>. there’s so much hand holding through required coursework (and homework) that one can’t hardly think deeply about anything actually original.
Take an actual graduate course in pure mathematics, very little hand holding.
>there’s basically no time or space for one to explore one’s own thoughts and program unless it specifically matches up with what someone else (namely an advisor) wants to do.
Not necessarily true. Find an adviser that will support YOUR interest (they exist). Sounds like you have some biases against PhD programs without actual experience of being in a good one.
> Take an actual graduate course in pure mathematics, very little hand holding.
i have taken many. and you missed my point. i didn’t mean having one’s hand held through the actual material. that isn’t true at all of course, in part due to poor teaching and in part due to the difficulty of the material. i meant that one is forced to take x amount of courses. i believe, past a certain level, that this becomes extremely limiting. you spend all this time and time effort doing coursework and going to class rather than researching. learning within a context is much better than learning without context, aka most courses. and many schools hardly take any coursework transfers. there aren’t many good reason for this.
and of course i have a bias because that’s what personal experience yields. but there’s no reason for you to insult me. i would wager my bias is shared by many who have been through ph.d. programs. and of course it’s not necessarily true. there are excellent advisors. but they are rare.
To offer another point of contrast - while it's true that you often need to spend a year taking courses, in most graduate programs they're very very flexible on what courses to take. And those courses themselves are very flexible on how much work you want to do.
I don't find this too troubling - it's important to have a shared fundamental knowledge so you can communicate effectively and not reinvent the wheel, and I don't think most programs are giving you busy work (that's really against the whole ethos).
>> you spend all this time and time effort doing coursework and going to class rather than researching
Is it possible the problem is particular to the US postgraduate system? In UK PhD programmers you are not required to follow any courses. That said, at least at my university as a PhD student you have the right to follow any courses you want for the duration of your PhD (obviously at no extra fee), which I'm absolutely taking advantage of.
I should also point out that a PhD is not just a time to do research- it's an opportunity to become an expert in your chosen field. And you don't do that just by inventing new knowledge. You need to also become familiar with the work others have contributed before you- and by "familiar" I mean "learn it very, very well". Perhaps the US universities are just trying to make sure you don't spend all your time with your nose in your own research, while ignoring everything others are doing around you?
just as a point of optimistic contrast, i've taken only three required courses over my PhD. some of my peers (who came in with better undergrad prereqs) have taken less, and in a few cases, none
You know I’d actually pay the crazy fees if only I could find a place that’d reteach me advanced maths “in context”. I find often that adding context means subtracting the “advanced” part :)
Study Physics. I'd take the math prerequisites and not understand what this is useful for, and then the first week of physics class we'd review the math and suddenly it would become quite practical.
Solid advise. I think finance massively recruits maths aptitude from physics for precisely this ability to connect hard core maths to models of the world.
I wouldn’t expect a pure mathematician to be good at this nor to care about it either.
Did you ever read “How to Solve it?” Polya says he became a mathematician because he was too clever to be a philosopher and not clever enough to be a physicist :)
Any PreCalculus text -> Stewart Calculus -> Strang + Axler Linear Algebra -> a Calculus based Statistics & Probability book. Do the problems in the books. Read each chapter. If you do that you'll know Calculus and Linear Algebra better than most. If you want to then move up from there study Real Analysis and higher level math like Measure theory (but this may not be necessary for your purposes).
In my experience, at my school testing is done to pass a professor's designed test cases. Usually you don't know the professor's test cases in advance.
I don't really agree with this. 30 isn't that old. Also, some 30 year olds still look like they're in their early 20s, so you can't tell their age to begin with.
OP, in a university setting it is easier to find mentors. Look for professors, grad students and in-class TAs if possible.
Thanks for taking the time to clarify your points. Although, I still disagree on a few views. Even if OP is 30 there isn't an inherent reason college is too late either at the undergraduate or graduate level. If OP had the funds or made specific life choices they could enroll back into a university and study. Some people aren't married/have kids at that age and can work side jobs or what have you to enroll back in school. Not everyone studied CS in their 20s and are satisfied with the careers they had up until that point. I know of individuals that made career changes in their mid-20s/30s. Most of them went back to school in one form or another. I think for those that did that actually set themselves up for a "career upgrade". I've seen students in class that look much older than everyone else taking undergraduate courses. I don't know their story but they aren't treated any differently by the university and I've even heard from professors they prefer older students over younger ones as their graduate students. Also, I've seen a CS PhD student that is 40+.
This is a bit of an overgeneralization. Are all computer science graduates software developers? Are professors with PhD degrees in CS not considered Computer Scientist? Your statement assumes graduates stop at the BS level and get programming jobs.
Yes the borders between are categories are blurry but it helps to start with a crude generalization. The only people I know who call themselves computer scientists publish papers, and most people don't start calling themselves computer scientists until they join the scientific community in some way.
Definitely, but when is the last time you interviewed a PhD? If so, did you give them technical questions? The comparison is between practitioners, not academics.
Beyond that, other industries DO use technical interviews. My entry-level interview in finance was extremely technical, but no subsequent interviews were technical. I just think the comparisons being drawn aren't realistic.
I work in med-tech, specifically orthopedics. I recently interviewed for a side job to help build an application related to genomic research. The most technical question I received (related to programming) was "do you have experience in python", and the answer didn't even matter. Why? My boss worked with their lead engineer, and all their researchers know my father. The human element changes things dramatically, and that seems significantly less prevalent in programming.
>So, unless you think they are lying, your point doesn't stand on limiting low-income students.
You missed the point. Poor kids in general don't go to Math & Science high schools, or high schools that offer college level courses in Calculus I-III, Number Theory, Abstract Algebra, Differential Equations, Linear Algebra, 1-2 semesters worth of programming, Data Structures, etc. These kids don't have have access to private tutors to ensure they ace their SATs, SAT Subjects, ACTs etc. They aren't enrolling in multiple ECs and they don't have teachers with PhDs writing them letters of recommendation. These kids don't have parents that went to colleges and don't have the resources handed to them as the kids that are getting into Brown, Harvard, Princeton, Stanford etc. If you look at the lower level high schools in America, they barely give any of their kids any advantage. They actually put them at a major disadvantage compared to the elite high schools.
It's great elite colleges have these needed based programs. But by virtue of their admissions criteria they are excluding lower income students on a vast scale.
Audit edx's Calculus sequence, taught by MIT. The courses are: Calculus 1A, 1B, 1C. You can watch MIT OCW's Linear Algebra course with Strang and/or enroll in: "Linear Algebra - Foundations to Frontiers" on edx. Use Khan academy for supplemental Calculus & Linear Algebra review. You can get Stewart's Calculus text and read through it/attempt the problem sets. Once you have a solid Calculus/Linear Algebra review you can take a look at: "Statistics 110: Probability" which is found free here: https://projects.iq.harvard.edu/stat110/home.
I'd like to see a list like this that included the field of mathematical logic. For whatever reason mathematical logic no longer seems to be a "popular" area of research, despite its deep connection to theoretical computer science. But there are distinction in study, as computer scientist tend not to go deeply into computability theory like a traditional mathematician would.
What exactly are you trying to learn? Mathematical logic is a huge field in its own right, with plenty of topics that are of historical interest and a lot of active research areas.
If you want to learn modern mathematical logic you're in for a rough time, since you'll basically have to learn category theory in order to understand the few really excellent textbooks which exist (e.g. Sketches of An Elephant). If you are interested in type theory you should try reading the Homotopy Type Theory book, which is (mostly) self contained.
I'm mostly interested in "modern" mathematical logic then. I'm very interested in learning category theory and its connections to programming language theory. I already know a little bit of category theory, but am open to any good beginner sources. I'm also interested in classic recursion theory and a bit of proof theory with its connections to CS. I don't know many people doing any of this and it doesn't seem that popular in math departments.
I think I understand why. Mathematical logic research has largely become focused on problems that, while important, seem very arcane from an outsiders perspective (even by the standards of other fields of math). The fundamental results of classical recursion/computability theory can be developed and presented with a fairly small amount of logic (see something like Cutland or Cooper). I'm not really super informed on the current state of the field though, so I may be misjudging the situation.
Take an actual graduate course in pure mathematics, very little hand holding.
>there’s basically no time or space for one to explore one’s own thoughts and program unless it specifically matches up with what someone else (namely an advisor) wants to do.
Not necessarily true. Find an adviser that will support YOUR interest (they exist). Sounds like you have some biases against PhD programs without actual experience of being in a good one.