Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | random_ind_dude's commentslogin

There are several industry and trade associations that Big Tech and other technology companies belong to. They lobby both state and federal governments for favourable regulation, to fight restrictive policies and sometimes to stifle competition from overseas. They also lobby the government individually, since they are obscenely rich. So if employers can collectively bargain for favourable policies, why can't labour? It is actually in the employees' interest to act as a collective since it gives them more power.

I think the idea was that if you kill half of the senior leadership, including the Ayatollah, in a huge bombing campaign, the rest would fold easily since the regime wasn't well-liked by the Iranian people. What they didn't anticipate was an even more competent and brutal second-rung of leaders stepping in, and the subsequent counterattacks by any means possible, that took Trump and his allies in the Gulf by surprise.

It turns out that even though they don't like the leadership, the average Iranian doesn't want their country to end up like Iraq.

If you believe the NYT, there was a plan to install ahmedinejad that went pear shaped, so in principle the administration planned for that?

People appraised of the leadership structure in Iran knew that taking out the top tier wouldn't work.

Evil people trying to make money from insider stock trading, at the cost of USA & Iranian lives didn't care to do their homework, nor even crib off the people they already paid to do the homework.

Doing it right would include going to Congress and not issuing unlawful orders, and making far less money for the USA regime.

They look like idiots but they're not that stupid. They weren't surprised, Trump got the 'win' he wanted.


Retired military guys have said they have been gaming out an Iran war for twenty years. President ignored their advice and listened to our friends in the middle east instead.

The reporting was that your friends in the Middle East pitched a year long boots on the ground occupation to back the decapitation strike and support regime change.

POTUS ignored everyone, and his duties as Chief Executive and Commander in Chief, and tried to get ‘half pregnant’.


Surely, DoD has been gaming out Iran war scenarios in every cycle since 1979.

> DoD has been gaming out Iran war scenarios in every cycle since 1979

For sure, but the DoW is a different animal, and here we are.


It isn't as simple as that - most Westerners have this idea that the Iran government is a repressive regime run by a dictator. But it is actually a hybrid democratic-authoritarian-theocratic system by design. This system allowed the Iranian people to exercise some choice on who governs them. Thus, many Iranians also admired and supported it as they see it something very "Iranian", unique and specific to their culture. (Remember that Iranians, unlike the individualistic West, are a collective / cooperative society, and thus some authoritarianism is part of their culture). Indeed, talk with any foreign diplomat or politicians, and they will tell you that among the Islamic states in the middle-east, Iran is the most democratic one. Western experts on the middle-east (and even Israeli ones) are well aware of this. And so they knew that the most desirable outcome of killing the current ruler was that it trigger a civil war (remember that the Ayatollah was also a religious leader, and has a great following amongst Shia Muslims around the world). A civil war would give them an excuse to send the troops to Iran, and divide their country by occupying parts of it, while Iranians themselves would provide the cannon-fodder for the whole conflict. Americans would also be more likely to support this. It would have allowed the invaders to chip away any resistance and slowly occupy the whole country. (Remember, the ultimate goal was always colonialism and resource grab. And of course, for the Israeli religious fundamentalists, their dream of annexing Iranian territory to forge the "Greater Israel").

Sure, the authoritarians remain in power with brute force. But we would be lying to ourselves if we don't acknowledge that there is still a substantial support for their current form of governance in the population.

An economic blockade, or attempts to starve them is again, something foolish, as it will only strengthen the hands of the religious leaders in Iran - martyrdom is a core part of Shia Islam and Iranian culture. (But sadly, yes, it may yet allow the Americans to subjugate and colonise the Iranians in time, if they are willing to overlook the war crimes and Iranian human cost of doing so, which is quite likely - the Iranians shouldn't forget that they are fighting a superpower who is quite comfortable with genocide. In such a case, it may actually be a better strategy, in the long-term to let them occupy you and then fight them).


I think it's some sort of Western blindness, to take something obviously sanctimonious and take it at face value. I'm sure many (most?) Christian kings of the European middle ages have claimed that their rule was necessary to worship the one true Christian god correctly, and not even the most devout Christians of today would buy this argument, and wouldn't really link their religion and feudalism together.

It's the same with Iranians and muslims in general - some power hungry people are using religion to usurp and hold on to power. Like the Christian kings of old, some of these people might be competent and otherwise benevolent, but I don't think either the common folk or the leadership of Iran is different to the rest of us.


Yeah, unlike Sunni muslims, Shia muslims (who are the majority in Iran) consider their Imams (religious clerics / leaders) to be an important / integral part of their religious system. Their Ayatollah can indeed be considered the equivalent to a Christian Pope. Of course, the Pope today, while having some political influence, is virtually a ceremonious role with no real political power beyond the Vatican (if that too), while the Ayatollah still retains a lot of political power in Iran (and even in other parts of middle-east).

As Napolean himself remarked, if a general didn't anticipate something, then it isn't his fault and he's still qualified to run the war. /obvious sarcasm

These bases got really smashed, people died! It's unbeleivable incompetence at the highest level to fail to plan like this. Look at how much planning went into Desert Storm, vs the Iran war which seems basically a back of the napkin "lets blow 'em up!!!! what are they gona even do about it??? :fistbump: :screaming_eagle_emoji:


Turns out most people don't like seeing their cities hammered with thousands of bombs and tend to not side with the foreign aggressor who is murdering their children and threatening to obliterate their civilization. Who could have known?!

Who could have anticipated that removing a leader by force would leave a power vacuum filled by a strongman?

Like, has that ever happened anywhere in the world? Maybe around iran?


They also waited to attack the regime until it had a chance to kill all those protesters who were rising up against them.

They literally couldn't attack faster, because they had pulled the primary strike assets out of the middle east to go kidnap the leader of Venezuela.

> What they didn't anticipate..

Actually they did. Every president has been advised an air campaign in Iran is futile. Donald Rumsfeld was proven wrong that you can’t win on air superiority alone.

.. it’s just too bad Trump fired anyone who wasn’t a yes man


We've known this since World War 2 - bombing cities and people is a poor strategy to win / end any war.

Nothing says rugged individualism like some good-old state-sponsored abstract art.


>There's definitely a risk of over-thinking things. Just do things. You're not likely to regret it.

Somebody probably gave Trump the same advice, and he took it to heart.


I think it's the old that need to be protected more on the Internet since they disproportionately fall prey to online scams. So let's age-gate their access to online services too. If you are old and want to send money to someone, you get age-gating and second-factor authorization from a competent young person. If you want to watch porn online, believe it or not, age-gating and second-factor authorization.


Honestly, I wouldn't be opposed to that either. If we're protecting kids, we should also protect the old and feeble. Old people, people with developmental handicaps, you name it: they're being exposed to a world that can and will abuse you if you have any faith in humanity left and don't have the technical skills to identify things like fake domains and scam sites.

For some reason we're making sure no 12 year old can drive or run for any government positions, but a 90 year old can keep the driver's license that they've had since before the start of colour television, or make critical decisions affecting millions. We can't have it both ways.


It would be hilarious when some services become unavailable to 55+. The whole age check scam will dissolve in a heartbeat


Maybe we should push that then, don't go around the problem but head face first into it. Force the bottom of the bucket to blow out.


Not necessary. People who still transfer their life savings to some "I'm with MicroSoft tech support" guy shouldn't be allowed to vote either TBH.


Waiting for the first 90 year old president...


Well Donny T is working on it but as the saying goes, if you want the gods to laugh - tell them your plans.


Non-fossil fuels make up 50% of India's installed power capacity. This year's peak power demand was 270GW, out of which 34% was supplied by renewables. The percentage of renewables in India's energy mix is going up every year, and there is no aversion to nuclear. Still, thermal power plants using coal remain a significant source of energy, and new coal plants are being planned and built. So India does care about emissions, but it also cares about energy security.


Reminds me of that sci-fi short film where kids are playing a VR game controlling virtual avatars looking for and shooting virtual enemies, while in the real world, unbeknownst to them, they are actually piloting robots that are hunting down and killing dissidents.


a dark update of ender's game


I thought that was just Ender's Game


Damn. I hope he/she remains safe. India's administration is stupid and extremely vindictive.


India's education sector is a real shit-show. The rot starts at the bottom: students that resort to cheating, the endless question paper leaks of national level examinations, and curricula that are stuck in the past. All these lead to the problem that affects the country's economic and social development: a lack of foundational research in frontier science and technology, where the country is always a follower and never a leader.

Maybe these things are to be expected, given that even the Prime Minister's academic credentials are suspected to be bogus.


> rot starts at the bottom: students that resort to cheating, the endless question paper leaks of national level examinations, and curricula that are stuck in the past. All these lead to the problem that affects the country's economic and social development

What you’re mentioning is purely the results of an economic system that incentivizes everyone to behave in a certain way. Upward mobility is non existent for a billion people and the only way to get a chance to that upward mobility is an arbitrary exam which pretty much seals the fate for the majority of the masses. And we’re not talking about a luxurious living we’re talking about an opportunity to just make a living and avoid abject poverty. And you’re blaming the people for doing whatever it takes? The rot is the system, not the people being forced to use it as it’s designed.


The system doesn't exist independent of the people. If those who are harmed do not punish the offenders, the offenders will see no reason to change their behaviour.


You’re putting too much agency into people that have very little or none. It’s easy to dismiss everything as “people are part of the system” but institutions are difficult to change in a democracy. You can riot in the streets, vote out a government and replace the people in charge, but the institutions in place will remain in place. The only way to fix it is to have elected representatives do their jobs, and you know how that turns out.


They do have the power to change things. Institutions can be made more accountable. The people just chose the option to continue with the status quo.


I don't think one has to wait for someone to start a movement. I pick up plastic bottles whenever I see them and drop them in the nearest trash bin that is meant for plastic bottles. I am in Kerala though, which is comparatively cleaner than the rest of India(except the north-eastern states).

The Kerala government is pushing for better waste management now with more trash bins placed at public places and a state-wide effort to segregate waste at the source and collect it from homes.

Still people litter with abandon and it's hard to change ingrained habits.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: