Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | nicf's commentslogin

If it makes you feel better, I've known the author personally for over ten years, and he is both a human being and an excellent teacher. I'm about as confident as I could imagine being that he wrote this book himself. (In order for this to completely reassure you, you of course have to trust me, but I thought I'd add my vote of confidence just in case it helps even a little.)

This book aside, though, the fact that writing is no longer definitive evidence of human thought is one of the things I dislike the most about the LLM era. I very much share your sadness about that.


I feel the need to be clear; I have no reason to suspect the author of using AI; and am even a bit irritated for the author that I have to entertain these suspicions writ large now. It is unfair to the author who hasn’t done anything to warrant that suspicion, but it’s the world we live in at the moment.

I vocalize this feeling I have, not because the author has done anything to warrant it, but here, in this forum, we commonly have folks saying “so what if it’s AI?”, and by bringing up these feelings we have around the industry, we can have the conversation and (hopefully) have other folks think twice about whether they would use AI to write their book.

I want to read this book and have added it to my list of things to read; and your vouching for the author does help. One underlying issue I have (that is a me problem) is that I know nothing about this particular area, and therefore know nothing about the experts in this area, so I rely on human vouching.


I don't mind if it is written by a human or a machine, but AI has a way of writing things that are exasperating, with unnecessary detours around the point that have lately made me very intolerant of stuff for which in the past I had more patience. As soon as I see content that reads like AI slop, I feel like I am wasting my time watching paint dry, and I throw it away.


It's also often wrong.

But also, I would like money I spend to go to people, not tokens.


Well, if we're going to have the conversation: so what if it were AI? Shouldn't the question be around correctness and good pedagogy? Shouldn't the question always be about vouching for those things? If it's actually done well (e.g. they were able to generate better illustrations than they otherwise could've), why exactly should someone think twice?

The author put his name and reputation to it. If it's excellent work, it's excellent work. If it's slop, it's slop.


> The author put his name and reputation to it.

For at least the past 5 years, Amazon.com has been completely flooded with throwaway brand names churned out from random sequences of characters selling white-labelled products. The ones that do poorly get discarded and replaced, and the ones that find traction get to climb the rankings.

Do you think the same doesn't apply to "authors" of books, social media posts, and even academic papers in 2026? It doesn't matter if someone's staked their reputation unless their reputation is already widely known and trusted to begin with.


Well, this person claims on their website to have a PhD in math from CMU and to have taught the topic at multiple state universities. You could dig some into whether that's true, and then rely on the reputation of the named institutions if you don't know anything about them.

Just like reputation already worked. People have associations with each other. People endorse each other. Endorsements carry some transitive weight (I suppose you could use graph theory to model this). This has nothing to do with AI. Yes, Amazon is full of constantly changing "brands" with no reputation. That is different from a person or company that does have a consistent reputation that you can look up, even if you hadn't heard of them until today. Even Amazon also has e.g. Samsung or Asus if you don't want to buy AHIKJASFDIUHER.


The difference in the post-LLM era is that false identities can stand up a cohesive background and online presence with extremely little effort or human input, as many times as desired.

You took a cursory glance at a CV on a website and decided that was probably good enough to keep suspicion at bay, this time. But digging more and more to build up trust requires more time and effort than a bad actor trying to advance an agenda would need to put in; It is asymmetric.


You can't just make up an identity, claim you have a PhD from a well-known university, and appear on someone else's (e.g. the university's) website. I asked ChatGPT:

> The author of https://vertex.degree/ claims to have a phd and taught courses. Can you find evidence from the named institutions?

And it gave me links to .edu sites corroborating the claims (e.g. he's on a registry of PhDs[0]). I asked if the institutions link to this site, and it said his personal site links to this site[1], and that CMU links to his personal site[2]. If anything it's far easier to check this stuff now. Took me 30 seconds.

[0] https://www.cmu.edu/math/grad/phd/past-recipients.html

[1] https://misha.fish/

[2] https://www.math.cmu.edu/users/math/mlavrov/


Sure, posting under a well-known research institutions own domain is a strong link in the trust chain in this example.

Of course you have to be able to trust that some post you find (which names a real person doing work in the field) really comes from that person and is not simply stealing their authority.

My point wasn't that this specific case is like that, but rather that online spaces are bombarded with claims that take far less effort to generate than it takes to verify or debunk. And once some story is seen by enough eyeballs, no withdrawal or retraction is going to have the same reach (bad actors already know this).


> For at least the past 5 years, Amazon.com has been completely flooded with throwaway brand names churned out from random sequences of characters selling white-labelled products.

The last time I looked into someone's complaint on HN about Chinese companies setting themselves up on Amazon with nonsense data and no way to contact them nor any theoretical method of holding them to account for misbehavior, I went to the product link the complaining comment provided and discovered that it was offered by a company whose registered place of business (listed on Amazon!) was obviously the poor owner's personal home address.


Norman Cook was decades ahead of his time. (Fatboy Slim was just the moniker that happened to win the inflection point lottery).


I answered this question elsewhere in this thread; here’s a link to it. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50273553


That doesn't really answer anything though. There are tons of human cranks out there too who are perfectly willing to spend tons of time on their "theories." Humans make errors too. If you don't have a way to evaluate the source material or some endorsement from someone you have a reason to trust, then AI doesn't change that. If you do have an endorsement (e.g. Terence Tao says some AI book is extremely well done, or puts out his own book that he openly used AI to write), then why would you discard it because AI?


Human expertise and appeal to authority have long been a proxy for correctness and soundness in a body of work.

It's not a perfect proxy, but I'm usually going to trust a domain expert over the confident idiot who constantly lies to me, hides and downplays mistakes, and flits around opposing positions like a drunken moth.

At this time, if I see a text is AI generated, I have to assume it is unsound and possibly even nefarious. There is way too much information assailing my daily life that I have no other rational choice.


I'm not the OP, but I can give my answer to this question, or at least one of my answers.

This book is presented as being written by a human. (In this case, a human I happen to know, which would add another dimension to my complaint, so let's imagine that weren't the case.) Maybe someday we'll live in a world where sticking a person's name at the top of a book doesn't carry the implication that they wrote the words in the book. That would make me sad for other reasons, but in any event, we don't live in that world right now, so for now, if you put a person's name on your book, you are claiming that that person wrote the book. If that's not true, you are lying, and like most people, I don't like being lied to.


Why does putting your name on it have to imply you wrote every word, and not instead, just attach your reputation to it, and say that you stand behind the words that are in it, regardless of who/what wrote the words? If we look at things that way, we can continue as we always have evaluating the content, pedagogy, etc. and associate good and bad content, pedagogy, etc with the author and know that when we see that author's name we'll know what we should expect (regardless of who wrote the individual words).

I'm imagining something more like the way we treat movie directors. When I see Michael Bay vs. Quentin Tarantino, I don't think that those people wrote the film, or set up every camera shot in minute detail, or designed the costumes, etc. but I know that they had a hand in arranging for all of that and it will all ultimately come through with their unique stamp on it.


You're proposing a new way that we could treat authorship that's different from how we currently treat authorship. There's an argument to be had about whether that would be better than our current system. My vote would be no, but I'm not claiming it's obvious one way or the other.

But regardless of whether you think your new system would be better, it's not the current system. Surely the question of whether someone is lying by putting their name on a book they didn't write can't depend on some hypothetical future change to the meaning of authorship that hasn't happened yet.


What do you mean "the" or "our" current system? That's entirely your interpretation, and we've always had a sliding scale of "non-authorship" from editors to ghostwriters. AI models are the same; you can use them in a heavily directed way (basically, as an editor, or in an outsourcing capacity for e.g. illustrations), or in a hands off way that you just endorse.


Editors can not say they are author.


> Maybe someday we'll live in a world where sticking a person's name at the top of a book doesn't carry the implication that they wrote the words in the book.

Not even an AI thing, we don't. Ghost writing has been going on for centuries.

I don't like that! I agree it's dishonest and I wish we lived in a world where having been exposed employing a ghostwriter is a disgrace no public figure can come back from. I don't like that AI has made it worse, either. At least with ghost writing there are some contexts (politicians, celebrity bios) where you might suspect it, but in most you won't.

But, we do live in that world right now.


Yeah, I'm also not a big fan of ghostwriting in the domains where it's prevalent. For what it's worth, though, academic writing is very much not one of those domains: taking LLM's out of it, if ten years ago it had turned out that the "author" of a math textbook like this one had paid someone else to write the whole book for them, that would be considered major academic misconduct and that person's reputation would have been pretty severely damaged. I do think it makes sense to take the norms of a particular subset of the publishing world into account when thinking about what a reasonable reader expects when they see someone's name on a book.


Even though I have no idea who you are, I appreciate your vote of confidence in the author. It matters. Thank you


I read them as making a much weaker claim than this: not that the Lean proof isn't valid, just that it is not actually a formalization of the natural-language proof in the PDF they provided alongside it. I haven't heard any PDE people claim that the Lean proof is invalid, and I have heard things from a lot of them that imply that they think it is valid. (I'm a former research mathematician, but this is very far from my specialty, so I'm not really equipped to evaluate this claim myself.)


By all accounts this result cost far more than a million dollars to produce, and either way OpenAI announced they won't be accepting the prize.


There are definitely some results which have this "a bunch of little hacks" quality you're describing, and while opinions differ I share your intuition that there's something a little disappointing about solving a big problem that way.

But I think FLT is about as far as one can get from that situation! Wiles's work was the culmination of centuries of theory-building work, and the concepts that were developed over that time are far more important than FLT; the thing Wiles actually proved (a special case of something called the "Modularity Theorem", the full version of which was proved a bit later) is itself much more valuable to human understanding of mathematics than FLT. It's certainly very cool that it can be used to answer such a simple question that was open for so long, and it makes for a great headline, but I think if you asked number theorists working in the area they would almost all tell you that they're much more grateful for the theory that came out of this quest than for the mere fact that the quest was completed.


I'm a private math tutor specializing in exactly this sort of material, and I agree with this very strongly. Knowing what "counts" as a proof is one of the most common gaps I see in students who come to me after self-studying, and most students do need some back-and-forth with an expert to really get that skill down. I imagine that LLM's could be very helpful for this if they were used judiciously!


This sounds like a fully general argument against being alive and having experiences; you could equally well call love a "brain hack". I also care a lot about solving practical problems, but the reason it's important to solve them is because it leads to human flourishing, which includes participating in all these activities you're deriding. Otherwise why are we doing anything at all?


The purpose is paying taxes, interest, rent and various tributes to the full extent of your capabilities and to sacrifice your life for the benefit of your rulers if ordered to.


I've been working for a few years now as a private tutor teaching proof-based math to adults. Maybe this should give me an incentive to join in on some of the cynical replies this has gotten, but that's not actually how I find myself feeling. I love teaching, especially in the one-on-one format, but it really doesn't scale; not everyone can afford a human tutor and there probably aren't nearly enough of them to meet the possible demand.

If a product like this worked well --- and I agree Andrew Ng's involvement seems like a positive sign --- then that would be great! Something I would wonder about from my past experience using LLM's for technical subjects is how to replicate a particular side of the student-teacher relationship. Sometimes a new student of mine will need to be told that they don't actually understand something as well as they think they do, and that they'd be better served by going more slowly than they might have wanted to. This "talking you down gently" conversation is one I'm happy to have (and sometimes it's actually me who's wrong!) but I'd be interested to see whether and how well an LLM run by a company that really wants to retain customers could pull this off.

It's hard to say without an actual product, of course. I'm looking forward to seeing what they come out with.


This was definitely something I saw on HN, but for what it's worth, in my conversations that night with other mathematicians no one brought up Lean proofs or peer review even as a joke. We just copied and pasted the polynomials into a computer algebra system and checked it ourselves and then said "holy shit, I guess the Jacobian conjecture is false". Couldn't have taken more than five minutes after we first saw the tweet.


Right, that's what was so funny about it. Finding a counterexample: an incredible mathematical achievement. Verifying a counterexample: barely even a weeknight homework problem in an undergraduate multivariable course.


I worked as a research mathematician for a while, and I've published peer-reviewed math papers. Reading this tweet put me in the strange position of feeling like defending the way peer review works in my (former) field, which I'm not used to doing. Among other problems it goes too slowly, it pays only the participants who provide the least value, and it was designed for a world that hasn't existed for a long time.

But this tweet paints a somewhat misleading picture of the role peer review plays in practice in modern math research. Reading this tweet could leave you with the impression that when someone proves a new result, no one pays any attention until it's gone through peer review and published in a journal. This just isn't true. ArXiv preprints are much more widely read than the journals' version of articles, and they go up essentially as soon as they're written. Certainly no one's waiting the year-plus it would take to get the article published in a journal! And even before that, mathematicians communicate their results to each other through slightly less formal channels, like blogs, conference talks, and regular human word of mouth.

In short, despite the sclerotic and parasitic nature of the journal system, the way ideas get disseminated in the field in practice is actually a lot closer to the ideal prewar picture he's describing in the tweet. I'm led to understand that this was less true before the Internet, but even by the time I started my PhD in 2009 things had been working the way I just described for quite a while.


I've spent some time working both as a math researcher and as a software engineer, and I think this comment actually underrates the similarity between the two fields as they're actually practiced.

Some math research does involve grabbing a single, fully specified conjecture off the shelf and hunting for a proof of it, and it's true that if you manage to solve a long-standing open problem, other mathematicians will be interested no matter how you did it.

But this isn't all of what they do, probably not even most of what they do. Like in software engineering, it's not always obvious which question would be the most useful one to ask. A lot of mathematical work also goes into what we call "theory-building", where you could say that primary work goes into coming up with definitions rather than theorems. Mathematicians also care a great deal about how something is proved; a lot of them are some of the most aesthetically picky people I've ever met. Words like "ugly", "beautiful", "creative", and "boring" are used to describe both definitions and proofs all the time.

From the outside, it can look like all they're doing is pumping out proofs at any cost. But I promise you that when I talk to mathematicians who don't have any experience building software, they have a similarly narrow view of that field as well! Both fields, from the inside, look a lot more human than you might expect.


I think that your take is quite optimistic. Having published in top tier journals my only experience is that mathematicians care about what other mathematicians worked on and failed to solve. Theory building papers are dime a dozen and don't get published in high tier journals unless they solve a problem.

Math is such that most theories are built after solving a problem and actually don't solve a larger class of problems. Etale Cohomology is an example of a rare exception. Grothendieck was mad that Deligne used adhoc complex analysis techniques to prove Weil. But everyone else was thrilled.

Whereas in CS, a good theory (library) solves a large class of problems. The reason being is that CS tackles general problems while math specific ones. Math on average solves problems that don't lead to solutions to other problems.

To me at least, math is more of a game like chess and coding is more of an art. There are aspects which are a game, like performance engineering but I'm pretty sure that LLMs will become superhuman at that soon


If your complaint is about the type of work that gets you published in a fancy math journal, then I'll happily join you on the barricades. Sure, getting a paper into Annals of Mathematics or whatever is more game than art in the sense I think you mean here.

But "what mathematicians care about" is much, much broader than what gets you published in a fancy journal. Mathematics as a human activity is millennia old, much older than the concept of journals or even universities, and that activity is, to me, very beautiful, worth preserving, and more of an art than a game. The incentive structure of academia for the past few decades has done a pretty bad job at preserving that art form, but that doesn't mean mathematicians as actual human beings don't care about it --- if they didn't, they probably would have chosen a different career.


Very fair. But when you say "What mathematicians care about", you are taking about mathematicians today, who really care mostly about politics


It seems to me you hooked onto the wrong part of proofs vs software compared to what OP meant. The difference OP cares about isn’t how much one cares about style. Instead the important difference lies in validation. A proof can be validated as either correct or wrong. That type of hard feedback really helps combat the optimism and desire for shortcuts of modern models.

Now, that still doesn’t help an LLM distinguish between good and bad correct proofs. But it still really helps a lot. On top of that, taste in proofs is a lot more uniform than taste in coding. That helps LLMs be better at judging the quality of a proof, because there’s less disagreement in the wider world.


The standards of proof are different from the fundamental operation of "OK, cool, you solved this problem. Why does this problem matter? Isn't it useless? Senseless? Meaningless?" You have this same question whether or not you're in an a priori discipline (mathematics), scientific fields proper, or engineering. "Absolute certainty" has nothing to do with it. I can assure you, people on the job are not looking for The Absolute Truth when doing their jobs, yet they still can question at a solution by asking: are we solving the right problem?

(Although in general, there's no true difference between "I answered the question correctly, but the question was mapped to this thing we call 'reality' wrong", and "I answered the question incorrectly", because you can (try) adding the constraints that you really wanted targeted in case A, to case B, and boom, suddenly a question/answer pair that was "Answered correctly, but question doesn't map to reality" now becomes, "You answered this question wrong". However, individuals generally tend to have some breakpoint to differentiate between the two).


That's a valuable extra distinction between Mathematics and Software.

In Mathematics there is much more clarity on what question you want to answer. It's much less likely you get an answer to a question, and then realize that the question was useless. Whereas in software its almost guaranteed that your first implementation, correct or otherwise, will solve the wrong problem.


Really? Not my experience at all.

If you're saying that math has a consolidating network effect, sure. There are a lot of people who think similar problems are important. I guarantee you that when math was small, that is not the case, and when coming up with new math, that's not the case, and when coming up with sub problems to tackle large problems, that is not the case.


No, what I'm saying is that I don't agree that taste in mathematics is more uniform than taste in coding! Mathematicians argue about taste all the time. Just as you might look at a piece of code and agree that it compiles and doesn't have any fatal bugs but still think it's badly written, hard to follow, hard to modify, or whatever else, mathematicians judge mathematical work using very similar criteria.


Maybe a subset of mathematicians, but if someone proved that RH was undecidable we would still give them the millennium prize.


The types who do ugly proofs, when they write code, produce spaghetti code. It's the same thought process going into how to approach something.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: