Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | nichos's commentslogin

The updated Firefox plugin still works.


Yea, but I just don't feel like going to a site that doesn't want me as a visitor. F them.


Or pay off student loan debt, it's all crooked, both sides.


"Both sides" is such an absurd claim these days.

It's like saying that a murderer and a jaywalker are both criminals, so they're basically the same.


Exactly. And by doing so, we slowly allow jaywalkers to become murderers but still viewed as "oh, it's just another person jaywalking again".


Lol I see you've never met a stallman type (ie your average hn disposition)


You’re right, the “both sides” claim really doesn’t work here.

Biden’s student loan forgiveness would have amounted to a gift of potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars to his most ardent supporters: young, college educated, poor people.

Trump’s proposal is a fraction of that, and all Americans would be eligible. If he’s trying to buy votes, he’s going to need to try a lot harder. This proposal is nothing like Biden’s vote buying scheme.


Funny that you wake up and rise only now. Where was you righteous indignation when Republicans promises tax cuts? Can you point me to your contemporary reaction to "no tax on tips"? What made you react only now?


Have you missed where Trump himself and many of the wealthiest people in the U.S. have had integer multiples of their wealth over just the past couple of years?

> young, college educated, poor people

Oh yea, you're correct, who needs those? Let's feed the 0.01%.


Please beware the false moral equivalence. Both sides is a position which advantages the incumbency.

What is your intent, beyond cynicism?


Biden promised $2000 and paid out $1400, still owes us $600 each.

https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/15/critics-say-bidens-covid-rel...



This looks really interesting. Thanks for sharing. I’ve already found some really good ideas here for the next version.

My focus is a bit different though. I’m trying to make the experience as simple and frictionless as possible, especially for non-technical amd old people.


I don't think they wanted black lung, they wanted jobs.


They wanted, specifically, mining jobs. They didn't want to be reskilled. They didn't want change. They wanted protectionism and fossil fuels and for the world to never have moved on from the 1970s or whatever golden age they imagine the commies in Washington stole from them. They also didn't want the kinds of environmental and health regulations that might have reduced black lung and other problems.

This is precisely the effect of what they wanted - what they already had, but worse.


Come on - coal mining - nonunion rules for health/safety = black lung.


And the Dev has been awesome. Very active project.


It's been bad since the patriot act.


Forgejo


Less power to the government.


Who decides what "hate" is though? Does it switch with every administration? Free speech, including "hate speech" should be allowed, as long as it doesn't violate the law (calls to violence, etc)


"Everything I disagree with is hate speech"

Reddit is filled with calls to violence, I would say it's gotten quite worse since. What's changed is that it all comes from one side now.

When you curate the echo chamber, the calls start coming from inside the house.


The particular problem is said speech quite often leads to calls of violence. And when a few people get banned for that you get dog whistles, sentences that are encoded calls for violence. Eventually the new slang is recognized for being violent and then it looks like the site has allowed calls of violence for months.

A short version of this is, if you let a nazi come to your bar, you have a nazi bar.


Calls for violence are free speech. Calls for "imminent" violence that serve to coordinate it have been decided not to be.

When you claim that calls for violence are not freedom of speech, it's a slippery slope that leads you to absurdities like speech that could "lead" to calls of violence are not freedom of speech, or that secret codes that could be interpreted as speech that would lead to calls to violence are not freedom of speech, or that violent-sounding slang that is eventually recognized as being encoded speech that would lead to calls of violence isn't freedom of speech, or that people who own bars who host people who use violent-sounding slang that is related to secret codes for speech that could lead to calls for violence are nazis.

And since nazis deserve to be violently suppressed...


So which right do you believe in more, private property or freedom of speech?


It's really not that hard to identify hate. We don't have to engage in epistemology


It is hard to identify though, someone is always offended by something. Free speech is about protecting speech you hate, not speech you agree with.


Nobody said anything about offensive words.


I agree that free speech is free speech, the private org that runs the platform has a veto, the assumption that these platforms are the equivilant of stepping into the street to stand on a box is a not realistic.

Even HN is only quasi-free speech, there are rules that will get one censored.

If you love freedom, there are mailing lists and other platforms but they arnt as high on dopamine and the audience gets a little bit more sketch.


Even the US never had free speech—there was always stuff you could/can say to get you gagged by the courts or thrown in prison. Your freedoms always stop at impacting other people.

Somehow we jut gave business owners more freedoms than we gave everyone else....


I guess I don't have a problem with a social media site blocking speech, we don't have to use them, if they are too draconian, nobody will.

But IRL it gets harder if ISPs get involved. I'm more interested in democratized platforms with privacy baked in, if you want free speech you might have to at least give the orgs you depend on for access plausible deniability


"Free speech" means you have freedom from retribution from the government. It doesn't mean your fellow citizens need to stand there and listen to your shit, nor does it mean you are entitled to any sort of platform or megaphone. It means you can scream on the side of the road into the ether and you won't be arrested for it.


> "Free speech" means you have freedom from retribution from the government.

No, it doesn't. The concept of "free speech" isn't limited to prior restraint, you're mistaking it for the dominant precedent in judicial interpretations of the the 1st Amendment of the US constitution.

> It doesn't mean your fellow citizens need to stand there and listen to your shit,

Nobody asked you, or claimed this.

> nor does it mean you are entitled to any sort of platform or megaphone.

You should look up common carrier previsions. If we had to depend on your interpretation of law or morality, they'd be able to shut off your electricity for speech violations.

> It means you can scream on the side of the road into the ether and you won't be arrested for it.

If that's all it meant, it would be dumb and useless. What's more, it doesn't mean that, you can be arrested for screaming on the side of the road.

You're wrong in every way you could be wrong.


Read a history book kid.


I agree on all counts. But the Donald was banned for mostly on topic posts. Reddit is a private business and they can do what they want, but there's consequences to their actions too. reddit has become an echo chamber now.


Still no line numbers....


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: