Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | refurb's commentslogin

The market is actually working perfectly.

Supply goes to those willing to pay the highest price (because they can use them at a high productivity).

RAN has a long lead time, so supply isn’t created overnight. That’s not a “market problem” that a physics problem.

It’s not a “market failure” because some customer can buy it at the price they want. Those customers always exist (people who wouldn’t buy 2 years ago unless it was cheaper)


What separates a company trying to “pump sales” through “circular financing” from a company with bucket loads of cash investing in startups who use their products?

How about companies who heavily discount their product to startups to support new uses for their products because it could create new demand?

I’d say “is Nvidia the only investor in this company?” If not then clearly other investors feel like the startup is an investment.

It’s a hell of an allegation to say it’s a pump and dump scheme since those same behaviors can just be smart business practice.


Why should there be a separation? If the startups using their product wouldn't have survived on their own or found other investors injecting as much money, that's a huge sign of circular economy.

Why would their be a separation between fraud and normal business?

It's all fraud.

At best, financing like that means any honest competitor that doesn't get on the honey train is at massive market disadvantage.

Kinda similar to when niche gets flooded by VC money. Now anyone with better product will get out-competed by people that can sell at cost or below it because they can ride the VC honey train till the competitors are extinct and they have captured the market


I mean, the examples you brought are all a bit fraud.

Investing in a company that uses your product is fraud?

Clearly it's not. That statement makes no sense at all.


None of these executive can sell company stock on a whim. They are “insiders” and if they want to sell they have to schedule it a year plus out in advance.

Yet another example of the media failing to do the most basic research into the topic they report on.

Do better yahoo news!


The article does talk about that 90 day thing:

> In Stevens's case, he didn't have such a trading plan, but that's not necessarily a red flag on its own.

Sounds like it’s not necessarily required and wasn’t followed here?

The format of the article makes it seem like it ends because it has a list of links to other articles but then it continues on. Confusing formatting for sure. And I’m not sure I understood it correctly.


The basis of them stating this is the lack of a check for a formal 10b5-1 plan.

There are a variety of other ways that he could schedule triggered sales that aren't immediately transparent to the media.

A lack of 10b5-1 does not directly correlate to not having any pre scheduled plan.

The fact that they're acquitting months to weeks, makes me feel like they're inventing news to throw on the pile of Nvidia headlines.

There are defined "open windows" he can sell, and these were sold in those permitted window.

It was also multiple batches over months.

He gave form 144 notice and portions were through trusts and charitable / foundation.

He filed multiple Form 144s notifying the SEC of proposed sales under Rule 144. Notable examples include a September 2026 notice for up to 5 million shares (roughly $1.09 billion) and earlier notices (e.g., involving 1.7 million shares in June 2026).

He's got this exact same pattern of behavior for the last 43 sales dating back to 2021.. it's the furthest that I left before I stopped.


It wasn't under a 10b5-1 plan, but in a large company like Nvidia there is zero chance the guy didn't go through a strict compliance process to document his preplan sales.

When I sold company stock (no where near a board director) there were so many hoops jump through and blackout period (even without seeing insider info) there were only small period you could actually trade.

The idea a board director, who is under an SEC microscope, didn't check all the boxes is just silly. Without an 10b5-1 plan (which provides an affirmative defenese), he has to prove his own innocence. Even without insider trading he's at risk of being convicted because someone didn't like his trades.


Compliance is against publicly known and formally acknowledged facts. This whole huang affairs thing could have been known weeks in advance but not be formally acknowledged. Compliance measures usually do nothing and only serve as a cover to make the argument that you just made.

Huh? You maybe shocked to learn companies don’t post their compliance issues on Facebook.

Just because youre not aware of what happens behind closed doors doesn’t mean nothing is happening behind closed doors.


If they are closed door meetings how do you know what happens? Either you are guessing too or breaking an NDA.

That's my point. You're making bold claims with zero evidence. You seem to think because compliance processes isn't public, it's not happening or it's a smokescreen.

I see insiders profit or book gains right before information hits the market like clockwork. What other conclusions am I supposed to draw? Where there is smoke there is fire, where there is this much smoke the whole forest is on fire.

He's not an executive.

> They are “insiders”

Yes.

> and if they want to sell they have to schedule it a year plus out in advance.

No. That isn't the standard they are actually required to meet.

In this case, trading shortly after earnings is generally considered to be fine because at that time, investors have most of the same information the executives and board do. It isn't a guarantee and they can use trading plans to be really safe, but it is traditionally allowed.


> In this case, trading shortly after earnings is generally considered to be fine because at that time

Trading shortly after earning but right before a major scandal that tanks the stock is going to open him up to SEC breathing down his neck.

> No. That isn't the standard they are actually required to meet.

Ok, it's not a requirement, but it's a safe horbor that protects the insider. Most people use it because it's risky not to.

Which is my point. The guy is an idiot if he didn't cross his t's and dot his i's on this trade since it's flashing red for some SEC worker.


And example of the commenters here who don't know even the most basic things about US economics.

Trump isn’t a CEO accountable to a board of directors.

See the difference?


Yes, you're absolutely correct, compared to US president, CEO of a company is accountable to much fewer people.

You're almost there! Good job.

Now what else is different? I'll give you 3 tries.


I’m sure there are people around me who steal from their employer or abuse their children and I don’t know it.

Does that make theft and child abuse ok too?


Is being a humanist mean you support authoritarian dictatorships growing in power so their subjugation of their citizens continues even longer?

Holy run on sentence.

And is your argument that a community who “champions freedom and progress” should be arguing for an authoritarian dictatorship to get access to the latest technology?


This is a bizarre statement from Singapore to be honest.

Why would the US “compel” a suspect they are investigating to cooperate with an investigation in a foreign country?

Can anyone name a investigation in the past where one country “compelled” a suspect to cooperate with a foreign power?

People have to keep in mind Singapore loves to sit on the fence of US-China relations ask I can also imagine the US doesn’t feel like Singapore is going to be much help anyways.


Any investigation for which letters rogatory issued. Probably hundreds.

Clearly not this though? Since the US never asked for assistance?

Not sure if you actually read the statement or just skimmed the titles but it seems like Singapore is just offering their side of the story and I don't see any "compelling"

Also what does Singapore's foreign policy have to do anything here? The statement states it already begun investigations once it saw that there was some foul play.

Not sure what you're getting at tbh


It’s not hard to “dominate” when you sell something at a loss. I can go to Australia and sell a $50,000 vehicle for $30,000 and it doesn’t make me a “shrewd businessperson”

In fact, China has been quite transparent about heavily investing and subsidizing key industries to dominate export markets.


I don't think he'd sell out to China. But I can believe he'd be sharing high valuable information during some pillow talk sessions.

If you have a CEO doing that, you need to fire them.


I doubt he was doing that.

All China needed was for her to sleep with him and nothing else. That was enough to bring him down. China won this round, too easy.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: