Are they modifiable after creation? If not that seems dangerously rigid until we reach a much more stable place with LLMs. It could be great for well worn architectures and models but building one now for LLMs seems like it'd be foolish when it'll be outdated in a few months.
Why would it be dangerous? It'd effectively be a stamped model at some point in time. The bleeding edge moves on every few months, but even now it seems to me that there's only a tenuous value proposition that's progressing for me. I'd rather have an instantaneous GPT 6, Opus 5.3, or Gemini Hydrogen that I own, rather than always leasing models I have no practical application for.
Dangerously rigid, or delightfully stable? The latest consumer models from claude and openAI are already good enough for so much, if they could run locally with minimal power usage.
The better question is, would someone be able to turn a profit offering a deepseek chip for a few hundred dollars? I wouldn't even care about the energy draw (within reason) having that running entirely locally at better than a few hundred TPS without going bankrupt to obtain VRAM would be a game changer.
It's a shame cops can't be trusted to not abuse it if given access not through the courts. Every single time a tool like this is given to them without massive fetters it's abused so they don't get to have the toy.
There's a ton of things that would make policing easier but we don't do them because they destroy other valuable parts of society. It'd be much easier to solve crimes if everyone had to wear networked body cameras and GPS trackers at all times but we don't do that because it destroys far more important things.
Counter point police have been able to prosecute crime without being able to defacto track every single person in the US via car and the corrosive effect of having that ability outweighs the gains. Plus on top of all of that they've proven time and time again they can't be trusted to contain themselves or their collegues from rampant abuse to stalk exes, celebrities, etc. just because they can.
>>"Counter point police have been able to prosecute crime without being able to defacto track every single person in the US"
This is not true, and I dont know why everyone believes that. Real-life policing looks nothing like Law and Order. Moreover, post-George Floyd, police have basically had a work stoppage. Real prosecution requires high agency work by the police and they aren't legally required to do that [1], so they don't, and no amount of voting and police union busting is going to help here. You can't require someone to be "stellar" at their jobs.
Having had real egregious crimes happen around me has exposed me to just how much crime you can simply get away with...all the time. The rich get private security and investigators, us plebes get "Sorry no one saw the shooting happen, so we can't do anything now please leave"
Flock has basically turned a high-agency job that police stopped doing, into a db lookup, that in some circumstances they can be forced into doing.
I agree with EFF, record it all and put it all behind a real warrant and a civilian judge with a high bar for approval.
P.S: Before you quote Benjamin Franklin at me, no I don't want a 100% hit rate, I just want a decent shot at crimes being solved by average police work and just even the slightest hint of deterrence.
Half the working class consistently vote for a soft-on-crime party with a rallying cry of defunding the police and an eye towards virtual amnesty for crimes ranging from immigration violations to DUI resulting in deaths to outright murder.
The "defund the police" thing isn't soft on crime, it's about getting police out of situations where they're causing harm and taking away military tools from them.
> virtual amnesty for crimes ranging from immigration violations to DUI resulting in deaths to outright murder
If you think a major political party wants amnesty for deaths you're deep in some kind of propaganda hole.
While these are technically manslaughter, only because they’ve been plead down from what should be 2nd degree murder, they are clearly not commensurate sentences to the crimes.
Remind me which Governor just commuted like 400 death sentences, single-handedly and without review?
The certainty of being caught is a lot bigger deterrence than some particular sentencing guidelines. This has been proven again and again in basic criminology [1]. The rest is just hyper-partisanship gear grinding.
We've known what the solution is for a while: catch and stop the criminals.
Yes, police morale is a problem, if the police stop working because "criminals will just be let out again". But that's what my original comment is trying to fix.
Just probation for killing someone is acceptable? That’s a wild world view.
As for political party, can you offer any evidence from the Democrat platform in the last 10 years that takes a position on addressing crime by increasing punishment, deterrence, or consequences?
> Just probation for killing someone is acceptable? That’s a wild world view.
Not usually, but
1. That has nothing at all to do with your earlier argument.
2. When someone tries to shoot you, you knock the gun out of their hand, it hits the floor and discharges into them... Yeah just probation sounds fine. That's not murder. And he already served a year and a half before that.
Edit: and I don't feel like researching platforms right now. I didn't make the claim, you did.
The other thing is a lot of people don't realize that the nature of the surveillance has changed. I'm not that concerned with random security cameras recording me most of the time because they're dumb and only record so I'm only really giving up information that anyone else there in the moment can already see. With flock and other newer systems though the data is collated and collected making it a complete dragnet for anyone in the area they operate in.
It's one of the places I hope the courts or legislature updates the 4th amendment to acknowledge that computer systems allow collection of individually innocuous data points to build into an effective panopticon. A lot of the limits on the 4th don't really include a realization that technology has made a lot of things so much easier to do that the government is able to do much more with the same information because they can cross compare it with so many other datapoints that they can cheaply do it for everyone instead of being restricted by the resources and having to choose who to investigate.
Because it went public. The secret finally reached someone who cared enough to slip it to reporters who took a few months to research and validate the claims. That person could either be someone who's hoping to benefit or someone who just thought it was wrong that it was allowed to go on so long.
The best books usually are quite difficult to adapt. It's a lot easier to give characters internality because you can just say what they're thinking in a book quickly in a way that's jarring in a show or movie. I can't remember the last time I heard an internal dialog on a show.
I watched the trailer, and it doesn't mesh with anything I remember from the book. As the GP says, the book is disorienting. Not because of internal monologue, but because of the language. It places new words in essential places, where you can't really parse the sentence, and have to form some sort of impression. The rest of the imagery has been done to death. Some bits from the trailer looked a lot like Blade Runner. But the neologisms, feeling out of depth, that's an essential part of the book, never done in movies AFAIK, and I don't see it in the trailer.
I'm reading The Peripheral (2014) by William Gibson, and it does exactly this. The lingo starts on page one, and then it's meaning is slowly revealed throughout the book. I don't know if this pattern has a name, but it's very pronounced.
There's a few different terms that get used for it. Argot is the name for that kind of secret or subgroup specific vocabulary. Then deep end world building is a more general term for just dumping the reader into the world with limited to no preamble to familiarize them with the world.
Neal Stephensons Anathem did that do me, took me quite a lot of pages to get behind some of the words. Loved that. Can you recommend other authors who do that?
I am watching right now Cyberpunk Edgerunners and it's doing the same, you're an outside watcher of a very different world, and it leaves the onus on you to figure out what the heck they're talking about.
Not sure if that's because it's not going to be there or if it's just the parts the trailer covers don't have Gibson's brand of techno-babble in it or if they were selected to not have it to not confuse people in the teaser.
Dexter had the best internal dialog I can remember; it's like the protagonist had two greatly contrasting personalities (his outward demeanor and then his internal dialog) which were constantly riffing off each other on screen, though it never got in the way. Just pitch perfect throughout.
For a show where the internal dialog eventually does become a bit annoying, look at You (in my mind, greatly inspired by Dexter).
Dexter might have been the last one I watched that featured it heavily for sure. At least among live action I guess I should caveat, anime still uses it quite a bit as a shortcut.
And if you want to jump from “annoying” to “cringe-inducing”, look no further than Lynch’s Dune. Yes, I too love the movie but the inner voices of the characters were not great.
Yes, it's a naive assumption that quality of the presented material doesn't impact consumer behavior, if they get flooded with loads of garbage books and people can't find good book they enjoy they'll stop shopping at Amazon and it doesn't matter if they make money off the slop. It's the same reason Youtube has quality filters for algorithmic feeds, if the stream gets too polluted with bad videos people will watch fewer videos.
It's exactly the same process that's causing people to avoid expensive purchases on Amazon due to the number of fake products that have infiltrated their supply. People move on if they're sold a lot of bunk goods from a place.
I don't know. For years Amazon has had a fraudulent item listing problem to the point where it's hard to trust them. They have made no effort that I have seen to solve it. I mean, why would they, their sales haven't declined.
So, I am skeptical books will be any different than all those knock-off drop-shipped items.
I think you're proving his point: You've identified that the fraudulent items make it hard to trust the marketplace, and (reading between the lines) that has affected your habits in relation to the marketplace.
Yes, but I am one person. Their overall sales numbers show that I am a rare breed. With how bad Amazon has gotten in this regard, I would have expected sales to decline if people cared about it as well. Until they feel it in their pocket book (and it doesn't look like they are) they won't do a whole lot about it.
I often trust AliEx more than Amazon these days. At least one of the two isn't pretending not to be what it is.
Plus Amazon has a long history of screwing over sellers. TL;DR if your product is actually successful, they'll make their own "Amazon Basics" version of your product, then deprioritize you (or even ban you over an excuse). They do this a lot. There's a lot more than just this, it's just an example.
I'd say that's hard to judge from the top line sales numbers, their broad sales could remain fine even when they lose larger rare purchases if they're bringing in enough new customers that are fine with only buying the slop.
Sales may not have declined, but returns have skyrocketed. I return at least as much stuff as I keep. Sometimes they tell me to just keep the crap because they know it's crap and it costs them more for me to return it than to just refund me and let me keep the crap thing.
And yet look at all the non-book products being sold on Amazon that are all garbage. Its the same slop problem and has been for a while, but they don't seem to be addressing that either. I have to assume it doesn't impact their bottom line as much as we think it should, consumers don't (or can't) care as much as we would hope.
There are two categories of (physical) products I buy on Amazon.
Regular “brand name” items sold in pretty much any big box retail store. I have more or less the same experience with Amazon as I do Walmart or Target or wherever for that category. Over thousands of orders I’ve never received a fake or had an issue outside of very rare packaging issues like damaged boxes.
The other category is “trash I need faster than aliexpress” and it’s basically exactly as-advertised for that junk. I usually get the item in two days or less where I am, and the quality level is more or less the same as ordering direct from China. Just trading expense for quicker latency. Useful for that last component for a project or whatnot.
I get that I might not be normal though. If I went to Amazon and searched for “grow lights” and got presented with what you get via that search I’d be quite frustrated. But I tend to research exactly what I want for those product categories and never had a problem getting what I expected.
reply