Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | jerf's commentslogin

The silver and golden rule both fail to capture the collective nature of the actions. There are many things where if one person does it, it really isn't that big a deal, but if everyone does it, it is. I don't care if you come by my house and pluck a twig off of a branch I happen to own. I won't even notice. But if a lot of people do that it becomes a problem. So you shouldn't pluck twigs off of a tree in a shared park even though it isn't that big a deal.

I tend to agree with the later philosophy that says Kant's idea is not a good foundation for philosophy itself, but as a social norm it is a useful one that captures something beyond the naive application of the golden or silver rules. If you want to abstract up above that naive application to the proposition that the golden or silver rules when understood more deeply encompasses this idea I wouldn't fight you, but I do think it is indeed an additional step and something that should be called out as an implication that is not immediately obvious to everyone.


That's separate from automatic buying though, which seems to be the main point here.

This reminds me of the whole house automation proposition, where the problem with it is that even if you remove 100% of the friction in my life from turning on and off light switches, you really haven't removed that much from my life. Replacements don't get very much "budget" before they're more hassle than they are worth and it doesn't take very many technical snafus where I can't actually turn my lights on because of the automation for the whole thing to go net negative.

The actual approval to spend the money is not the hard part. I'm not doing it hundreds of times per day. The research of what to spend it on is the hard part. The agents already do that well enough. Even if you save me 100% of the effort of actually buying a product you're not really saving me that much, and most importantly, it doesn't take much for the whole proposition to go negative because there wasn't much positive in the first place. One product I didn't really want and have to physically return negates in one fell swoop quite a few "oh thank goodness I didn't have to approve this purchase". One misinterpretation that causes the agent to spend 10x what I really wanted to spend negates months of benefits.

This is one of those features where it's something OpenAI wants rather than something most people are going to want. Yes, of course OpenAI wants direct unfettered access to your credit card. Most businesses would love that. But just because they can wave the words "AI Agent!" in your face doesn't mean you should actually give it to them.


It was CGA specifically that was terrible, though. I'd take 4-shade grey Gameboy graphics over that color palette. There's nothing wrong with 4 colors per se, but there's a lot wrong with those four colors.

A couple more registers to have some kind of selection of the colors would have gone a long way.


To be precise, you could have one of (usually) two palettes, in dark/bright variants:

* Black, green, red, yellow

* Black, cyan, purple, white

Technically, it was possible to have a different colour than black on both of these palettes, but this was usually not used and was left as black.

(Technically there was an unofficial third palette you could use in a different screen mode - black, cyan, red, white - but this wasn't documented and I've never seen it used outside of CGA test/demo programs)

Note the absence of blue!


Enjoy it while you can. You can see the AI companies have already started the process of locking us out of this, with Opus 5.5.

God forbid our fans, our fans of all things, might be broken of their dependencies on the internet. The plebians can't be allowed to do that. Every relay must be cloud-connected so it can be monetized and disabled for whatever dumb ass reasons someone might want to disable it.


Just use abliterated/uncensored self-hosted models. This is why we need them and the hardware to run them. Yes, the API models which will further close the walled gardens will evolve faster than the open-weights ones, but I'm hopeful about the community as a hole rejecting this status quo.

Is there hardware you would suggest that you can actually buy today? Pricing is out of control right now, if you can even find stock.

An RTX4090 or a 128gb macbook can generate a pretty reasonable number of tok/sec. Those are not cheap, but within the realm of serious hobbyist. I really hope the AI bubble deflates a bit so consumers can get more powerful hardware at the low thousand $ range.

> locking us out of this, with Opus 5.5

I hear this a lot but I've never hit this.

For weeks now I've been working on a shared recompilation project of Switch 1 and 2 games, and Opus 5.5 has handled that with no issue.

Over 10 supported Switch 1 games, and 3 supported Switch 2 games, and never once has Opus 5.5 denied anything


OpenAI and Anthropic models seem to be the most affected by these barriers, from my own experience.

Mistral, QWEN, and other models (read non-American) tend to have little to no restrictions. There were some tasks where I was actively trying to sabotage my own local network and Mistral had no issue helping. Anthropic and OpenAI refused outright or had to be "convinced" but would often hit further barricades along the way.


> I hear this a lot but I've never hit this.

Opus 5.5 will absolutely refuse to touch anti-cheat systems in video games, even when the end game isn't to cheat but to work on Linux compatibility or to bypass/spoof the checks to enable gameplay.


Sure but as easy it is to hack these devices as easy it is to harden it.

So this only works on products that was developed before ~now.

The solution is to not buy crap regardless if you can make it work or not.


> So this only works on products that was developed before ~now.

You're under the assumption that the companies producing these give a shit about security. It'll probably increase a bit but I doubt it will be by much. If they have shipped devices that leave the doors wide open for almost any intrusion, they won't invest engineering/AI time and money to make these better than before and certainly won't review the code that the model spit out beyond a quick check if the promised base functionality still works.


I'm not. But no AI will produce anything that is as bad as the state of current products.

> So this only works on products that was developed before ~now.

The Home Assistant hackers are some of the most persistent reverse engineers that I have seen. Almost as much as game crackers and cheat developers.


The other problem is that the manufacturers can also use AI to improve their DRM and do red-teaming to fix "vulnerabilities" before release. Right now they're not because it actually takes some effort but eventually they'll be able to just tell their agents "make sure no unauthorized clients can connect". I expect that several years from now there will be a sizeable market for pre-2027 hackable devices.

Coway sells tons of devices with no smart/connected features. Their best-reviewed ones for home air purification are not connected. Everyone will be better served by supporting such product lines or pressuring companies to create them more than they will be by reverse engineering "connected" features no one ever needed.

Apparently there's a website which already addresses your concerns about fans - nothing else - only fans.

at least current models are safe, glm is very capable in terms of RE

"It's literally a use it or lose it market right now."

Are you sure? The point of this stockpiling was to create that impression. Now that you have data that that foundation behind that impression is manufactured and faked, you need to reconsider everything that was resting on that foundation. The demand is just so incredible needs to be reexamined from scratch now in light of the active attempts to forge that signal.

It is also worth remembering that this is a prime example of a situation that is not black or white. The absolute size of the demand, however large it may be, is not the question. It's the size relative to the supply, supply which includes all the pumping shenanigans that are coming into the light. The "AI bubble" has never been if there is demand or if the tech has real use, it has always been a relative question about if the build out could possibly make economic sense.


Given that you practically cannot buy memory or storage right now because all of the capacity is taken up by hyperscalers... even if it was a self-fulfilling prophecy, it's still currently fulfilled

That just represents the inertia of the whole system operating on old assumptions, given that it's only still early in the process of coming to light in a public way how much of the frantic purchasing has literally been sitting in a warehouse, depreciating. I mean, I've been pretty suspicious of this for literally years now, but it's been a "conspiracy theory" that this amazing demand is manufactured by a variety of financial hacks rather than just pure demand that the system as a whole has not paid attention to because number was going up, do not question number going up lest the number stop going up.

You need to apply first-principles thinking to this sort of scenario. Beliefs like the demand is crazy do not just exist floating through space; they exist on top of a specific set of facts and deductions from those facts, which can be very easy to forget when a fact seems to be true for a long period of time. When the set of facts and deductions a conclusion rests on are found to be faulty, the conclusions need to be re-examined from scratch. It is not generally impossible that a fact could still end up being true, just for different reasons.

However in this specific case, it strikes me as extraordinarily unlikely. If the shortage has been manufactured, then all assumptions around demand and possible profitability have to be completely re-examined. Once the system digests this, because these things do take some time, it can cease to be a "use it or lose it" market very, very quickly, and turn incredibly quickly into a "liquidate everything you can while it still has some sort of value" because of massive, massive oversupply. What is the value of a rack of nVidia processors that nobody can turn on? What is the value of a rack of nVidia processors that nobody can turn on when there are warehouses' worth of the things? Anyone who blind operates on "it's a use it or lose it market" will lose their shirts on the transactions. "It's a use it or lose it market" is not a foundation; it is contingent on a lot of things, some of which are being shown to be false.


To be fair I did say "right now". The demand hasn't stopped quite yet.

I look forward to the next R710 where you can just buy enterprise grade servers for a few hundred bucks and as long as you have somewhere to put a hurricane level of noise, you can Just Have terabytes of memory at home. Or many-GPU in this case.


signed closed source drivers for hardware that can restrict which algorithms can be run on it locally... temporally...

edit: i'd willingly bet that AMD has a backroom deal to tank their performance and options to encourage this homogenous deployment overseas. swallow the hook.


