Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | klez's commentslogin

This explains a bit better what the issue is: https://en.ilsole24ore.com/art/facebooks-data-protection-reg...

TL;DR: they didn't thoroughly explain the users what they were consenting to when giving the app access to the gallery.


WhatsApp has a similar issue. You can't share just one photo, you have to give it access to all photos.

This isn't the case for me on Android anyway. You can turn off access for media & photos in settings, and then yes, it nags you to enable it, but there's still two ways to send photos:

* either share from an outside app, e.g. the gallery, choose "share", choose "whatsapp". This gives it access only to the photo you shared from the other app.

* and in Android's settings you can give Whatsapp access to a subset of photos, then it works normally on only that subset. Then you can always add more from outside that set, by pressing the paperclip icon when you write the message, there you see the "gallery option", then you see the limited subset of photos you gave access to, at the bottom right you have a folder picker icon which opens the system's gallery picker view (google photos in my case), where you can see all photos, and it can then access that photo too.

* if you chose no access to media at all, but if whatsapp has camera access, click on the paperclip icon in the message box, then, "camera", then the "gallery" icon, there you get a screen prompting for gallery access, but on the bottom right it has the same folder icon that gives access to the system photo picker, which again will only allow access to the photo you pick there.

The first two cases are pretty low-friction.


GrapheneOS supports sandboxed storage called Storage Scope. You can make any app think it has full Storage and "Photos and Videos" permission while it is fully sandboxed and user can selectively pick the files to add to the scope.

I believe Android 17 also offers "Limited" storage option to allow permission to select Photos and Videos.


> You can't share just one photo, you have to give it access to all photos

Works for me on an alternate Android OS without photos permission, but it's buggy (possibly on purpose) and often requires doing the sharing intent action twice.

WhatsApp only has "Network", "Notifications" and "Sensors" permission on my phone


Hm, at least on iPhone I used to be able to allow only some photos.

You can just keep calling it a planet in everyday conversation if that's your jam. There's no astronomy police that will come to get you if you do.

Just expect to be corrected and "well, achually"-ed by people who follow the current naming system, especially in science circles.


Right. Somewhat similar to other dual-use words like “work”, “energy”, “power”, “momentum”.

With such “well, ackshually”s as “you didn’t really do any work at all when you were pushing on that tree trunk” and “you specified watts, but you really wanted to use lumens”.


I'm amused that you described a group policing terminology right after saying there's no group policing terminology.

You said colloquially. They are talking more formally.

That it's centralized, while serial numbers are not (you could easily have two manufacturers that use the same numbering scheme and find yourself with two different appliances from two different manufacturers with the same serial number).

This is more akin to VINs for vehicles. EDIT: and not even that is an accurate comparison.


> If you really want a firm anti-AI community with staying power, it’s looking like you will need a neo-Amish movement, complete with isolationism.

The funny thing is that as soon as communities do this and take an anti-LLM stance they get mocked, called luddites, they get told they're living in a word that doesn't exist anymore and that AI is here to stay, stop going against the current.

What a time to be online...


The only correct answer is to give those people the middle finger.

And to work to pass legislation to give them the middle finger.

AI may be one of the most harmful technologies we have created. It's time to treat it as toxic.


I still think social media has done more damage, but we don't think of it that way right now because of shifting baseline syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shifting_baseline

The Luddites weren't against technology, they were against the inhumane exploitation of workers and dangerous child labor, made that much worse through technology. All Ludd supposedly did was smash a couple frames after being criticized for his output, but the Luddites' grievances were really just the foremost among those that had been simmering among textile workers for as long as there has ever been a textile industry, long before industrial automation was a thing.

As for myself, I certainly don't want a community based on reactionary dogma, but I would certainly prefer to be around people who at least have their eyes open, and are aware of the corrosive effects that AI can have or already does.


The Luddites were about protecting their privileged hereditary position against competition from women and other outsiders. Not unlike the privilege of contemporary software engineers like myself.

A lot of labor unions were about racism and xenophobia too, but they did agitate for better working conditions nonetheless. For sure it's not black and white.

...against competition from women, who of course infamously had never been part of the textile industry? Who knew the Molyneux sisters were the Molyneux brothers all along?

Maybe try to inform yourself about the historical context before popping off? The Luddites were part of a medieval craft guild that was largely hereditary and had never admitted women. They even roughed up female weavers to deter them from employment in the trade.

Of course weaving has largely been a female-dominated craft from time immemorial. That doesn't mean you can just apply stereotypes to a historical situation you apparently know nothing about and pretend you're being both witty and insightful.


> Maybe try to inform yourself about the historical context before popping off?

Who exactly do you think the Molyneux sisters I referred to were?


Then block those people. Either they're stupid and don't understand the bad incentives that LLMs create in forums, or they do understand and they're malicious.

I keep seeing hints of these communities existing, here in hn comments. Every time a thread is about communities that are still good, still human etc someone pops up saying these communities exist, but no-one ever mentions what these communities are.

I mean, I get it: one risks eternal-september-ing them as soon as the hn crowd finds out about them, but sometimes it's really frustrating going down a thread hoping to find better indications for these mythical great communities and always coming back empty-handed.


I'm part of a maker community that I really enjoy being a part of. We don't invite random people, but if someone makes something cool, I'll send them an invitation. I think it's this sort of thing that people are referring to when they talk about these communities.

The couple of enthusiast email lists I'm on are still real people, as far as I can tell.

I think they definitionally have to be smallish groups of people who actually know each other at least a little bit, so you can't just fill in a sign-up form and join one, but you can start your own.

Online the only one I've seen is discord, I don't really like the discord experience though

https://lobste.rs?

I know other communities that I really doubt would appeal to anyone here. However, Lobsters is basically Hacker News, but anti-AI, smaller, and with a (low) barrier to entry.

Two more: https://tildes.net, and https://indieforums.linklists.net/ (a giant list of them).


Lobsters is currently undergoing a schism over AI that may prove fatal.

> someone pops up saying these communities exist,

Maybe send those people a hand-written email ;)


An LLM-free community is exactly the problem my product is trying to solve, do you have 15mins next week? lol

We're all lurking in Cixin's dark forest, watching. The aliens are already here, and they're hungry for more tokens.

Yeah. Because we don't want hacker news assholes to find them and destroy them, the way they've been systematically pillaging the rest of the Internet.

"I saw you posted about a community.."


I'm pretty sure apt is written in C++. Am I remembering wrong?

parts of apt are being redone in rust, but anyway this seems to be a logic bug (in c++ code)


What does Arch do in particular to cause a mess? It's been a hot minute since I last used it and surely didn't use pandoc back then.


Haskell packages in arch are dynamically, rather than statically, linked, which pulls in a large amount of transitive dependencies (reportedly in the neighborhood of a gigabyte). The maintainer has a pretty reasonable (to my eyes) explanation[1] as to why this is the case, but admittedly if I were an arch user I'd probably find it a bit annoying.

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/9emwtu/comment/e5qss...


They build and link all Haskell libraries dynamically.


> Fernando Alonso said there was now "too much technology" involved in the series

> "That’s the problem that we have," [Max Verstappen] said. "These engines are so complicated[...]"

Am I the only one who raised an eyebrow reading this? Hasn't "technology" always been a big point of F1? Or do they think that only "software" is "technology"?


When you step on the loud paddle but computer says "No" although there is no reason to say "No", that's too much technology.

If you cannot drive in wet conditions without computer intervention because your electric engine applies too much torque for mortal humans to control, that's too much technology.


Agreed. It's misattributing quotes and talking about OpenBSD releases from more than a year ago as if they were upcoming releases. Something's seriously wrong with this article.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: