falling. As you can see in the chart, global sales peaked in 2017. This is calculated based on data from the International Energy Agency. Bloomberg New Energy Finance also estimated this peak occurred around that time. Sales of electric cars, on the other hand, are growing quickly. They more than doubled in the three years from 2022 to 2025." [My note: Rate of change! Doubling in 3 years, and it is very likely the time it takes before next doubling continues to decline.]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phase-out_of_fossil_fuel_vehic...

Certainly, there is a place for mass transit, biking (including e-bikes!), and walking where possible. In lots of places, it isn't possible, and so EVs will be sold to folks who want them. The faster we can impair combustion vehicles sales, the faster we get to 100% EV sales. If you want mobility, electric only.

The world’s 280 million electric bikes and mopeds are cutting demand for oil far more than electric cars - https://theconversation.com/the-worlds-280-million-electric-... - November 16th, 2023

280 million e-bikes are slashing oil demand far more than electric vehicles - https://arstechnica.com/cars/2023/11/280-million-e-bikes-are... - November 11th, 2026

(where are these ebikes built? China)


> (where are these ebikes built? China)

Yea it's fine that China builds electric bikes because that's not a manufacturing capacity that the west cares about. In the US and Canada at least we need better infrastructure so that more people are riding them, or manual bikes, or walking.

> Certainly, there is a place for mass transit, biking (including e-bikes!), and walking where possible. In lots of places, it isn't possible, and so EVs will be sold to folks who want them. The faster we can impair combustion vehicles sales, the faster we get to 100% EV sales. If you want mobility, electric only.

I also disagree that "in a lot of places it isn't possible". It is, actually. Most people live in urban areas and if we slightly adjust how we build and allow for proper levels of density then we don't even have to sell cars (which are a huge burden for the less wealthy).

There is no goal to get to 100% EV sales. If there is, I would support it as long as they're not Chinese. I'd rather buy another ICE vehicle than a Chinese EV because I care more about union jobs, American manufacturing capacity, and things like that than I do muddled visions of "if we just had EVs we would save the planet".

> Legacy auto and nation states can protect their domestic markets only for so long,

Well we can do it forever.

> and countries without any domestic auto manufacturing are going to consume all of the cheap EVs China will build for them.

Yea that's totally fine. The profitable customers though still remain in the west so if China wants to sell low priced EVs and follow the Android-ification strategy of gaining low-value market share I say more power to them. But we're not going to allow our jobs to go away and our industries to collapse. It's non-negotiable.

As your articles point out, China's increasing exports particularly to nearby countries which never had American markets to really begin with. I say that's a great thing for everyone. But you also have to acknowledge that the drive for Chinese exports is because of manufacturing overcapacity (this is a fact that can't be disputed) and because auto sales in China are falling (20% YoY) and their internal market is facing quite the challenge. But since we have auto industries we're not going to allow ours to collapse just to save Chinese jobs. It's nonsense.


> But we're not going to allow our jobs to go away and our industries to collapse. It's non-negotiable.

He said, in the thread "Mercedes-Benz to halt 'all future investments' in Germany." and while VW has ~100k layoffs planned. You say "allow it" like it is a choice. You can play to win, or lose, and western automakers are not currently playing to win. Maybe this changes! But probably not. It's easy to change, accept a reduction in profits and invest in EV production. But you're not keeping historical profits and winning, as a legacy automaker, as long as Chinese automakers are willing to make ~5% margins on their vehicles.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50484586 ("This is on the heels of VW also pulling out of Germany (as of just two days ago). VW is scrapping their biggest plant in Dresden and also shifting manufacturing to Eastern Europe and out of Germany for four other plants. German automakers can not longer remain competitive, for a few reasons.")

Certainly looks like the jobs are going away and the industries are collapsing, based on a preponderance of the evidence.


That's because auto sales collapsed in China [1] - did you forget the comment where I pointed out Chinese market sales are down 20% YoY across the board? - not because all of a sudden a bunch of Chinese EVs were imported. Volkswagen is working on building a massive new manufacturing facility in the US even [3].

Of course, the import of Chinese EVs would have an effect [2], and how the EU responds to that will be very interesting, but you're not looking at the broad picture and instead focusing on an ideological argument.

[1] https://apnews.com/article/cars-china-economy-europe-sales-d...

[2] Welcome to find another source but this one says Chinese EV penetration is less than 10% https://www.evchina.co/news/chinese-ev-sales-europe

[3] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2026/oct/25/volkswagen-...


I am looking at the economics and trajectories, I'm unsure you think this is ideology. EV sales continue to rise, and China makes them, no other country is building EVs at this scale, and that is unlikely to change in the near term. Are EV sales globally going to go down? No, they are doubling every 2-3 years. Is China going to slow down building? No, they have to keep their exports humming. The world is their market, and they will sell into it forever (~90M units/year, as mentioned). Some countries may attempt or succeed at keeping them out, but the rest of the world will take the cheap EVs.

Do you disagree with this? My entire thesis is data, evidence, and observation driven. Are you arguing someone will build faster? If so, who? Provide evidence. Are you arguing protectionist policies? Sure, but only a few countries have auto manufacturing to protect, the rest of the world does not. So, where's the disconnect?


I've already explained in my posts above what the picture is. I don't really have anything else to say when you're just repeating what I've already walked through. Maybe someone else has some different insight. I hope you have a nice day!

This is multi-faceted and I agree that AI is destroying some levels of trust, but many of the publications on the Internet were never deserving of trust anyway so I'd describe it as formalizing or recognizing distrust or lack of credibility and, in a manner of speaking now that the tide is going out we can see who has been swimming naked.

One of the other facets is the idea that trust is now being lost due to AI. It's unfortunate that it seems that publications like The Atlantic (and others) are now going to scapegoat the lost of trust that they've earned over the last decade or so to be about AI when it's actually about bad, biased writing with a default point of view, and lack of intellectual honesty and an inability to facilitate intellectual debate and discussion.

As some of these publications continue to spiral into irrelevancy I think what is a bit tragic is they'll never really understand why. They'll blame AI, which will likely destroy all but the top-tier sites, but in reality the quality of the writing and honesty went down the drain next to their ad-filled garbage pages and other spam.


Good work pointing this out. One of the great things about AI is eventually people are going to learn to stop trusting these kinds of websites “it’s all AI slop” and revert back to paid journalism because while the writing can be done by AI, the research and verification largely cannot.

Or so I hope. More likely is people will continue to engage with low-quality information and come to believe all sorts of nonsense, misquotes? Conspiracy theories, and more as they always have…


Did you actually read it? How does the full quote not support the articles framing?

Journalism was always the lowest of the low of vocations. It isn't surprising that a simple robot can do it just as well as your run of the mill scribbler.

There is nothing good to go back to because there was nothing good about journalism at any point in the history of mankind.

These freaks don't actually coldly manipulate you with sensationalist headlines, they are exactly as excited to write pages about gruesome family murder as the text suggests.

Now that they compete with TikTok sending you tragedy after tragedy right into your pineal gland, it has been a rough patch to be a traditional corpse picture snatcher.


This is quite an extreme, and I think wildly disingenuous, take.

The job of a journalist is not to be a "scribe" or "scribbler".

The job is to investigate, corroborate, and report. Journalism is what has exposed corruption in governments all over the world.

To reduce a profession down to its worst participants is an action rooted in emotion over reason.


I personally put a fairly high degree of value in the 'genuine' investigative journalist you're referring to.

The more recent spate of sensationalist journalists however are less remarkable. The ones that parrot headlines from other places, or worse paraphrase to make them get more views.


I absolutely agree that those who do not take their jobs seriously are not praiseworthy.

My pushback stems from what I perceive as a lopsided amount of ire directed at "journalists" without nuance.

I don't think most people make any sort of distinction when they voice this ire, as we see above with the commenter I initially responded to decrying "journalism" as the "lowest of vocations" and claiming it has never had any value.

Clickbait/yellow journalism has always been the cost of having a free press. We should shame those people when we see them, but should not throw the baby out with the bathwater.


[flagged]


Found the journo

My iCloud email account is working just fine too. Security through obscurity ;)

Proliferation of something doesn't mean it's dominant. Android has the dominant global market share, but Apple makes all the money.

W.r.t the United States government and its people restricting sales of the most advanced chips form Nvidia there are two realistic conclusions you can draw (neither of which result in SMIC and/or Huawei "obliterating" anyone):

1. China is behind and needs to catch up, and the way to do that is through subterfuge to get more chips imported into the country. In other words, they can't match Nvidia + American tech stack for the foreseeable future.

2. China can "just catch up", which begs the question why they don't have their own Nvidia already, and so it doesn't matter whether the US restricts the sale or not other than maybe a few billion dollars in lost sales to a few companies which isn't really relevant.

With respect to Chinese electric cars and the American market, the American market is highly profitable and while we don't have great EVs we also don't really need them for anything, and while China maintains a stranglehold on rare earth mineral processing we can't put ourselves in a position where an adversary can effectively shut down our auto industry and leave us in a bad position. Of course there are existing single points of failure, chokeholds, and things like that, but there's no need to add fuel to the fire.

Most Chinese automakers are not competitive, the Chinese auto market is slowing down, and many of the automakers are operating on state subsidies and have built factories which are not able due to lack of demand to produce the volumes of vehicles that were expected. American strategy (and soon European strategy) to limit imports of Chinese vehicles results in a resounding win for union jobs, stability of American, European, Japanese, and Korean automakers, and uses what I'll describe as a judo move (using your opponents strengths and momentum against them) to harm the Chinese economy and their goal of instituting mass manufacturing overcapacity.


2. China can "just catch up", which begs the question why they don't have their own Nvidia already

Have you looked at Huawei Ascend chips? They are on a 7nm process, so at first blush you could say they're not competitive. I think they run at at between 15045% the performance of Nvidia's fancy chips (Grace Blackwell etc) and also consume a lot more power, presumably requiring more power again to dissipate the resulting heat.

On the plus side, though, they're designed from the group up to sit in massive arrays have 4tb of memory interconnect bandwidth. My understandin g is that model providers like Deepseek are doing their training on nvidia gPUs but all the inference is moving toward Huawei.

At some point they'll be caught up, either via lithography breakthroughs, or by building on their architectual strengths.


> which begs the question why they don't have their own Nvidia already

Because they don't have TSMC or ASML and the Dutch can turn those lithography machines off from the other side of the world. Nvidia is likely the least important part of the supply chain which is why governments were not very concerned with the behavior which they would have been aware of for a while.


Sure but you can throw both of those companies in there. I think it just adds to the point.

Nvidia might be the easiest to replicate (I'm not sure if that's true or not) but my point was that you can draw the conclusion either they can't actually replicate this supply chain so they are behind and are importing as many chips as they can get away with or certain companies are trying to (which may not be a distinction since many Chinese companies have CCP officers inside the company), or they can do it and haven't... but that doesn't make any sense because they would obviously want that entire stack.


> can't actually replicate this supply chain

Can't actually replicate this supply chain yet.


1. It's not just about profit. Sometimes it's really about market share.

2. You live under a rock it you don't see the earthquake that Chinese automakers are. Or chip makers. You seem absolutely oblivious of the world around you. Something US CEOs that travel the world extensively are not.

3. European carmakers are by nature export oriented and they oppose tariffs on Chinese cars, especially German carmakers. Reality is that neither European nor US carmakers (and many other technological sectors) can't keep the pace with Asians, whether it's making ships, steel, chips, tvs, or cars. We just don't. It's only US car makers that can be happy of those measures, because the cars Americans make suck, are ugly, expensive and inefficient. You had a brief period with Tesla being some kind of innovator in the space, but that's also over.


The reason this is happening is because we are deferent to Wall Street. It's impossible for extremely high returns on capital to coexist with a robust and growing manufacturing sector.

Wall Street can and does demand that companies pay them dividends instead of investing in capacity. What you need is a willingness to accept lower returns on capital and higher savings rates. China makes those things happen, and that's why its manufacturing sector is able to grow the way that it does.

American technology and European technology are, of course, top-notch. What's different is the required return on capital and the labor market. Both of those are primarily dictated by industrial policies of the respective governments.


> 3. European carmakers are by nature export oriented

Chinese cars are selling less in China (20% less this year IIRC) so that is the reason why they must sell abroad. Not that they are not good.


> It's not just about profit. Sometimes it's really about market share.

No it's never just about market share. Market share and accumulating it would just be a means to an end of either eventually making a profit, or squeezing out competitors to raise prices later. At the end of the day you'd 100% of the time rather be Apple (it's objectively irrational to suggest otherwise) than another player in this space.

Besides the American market which is where the profits are is also the second largest market by volume. In China the car companies are struggling to make money because of state subsidies, aggressive pricing, and very intense competition. Those companies that are looking to survive are looking to global markets (primarily the EU and US) so that they can actually survive and make money. As they increasingly get shut out of these two markets China is in for a consolidation of automakers which will result in a lot of lost jobs and companies going bankrupt. China's internal auto market was down 22% YoY for example [1].

> You live under a rock it you don't see the earthquake that Chinese automakers are.

Please stop writing things like this as it's a violation of site guidelines.

> European carmakers are by nature export oriented and they oppose tariffs on Chinese cars, especially German carmakers.

That's false. You can do a cursory Google search for the latest here but in general the EU is taking action, led by Germany, to introduce tariffs or other market restrictions to slow the import of Chinese cars. Germany has been shedding 10s of thousands of jobs in the automotive and machinery sector.

> Reality is that neither European nor US carmakers (and many other technological sectors) can't keep the pace with Asians, whether it's making ships, steel, chips, tvs, or cars. We just don't.

This is also false. There's nothing special about "Asians" that enable them to make things. Countries like China by virtue of their incredibly deep labor pool enabled them to scale up mass manufacturing, but in the United States for example we can compete (and the Chinese are doing this too) with robotics and other automation tools. Most of our alleged inability to manufacture these products just stems from decades of industrial policy assuming that China in particular would be a welcoming and liberalizing partner but that assumption turned out to be false.

[1] https://www.wsj.com/business/autos/everyone-loves-chinese-ca...

[2] I want to be clear here. While I detest the authoritarian Chinese Communist Party and all communist ideology, I'm not trying to suggest that China's auto market or manufacturers suck, or don't make great cars, or whatever. My point of view is that the arguments put forth about Chinese dominance seem incorrect to me as stated and I'm in principle arguing against the arguments because they're in my view bad, not because of anything to do with the Chinese.


> Please stop writing things like this as it's a violation of site guidelines.

sensitive little bitch


Nonsense, enter a Chinese ship, or car maker, and you'll find more automation than in western counter part.

BYD assembles 95%+ of their cars with robots.

You keep talking nonsense and stereotypes, exactly the kind of things that keep west non competitive in manufacturing and technology.


I wrote that China's labor pool enabled them to scale up mass manufacturing. I didn't write that China only manufactures products with high-intensity labor or anything of the sort.

I also wrote that "but in the United States for example we can compete (and the Chinese are doing this too) with robotics and other automation tools.".

As you can see, I wrote, explicitly, that the Chinese are competing with robotics and automation tools, and I wrote that America can also do this, and we'll have to, because automation and robotics are the future.

You're so quick to be argumentative and jump to defend China that you are missing key points that others have written. Please engage with the substance of the post and what was written and stop with the low-quality comments. Thanks!


>they can't match Nvidia + American tech stack for the foreseeable future.

>China can "just catch up", which begs the question why they don't have their own Nvidia already

What about Huawei and their Ascend chips?

DeepSeek and z.ai now run their models on Ascends, and inference is basically a solved problem (especially with the architectural/ML optimizations, like 90% of them come from China right now).

From what I understand, they lack compute for training - their own chips can do it too but they're slower and you need ~4 times more GPUs. Plus CUDA is a more mature stack than whatever Huawei provides (e.g. DeepSeek once failed to train on Ascends because they struggled with the stack). As long as China can buy Nvidia chips, it's cheaper and easier to just use smuggled chips but it doesn't mean they desperately need them.

>many of the automakers are operating on state subsidies

As opposed to many "successful" US companies living off investments without being actually profitable for years (or ever)?


> What about Huawei and their Ascend chips? From what I understand, they lack compute for training - their own chips can do it too but they're slower and you need more of them. Slower = lagging behind the US further over time. As long as China can buy Nvidia chips, it's cheaper and easier to just use smuggled chips but it doesn't mean they desperately need them.

It's a catch-22 of sorts.

Either China can catch up (what exactly that will mean I'm unsure but I believe they will be able to), in which case we don't need to sell them the chips to let them do it faster, or they can't catch up in which case we shouldn't sell them chips allowing them to do so.

I'm just not seeing a compelling argument to sell them state of the art chips here.

> As opposed to many US companies living off investments without being profitable for years (or ever)?

No it's not comparable


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: