Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | jumploops's commentslogin

The FAA hug of death

Seems related to the rollout of their new AI tool? [0]

[0]https://gizmodo.com/the-faa-is-rolling-out-its-ai-air-traffi...


> The FAA has reassured the public and airlines that SMART only suggests routes and doesn't affect air safety.

> [The] FAA also says a D.C.-based team of experts validates findings before they’re ever passed on to air traffic control, and the controllers retain the final decision on whether to accept SMART’s suggestions.

Seems unlikely.


Depends if an AI DoSed an important service or not.

There used to be a lot of invisible gatekeepers in a pre-AI world. At work, everyone can ask their agent to query SQL on databases that they were supposed to use through an application. The application and the security by obscurity(end users didn't know how to connect to the DB nor did they know SQL) were the gate keepers.


That was my thinking as well. AI sending out requests to legacy stable systems is often not a good mix and can overwhelm things pretty quickly.

Doubtful. That tool likely suggests "improved" clearances, which a controller can use at their discretion. It likely does not control clearances directly.

And the early reports describe the issue as related to ATC communication infrastructure.


Awkward timing, to say the least.

Those engineers are no doubt panicking, even if they aren't the cause.

While I don't have insider knowledge of this particular deployment, there was a strong industry-wide push towards "ship unreviewed AI generated code and hope for the best", partly driven by the fact that AI writes code faster than humans have bandwidth to properly review.

Under the hypothesis that some under-reviewed AI generated code made it into prod, the situation could be qualified as "engineers are panicking, because they don't know if they are the cause or not"


I’m always surprised how bad YouTube’s recommendation algorithm seems to be.

Maybe it’s because I don’t watch enough videos, but it’s sort of like Amazon, in that it will suggest the exact same content/topic.

I rarely use TikTok, only to view links people send me (similar to YouTube), but the recommended content is miles ahead, making it much more difficult to close compared to YT.


My YouTube feed is pretty good; it's full of technical discourse on topics that I enjoy learning about, ranging from electronics hacking to civil engineering. That's probably the result of a long number of years of continuous training:

Good video, with a positive combination of presentation quality and a topic I enjoy? Watch it -- maybe now or later, but it gets watched. Thumbs up. Maybe even subscribe. That's what I'm there for.

Mediocre video, whether due to content or presentation? Watch parts of it, but probably not with any sense of completeness. No rating.

Bad video, with content I don't enjoy or with off-putting presentation? Stop watching. Thumbs down, and/or back out to use three-dot menu and "Not interested"

Bad ragebait scaremongering video with emotionally-distressing title? No watching at all. Three-dot menu and "Don't recommend this channel."

---

I get a lot of good stuff. Some mediocre stuff. Very little bad stuff. Almost zero ragebait.

It works well enough that an unfiltered, logged-out view of YouTube is completely and utterly appalling by comparison. That place is fucking awful without training.

(And no ads, because ads have never been a thing for me on YouTube and I experience no compulsion to change that.)


I think that most people make little use of the negative feedback options, mainly because they are more clicks away (dark patterns). A addon that gives them a button next to the thums up could help.


Yeah, perhaps I'm more-willing to put effort into it than some others are and making it easier would help us all out.

I do wonder if the relative inaccessibility of negative feedback paths is due to malfeasance/dark patterns/whatever or just stupidity, though.

If the purpose of YouTube is to show ads to people (it is), then that means maximizing viewership. In this way, it doesn't really matter what people are watching as long as they're actually watching it. More hours of streaming consumption = more hours of ads viewed, and the clock doesn't care if it's positive and enjoyable content or rage-inducing clickbait.

So with meaningful feedback, the good stuff should be able to float up to the top. That would gain viewers, which gains ad placements, which gains money. Everyone wins.

---

Unless, of course, I'm wrong about society. Maybe the majority of potential viewers really do enjoy sitting around and being angry and/or fearful, and find some kind of emotional reward by being incensed.

And clearly, some are: Switching on an AM radio in Anywhere, USA demonstrates this well (the vitriol is off the charts).

I'm just not willing to accept that this represents most people, at least not just yet.

(But if that is an accurate portrayal of the state of things, then: Ragebait means more viewers and more dollars. And thereby, there can be no hope for the platform ever recovering at all. If it pays more to get worse, then it shall simply become worse.)


Do you have web activity turned off or use a separate old style Youtube account? Mine is also bad but I think it's because of those for me.


I was thinking it would be good if there was something similar for kids. They seem to fall into a whirlpool of trash content.


The Kid Should See This is basically exactly that. Highly recommended.


For YouTube nerds I curate a list of channels. Size of list 3993 feeds: - https://github.com/rumca-js/awesome-database-top/blob/main/l...

From that list 731 are blocked in my rss feed. I do read and cache rest.

I sometimes check through website what new has entered the system. It is surprising to see something there new. It is so exiting to see something outside of my bubble.

YouTube algorithm has a lot to comb through, but I am too surprised how suggestion are bland, and unattractive. I am also surprised how difficult is to find new channels through YouTube search.


>Maybe it’s because I don’t watch enough videos, but it’s sort of like Amazon, in that it will suggest the exact same content/topic.

I've got years of history and it does the exact same thing for me. I watched one news video about the pope and now half of my feed is Catholic news channels.

I buy a mattress on Amazon and I get recommendations for... ten other mattresses? Like what's the logic here, I have an entire garage where I just keep stacking them up to the ceiling? Just show me something else. Is there a human being out there whose like "I bought a French press last week, what could I need this week, five more French Presses?"

I do not understand how these dystopian surveillance companies with their infinite data points are so bad even at this


I suspect they know perfectly well when they can't make money from someone, so they deliberately serve up boring crap to save on hosting costs.


Bad by what metric? They're interested in getting you to watch ads, they couldn't care less what you want.


I’ve been thinking about how we’re still in the early days of agents, similar to the early days of the internet, happily opening up our machines and running new protocols.

Soon (now?) the threats will become ever more complex, and we’ll be back in the early-2000s-like virus storms.


My router got hacked the other month (left web interface open to internet) after being exposed to the internet and the persistence left behind was overly commented LLM artifacts. I caught it in like 5 minutes so they weren’t able to do much but it was eye opening how much more basic practices like firewalls are not something that can be ignored even if you update your firmware frequently.


What if I told you nothing new is happening? Except casuals are noticing what the industry knew and saw for decades?

Script kiddies aren't new. Metasploit has been around literally decades. vx-underground existed for years, not to mention older open source projects that collect all known malware dev tools. APTs have been pwning stuff, script kiddies have been doing their thing. Nothing significant has changed for anyone in the know.

Just because LLMs automated some offensive stuff doesn't mean there's gonna be new magic collapse of society.


Given that our knowing-and-seeing industry is also the thing which enabled and then desperately shepherded humanity out-of every IT deficiency that has ever existed, our inside perspective is still highly fallible too.


This feels like a much more achievable vision of the future (until we all have PCB contact lenses).

The main problem with "personal AI"... is that it's, by definition, for one user.

In the physical world, the environment should be smart, not just our view of it.

This is definitely one of the cooler things I've seen on HN. Nice work!


Have you checked every page of every volume of TAOCP?


“And that was how CS became a real engineering degree”


The Chinese labs have shown that distillation is incredibly effective, but the major US frontier labs haven’t (yet) been incentivized to shrink their models in the same way.

This model might be the first step in that direction, as competition heats up between OpenAI and Anthropic.


Distillation is also a broad term - I think most specifically, it refers to training a smaller model on a larger/better model's full output token distribution rather than normal pretraining, which only can access the next token in the data that was actually used.

It's also used to describe the SFT bootstrapping for posttraining, which is what people generally refer to as Chinese labs "distilling".

I would almost guarantee that smaller US frontier models (ex Luna/Sonnet) are distilled from their respective large models.


Isn't that roughly what Haiku/Sonnet/Luna/Terra are?


> The Chinese labs have shown that distillation is incredibly effective, but the major US frontier labs haven’t (yet) been incentivized to shrink their models in the same way

Have they, actually? A lots of speculation and claims but what is the level of admittance?


Qwen 3.8-27B being on par with Opus 4.6 from ~18 months earlier is a sort of case in point, right?



If the Terminal Bench 4.0 scores are to be believed[0] GPT-6.1 is an incredibly efficient model.

Yes, benchmarks aren't real work blah blah, but the delta here is so large compared to Astra, it makes it seem like this is distilled Bel or similar.

[0]https://x.com/thsottiaux/status/2105007628460109953


That seems likely, in the API GPT-6.1 Sol requires reasoning, just like Astra, whereas GPT-6 Sol (and Luna) allow "none"


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: