Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | marklar423's commentslogin

It's annoying but it is possible; it comes down to allowing mdns broadcast across vlans and adding a static route for the border router

I used this guide if you're interested - https://ndo.dev/blog/hassio-thread-setup/, it's been working without fuss.


Amazing, thank you!

Looks like this was published recently. When I did research about 6 months ago there wasn't really much information other than a vague "you need to do mdns broadcast and a bunch of firewall hackery" at which point I gave up as it was not worth the effort.

Still not sure if it's worth the effort but at least there's a guide :)


Maybe things have changed but I always found mDNS reflectors to be unreliable.

I think this interpretation is a bit too negative. Undoubtedly the companies want to spy on you, and with Thread 1.3 they were already perfectly capable of doing so - via your Thread border router, which connects to the normal LAN and can talk to the Internet (if you let it). Allocating Thread devices from global IPv6 blocks (GUAs) doesn't change that, it just removes the NAT between Thread devices and the border router.

Before Thread 1.4 the IPv6 addresses used by the Thread network were all ULAs - i.e. the devices were only routable locally and didn't have a global IPv6 address, so if you did happen to want to talk to your Thread devices over the internet, it was possible but the Thread border router had to do NAT for you.

With Thread 1.4 the border router can assign device IPs straight from the global IPv6 block assigned by your ISP, which means you can directly access your Thread device over the internet without the NAT provided by the Thread border router.

If you don't want to locally host your smart home automations (you and I do, but the average consumer doesn't) this can be very useful. It's also really helpful if you want to access your own devices remotely over the Internet and not need to bother with port forwarding.

IMO this fits perfectly with the philosophy of IPv6 - every device can have a globally routable IP address without needing NAT.

If you don't want your devices reaching out to the Internet (like I don't), the solution is to put all that stuff on its own VLAN with no Internet access (which I do).


I think this interpretation is a bit too negative.

You wrote a long message to say that you agree with me technically, but then said that it has good uses as well. I don't disagree with that, but the problem with these companies is - you give them one finger and they take your whole hand. Besides that,

If you don't want to locally host your smart home automations (you and I do, but the average consumer doesn't) this can be very useful. It's also really helpful if you want to access your own devices remotely over the Internet and not need to bother with port forwarding.

this implies that this is not possible with Zigbee. You can use your devices remotely with Zigbee, but it is fully governed by your Zigbee hub/coordinator. You can use Home Assistant, the IKEA hub, the Samsung SmartThings hub, Homey, etc. to control your Zigbee devices remotely. The very big, but relevant difference is that the devices themselves cannot connect to the mothership to do analytics or to lock away functionality. There were already some Thread + Matter devices that required talking to the manufacturer's servers to get all functionality (I think e.g. some Nuki devices, but I might misremember).

If you don't want your devices reaching out to the Internet (like I don't), the solution is to put all that stuff on its own VLAN with no Internet access (which I do).

Putting Thread + Matter devices on a different VLAN than e.g. your phone which you are commissioning it with is very fragile. So fragile that most Matter documentation just says "your phone needs to be on the same WiFi network as your smarthome hub". It is possible (I had such a setup for a while), but requires that you e.g. do allow mDNS advertisements across VLANs (since Matter relies heavily on mDNS). Since you are talking about average consumers, Zigbee will give them privacy without any extra work, whereas with Thread + Matter they have to set up their network in a way that their ISP-provided router most likely doesn't even support.

Thread + Matter has no point outside very large deployments and giving a bunch of companies the opportunity to start data mining your sensor data as well.


> There were already some Thread + Matter devices that required talking to the manufacturer's servers to get all functionality

The most I have seen that is rather the functionality not being available in matter (ie the standard does not support it) so they are only available on zigbee with the manufacturers app.

In my personal experience

> Zigbee will give them privacy without any extra work

Was exactly as fragile and dependent on manufacturer infrastructure for some fratures as you describe MoT. (the privacy part is true though, and as mentioned all the time: I have heard others had much better experiences than me with zigbee)


The most I have seen that is rather the functionality not being available in matter (ie the standard does not support it) so they are only available on zigbee with the manufacturers app.

No, it's also used for remote access, see e.g. Nuki and Tado.

Not super-nefarious, but this is probably just the beginning. If companies can gather data they will and if manufacturers can add features that require subscriptions, they will. The line always has to go up and Thread offers them the means to do so. If you give the opportunity, this always happens (see e.g. TVs, 'owning the glass').

Was exactly as fragile and dependent on manufacturer infrastructure for some fratures as you describe MoT.

I have over 50 Zigbee devices and never have a single issue (using HA and zigbee2mqtt, some on a separate Hue network). The Matter over Thread devices that I have, regularly drop off the network (no interference, etc., they just still seem very buggy). This also makes complete sense, since Thread adds a lot of complexity (IPv6, TREL, communication between border routers, etc.).


> If you don't want your devices reaching out to the Internet (like I don't), the solution is to put all that stuff on its own VLAN with no Internet access (which I do).

Or, if there is already a perfectly functioning open standard that just works and it's private by default (ZigBee) boycott the new standard created and forced upon us by BigTech and don't buy that hardware.


Why not?

Erasure can be done much more efficiently with crypto erasure, where you encrypt the user data and just delete the key when users request deletion. This way you don't need to spend expensive tape vault / library time rewriting a tape.

how does that work 'down the road' in 10 or 20 years?

By that time you've lost the key so the data is already deleted.

Do you mean the encryption might be broken in 20 years, or how do you keep the key for 20 years?

AFAIK, symmetric encryption (which is what you'd use for crypto erasure) is not thought to be vulnerable to quantum computers, and it would be a huge mathematical breakthrough if it turned out that currently-known symmetric crypto algorithms were actually weak.

Are there any games you like that you felt did give you a real significant choice in how the story played out?


Going back to the 90's the Original Fallout games (the Turn based ones) would give you different endings depending on the choices you made through out the game. Most recently Baldur's Gate 3.

Edit: Deus Ex series too


Ah we have the same taste in games :)

I originally asked because for most of the games I've played (and the ones you mention) the overall story played out the same regardless of your choices.

There could be branches and dialog changes but they always reconverged at important story points that stayed constant. And of course the cutscenes at very end would be different. Take DeusEx - some minor things would be different depending on your actions, and at the end you basically got to press a button to choose your ending.

The only real exception I can think of is Fallout New Vegas, where the game storyline would become wildly different as you chose to help different factions....that game was a rare exemplar of "choices matter".


Deus Ex which gives you three choices at the end?


re #1 - I know families in similar positions, and a secondary lock placed high up on the door has been a lifesaver (literally), and gives much-needed peace of mind.

Example: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07DR9CMGZ


We almost got these, but there's one problem... fire. We found we were able to manage the situation as described.

Honestly, after the 3rd time of him trying to run and us stopping him due to the automations he stopped.


Very well said, I often feel the same way.

About memories - throwing away the associated item often feels like admitting that you can't go back to the moment represented by the item. It's hard to face that small grief so it's easier to keep it there.


I agree but I think being usable by the keyboard isn't enough, because the shortcuts are often hard to discover and remember. I think the ideal is - like good TUIs - GUIs should put obvious hints on screen how to navigate via keyboard.

It would be really great to have some GUI frameworks for the common platforms (including web!) designed to do this and have some opinions on common shortcuts for common actions so we can standardize on something.


Agreed. Also, I would support everyone building off of vim principles. If keyboard bindings are somewhat consistent across applications, that would be really nice and there are already a bunch of options using vim bindings as a starting point, since they make intuitive sense once you've learned the "language" vim uses.


Yeah, keyboard binding consistency is what I really want. Ideally, you could choose between Vim, Emacs, <whatever else> keybindings for the program you're using.

I think what's also needed is a standard way of navigating what I guess I'll call the "focus tree". For example, if I'm running Vim inside of a terminal multiplexer (eg: Zellij) inside of a terminal emulator inside of a tiling window manager (eg: xmonad)...

It would be GREAT if I could use Vi keybindings to navigate windows in whatever "focus layer" I'm at... and then have a "standard" keybinding to navigate up and down that tree (eg: "Ctrl + >" and "Ctrl + <").

Right now, everyone seems to solve the "focus tree" problem by trying to choose a control key combination that won't collide with any other process that might be listening for key chords at the same time.


To me, the funniest part of this is:

> We had to change them all


I'm assuming a bot running a headless browser instance can still get past it?

It's still valuable to raise the cost of scraping of course. I don't think anything can really stop a determined scraper from impersonating a human. I wonder though if a system similar to Anubis but mining some crypto would make bots _welcome_ - since they're paying for their traffic.


People tried this in 2013 or so, there's no point to it. Doing proof of work in javascript in a browser is so crushingly, pointlessly slow that there's no value at all. Some browsers also intentionally detect attempts to do proof of work and attempt to block it entirely.


> Some browsers also intentionally detect attempts to do proof of work and attempt to block it entirely.

Then they'd be blocking themselves from the website.


https://blog.mozilla.org/en/firefox/block-cryptominers-with-...

    To help you combat these unwelcome scripts, we’ve partnered with Disconnect and compiled lists of domains that serve cryptomining scripts so you can block them directly through Firefox. When you download Firefox,  tracking protection is enabled by default, blocking known cryptominers.


Technically true, but the list is mostly nonfunctional - cryptominers are basically extinct in the wild, and most of the domains on the list have expired or no longer serve mining scripts.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: