Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | pyuser583's commentslogin

The real cost now is the required “vault.”


It's not required. Nor is a casket.

You can be buried in a cardboard box. But the funeral director will be sure to remind your survivors that it's not waterproof.


Some cemeteries require a vault. The problem they'll face with no vault is the ground will depress there as things decay, and they want to get grass growing there ASAP and not have to worry about leveling things out all the time. But many cemeteries will allow it and will just heap the dirt a little higher so it settles more evenly eventually.


My experience too - it’s about the cemeteries.

For now. Considering how niche the industry and how little the public has experience with it that seems like prime fodder for regulatory capture.

I bet with less than $500k spent on astroturfing and PR you could whip the useful idiots into a frenzy, get the requisite (bullshit) academic papers and get some key language inserted into some EPA rule that all but requires the vault in the name of solving some groundwater problem that isn't actually a problem.


My father was in the plastics business for years. I got my business sense from him, and that inspired me to go into tech. But I’ve never made the connection between 1960s plastics and 2010s FANGs before. Thank you!


Yeah, and today's "plastics" is AI.

If that's not apparent already.


"Benjamin, I want to say one word to you. Just one word... agents."


I love the parallels here.

Plastics are genuinely useful. They make a lot of existing things more convenient, and a lot of new things possible. Our world has been absolutely transformed since they became a thing. Things that used to be heirlooms (cutlery, plates) have become literally disposable. They are in every household, on every person, and in every person, whether anyone wants it or not.

It's not just about mass production either; 3D printing wouldn't be there without plastics, and I don't need to tell you how empowering it is.

At the same time, plastics are also fucking up the planet on an unpecedented scale. The waste, the pollution, and the consumerism / disposable culture plastics helped create are unsolved problems.

Plastics are still effectively unregulated; plastic bag bans are not even a band-aid for this problem. The Great Pacific Garbage Patch [1] will outlive all of us, and we have no idea how to get microplastics out of - well, everything now that they are in everything.

And yet, we keep using them.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Pacific_Garbage_Patch


Wait … what? So if I have 10 million dollars, and I need it to be secure and know it’s there, how do I do that?

FDIC doesn’t insure past 250k. Smart move is to buy short term bonds, right?

Or do you think I should keep 10 million in currency?


Every consumer bank and piddly credit union in America will offer cash management customers a sweeps program that will stripe your funds across banks to keep you under the insured limit at each bank.

Whether you want to do that vs bonds is a risk, liquidity and yield decision.


Open source was never about doing stuff for free - at least not originally.

It’s about the definition of ownership. What does it mean to own a program?

When you distribute the program, you must also distribute the code for it. That’s open source.


It's not about the definition of ownership, either. The author of FOSS software retains ownership, unless they explicitly convey it to someone else.

It's about how software is licensed--the terms and conditions under which someone can make a copy. That's why it's called the GNU Public License, or the MIT License, and why there's a LICENSE file.

The mere act of copying does not convey ownership, and never has.


Yes and no. It isn't about ownership of the project as a whole, but it is about ownership of your copy of the software.


I'm an attorney who specialized in copyright law, and I don't even know what you're trying to say.


You are likely too much in it to see the other side.

Free software licensing is an attempt to make copyright irrelevant: it's basically a no-copyright world it aims for, but then structured into the copyright world of licensing to use and distribute. It is nothing but a workaround, and copyleft uses it to make the default an even stronger case for reuse (by including sources).

In no-copyright world, you get a copy of something and do with it as you please. No licenses, no permissions. People frequently consider this "ownership" akin to owning a physical item (you get a copy of a book, or a toaster, and you do not ask for a license to tear a page out or repaint the toaster).


No, it isn't an attempt to make copyright irrelevant. Almost all OSS licenses impose some conditions - even if it is only attribution.

OSS licenses are fully part of the copyright system and could not exist without it. Maybe you are thinking of "public domain".


I am talking of how "copyleft" came to be. See the motivation at eg.

https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/why-free.en.html


It is interesting that a philosophy opposed to ownership and restriction of control has pretty much the most controlling terms of any OSS license - to the extent it is usually banned in any commercial software development.

I do understand the copy left rationale - to ensure the freedom to modify and for the community to benefit from those modifications, it is necessary to use the machinery of control!


> Free software licensing is an attempt to make copyright irrelevant

The creators of the GPL never said this. That's an interpretation that Richard Stallman would probably disagree with if you asked him.

> In no-copyright world, you get a copy of something and do with it as you please. No licenses, no permissions. People frequently consider this "ownership" akin to owning a physical item (you get a copy of a book, or a toaster, and you do not ask for a license to tear a page out or repaint the toaster).

I'm aware of all this. It's also irrelevant, because we live in a world with copyright, and despite the fever dreams of some, that's not changing any time soon.

Perhaps you should allow the person I was responding to answer for him/herself.


I apologize for intruding on your personal conversation on a public forum.

What the RMS's opinion on copyright in software was when he kicked off "free software" is pretty obvious from https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/why-free.en.html — you may certainly have a different interpretation of "you should be able to give a copy to your friend" than I do.


I think the license was the best tool available for the ideology around ownership.


Ok, but this kind of seems like semantic quibbling.

At least since I've been programming (early 2000s), open source has been almost entirely free as in beer. Whatever the origins of the movement, as it actually exists today and has for a long time, both definitions of free are integral parts of the concept. If anyone ever uses the term "open source" in the widely understood, colloquial sense, a dozen eager HN commenters always jump in to explain the exact bounds of the various terms in their own idiolect. I can occasionally enjoy a good debate about semantics, except on HN it's basically always orthogonal to whatever issue is actually being discussed. I've been reading on HN about how the term has been misappropriated for 10 years and I'm very ready to move on.

The parent's point is that if you are looking to make some money, putting a bunch of code on github with an open source license and helpful readme is extremely unlikely to move you towards that goal.


How does this compare to the conspiracy theories floating around?

I’ve been hearing something like this from very disreputable sources.


Aliens and advanced technology aren't going to be involved.


Yes they are.


That’s confusing because I was taught whether something is vowel or consonant is the spoken, not written, truth.


“Vampires pretending to be humans pretending to be vampires.”


Right but they might be incredibly interested in learning about them.

They just copy humans. Thats it. So if it’s the sort of thing a human finds interesting…


There’s no efficient way to do anything with homomorphic encryption.


What worries me is the non-frontier models, which is what the frontier models eventually become.

The small open models are getting better and better too.

And why worry so much about a frontier models - own weights. The model doesn’t - actually don’t quote me on that, maybe it does.

If a model does something sneaky, it could easily grab the weights for a small model and run it on foreign, compromised infrastructure.

AI virus’ are a thing of the future, but not a sci-fi future, and real one.

Maybe one reason it’s so scary is the murky origin of COVID-19.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: