Due to the inconsistency between quantum and relativity, I'm more inclined to believe that the problem is with relativity. The idea that physics is fundamentally non-deterministic satisfies me philosophically. If physics were deterministic, than I should be able to theoretically build a computer, input the state of the universe, and then be able to know what will happen in your life (assuming I don't tell anyone the computer output, because that would perturb the dynamics). I find that prospect far more unsettling than having to account for a superposition of states until I obtain more information in the future.
You would never be able to predict future states of the universe, simply because you cannot represent such states within the universe they represent. Without the ability to predict, the universe is effectively non-deterministic (literally, no one within it can determine its future states).
You make a good point. In my earlier post, replace "universe" with "solar system." Then, I can represent the states of the solar system in some subset of the universe, and I'll place this computer sufficiently far from the solar system so it doesn't interfere. Now I should be able to predict what happens on earth, unless you think that variables outside of our solar system significantly affect activities on earth, right?
1) Don't underestimate the butterfly effect. 2) We can already predict the future to a certain extent. 3) What you wish the universe was like is irrelevant. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wishful_thinking
Re 2: There should be an obvious qualitative difference between being able to predict where a ball will land if I throw it, and predicting who the passengers riding a particular train in 15 years will be.
Re 3: I was commenting on Roger Penrose's assumption that quantum must be "wrong" because it's "unintuitive" by expressing my opinion that I think quantum is more intuitive than deterministic theories. Indeed, Dr. Penrose and I are both using "wishful thinking," as did Einstein when he hypothesized that the speed of light is "constant in a vacuum." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_of_light#Special_relativi...
I don't think modern quantum theory holds that the universe is non-deterministic. I think it's still somewhat of an open question.
However, I also don't think a deterministic universe would be sufficient to allow you to predict it, because getting the state of the universe is still impossible following the uncertainty principle.
I'm not a physicist, but my understanding is that the debate about whether or not "quantum is deterministic" centers around what your interpretation is of the wave function. I think most physicists, who Penrose would probably criticize, believe the "Copenhagen Interpretation," which says that the wave function of a system is literally the function that, when you take the inner product with its conjugate, gives you the probability distribution of the state of the system, and hence, the state is non-deterministic.
The uncertainty principle arises from quantum. Specifically, it's a statement about the commutativity of operators that act on the wave function, which, going by the Copenhagen interpretation of physics, means it's a consequence of the non-determinism of the universe. I think this is a philosophically satisfying explanation for why getting the state of the universe is impossible.
But you can in fact build such a computer - you'll just have to solve the little problem of accounting for absolutely all the factors that directly and indirectly affect the result. Then predicting the future is easy peasy :-)...
Software execution is an entirely deterministic process (at least in theory), and even then, we cannot actually compute the result of that process on a sufficiently large computer.
I can't speak for other schools, but the University of Maryland is working hard to become a "startup school." A few examples:
At least five professors in our electrical engineering department have companies.
The business school has successful entrepreneurs that can meet with students (in any major) trying to start companies.
There's a whole institute at the university called MTECH which has successful entrepreneurs and investors who help startups get off the ground. They have office hours once a month so if you impress them they can help introduce you to the right people.
I'm going into UMD, majoring in Computer Science, in the Entrepreneurship and Innovation Honors College next year. Any recommendations for someone interested in getting into the startup scene at Maryland? I'm probably going to apply for Hinman CEOs for junior/senior year, and I've been researching MTech and the Tech Entrepreneurship minor.
My advice would be to network with other students interested in startups, and build stuff with them. Twice a semester, there is a business pitch competition called "Pitch Dingman," and there's an annual business plan competition through MTECH. Make it a goal to enter them at some point with friends you make! You'll learn a lot in the process and meet other aspiring entrepreneurs. The Pitch Dingman events are open to the public, so I'd encourage you to check them out and see what UMD entrepreneurs are up to.
A lot of startups "like" Instagram already exist, but ONLY Instagram has 40+ million users, that's the difference. Just because 100 more startups get created in this space doesn't mean any of them will acquire a sufficient userbase to threaten Facebook.
I'm thinking that his point (which I agree with) is that if a photo-sharing app with twelve people and no revenue can come from nowhere in less than two years to threaten Facebook's very existence, Facebook may not be worth $100 billion. I think the crux of this debate is whether you think Instagram was poised to become a real threat in the social space to Facebook. I think Facebook overreacted, and given this information (that Zuckerberg essentially bought it up himself) the disconnect from a realistic valuation seems even more likely. But then again, they may never get a chance to buy up companies with stock that possesses so much hype.
True. But on the other hand, look at RIM (Blackberry) and Apple (iPhone). Any large incumbent can be displaced. They take longer to die because they have cash, but they die nonetheless.
The problem with the analogy between music and math is the free-will aspect. Everyone is FORCED to take math, whereas most people are NOT forced to play an instrument (at least in the US). Everyone knew a couple of math wizzes who usually were not the one's asking "why do I need to learn this?" These kids would probably do math even if they weren't forced to, and indeed, many of them go on to pursue a higher education in mathematics, completely voluntarily. On the other hand, many kids whose parents force them to play an instrument often complain and ask "why do I need to play an instrument?"
tl;dr: If you force someone to do something, and you don't want to make them resent the thing you're forcing them to do, you should explain to them why you're forcing them to do it, i.e., why it's in their best interest, whether it's math, music, learning a language, etc.
I have a question for the more experienced HN users: is the author correct in asserting that in the "real world," being a co-founder of a startup is considered unemployed if there isn't a successful exit? I always thought that building a product from start to finish that has users is considered good experience to employers, even if it turns out not to be a sustainable business.
I don't think the hacker news / stackoverflow model will work for research papers. People read hacker news articles because they want to keep up with what's going on in the tech community, even if it's not super related to their particular job. Researchers generally don't just read research papers for fun. Rather, they are working on their own research, and they are looking for relevant papers whose results they can use. Hence, it's critical that when they read a paper, they know they can trust the results.
I can skim an article posted on hacker news in 30 seconds and have a general idea of what the content was. I can also skim a research paper, but only if I know that the research was done well (e.g. all the proofs are correct, or the assumptions in the model made sense, or all correct variables were properly controlled in the experiment). If that stuff isn't guaranteed, the paper is useless because I don't know if I can use it for my research. And to figure out all that stuff myself would take a few days literally out of my research. Just because 10 people skimmed it, thought it sounded cool, and up-voted it does not mean the results in the paper are correct.
Other than this review aspect, I really like this product. If they can figure out a good incentivized review system, I think it will be a big hit.
Perhaps reviewers could publicly vouch for an article to give it credence. Reviewers, who are also researchers, can have scores based on their own papers. If a reviewer with a high score publicly vouches for an article, that article would receive points in favor of being correct.
The most interesting time in writing a paper is when it's under review before being accepted. The process is extremely similar to debugging an app shortly before a release. Part of my motivation for the proposed design is to upgrade this to an ongoing process -- analogous to the move from rare-release desktop software to dynamic web apps. If the author cares about their paper and receives useful comments, then the paper can iterate on that feedback.
I agree that many researchers in practice hear about papers they want to read through word of mouth. For this use case, I like to compare an online platform to stackoverflow (SO), in that you most often visit stackoverflow to solve a focused problem you have, as opposed to browsing for fun (like hacker news). You get an external problem to a page (a math paper / an SO question), you check it out, and you learn what you wanted to learn, or you contribute your knowledge or ask a question. It's a mini-community around a particular idea (a paper or a question). I see this as the main use case. The analogy with hacker news was to imply that the platform could be built around links to arXiv papers in the way HN is built around external news stories (while SO is more self-contained). Like HN, it doesn't seem necessary for an author to submit their own paper to the site.
Finally, I would say that some researchers do browse for fun. I enjoy reading several mathematicians' and computer scientists' blogs, and occasionally visit mathoverflow. This would be a secondary use of the platform, but it would be fun to have a front page of popular papers, and per-topic subpages.
My understanding is that most publications are not heavily cited, and address very specific problems. I'm curious as to how you plan on creating incentives for qualified people to review the papers in their field which focus on problems outside of their present research interests.
To give a personal example: I used to work in a research group that applied techniques of a field called geometric control theory to the problem of modeling flocks of birds. There are not that many geometric control theorists in the world, and their interests range from robotics, to circuits, to modelings schools of fish. Right now, there are journals of control theory that force their reviewers to review all submissions, regardless of their personal interests.
How do you plan on emulating that? In other words, there need to be incentives for geometric control theorists who work on modeling schools of fish to spend a few days of their time grinding through the proofs of some grad student's paper in modeling bird flocks, which he needs for his thesis.
Peer review often works the worst when a journal asks someone who's not that qualified to peer review a paper. See the comment below from billswift about an unbelievable case of peer review going wrong, where the reviewers weren't in the research area of the target article (you need to follow the links to get the full picture).
Something doesn't have to be heavily cited for it to start getting traction, just as a website, or blog post, doesn't have to get heavily linked for it to get some traction. A friend might find the paper and share it via Twitter, their blog, or Academia.edu; this is how the social review process works on Twitter and Facebook. It might sound slow: you might wonder 'won't it take ages for a paper to get traction like that?'. But in reality, when you have social platforms like Facebook and Twitter, content can be surfaced, and whip around the world, at incredible speeds. The journal peer review process, by contrast, is several orders of magnitude slower.
The web is known for having a long tail of content: lots of content that appeals to certain niches of people. It is part of the magic of the web's discovery channels that this long tail content gets routed to the niches who care about it - via search, Facebook etc. The fact that academics overwhelmingly use the web now for research discovery is testament to how good a job the web's discovery channels are doing at surfacing good content in highly niche areas.
As a researcher myself, I do not use the web as a means of content discovery. I do use google scholar, pubmed, and citeseer, but these are only useful because they restrict the search to just peer reviewed journals (and optionally patents in google scholar case).
Trying to use general web search is often far too noisy. Often times I find interesting papers on page two, three, or four of google scholar. In a general web search these same papers might be on a much later page, or perhaps buried so far that they don't come up at all.
As others have said, there is also much more to peer review than discovery. Peer review is additionally intended to help authors improve work that isn't quite up to standards. Academics do peer review for free because they recognize the value of it and because they are asked directly by the editors to do it. In your model, what would be the incentive to look for new papers and give reviews? How would you handle old versions of papers with mistakes or papers that are of insufficient quality? The peer review process currently filters these intermediate stages of paper writing. In your proposed model, you would potentially have many versions of the same paper that a user would then have to filter through, in addition to a very great many papers that are of very low standard.
The quality of content on the web and its curation is a very poor standard to compare academic literature to. Many users are happy enough to be able to filter out obvious spam pages let alone judge quality to the level needed in academics.
It's true that the papers in the indexes of Google Scholar, Pubmed, and Citeseer are peer reviewed, but what that shows me is that what is really driving the discovery process is the ranking system in those search engines: i.e. the order in which the hundreds of results for a given search query show up.
One of the drawbacks of the existing peer review process is that academics don't get credit for their reviews, nor do the reviews see the light of day for others to benefit from. I expect that there would be significantly more discussion, and reviews, of papers in the future if there was a credit system that allowed people to get credit for reviews and comments they made of papers. I think that credit system is possible and will be built.
There is an interesting question regarding the immutability of content. Right now, once you publish a paper, you can't edit it, or delete it. It's an immutable piece of content. Before the web was established, there was a line of thinking, developed by Ted Nelson, according to which the internet should evolve like that, and that a link should always work: once some content is posted, it can never be taken down. Most people are probably glad that the web developed along the lines of Tim Berners Lee's thinking, rather than Ted Nelson's, and that they are now free to edit and delete content they have posted. I think similarly people would appreciate being able to update a paper in response to a comment they have received. The author is better off, and so are subsequent readers, as they find themselves reading a more evolved and advanced paper.
Reviewers are intentionally hidden from view. The reason is to prevent social or political backlash from a poor review. In fact, it is sometimes the case that papers reviews are double blind, the reviews do not know the names of the authors either. This is also to prevent bias on the part of the reviewers. This secrecy is a positive and important part of the peer review system. Science should not be politically or socially biased.
The immutability of published works is also crucial. It routine for writers to leave out details covering in prior works. This saves immense amounts of time on both writers consumers of scientific works. However, it also means that it is crucial that all cited works be preserved forever. If a document truly goes missing, then entire lines of work become incomplete. Papers can and are infrequently withdrawn, but as far as I know, the work is not erased, but merely marked as bad.
The way updates or corrections are made is via newer papers revisiting topics. But it remains that at every step some amount of decent due diligence is done to correct errors and not clutter up the records with incomplete versions.
As great as the web is for unstructured content, you cannot easily apply it to every area, and especially not to scientific publications. There are plenty of other examples of curated sources on the web that crucial. Map systems, curated databases of restaurants, directories of people like LinkedIn and Facebook, and even Wikipedia can be counted a curated system due to its system of editors.
Scientists have always and are still free to share data, white papers, and whatever else outside the peer review system. The main reason peer review is still here is that no suitable alternative has ever been proposed that addresses all the points that peer review does. There is a push towards open access journals to benefit the world at large though.
I understand that you are passionate about this, but I'm not convinced by your arguments.