I fully, 100% expect that this is the golden age of AI for mere mortals. Right now the overriding drive is to get it out there and get as many people paying as much as possible for it, which fights against limiting it more than absolutely necessary. So we can still make videos with trademarked characters and reverse engineer proprietary software and all that sort of stuff right now.

But enjoy it while you can, because for all their singing the praises of how it empowers people now, as soon as it actually, you know, empowers the people, the establishment will start shutting it down on one side while enshittification starts eating it from the other.

Both of those trends have already started, they're just being outrun by the pace of progress and the need for revenue. But both of those things will eventually pass.


Local.

Yeah, this has that schoolyard "hey, no fair winning, new rule only I get the good ball!" energy all over it.

Unfortunately I expect this to get continually worse for the foreseeable future. We already have "we can use AI to crack things but you can't" pretty well in place and that is just the harbinger. Companies can use AIs to "nudge" us to their heart's content but we can't use AI to counter it is pretty obviously going to be something they push for.


Many aspects of the internet have improved. For all its issues YouTube is better now than it was ten years ago... at least, given the way I use it and with the curation I apply. There are plenty of other things that have improved too.

However, what used to be a diversity of communities has been horrifically, horrifically crushed into a vastly less diverse set and it's not just nostalgia saying so. Everyone has been herded into centralized systems all of which are so large that they have significantly converged into the same thing, whether you're on Reddit or Facebook or X, despite the superficial differences and the various reactions people may have to various elements of that list.

My local BBS, run by high school students for the local high school students, had picnics. It's been a long time since I was a member of a community that could do something like that routinely. And to the extent you want to say well jerf that's obviously because..., the things that come after "because" are the point I'm making here. I'm not mystified by the effect. Nor is it the only thing that has changed for the worse, it's just a nice little snapshot that is easy to ponder.

Everything on the internet is structured to constantly make things bigger and bigger. But there's a time and place for not bigger.


i agree with you entirely, so i wasn't going to "that's obviously because" you, anyway. my own reflection is that when I first got on the internet the intersection of people I knew on the Internet and IRL was an empty set, then for about 10-15 years it was nearly a perfect union, and now it's pretty close to disjoint again.

i don't think LLMs are going to end human-to-human interaction on the Internet, it'll look different, but as long as >1 human values community with only humans, it will find a way.


YouTube used to be things people made for fun, now it's all content made for clicks and monetisation. It's just cable TV but non-linear (which in the TV business means you can choose what to watch next, not have a fixed selection of live channels).

My YouTube isn't that.

But it has taken a heavy hand with the "Don't Show Channel Again" and the hand is getting heavier over time. YouTube seems to have some idea that I am uninterested in the dozens of AI slop TTS + AI slop animation channels that are popping up every day but it keeps probing me, just in case maybe I've changed my mind.

It also takes a certain amount of discipline. While it's not like my feed is nothing but high-brow university channels, you do want to make sure you don't leave any cute animal videos or reaction videos accidentally clicked on or anything else you don't want to see hundreds more videos of in your watch history. If you do decide to watch some junk you have to remove the junk from your watch history. I have no illusions that removing things from my watch history has anything to do with "privacy" but it definitely does impact The Algorithm, and I've seen little evidence that The Algorithm is using those videos anyhow... it really does seem to 100% remove them from consideration.


I haven't pursued this as a conscious policy but I can confirm that every time I've done it I've always discovered something that would have invalidated the benchmark if I wasn't looking at it while it ran. Article mentions it but I've seen something as simple as "gee that's strange that should be using all my cores not just one" several times over, or equally stupid things.

Making it so they aren't in the pool of errors that can be made. I want to be able to type swear words, but I don't want profanity to come out when I try to swipe "duck". Socially, emotionally, and politically loaded phrases make sense to require a bit more care for.

That is a general answer to your question. It is not a specific defense of the particular word list in question. But I can say I've been surprised a few times about what I accidentally swiped on Android. Bitch isn't swipable but I have "bitchiest" readily available, for instance.


Then have "child friendly mode" be an option and the adults can have "fuck" back. This isn't a difficult design problem.

This is just the type of thing that makes everyone hate modern technology.


I like having a phone that doesn't spontaneously insert "fuck" into my messages because it thought I might mean that. That could lead to some unfortunate situations. When I want to use the word I'm perfectly capable of typing it.

I get "fuck" and "duck". I don't get "the occupied territories", "the Hamas movement", and "Trayvon Martin".

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: