Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | rascalpenguin's commentslogin

This is very true, and is the case with many 'laws'. Another example is with centre of masses: Take a hollow sphere, clearly the c.o.m. should be in the very middle, yet an object placed inside has not force whatsoever on it so it isn't attracted to the c.o.m. and the idea breaks down (NB objects outside are attracted predictably).

This is because this idea is purely a tool to make calculations of large groups of particles as easy as one, but it does break down occasionally.


Which law are you thinking of? There isn't a physical law I'm aware of that claims gravitational attraction toward a center of mass, you might be conflating several laws or thinking of an approximation rule that was never intended to cover one object inside or even near another.

Newton's law of gravitation is stated in terms of a particle to particle relationship.

Center of Mass is the balance point of an object, and objects will always rotate around their center of mass unless constrained, but this doesn't relate to gravity.

You can approximate gravity at a distance from any object by using the object's center of mass, but that approximation breaks down when you're close to it.


I don't think that's true. An object would be attracted to the inner surface of the sphere because that's where the mass actually is. The shape you're describing doesn't have a center of mass the way we traditionally think of it.


It's absolutely true, and it's known as the shell theorem. It's an old result actually.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shell_theorem


An object inside the hollow sphere would in fact be attracted to each individual mass-ful particle on the surface of the hollow sphere. But (assuming uniform density on the sphere) the net effect is 0 (it feels no gravitational attraction whatsoever).

The best way to prove this is to compute the gravitational force between your object and any arbitrary particle on the surface, then do the integration over all the particles (across the 3 dimensions).


The best way is to use symmetry. Ask yourself, which way would the net force be directed?


I don't find this satisfactory - someone could just answer with "towards the center of the sphere", as if the center were some equilibrium.


At the center of a uniform hollow sphere the force will be precisely 0.


Every pyhsics problem with a uniform sphere reaches the escape velocity necessary to escape the complex calculus problem well.


Not just at the center; everywhere inside it.


Of course, Gauss's law. :)


I imagine this is because the majority of revenue is spent on growing the buisness, rather than going into profit (As profit = revenue - expenses). As Tesla still has a lot more space to grow. Same method Amazon did until recently for years.


Yes, but note that a lot of investments can be made without reducing profit.

"Expenses", in this sense is not "cash out". When you buy a building, you're just moving value from one store to another (cash -> assets). Only the deprecation (something like 5% p.a. for a building) has an impact on profits.

(although, for technology companies, investments often hurt profits more than for more traditional companies, mainly b/c typical tech investments are hard to value accurately and therefore deprecate immediately or faster – self-created IP as one example)


Excellent! Thank you for pointing that out. "Profit" is a comical term, how can we measure the net savings for humanity-at-large from such endeavors?


I wouldn't exactly call it comical. It's just that it's a political term rather than a financial one. Deciding to take a profit this year is an important signifier for the investors, who all must have the same question in mind, how long is it going to take for their investment to pay off.

As long as Musk decides to roll all revenues back into operations, investors get nothing. Musk has a reputation as someone who doesn't really care all that much about his investors, this is a move carefully designed to massage that image. Musk still doesn't care about his investors, but throwing a little cash their way keeps their voices from building to a crescendo.

As for what humanity is getting out of the deal, they already got the Model S and X, it's soon going to get the 3.


humanity is getting out of the deal, they already got the Model S and X, it's soon going to get the 3

Let's not be too breathless when we describe the cars that a few hundred thousand of the wealthiest people on the planet have purchased.


> Let's not be too breathless

Well, you know, I wasn't. The opposite actually.


... at a considerable cost to taxpayers in what was essentially a large upward wealth transfer.

It might be worth it in the end, but call a spade a spade.


In the US gas is subsidized to hell. It's not even close compared to EV credits paid out.


The ZEV credits that Tesla receives, and sells on, aren't paid for by taxpayers - they're paid for by other automakers.

Ultimately, it comes out of the profits of whichever automakers aren't producing enough low-emission cars.


Interesting. This is my first time learning about ZEV credits. That's actually pretty cool.


Gasoline is not subsidized, it is heavily taxed.


Yes, gasoline is taxed at the retail level (though not particularly heavily in the US).

However oil & gas production receives significant subsidies in many (most?) countries around the world, including the US.

In addition, oil used for things like aviation fuel, heating, power generation, and maritime fuels used for shipping, are typically completely tax-free.


> As long as Musk decides to roll all revenues back into operations, investors get nothing.

Don't investors get a higher-valued company (and thus higher share price)? At the end of the day, capital gains is capital gains, whether it's realized via dividends or share buybacks or not.


Most investors value growth as well as income. And that's especially the case for Tesla investors, who bought a stock that has a ton of growth already priced into it.


Yeah that's right. Further, it's not that Musk just tells investors to go do one for humanity. They know if they let the business grow more now, they get even larger profits later.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: