Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | mainecoder's commentslogin

Their main contention is that the US is exercising extraterritorial jurisdiction and there is precedent for that as well, and there is a growing group of lawmakers who are willing to explicitly have it so.

From the article, ""The bipartisan legislation would give U.S. allies, including the Netherlands and Japan, 150 days to align restrictions on sales and servicing of advanced chipmaking equipment to China with those imposed by Washington, or show progress toward doing so. If they fail to comply, the U.S. Commerce Department would be required to extend American export controls unilaterally to equipment supplied from those countries." The US implicitly has jurisdiction over the Netherlands and Japan in that neither country has full sovereignty to resist the demands of the US. The issue for them seems to be the very explicitness of the law saying it will extend export controls unilaterally. Is this understanding correct?


> The US implicitly has jurisdiction over the Netherlands and Japan in that neither country has full sovereignty to resist the demands of the US.

That's not my read on this situation. Japan and the Netherlands are free to choose not to comply, the US doesn't have jurisdiction and can't force compliance. The countries may not like the results though, at which point choosing to comply us the less shitty option.

Having leverage to put another country in a difficult decision is different than having jurisdiction over them.


You are free to choose to not comply with the laws in your country, but you might not like the resulting actions your countries executive will take.

Sovereignty of states means that they are only responsible with their actions towards themself. Using leverage to influence the decision of another country IS trying to subvert their sovereignty.


Uhhh the US cannot force compliance? How many missiles do you think it would require to take ASML out of competition?

Without ASML the US wouldn't be able to source the best semiconductors ever produced, sure it can force compliance by destroying it all but it'd be creating a much larger issue for itself than other means available to force compliance (like sanctions).

Either way, forcing compliance through destruction or sanctions, has a diplomatic and political cost, if that's what the USA chooses to do it will be spending the little political capital it has left with its closest allies.


Is your expectation here that this issue would lead directly to a military conflict? Not my expectation in anyway, it seems like it just lead to more stupid trade wars from the Trump administration.

A blockade or siege is a militaric tactic and sanctions are basically the dynamic pricing variant of them. Sanctions are applied as an answer to a militaric threat all the time and are intended to change the outcome of a war. Wars are won with logistic and economy ultimately and this is a measure intended to alter the logistic and economic capability of a another country.

I think that's a reasonable expectation. The US does it regularly, but usually in south america, not europe

I think that is what I got out of it.. The US absolutely has the sovereign authority to restrict exports of American technology; for better or for worse. Likewise, the Netherlands has the same authority over Dutch technology. I think the headline perhaps makes this a little ambiguous... The argument I see is really how much authority the US should have over Dutch companies and Dutch-made equipment that incorporate American technology.

I am really curious if NL or Japan actually have "the same authority". I had in mind that the extraterritorial control US has over its technology was somewhat "american exceptionalism" and not fully recognized in Europe (but that they often comply in practice under US pressure). If someone more expert than me on the question can enlighten me, I would be happy. In the meanwhile, I found an article a bit older but with more details on the problem [1].

[1] https://www.techpolicy.press/why-asmls-semiconductor-monopol...


because western countries operate on a principle of equality before the court regardless of who it is and this principle shall not be broken even if the those in court practice their laws differently. Creating another special system for addressing this would open a way for the abuse of justice thus it better to maintain the system as is.

can someone please explain how they can heat the blood I understand they can stop the freezing but you cannot set the temperature of a refrigerator to a point where it literally heats the stuff inside since a refrigerator do not have the mean to warm objects inside it can only remove the heat.


It's the defrost cycle.

Modern "frost-free" freezers have resistive heaters inside them.


Why would anyone buy a frost-free medical freezer? That's terrible for safety and product longevity with all the freeze thaw cycles.


Basically understand that fridges and freezers work by making a surface, heat exchanger or some type of pipe cold. Being cold leads to moisture in ambient air condensing on that. And being usually below freezing to icing on it. Ice is not very good heat conductor. So you want occasionally get rid of it. Easiest way to achieve this is heating it. Simple resistive heaters are cheap and maluable for this.

Now if you can control these heaters you can pump up the temperature to quite high. And I imagine with certain uses cases actually emptying the whole thing heating it up to melt ice and then bringing temp back down is not that unreasonable process. Also allows keeping the temperature in very close range. For home appliances bit more temperature variation is acceptable.


Maybe it could be combined with thermostats? E.g. one for "if it ever gets hotter than N degrees, disconnect all heating elements and trigger some alarm", another one for "if it's warmer than X for longer than Y minutes, do the same". That could also be to the network, too, it just would never read from it, or from anything electronically. Just bimetals closing or opening circuits, basically. How expensive would that even be? (If you planned for it from day 1 of the design I mean, not retrofitting things)


Or just do it the better, manual, way - point a heat lamp and fan at it with the unit open. Even if you melt the ice inside, you still need to remove the moisture. The manual process is not that intensive and needs to be performed very infrequently.


Fridge at home totally, no idea about blood banks, but freezers in supermarkets probably not so much? I would imagine being able to start a warming cycle, then going around with dry towels to wipe out the water, especially if you have to do it while the store is open, is a lot more feasible.

But how about this, maybe something that keeps an eye on the state and rate of ice buildup, and helps schedule doing it when it's actually necessary, and maybe helps spot issues that cause quicker buildup.


Yeah, even at home towels are used.

That could be useful. An easy implementation might to to track temperature trends with power draw relative to the other units. You might have to account for door openings, but seems like a good way to mark units for mechanical inspection.


Seems like it's more of a walk in freezer situation and it can be controlled in either direction.


it's just you, it looks good on my computer, next time check on internet archive instead of asking DIY


I think there should be alternatives and once a candidate medication advances many tests the last test before Human trials should be animal trials, it is more unethical to try it directly on humans. It is simply better that a human is spared suffering if complex interaction not caught by the alternatives exist.


Does not matter if it is opensource if a piece of rock is designated a National Security Risk because the Rock came from CHina that is it, that rock is a national security risk. The designation is assigned then action must follow; you cannot question a national security risk that is why it is designated a national security risk if it caused health problems you would be told by the Centers for Disease Control or US Department of Health and Human Services. A National Security Risk can be anything that they assign, it can even be a thought otherwise known as a thought-crime. Stop asking why?


Amazing work this is really innovative and it could be applied to a larger drones provided that the margin of error is reduced.


It is amazing but this one won't be practical the way it is right now when scaled up, but there is a unique element in there that probably could be re-used.


Anyone commenting please watch the video first. Would a reasonable jury determine this to be Attempted Second-degree Murder? perhaps it is, any thoughts from a person with criminal law experience? We clearly see the car turning, going out of its way towards the person. Additionally, a pursuit on foot would have been possible the car qualifies as a deadly weapon in this case I think.


> criminal law experience

So IANAL, let alone a trial-lawyer, but I did spend weeks/days with 11 other people listening/deliberating after a cop-adjacent defendant non-fatally shot somebody.

> Attempted Second-degree Murder?

Hold up, what this means varies by state: Illinois law says that second-degree still requires an intent to kill [0], and I think the prosecution may have a hard time proving beyond reasonable doubt that the driver intended to turn the victim into road-splatter.

In contrast, the next step down of (attempted?) "Involuntary Manslaughter and Reckless Homicide" seems much easier to prove, and explicitly draws in a surprising number of vehicle-related details.

[0] https://www.ilga.gov/legislation/ILCS/details?MajorTopic=RIG...


"intent" is not what you're representing. You don't have to be a lawyer to understand using lethal force will result in death.

A reasonable person would expect severe injury or death from running somebody over, and that is enough to satisfy 'intent.'

"Caaarl!! THAT KILLS PEOPLE!" "How was I supposed to know stabbing him 37 times in the chest would do that?"


Did you read the link with the law? You are begging the question that the driver's direct intent was to run the victim over. (Not recklessness, idiocy, target fixation, etc.)

It's quite possible, but if you're going to prosecute someone in a court case, you've got to have a lot more than just "it fits the pattern for these assholes."


>Would a reasonable jury determine this to be Attempted Second-degree Murder?

would you?

I would certainly consider him guilty, if not of exactly that crime.


> Would a reasonable jury determine this to be Attempted Second-degree Murder?

No, because it’s a law enforcement officer doing it.


> No, because it’s a law enforcement officer doing it.

Possible! Many police officers have gone to jail for murdering people.


Not to mention the "re-positioning" of the victim's vehicle to shore up ICE's narrative.

Don't worry though, just like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50090246 someone will be along to say "mistakes are inevitable, but we need to enforce immigration law, and this is an acceptable price, though not ideal".


the right may not be clear sometimes but the wrong definitely is


he he boi that's right cooking videos are entertainment if you actually cook you read something called a recipe (it's the algorithm that returns the food you want)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: