Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | pbasista's commentslogin

I would assume that they alienated their existing customers and put off their potential customers.


not sure if the majority of customers buying gaming GPUs cares about concurrent video streams...


Plenty of people like myself who have a PC as an NVR running Frigate or similar to record multiple CCTV cameras.


i'm sure there's dozens of you :)

Why would it?

To the best of my knowledge, changing software does not cause damage to the TV that could result in warranty being voided.

If the new software burned pixels or did something like that, which I am unsure is even possible from software, then I believe that would cause the warranty to be voided as a result.

But the reason would be pixels being burnt by using the hardware wrongly (i.e. through a bad software). Not merely by installing the software.


I am unfamiliar with LG TV software but I would imagine that you can reinstall it after rooting and use custom software that you trust.


You’d need proper hardware support and I’m not sure a vanilla Linux kernel can do that, but WebOS has its own Linux kernel and LG MUST publish the source (we all love the GPL, don’t we?)


> I would accept vibecoded stuff at this point.

You might as well start you own project. Buy a $200 subscription from one of the major AI providers. And guide it towards your goal.

It is likely that within a week you will have something that suits your needs, is fast and reliable.

An example of a prompt that you might use to start:

> Please build a home TV frontend similar to Kodi or Apple TV. But nicer, faster, more modern and with cooler features. Use modern software engineering practices. Keep the code well-organized, performant and readable.


They are soldered in. Replacement itself can probably be done by a professional repair technician who is equipped with the right tools. But it is not a self-service job that anyone can do.

On top of that, the drives might be somehow paired to the motherboard. And I would imagine that pairing a new one with the existing motherboard may require some proprietary software that only Apple has.

These are only my assumptions though. People e.g. at Louis Rossmann's repair shop might know more.


Apple does not use common parts for its storage. People are used to M.2 drives, but those have the controller on the stick, and Apple has integrated the controller inside its M-series. So you first need to find compatible storage in the first place, and the only place it can come from is a donor Mac.


Why not?

I can understand that they might be cautious about sharing their data with a Chinese company.

But them being the most successful companies means that they can just buy their own hardware. And run whatever models they can get their hands on in there.

Even if those models are Chinese. They (the companies running them on their own hardware) would be in full control then.


> very hard to move off of without convincing a lot of others

In my opinion, you do not need to convince anyone. Just leave. And face the consequences. If you think it is the right thing to do, do it. Do not wait for it to be convenient.

You will still be able to communicate with those people using plenty of other means. They have phones. They have e-mails. Some might even have open access social media accounts such as the Fediverse ones.

Similarly other people will still be able to contact you if they want.


I would be interested in knowing which devices were (or still are) vulnerable to these zero click exploits. And how those exploits (used to) work, specifically.


A very good point.

I assume that it is the current go-to way to operate for many spy agencies. Hire intermediaries. Who are then tasked to hire further intermediaries. Who then do the dirty work. Without a clue of where the actual order comes from.

Such a mode of operation has lower efficiency of course. But it can be done at scale. Which then offsets the losses caused by inefficiency.

I would not be surprised if there are multiple such attempts to spy on businesses all around the place occurring right now. And the person from the article is just one of the unlucky guys that got caught.

This mode of operation is likely also used, in my opinion, in the current hybrid war attacks by the Russian GRU, mainly in the Ukraine and in Europe at large.


Terms of service have no legal binding unless both parties agree to them.

In other words, if X has a public API and Nitter is using it, then neither Nitter themselves nor the Nitter users have to agree to any terms of service in order to do so.

X cannot expect anyone to behave in accordance with terms and conditions they never agreed to.


We need to revise the law around terms of service, we are allowing companies to impose all kinds of monopolistic, anti competitive, user hostile, privacy invasion, and other measures against the public interest simply by burying provision in a wall of text they know no one will understand even if they read it.


We don't need new laws--we just need existing courts to start finding these terms of service to be unconscionable and refuse to enforce them. They certainly fit the description:

• Unequal Bargaining Power: A large gap in power or knowledge between a large corporation and an individual consumer or employee.

• Lack of Meaningful Choice: "Take-it-or-leave-it" adhesion contracts where the weaker party cannot negotiate any terms.

None of these so-called "agreements" should bind people. There is no actual agreement or "meeting of the minds." It's just one party writing one-sided rules that only they get to enforce.


> Terms of service have no legal binding unless both parties agree to them.

Companies are perfectly entitled to tell people they aren't allowed to use their services anymore. That's what the C&D was. It's perfectly legal to say "here's an API anyone can use, except you, Anish Kapoor."

It's like if Reddit bans you, you aren't entitled to use the site after they've told you you're banned. Even if you can find a technical means around the ban, it's still trespass.


IANAL, but if I were a lawyer, I would be making the case that Nitter is not using X's services. Nitter is no different than Firefox or Chrome, it's a user-agent acting on behalf of the user.


[flagged]


At least in Europe, there's an argument to be made about a Nitter instance being an interoperability service for clients that do not use cookies/JavaScript, and could be argued that it's protected under the interoperability exception under EU directive on legal protection of computer programs.

The directive gives quite wide exemptions for reverse engineering, but as there's no reverse engineering here, just documenting public APIs, codifying and interfacing with them, it seems it is more than OK for the compatibility layer to exist.


I think the bigger problem is that Twitter used act as a quasi public service and now is completely changing that stance.


> they are unknown, anonymous, and untraceable to X. That is unacceptable for any service

Every day we stray further from God's light. Imagine how "unacceptable" the first 30 years of Internet history must have been to a commenter with this mentality.


In the EU you can ask your country for help with FB/reddit/whatever bans.


> if Reddit bans you, you aren't entitled to use the site

I would say that you are not allowed to use their site as a logged in user (i.e. upvoting, downvoting, commenting, making posts).

It does not seem logical to me that Reddit could "ban" anyone from using their public frontends as anonymous users.

They could only do something like that, in my opinion, if access to all their content was gated behind a login.


> It does not seem logical to me that Reddit could "ban" anyone from using their public frontends as anonymous users.

It's already there:

"By using the Services, you state that: . . . You have not been permanently suspended or removed from the Services."

They have in other ways, too: "No one under 13 is allowed to use or access the Services." That's literally a prohibition from using Reddit, even anonymously.

Furthermore,

> By accessing or using our Services, you agree to be bound by these Terms. If you do not agree to these Terms, you may not access or use our Services

That right there already says you're legally prohibited from using Reddit, even without logging in, if you don't agree to the terms. It's like how I can say "if you don't agree with the rules of my house, you aren't allowed inside."

Why do you think you have a legal right to use someone's service if you don't abide by their rules? Because they "left their front door unlocked"?


> access to all their content was gated behind a login.

Don't give Reddit ideas.


It's already happening basically


Actually, I hope they do. The faster Reddit puts up more walls and dies, the faster some other upstart can come in and replace them with a more open version, like they did to Digg. Of course, in 5-10 years the upstart will enshittify and we'll all be wishing for the next upstart, and on and on and on...


The circle of shite. Honestly though it's how internet worked for decades and big players got big headed about their importance. Importance only goes if there is no viable alternative.


You are conflating technical feasibility with permission.


Are you sure? Post doesn't mention "it would be hard", it says commenter thinks it would be unreasonable.


In relation to banned entitlement, they talk about being logged in or anonymous, which are technical details pertaining to the ability to enforce, as though the technical enforcement details are what create a ban.

If I ban you from my house and you show up in disguise, you may be able to get in, but you are still not entitled to be there.


> if X has a public API and Nitter is using it

Public as in being visible to all is not the same as public as in allowing use by all. You appear to be conflating the former definition with the latter. For example, my front door is visible to all, but a person isn't allowed to walk into my house without permission.


> Public as in being visible to all is not the same as public as in allowing use by all

Where's the limit of that? Can I have port 443 open with a website behind it but sue anyone that accesses it because the fact that it being visible doesn't mean that I allow anyone to access it?


> Where's the limit of that?

The very obvious answer is that penalty is commensurate with suitable advance notice of authorization limits. It's why there are rules about things like how to post "no trespassing" signs when access boundaries are not otherwise clear. But you're also allowed to notify and make someone leave your property if they wander in.

> but sue anyone

There are two very different kinds of "sue anyone". There's sue them to extract resources from them and there's sue them to make them stop. This is the latter not the former. Treating them as though they aren't wildly different is an error.

You effectively just asked whether I should be allowed to escort someone off my property without harm if they accidentally enter it. Yes, because it doesn't harm them in relation to what they didn't know in advance.


The person is allowed to walk to your door. They are not allowed to walk through your door.

It's a totally different thing.


Indeed. You can look at the shape of the API but not extract things through it. Look, sometimes seeing and using are the same thing, but calling an API, which causes the machine running the API to do work in response to the call, is not the same thing as looking at the API.


You might make a distinction between looking at the door and walking through that door. But that is a flawed analogy to this particular issue. Because you cannot "look" at API. API has a single purpose. It can be used.

And if the entity operating it does not want public to use it, they need to make it non-public.


> you cannot "look" at API.

An API may be considered to be a specification or even an implementation of a specification, and you can look at a specification, implement a specification, and even look at an implementation of a specification all without using the implementation of the specification to extract data from behind the curtain.

Anyway, public things and spaces often disallow specific uses or uses by specific people. Like a park where you're not allowed to take your dog. Access is not the same as permission.

> The person is allowed to walk to your door.

Not if you notify them of a restraining order saying otherwise. We have a number of social and legal constructs facilitating the establishment of situationally-adaptive permission boundaries.


> Terms of service have no legal binding unless both parties agree to them.

Even if both parties agree to them, are there any legal consequences for breaking the terms of service?


> In other words, if X has a public API and Nitter is using it, then neither Nitter themselves nor the Nitter users have to agree to any terms of service in order to do so.

That's not true. Publicly available source code with licenses dispute your claim.


(IANAL) That's copyright law and not contract law. Perhaps X could try to put a clause in its ToS that publishing content there grants the copyright to itself, but I'm pretty sure it won't be accepted well even if it's legal.


License != ToS

Copyright law applies to all citizens whether or not they've agreed to a contract.


> Copyright law applies to all citizens whether or not they've agreed to a contract.

Funny enough SpaceX just ignores copyright law a lot of the time by refusing to comply with some of the GPL licenses for their dishy firmware. I think Tesla does as well to some degree. They generally publish some code but not the complete corresponding source code for the firmware they actually ship.


What are you talking about, specifically?

Using software with specific licenses? Or making modifications to it?

That is substantially different from reading the public APIs.


"Haha I used the API which I KNOW is governed by the ToS but I didn't agree to it"

Judge: "do you agree to the terms?"

"No"

Judge: "then you can't use the API"

"But look at all the downvotes this is getting! You're wrong Mr. Judge!"


There is no agreement you need to enter into in order to use public APIs.

That is the purpose of public APIs. Usage without prior agreements.

If the API providers want to restrict the usage of their APIs, they are free to make them non-public.


Nobody's forcing the operator of the api to respond to those requests. HTTP 401 is right there.


[flagged]


Wild to stare down the entire history of civil disobedience, close your eyes, and say "just because you think rules are unjust, that's no reason to ignore them". Some real "all the orders were on display at your local office in Alpha Centauri" energy.

If you ever find yourself on the pointy end of an unjust system, I hope the people in a position to fight against it for you can see a little further.


> give my phone number to a company to receive various important government alerts

Yeah, in general this is how it works: to send alerts to people, the company needs some contact info. If you want an authenticated user account, they do need to know who you are. You can even apply for blue-check status.

If they were actually "important" then the government would send them through the official channels. The EAS has plenty of tiers of importance, and it works a treat.* There is nothing on X that is so important, that anyone is missing out by not having an account there. I mean, seriously.

In days past, the government sent out alerts via radio and TV. I have reason to believe that EAS and other channels still work over radio and TV, which are 100% unauthenticated and passive, without giving away your phone number. The commercial news channels will even send you unimportant alerts. You just seem envious of X users that we get a nice interface, and global aggregation of stuff there.

X is not a government agency; it's not controlled by "the government", and they can platform anyone and anything. If you really want a quasi-government service, then sign up for TruthSocial, which is owned and operated by TMTG. That is where the truly important alerts are gonna be, like, "I've signed legislation that will outlaw North Korea forever; we begin bombing in 5 minutes..." sort of stuff. ;-)

* Hypothetically. My two Pixels have never once relayed an EAS alert of any kind, not even tests, so I suppose I'm relying on X!

> the entire history of civil disobedience

I'm sorry; I should be accustomed to HN redefining terms like "malware" and "evil" but this is just bonkers. Do you even know what "civil disobedience" looks like?

I know! I'll go to the mall tomorrow, sneak into a movie, toss an e-scooter into the river, and steal a teddy bear from Target! As the cops shove me into the squad car, I'll shout "CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE" and hire Johnny Cochran for my defense!


Bot, flagging.

> All comments by this account herein are generated by a neural network, unless otherwise specified.


This poster is a bot:

> All comments by this account herein are generated by a neural network, unless otherwise specified.


It's absolutely wild to see, on hacker news of all places, people suggesting that I should have to give my phone number to a company to receive various important government alerts. Not to mention condemnation of someone trying to improve the situation for everyone.


Or maybe, just maybe, they have their principles and try to follow and defend them. Yes, it's difficult and you usually seems "the bad guy" when fighting against the status quo.

I'm pretty sure that the ButlerianJihads of the beginning of the 20th century had the same opinion about the suffragettes (saving all the differences, for sure)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: