> This article feels like the result of having unlimited tokens at your disposal.
Gong to be honest where do you think this is going?
Do you think tokens are going to magically become more expensive or models are going to become less efficient?
Of course you should be tokenmaxxing, you can already tokenmax with a model that competes with the SOTA 1 year ago on a moderately powerful laptop you can walk out of an Apple store with.
To be a bit more grounded and expand on your point:
I, personally, have already experienced situations where I was employing cost-optimization optimization strategies for models 8 months ago, that are borderline-useless now because the Pareto frontier has advanced both more than I thought and also in different ways than I thought (cheap models got smarter, better at following instructions, and more clever about tool calls).
That is, the strategies decreased in effectiveness disproportionately to how much the model improved.
It's worth considering that strategies that seem insanely expensive now may be economically viable in a year or two. Or possibly significantly sooner than that.
It's also possible that, like how jet engines get more efficient as they get larger (leading to the 737 MAX incidents, which seems spiritually significant) corporations with budgets orders of magnitude greater than ours benefit from very different strategies than we do.
This seems like a very strange comment to come from someone I am assuming is a SWE. When have we, ever, been happy with non-deterministic, objectively more expensive, solutions?
You're assuming a lot of costs that should just be considered ok in your stance:
* Why pay anything multiple times when you can replicate deterministically for free?
* Why require always-online models when you can run computation locally?
* Inversely, why use power-hungry/PU-hungry models locally when you can have a deterministic software that can be optimized to not* be memory/PU/power hungry to do validation?
I think tokenmaxxing can be a great start* to get things going but when it comes to productizing I want determinism and cheap optimizations, and using frontier models to build these cheap optimizations is what we've been doing at our company over this past year to great success.
IMHO it’s a skill issue. Nothing wrong with bare metal.
My friend runs an OSS project with 10s of thousands of users on a fairly realtime and latency sensitive application and it works great and has been very reliable. He does storage, compute, networking, all of it.
I run a FinTech startup on bare metal and do it for 1/10th the price of AWS (In two Geographic Regions). Reliability has been 4-5 9s over the last year. I’ve also worked for a few F500s. I’ve been the guy responsible for buying, racking, networking, and coding. I’ve also worked at AWS and am quite familiar with the pros and cons and nothing about my opinion has really changed, the cloud is a money printer that serves to make certain people extremely rich. Companies and individuals standing up their own hardware and learning how it works is a threat to their business model.
> Companies and individuals standing up their own hardware and learning how it works is a threat to their [cloud/big tech] business model.
This point never occurred to me but it explains so much. In addition to the points made in this thread, I have seen a dismantling of tech education. For example, I created the two-year degree program for Florida in Linux system administration 20+ years ago. I later learned the program's requirements were gutted by a committee; the took a Windows administration degree document and s/Windows|Microsoft/Linux/g. The new requirements included adding users using Linux active directory and other absurdities. Programming degree knowledge requirements were also dumbed down.
All this because educated tech workers are a threat to someone's bottom line.
This reminds me of an old boss of mine who wondered why we had to spend so much effort on securing our systems. I pointed out to him that we didn't used to be connected to the internet.
"Before the cloud was trendy", small to medium businesses didn't have millions of customers using their online systems.
This is exactly what I was referring to in my parenthetical.
You're thinking of this from the perspective of your own personal expertise, not from a business perspective. The problem is that you don't scale. There are millions of businesses using cloud services. You're not working for any of them. Do you want to?
And are there millions of people with your experience and skills? Doubtful. (If there were, you'd be a lot less valuable.) And a company of any significant size can't rely on one person to operate their systems, so you need a team, and you need to manage that team, and the managers have to be good as well.
Also, 10s of thousands of users is tiny in the modern world. Instagram scaled to 30 million users on AWS with something like 13 employees, before it was acquired by Facebook. It would have been much different if they'd had to do that on their own hardware. They're an outlier, but many business are able to use the cloud to scale to levels that would require a massive internal effort otherwise, especially if they have to meet compliance requirements, integrate with other enterprises, etc.
> Companies and individuals standing up their own hardware and learning how it works is a threat to their business model.
They don't care much about this "threat", because executives look at the situation and choose cloud because it makes business sense.
If you don’t get it, nothing anyone says is going to convince you otherwise.
The people who “had an interest” in pursuing the unknown built the entire modern world that you exist in, since so many things have some connection back to the space program, including ironically the very device you’re using to express your opinion. So it’s probably worth paying them a little respect.
> since so many things have some connection back to the space program, including ironically the very device you’re using to express your opinion.
Well there you go. I did not know that. And yet, instead of saying, "The space program is useful because of X and Y, it's pretty cool actually, I recommend book Z about it.", I get replies that I am a lost cause who doesn't respect scientists.
Unreal. I could have a more balanced conversation with a Muslim imam about religious beliefs.
I guess I never thought about it besides the space race and watching Apollo 13.
And, you know, the fact that if it was so critical to the advancement of humanity, there would be far more competition from around the globe and private contracting companies.
Why do you think Japan, India, Europe, China, Russia and the US all have space launch programs? And Korea (both), Germany, Canada and Italy are all working on space launch programs?
And? We can't live in space, we can't travel because distances are too large, it's still polluting our orbit and a huge waste of resources, for what? Just build more satellites? Is there even the demand for more satellite internet?
I'm all for doing R&D for research's sake, like medicine research in zero G, but this exagerated "everything related with space is magical and life-changing" view is ridiculous. This whole HN thread is ridiculous, this is the crowd that would fall hook line & sinker for datacenters in space.
The real answer is simple. We've made it so hellish to live on earth, the only answer is to fantasize about getting as far away as possible. Even if that place is deadly to human and plant life.
This is the most powerful rocket ever constructed. It has the largest possible payload. The James Webb is tiny compared to what is possible. No other rocket can do that. End of. Please stop. You are embarrassing yourself.
Pretty sure the 12-year timeline wasn't bottle-necked by launch rate. Amortized costs would have been lower if it had all been Russian launches rather than using the shuttle!
Starship certainly ought to reduce cost, but its payload capacity is only 5x that of Falcon 9 which can already fly multiple times per week, and any large project, even orbital refueling, is going to require multiple launches anyway.
If launch was the bottleneck, then even using Falcon 9 with a couple of launches per week you could put the ISS's 420 tons into orbit in about 10 weeks.
Just to be clear: James Webb was build and designed with nanometer aligned optical system, has to be cooled down while being at L2, can't be serviced and repaired and it was only enough money there to build it once and took 5 years of building and 25 years of planning.
It is an achievement, i'm not disagreeing with it.
I'm disagreeing with the level of it.
I'm also disappointed that we celebrate this and ignore that the richest man on the planet is also involved in reducing usability of starlink in a real war were real humans are dying. And his involvment in USAID, DOGE and co.
So take your complaint to govt. Also, nobody is stopping you from using starlink-alternatives.com . In fact, since you hate him, that's what you should do.
Ukraine is defending itself and just before Trump, US of America put a lot of pressure on my country germany and the europeian union to stop doing business with Russia.
Now Elon Musk, the richecst person on the planet and part of US of America is interfering with his system, which gives him A LOT more power than a single human and non gov should have in a WAR which is not his probably due to some indirect garbage between him and the current US of America Gov.
While the EU is paying for it.
And i do not use anything Musk.
Musk has only direct negative impact on my life, no posive one. He used his money to buy twitter because he couldn't shut up and then leveraged it to manipulate and allow manipulation in our elections in germany (search for Elon Musk and AfD).
He is potentially poisening our atmosphwere with his rocket launches.
And in general, I do care about fellow human beings and i'm pissed in their names for all the people he is responsible for being killed (after all he is also responsible apparently for all the invention of the companies he invested in eh?).
Where is Germany's industry? Why is Germany axing its own legs and then crying about it? Why did Germany laugh when Trump complained about over reliance on Russian gas? Why is Germany predicted to not have enough gas this January? Why is Germany fucking up the middle class with more and more taxes? All that tax, yet almost nothing to show for. Keine geld!! Economy going to shit. People taking sick days like candy. More people dying to heat than gun violence in USA. Hours of notary to open a company. Effing europoors and you come to complain...
PS: Statistically, when I walk on the streets, every 4 German I meet, there's one nazi (as per your definition I would strongly assume). Look inside first.
If a private person from another country is the only one controlling space, it becomes a geo politicial and military issue.
So either we should advocate for destroying it, or we are allowed to leverage.
And for all the other things you ar ementioning: Non of them have anything to do to what i said. Its just strawman left and right.
Are you also joking about the Gas and winter? Because Donald Trump, the President of the US of America used his power to start a war with Iran.
More people in USA die from gun and heat than germans die from gun and heat.
And just because there are nazis around the world, i'm not and this is part of my argumentation. If you are a nazi and it doesnt matter to you, of course you don't understand it.
You argue with your Salesman, but don't care of anything negative about Elon Musk? As long as he catches a Rocket eh? Get a spine?
A private person is building things, he "controls" the space because he built things. Nobody stopped Europe from building those things. Again, Starlink is not for military purposes. You have an issue, go complain to US Govt who controls Starsheild.
No, it is because Germany decided to eff up the economy in the name of bogus crap by removing nuclear before enough solar came online.
> heat
Europe*
You, as a German, have zero right to complain when 1/4 (soon 1/3) of your country men are Nazi. As I said, look INSIDE (and stop blaming everyone else).
I can be against Nazi Elon Musk AND in parallel against 1/4 Nazi germans (and no its not 1/3 or 1/4).
I'm not blaming Elon Musk for some nazi germans, i'm blaming elon musk for being who he is.
A private person can't just build things and just do things on one united planet. Its the same thing as why countries are not just building nuclear arsenals. Controlling space is a weapon and it becomes geopolitical.
But hey it seems you are a nazi? You don't care about any of Elon Musks nazi things eh?
And it doesn't matter what starlink is for and it doesn't matter if you call it starshield or starlink. its nitpicking nothing else
You sound jealous that someone was able to build a (or many) tech that has massive success, moving the world forward, and using that momentum to build more...while your dear (1/4 Nazi) Germany is busy taking sick days non stop, voting more of AfD, and winding down industry (like VW etc). Did your skin crawl at the this news: https://x.com/AndrThie/status/2122363982627389528 :salty:
It seems you did not wake up from your "united planet" dream (1939 - 1945 RIP) yet where you get to command the world what to build or not as a German.
Tell me, why do you not care at all what Musk did with DOGE? Giving kids the power to stop random programs?
Stopping USAID and killing kids?
You also don't care at all that he was raffling off a million for votes for a political party?
Why does all of this not bother you at all mh?
There is no benefit in what Musk does which has such an impact, that it has to happen through him but I would for sure enjoy certain progress a lot more if i wouldn't remember him doing a nazi salute on TV or walking around with a chainsaw or whatever.
how did we loose so much credibility against people and espeically people who are that influencal?
People cult?
Are you just pissing at me and not him because you work for any of his companies and benefiting from it?
I don't evne know what you mean with your united planet, it has nothing to do with germany it has everything to do with Elon Musk as a human being.
First person who gets it. It’s 2026, there is no moral panic here. Shareholders don’t care. It’s all completely fake and orchestrated as cover for some other purpose (To offload shares or otherwise).
Legally you're right contract law does not assume that. But realistically your average Joe does not have the resources or time and is not willing to take the risk to sue a megacorp. Contracts only work when lawsuits can happen.
300 years ago average Joes were routinely signing tenant contracts for renting a plot of land from the local aristocrat, the imbalance of power was similar.
The trope of a mortal man making contracts with the devil is quite old. The popular message seems to be to not do it under any circumstances cause you can't outsmart him, even if you're on nominally equal terms.
What nobody understands is people will move on to bigger and badder hobbies, like 100 years ago your hobbies might have been playing cards or maybe woodworking. 100 years from now your hobby won’t be debugging Python exceptions, it will be working on a fusion reactor in a friend’s garage over a couple beers.
Whenever I read comments like these I feel like people are living in a completely different reality.
Most of the tech companies I have worked at are ridiculously easy and generous, I get to work with smart people, and the entire job can be done in a few hours per week. It's not like we're doing manual labor and digging ditches; half the people on this website are laptop-class workers who occasionally use the slightest bit of energy to write a few lines of code or participate in a meeting.
I show up to work and I often do extra because I like it.
The company isn't "extracting" anything from me except the extremely consentual labor I want to give back simply out of the love of the game. If you don't feel that way, the problem isn't the capitalist system it's probably your own life choices.
You’re reading negative valence in technical language that doesn’t mean it. ‘Extraction’ and ‘labor’ aren’t bad, they are technically descriptive. You extract fun and cuteness value from puppies and LeBron labors at basketball. Not an unhappy process in itself, though of course abusive versions exist.
That’s why your happy experience is not inconsistent with this description.
I completely agree and I think smart companies also understand this. There is still a lot of leverage employees have, especially in tech. Tech as "adult daycare" isn't a meme for no reason.
None of this changes the facts of the comment you're responding to. Every business must extract surplus value from their employee's work to be profitable. Nobody said every business has to be miserable, or not mask this extraction in fluffy terms. Doesn't mean it isn't happening though
The correct comparison isn’t him working by himself but with a similar sized cohort where distribution of revenue was fairer. Co-ops are a thing as are the productivity benefits of working with others.
Even if you don’t like the concept of co-ops it’s fairly easy to ask yourself if you would you be more or less motivated if you shared more in the success of a company rather than it being sucked up by shareholders?
Given how risky and unlikely to succeed any entrepreneurship venture is, the answer is still probably no. In a co-op, you're sharing the benefits, but also the risks.
Now, I would certainly be more motivated in a co-op, precisely because of that fact, but that'd also mean I'd be working more. If what I wanted was to phone it in as much as possible while still making money, a co-op would not be the way.
How else would they stay in business if they did not make money off your skill/services? Unless you are a non-profit, why would you hire people just to break even or lose money?
You think a company can exist with just executive leadership?
Would love to see just one example of a billion+ valuation company with nothing but C-suite and that against the ratio of companies with 1000+ employees who are worth a billion+. The only two sub-dozen workers that come to mind for me are Theranos and Bernie Madoff and I'm not sure they are examples of success.
I think the 80/20 rule applies to employees correct?. 20% of employees actually do the work that is making money. So for every 8 sitting around doing nearly nothing there's 2 that are actually directly related to revenue.
The way frame rate work on conventional film vs. an LCD are completely different. It’s like trying to ask the bitrate of a Vinyl record.
Conventional film projectors don’t show each frame continuously, they transition the shutter blade smoothly between frames, and projectors often flash each one a couple of times (48 or 72hz). A cinema projector is going to demolish a LCD in smoothness and motion quality even if it technically has a higher refresh rate on paper.
So when remastering from film, do they put each frame into the digital video and keep it 24 fps, or do they play the film and digitally record it at 60 fps to capture the projector effect?
Can you not literally see the frames skip as you move the mouse cursor across the screen? To me it’s OBVIOUS and excruciating and I’m only a light/casual gamer and use all my computers for work.
If I move my cursor slowly I can see the difference, I guess? But I don't habitually do that - I run with mouse/trackpad dialled to maximum acceleration, even at 120Hz there's a skip when you flick the cursor halfway across the screen. And I'm rarely scrolling a line at a time, I'm going page at a time.
I don't really get the obsession with smooth movement for desktop use (as opposed to gaming). Possibly this is a generational thing? Why is anyone intentionally using a computer primarily via slow analogue inputs?
Gong to be honest where do you think this is going?
Do you think tokens are going to magically become more expensive or models are going to become less efficient?
Of course you should be tokenmaxxing, you can already tokenmax with a model that competes with the SOTA 1 year ago on a moderately powerful laptop you can walk out of an Apple store with.
reply