Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | s8s8discourse's commentslogin

SME industrial production. Business electricity is/can be significantly more expensive than domestic electricity prices. It's a significant variable cost.

Consider a small CNC routing enterprise running 4 machines. Each machine averages 25kW, with extraction, air supply etc contributing another 50kw. Heating the space in winter (CNC routers lock out if the ambient temperature drops below 18c) is incredibly inefficient, because when the extractors are running you're emptying the workshop of air (that you paid to heat) multiple times an hour.

Pre-covid the hourly electricity run rate would be in the region of £45/hr (0.27p / kWh)

At the worst of the energy price crises, the run rate was > £180/hr (I know of one shop that was paying 111p/kWh for a period).

Now we're paying 0.38p / kWh or £70/hr. That's a baseline increase of >£10k a year...

SME workshops have died because their pricing model just couldn't flex to accommodate that.

STABLE energy pricing is equally important as CHEAP energy pricing.


SME workshops made an assumption they would be able to get cheap electricity for the entire time. The reason prices went upto 111p/kWh was because of the price of gas and oil skyrocketting as demand ballooned post covid, sanctions hit, and fears of war skyrocketed. That's nothing to do with renewables.

If variation is a significant and long term then grid sized storage will buy low and sell high.


You can fix for 24 months at 21p/kWh now with octopus business.

I think half the problem of this is people signing terrible business energy deals and not switching aggressively enough.


I presume he is thinking on the basis of Russia deploying another 200,000 troops and the effect that may have on undoing the gains of late (whether it will or not is another matter...).

Extending that thought process, if a partial mobilisation realises 200,000 troops to fight, then the next logical step after that fails is a full mobilisation with pundits suggesting up to 1,000,000 "soldiers".

There is some merit in thinking that the sheer size of Russia means they can just keep churning out men for a zerg rush at a rate exceeding that which Ukraine can deal with, at a cost:benefit ratio acceptable for Russia but crushing for Ukraine.


>Russia deploying another 200,000 troops

It is a very hard task even to just deploy, let alone with any gain. In February after months and months of training Russia has deployed to Ukraine about that number of the best forces it had (like Kantemirovskaya tank division). We've seen how it went.

The newly mobilized forces, even after 2-3 months of announced training, will be an order of magnitude worse with worse hardware (that if China doesn't help - there is a reason Putin made the announcement right after the Shanghai Organization summit, may be China promised something, though that would most probably accelerate US hardware to Ukraine). Deploying such forces to a battlefield, especially a one like in Ukraine - as they say it is much more harsh than even Chechen war - one risks loosing them as they come. For now Russia announced plans to use them initially in the 2nd/3rd lines of defense.

As an example - during recent Harkiv counter-offensive by Ukraine Russia was trying to stop Ukraine by throwing in significant new, recently recruited, additional forces without any staging, battle order forming, etc. - those forces were just destroyed as they came by Ukraine as a result.

Giving Ukraine more and better weapons will nullify any Russian number advantage and thus is the shortest path to end this war.


While my opinion is nothing more than armchair general - I agree. The overwhelming evidence supports this, even before the incredible counter offensive.

Even prior to the arrival of HIMARS, the decimation of Russian armour was astounding. And that was with weapons NATO infantry teams, the least specialist, most numerous bread and butter soldier force, are all trained on and supplied with.

As it stands; the Ukranians are better fed, equipped, supplied, intelligenced (!), and have the ability to rotate in and out of theatre to keep up momentum. As the offensive continues, their armaments increase in both quantity (captured russian equipment) and efficacy (NATO finally testing their weapons against that which they've theorised about fighting for the past 50 years). With every passing month, cadres of soldiers pass out from NATO training in the UK and throughout the EU.

Prediction - with that in mind - the Russians won't wait 2-3 months to deploy conscripts. They'll start loading trains this week.

It's going to be horrific. The metaphor of Russian gloves coming off will prove to be nothing but allowing them to shove greater quantities of meat into the grinder.


> They'll start loading trains this week.

Already happening. https://t.co/Wklq8me5tq

Also keeping the mobilized in 2nd-3rd line defense makes little sense. The current units on the front must be tired, decimated and in need of either retiring back for some rest/recovery/replenisment.

Rusty soldiers will get sent right into first line with all their rusty weapons, and other stock they have to buy themselves if they wish to not bleed to death from simple wounds. https://t.co/JEAxSNOLer https://t.co/GBhRj0g3y3 https://t.co/JnlN5lq51G

Also all this mobilization is unexplicably happening at the start of fall/winter seasons. When/if Russians finally manage to ship most of the people to Ukraine, it will already be winter, and they'll be freezing to death in areas with no working infrastructure, just like during late winter/early autmn earlier this year.

I really don't get it. The leadership must be grasping at straws with very little regard for human life.


> "The rest is rotting"

Is it, though? Because operations I've been to use every last available ounce of the tree. Trunk and limbs are sawn, small limbs, branches, bark, and offcuts are ground for biomass heating. Yes, it's burnt, but releasing no more carbon than it captured in its lifecycle and to provide a tangible end result that would otherwise be achieved with fossil fuels.

Root stumps rot, yes, but providing a breeding ground for insects and hence birds and small mammals and hence predators. They also fix soil beneficial bacteria and fungi, and having spent all their energy breaking up the soil and then breaking down they prepare the best soil bed for the new tree to take its place and sequester more carbon.

It's not the perfect process, by any means, but wood as a building material is infinitely more sustainable than concrete, gypsum and stone.


> It's not the perfect process, by any means, but wood as a building material is infinitely more sustainable than concrete, gypsum and stone.

Cool, show me the part where any of that means this company has a right to claim carbon negative?

Onus isn't on me here.


That's not what I said.

I just pointed out that your emotional response that backs your argument isn't necessarily reflective of what actually happens.


Trees only have a finite lifespan. Even "wild" forests reach end of life stage and that's when responsible logging and forestry management can promote healthier forests.

Using those trees sequesters the captured carbon into structures. Leaving them to stand and die in the forest releases that captured carbon.


> Trees only have a finite lifespan. Even "wild" forests reach end of life stage and that's when responsible logging and forestry management can promote healthier forests.

I absolutely agree with you.

In the book "A Landowner's Guide to Managing Your Woods" the authors point out that the fragmentation of contiguous forest parcels into small private holdings is problematic when it comes to managing healthy forests in the US, especially in the Eastern part of the United States.

The book points out that in 2006 the United States grew 26.7B+ cubic feet of new timber, but has only harvested 7.6B cubic feet. The reason being that much of that acreage is not accessible to harvest.

Many small land owners of forest properties are reluctant to harvest mature trees due to conservation messaging in earlier decades. They often also manage the mature stands of forest in their small parcel for their pleasure, not for 'forest health' or optimal carbon sequestration. Imagine anyone buying a shoreline cabin property and then electively cutting down all of the mature trees on the property.

Secondly, and more importantly, many foresters can not economically harvest from small acreage/parcels. Unless many nearby land owners band together to have their forests managed at the same time, it doesn't happen.

I'm guessing that most dead-stand is going up in smoke (literally turned into firewood) because it has no utility as lumber once it has started to rot or is attacked by parasites.

For larger contiguous tracts, some counties in the US States will tax-incentivize property owners for adopting a forest management plan (that includes timed harvests of mature trees).

Some US states are also purposely expanding public forests to increase contiguous holding and close gaps (of private ownership). The goal is not necessarily to expand the boundary, but rather the consolidate the holding within the existing boundary to incentivize large tract harvest (among other reasons).

Land owners who are managing habitat for hunting are often proactively, positively harvesting (by bringing in logging companies to make clearings). Cervidae (deer, moose, elk) need contiguous stands of immature trees for habitat.

> Leaving them to stand and die in the forest releases that captured carbon.

I own a stand of mature oaks that are quickly succumbing to oak wilt. They are being naturally replaced by aggressively spreading sugar maple, which can propagate quickly in a shaded understory and then bolt up when the dominating oaks die off due to disease.

I've been turning the dying mature oaks into lumber and firewood. If they're too far gone, they have no utility other than as firewood. I'm considering pre-emptive salvage in the areas that the oak wilt is prevalent so they're not completely relegated to firewood.


Trees can grow over a century and stay up for centuries. Large old trees over here have scars from multiple survived forest firest etc.

Cutting down a 50 year old tree and putting it to a building instead of letting it grow is not an obvious carbon sink to me. The branches might be used for energy nowadays, but the bark and roots will release CO2 etc. The new sapling will grow very slowly (kg carbon per year) for the first 15 years.


Some trees can grow over a century. Some can't. Some trees growth top out by 50 years and then grow incredibly slowly (sequestering carbon at a much slower rate). Some grow for 300 years and sequester carbon at a constant rate. Which is why it's called woodland _management_.

"Having survived multiple forest fires" says a lot to me. Surviving a forest fire still invokes a huge release of otherwise captured carbon for no gain. Harvesting trees for timber means the bulk of the tree sequesters carbon into the structure, and the waste byproduct can be utilised to provide energy for the process.

With the correct tooling and processes, it's as close to carbon neutral as you can get.


>Surviving a forest fire still invokes a huge release of otherwise captured carbon for no gain

The cycle of life for some trees involves forest fires, so I wouldn't write off forest fires as having "no gain".


Sure. Willows grow fast and are short lived. Typically you don't make timber out of willow either, though you can use it in building, it's a different method (and might be great).

My examples were of typical local forests here, which are long and slow growth by majority.

I know there are a lot of people with vested interest in selling logging as CO2 negative, and I see the idea promoted all the time.


Letting a tree grow to complete maturity is a gamble.

Many of the US's classic native tree species are under incredible stress (or nearly wiped out) due to the rapid spread of parasites and disease, e.g., oak wilt, emerald ash borer, Dutch elm disease, American chestnut blight, Beech bark disease, et al. Many large stands will never reach maturity/old-age. Most American hardwoods only have a maximum lifespan of 250 - 300 years.

In a stand of mature trees, only the healthiest tree specimens should remain, as they will be the most resistant to disease and parasites.

Public forests managers are using something called "pre-emptive salvage", i.e., if a parasite has breached an area extensively, they're going to log off those stands while the wood can be salvaged into products (other than firewood).

> The new sapling will grow very slowly (kg carbon per year) for the first 15 years.

The rate of growth is really a function of access to light and water (and nutrients) [mostly light]. Some trees (like sugar maple) will grow slowly, nearly dormant, in the understory of a mature forest, and explode with growth when a column of light opens up due to the death of a mature neighboring tree.

Some trees (Redwood) grow incredibly quickly, reaching 6+ feet diameter in 100 years. Other trees only regenerate when clear cut, and have short lifespans (Aspen at 70ish years).


>Some trees (like sugar maple) will grow slowly, nearly dormant, in the understory of a mature forest, and explode with growth when a column of light opens up due to the death of a mature neighboring tree.

There is unrest in the forest There is trouble with the trees For the maples want more sunlight And the oaks ignore their pleas


I agree.

Clear cutting is the dominant forestry method here. Everything else was actually illegal only a short while ago. One can personally sample by eye the wood piles one sees on forest roads, or on wood trucks. In general, the material is quite small. There is very little forest in the whole country that has trees that are over 100 years old, and it's not because of forest fires.

My family owns forest and some of that was felled 60 years ago. The trees are quite small for clear cutting. The plan is to remove some of them, to make the others grow more. The proposed standard alternative (that most neighbors are doing), clear cutting it all and planting saplings - would that really be carbon negative? The trees in a way have the most growth potential right now.


In the last two years I've been committing just 16-24 hours/week of actual sit-down-at-desk work to the projects/contracts I've worked on. Despite not working 40 hours, I hit all my deliverables and leave my clients very happy. No secret sauce - I just focus on getting deliverables done and religiously avoid "stuff-and-fluff".

That to say; recruiters, team leads et al have little idea of how workload converts to time. If you're measuring hours you've already lost. The only thing that matters is output value.

> Michael Scott: Jim Halpert: Not a hard worker. I can spend all day on a project, and he will finish the same project in a half an hour.


There isn't sufficient margin in drink to float a pub. The margin is in food (and to an extent, dispensed soft drinks).

Because priority becomes food over drink, people are willing (and able) to drive further for a better pub. Competition increases and you don't need a 'local' for every village or part of town anymore. Less pubs can serve more people because rather than regulars "propping up the bar" 3-5 nights a week for an extended session, you get restaurant-esque table turnover.

This is desirable for landlords - they often live above their pubs - profit from food service means you can shut earlier, you don't have regular fights or trouble from drunk customers and general toil is lower.

But some publicans just won't (or can't) adapt. They won't or can't invest in kitchen and chef. They can't or won't learn how to market and attract new, younger customers. Inflation, energy pricing, COVID shutdowns et al have all just accelerated the demise of the "pub pub".

The old "pub pub" crowd are now well served by the Wetherspoons, who have the advantage of controlling their margins in ways Brewery landlords can't compete with (mass purchasing, pre-prepared food, all their pubs are "new" buildings that don't have the insane maintenance and insurance overheads of a 200+ year old pub building etcetc).

We may be at a record low, but I suspect we'll be setting new lows for some years to come yet.

src: family of publicans from 193Xs ~> 200X. Tried to buy a pub at the 'end' of COVID restrictions.


Having invested in this business before, the margin is entirely in alcohol. Typical drink costs <50p and sold for >20x. Food has nowhere near those margins given the labor and materials required.


Yeah no idea what that part is about. The margins are absolutely in the alcohol, and the food is to get you to spend longer sitting there drinking with friends.

Src: Ran a bar for 4 years.


Some pubs successfully transition into a sort of trendy, highly publicized concept restaurant which charges a premium for food and essentially attracts well off restaurant customers who tend to drink more than average. I think that might be the model he had in mind. Most pubs won't be able to do this however as the market for it is only so big and it will tend to alienate their regular customer base.


Doesn't it depend on the absolute amount of profit per customer per hour?

For instance, if a person goes out and has 3 beers over two hours at $6 each, say the profit is $5 per beer or $15.

Instead if that person comes in and orders a meal for $30, with a 50% margin, he's made the same amount and likely didn't stay as long. Basically food is more absolute profit per customer per hour. And you get the benefit of not dealing with drunk people. That's why they they often don't let you take a table if you're not ordering food.


A 50% margin on a meal is enormous. Expect single digits. Food requires someone to cook it, a lot more storage, a lot more tools and dishes and what not.


I've worked in serval bar kitchens where the food was a loss leader and basically only there to allow the business to more easily aquire a liquor license.


Fair enough. The customer may order some soft-drinks or alcohol drinks at the bar. Also I hear deserts are high margin. My point is that relative margin is not the thing you would want to optimize on. You'd want to maximize profit per customer per hour.


His point still stands. Your original estimate of the margin was just not realistic.

This obviously varies depending on many factors, but when you factor in labor, ingredients, equipment etc. 10% is a good margin on food. In your hypothetical example the customer who came in, had a meal and nothing else, and then left earned the pub $3 in profit. Someone who has a few drinks in the same amount of time will usually generate more profit.


Having lived and grown up in this business (above a pub since a child) -- you're right.


Not saying I don't believe you but why would a Brit leave out the 'u' in labour?


A bit OT but American English is becoming very popular over here in the UK. It's very common to see z instead of s in words for example. I wouldn't be surprised to see the u dropped at all.


"z" has been a valid alternative to "s" since I was a boy (and I can no longer claim to be a spring chicken).

What I have noticed more of is children saying "zee" instead of "zed". I beat those children and they come to realise that they deserve it.


I grew up here in the US saying "zee". It's only now, in my wiser years, that I'm realizing the obvious: with "bee", "cee", and "dee" (amongst others) all sounding similar-ish already that we really ought to embrace "zed" for clarity.

Or we could all memorize something like the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NATO_phonetic_alphabet, I guess.


Why add another consonant to the name of a consonant? Literally the only letter that's like that.

Americans and the British (and a couple billion other people) share a language that is spelled like shit. We should steal simplifications from each other as much as possible.


I think you missed a few, and it's not just consonants:

Ay, see, ef, jee, aitch, aye, jay, kay, oh, kyuu, yuu, double-yuu, eks, why?, zed.

It's because the English alphabet is not a phonetic lettering system. If I were American I'd:

a) start saying "t" in the middle of a word as a "t" instead of a "d", and

b) vastly improve the standard of my spelling and those around me

before telling anyone, especially British people, that words shouldn't be spelt "like shit".

Personally, I'm with the Arguments against reform section of Wikipedia[1]:

> English is a West Germanic language that has borrowed many words from non-Germanic languages, and the spelling of a word often reflects its origin. This sometimes gives a clue as to the meaning of the word. Even if their pronunciation has strayed from the original pronunciation, the spelling is a record of the phoneme.

Which is how I can usually guess the correct pronunciation and meaning of an unfamiliar word while I see highly educated Americans butcher the pronunciation of anything outside the common vernacular. These "simplifications" are doing anything but.

However:

> Another criticism is that a reform may favor one dialect or pronunciation over others, creating a standard language

If I could force North Americans to speak better then I might be persuaded.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English-language_spelling_refo...

Edit: an important point was missed!


> If I were American I'd:

> a) start saying "t" in the middle of a word as a "t" instead of a "d"

Americans do not have a distinction between intervocalic /t/ and intervocalic /d/. (Though you have to be careful - that analysis requires you to commit to a "syllabic /n/" model of words like "kitten".)

But while /t/ and /d/ are pronounced identically in that context, you can't say that /t/ is being pronounced "as /d/". They are both flapped, which is a sound just as distinct from [d] as it is from [t].


Budder.


I'm an American, but I use "zed" over "zee" in some contexts (such as ham radio) because "zee" is too easily confusable with the other letters it rhymes with: bee, see, dee, gee, pee, tee. It's definitely an advantage. And you don't have to drop into NATO phonetic with its multiple syllables per letter.


More people in the world say “zee” than “zed”. I’m surprised to hear a British person wants to sound like they’re French. (I’m just kidding as I hope you are about beating children)


Are you sure? I think they say zed in India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh. That’s quite a few English speakers.


Canada, NZ, Australia, South Africa, Nigeria...


Whatever the internet tells you about what is "standard"... as someone who has spent his life in New Zealand, I can assure you the majority of under-30s usually use "zee". "Zed" is on its way out.

It probably started with the popularity things like Sesame Street and Dragon Ball Z (Dragon Ball Zee).

However, interestingly, the one time everyone uses "zed" is when we acronymise the country name -- NZ, or N-Zed.


From [1]:

> Population > 2018 estimate > 1,352,642,280

> Official languages > Hindi > English

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/India


You do realize that a minority of people in India speak English, right?

As a starting point, this source lists about 128 million people: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_English-s...


You've given a figure that is around a third of the entire population of the United States, so I think I'm on safe ground, even taking into account the Indian government's well known inability at accurate record taking, but thanks for the list, Pakistan has "187,758,480" under English speakers. No chance of them saying "zee".

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31983828


Thanks to India, more people in the world say "w" like "v" but I feel safe knowing that Indians have a better accent and better spelling than anyone in North America, and I would never joke about anything this serious.

;-)


Most “American” spelling came from Britain originally.


Soccer for example is English slang from back when.


An abbreviation of “association football”.


Maybe adapting to internationalized (American at this point) English.

Also, what they say is what I’ve heard anecdotally several times and it makes sense when comparing even retail prices vs per drink prices.


> Maybe adapting to internationalized (American at this point) English.

I suggest that in the highly unlikely event this is true that we (the rest of the properly educated British) hunt this person down and dispose of them. After imposing a number of spelling tests first, of course.


As an expat Brit who has been living with ESL speakers for over a decade and gotten sloppy on many of these things, some part of me lives in constant fear of exactly this eventuality.

Ain't been caught yet tho


We are watching…


One obvious theory is that 'tamade' never learned British English; the username appears to be Chinese.

I doubt you're required to be a British national in order to invest in British pubs.


Tamade doesn’t sound in anyway like a Chinese username (maybe Japanese phonetically, but that could easily be a coincidence), but I would let them speak for themselves.



Ah, ok then. To me it looks like “your mom’s” and then cutoff.


seanmcdirmid surely knows that; I assumed he was saying it was unlikely to be used as a username. But I don't know why that would be.


> Tamade doesn’t sound in anyway like a Chinese username

Context is pretty much everything; the only Chinese username I can more or less reel off from memory is '基妮真特么老油条... sabibibi', and I may be forgetting parts of it, but certainly there's plenty of swearing.


'colour' isn't a valid CSS property, and 'serialisation' is inconsistent within a codebase written by Americans.

Over time it's natural to drift towards en-US spellings when conversing online, even with a spellchecker.


Never said I was a Brit :P In fact, a big chunk of UK pubs are owned by global PE funds.


And a good kitchen is 40% of the total floor area of a restaurant.


Not that I can claim to understand the business model at all, but usually people that buy food are buying drinks too. You ought to happily make a loss on food if it is guaranteed to be exceeded by increased drink sales.


That's how it used to be, but from what I understand, cheap alcohol from supermarkets has shrunk volumes to levels where overall profits are thinner than in food.


That's not the case; the vast majority of a pub's margin still comes from alcohol. GP comment is just wrong.


Wow, this is complete opposite of America. I have run several bars/restaurants and most of our money came from alcohol sales. Food was still profitable, but much tighter margins. A lot more labor goes into the food side of the business too, and we couldn't get away with marking things up 4x like you can with wine.

I think as you get into Michelin-starred places, the name of the chef and the quality of the food is enough to allow you to charge more, and also to cheap out on labor - some of the top restaurants in Chicago collude to pay their cooks $10-12/hr, for example.


I was under the impression that margins on alcohol were huge. At least where I am, proprietors trip over themselves to get alcohol licenses, and those licenses go for hefty premiums.


They are - usually a place will charge 3-4x, sometimes 5-6x depending on the type of liquor and brand, what they paid for the product. You lose a bit to labor if you're making craft cocktails, as there can be a lot of prep behind those. Having a good wine list usually means have a sommelier or wine steward who will get paid a bit more than the rest of the serving staff. But for the most part the labor costs for front-of-house are nothing ($2.13/hr in a lot of states) compared to the cooking staff.


I have a friend who owns a popular bar and a popular coffee shop. He says he makes far more profit off the coffee shop (which has baked goods and sandwiches and salads) than the bar. Might be different in disparate places.


"I wish I had opened a bar" - every restaurant owner I have met.


I'd think those low wages are also partly explained by the desirability of working at a top place (good for your CV and for acquiring actual skills). Pretty similar to how the game industry attracts talent out of proportion to the monetary compensation they pay.


They're 100% explained by that, not just partially. At all of the top-rated restaurants in every city I've cooked in, all the chefs are buddies. It's very common for there to be a tacit agreement to just not pay more than $X, that way they can all keep labor costs down.


do you have any sourced examples for this collusion?

a friend of mine bailed the craft after being offered minimum wage and a 60 hour requirement in the kitchen of a Michelin star restaurant in NYC


It's me, I'm the source. I worked in a lot of those Michelin-starred places in quite a few cities.

I also bailed. The pay and hours were a large part of it. But I did it for years and years.


has there been any attempt to pursue this legally?


I know there have been some higher-profile suits filed against some famous and semi-famous chefs for unpaid wages/stolen tips (Mario Batali, Tom Douglas, Charlie Trotter, a few others), but it's hard to directly challenge collusion like this when it's very unofficial. And a quick way to end your career and get blacklisted from any other high end restaurant.


Are the chefs also the owners or managers?


In a lot of the Michelin places, usually the chef will have a stake in it. To get investors behind them, they usually already have a name and bit of cachet and also worked for other Michelin-starred chefs. The ones I've worked at have varied from "celebrity chef, never actually in the kitchen, everything is actually created by the chef de cuisine and sous" to "micromanaging psycho" to "humble dude who just wants to make good food." So it varies - some manage every aspect of it, but usually there is a dedicated team for the front-of-house and the chef just does the creative side of the food, collaborating usually with his chef de cuisine and sous chefs. CDC and sous handle the day-to-day stuff like ordering, inventory, scheduling.


> The old "pub pub" crowd are now well served by the Wetherspoons, who have the advantage of controlling their margins in ways Brewery landlords can't compete with (mass purchasing, pre-prepared food, all their pubs are "new" buildings that don't have the insane maintenance and insurance overheads of a 200+ year old pub building etcetc).

Bit untrue on your last statement. Wetherspoons have a habit of occupying traditional/landmark buildings. For all the negative they do against the independent pub trade by outpricing with their brewery deals they do a cracking job in preservation by using & maintaining old buildings that would otherwise go to ruin.

Just in Glasgow for example you've got The Counting House (George Square) which was an old premises of the Bank Of Scotland in the late 19th century and The Crystal Palace also built in the 19th century which houses one of the oldest lift/elevator installations in the UK.


whetherspoons don't have "habits", they have corporate strategies. If they think they need a marquee building in a given area (typically to achieve a higher degree of brand acceptance, or to disguise), they'll occupy an old one; if they don't, they'll happily go for a recent build. They don't have values or habits, they are only interested in what makes them money.

In my neck of the woods (NW England), most Wetherspoons are in new buildings, except in the city centre. Not that it makes any difference to me: I have not stepped in one since it became very clear in 2016 that the owner is a racist piece of work.


> There isn't sufficient margin in drink to float a pub. The margin is in food (and to an extent, dispensed soft drinks).

In the US, the exact opposite is true. Alcohol sales are where the money is made (and yes, soft drink sales, but there's usually far less of that in an actual bar.) Food has nowhere near the profit margin. Multiple restaurant owners have told me this for years.

Why is it the opposite in the UK?


The food in many of these pubs is of very low quality and is designed to be quickly prepared (reheated) at scale with no complex steps involved. After a short time in the UK you can quickly tell what sort of food you can expect in a given pub, so I think most Brits know what they're getting. Personally, I think this (plus the fact that a large amount of the population take pride in enjoying shit food) give the UK a bad reputation re food.

And you'd actually be surprised how much soft drinks are served in pubs. They're very low wastage - so if your company budgets that X% will be lost for some reason, you'll very likely undershoot that and have only X/2% wasted. Additionally you can adjust the syrup/carbonated water mix so that your margins for each serving are higher. The dodgy pub I worked at as a student frequently used soft drinks as a way to balance stock in case of wastage (or in the case of a corrupt assistant manager, theft). Towards the end of a given stock-keeping period (monthly?) we'd often be told something like "Tennent's is down, ring it up in the tills as 3 small diet cokes" - meaning that there is less of a given beer in the stock room than expected when accounting for how much we ordered and how much we sold, and to correct for this we'd use take advantage of the surplus of coke stock (after a price adjustment) to try to counteract this. God help you if anyone asked for a receipt and accused you of swindling them ...


Why on earth would you do this rather than expensing the missing beer and trying to figure out why it happened? I.e. who is walking out the back door with it?


See my other comment, there was for some reason an incentive to NOT account for this. It seems stupid now that I’m out in the real world, but when you’re making £5/hour:

- you don’t really feel empowered to challenge this sort of thing

- stock or till shortfalls of small amounts like £20 that are threatened to come out of your paycheque feel much more serious than they were, especially when you’re a student in an expensive city and that £20 feeds you for a week

- the reason it happened is often known, there’s just a reluctance to account for it correctly. We are taking about very small amounts here


The people doing this are clearly getting one over on the owners. It's common for pub employees to swindle the owner.


We weren’t swindling anyone :-) The manager of the pub (or I guess the licensee?) was the one telling us to do this. And the reason they’d do this is because the pub was part of a group of pubs, and there were incentives for the managers to hit wastage targets. So if there was a shortfall in some beer (like some somehow wasn’t usable, or there was a fuckup when switching a keg that caused the first 5 pints or so to be pure foam, or on a busy night on a big round you’d incorrectly ring something up without noticing) they’d try to recover that this way.

There wasn’t much theft that I was aware of, other than one assistant manager (who was constantly accusing us of stealing) was caught red handed stealing stock, but that was whisky or rum which wasn’t part of this iirc (when entire bottle goes missing, that really sticks out - very stupid man)


Plenty of pubs competing with each other, and the pub culture is one of sitting and drinking slowly. A US bar is to a pub what McDonald's is to a restaurant - a very different business model that relies on pushing people through quickly.


I’m not sure what US bars you’ve been to, but I definitely haven’t seen anywhere near that level of difference to a pub in the UK. There’s often more of a focus on food and meals in a pub than a typical bar that’s branded as a bar, but both seem to encourage longer visits, pubs slightly more so.


It's not. I'm not sure where OP got that idea from. The margin is in alcohol in the UK too, in pubs but also in restaurants.


In NSW (a state in Australia) a bar/pub is often just an excuse for a poker machine license, with all the actual revenue coming from gambling


This is so strange, and the exact opposite of America. In America margins on drink are 100-200%+ while margins on food are much less when you take into account untipped workers fixing it. It must be the tipping difference, since bartenders are basically free labor in America.


It sounds strange because it's just false. The vast majority of the margin in UK pubs comes from alcohol sales. I've worked and invested in the industry and it would be a very very unusual pub where this was not the case.

As an aside, this is classic HN: very authoritative sounding comment, voted right to the top, spouting complete nonsense.


There does need to be a little nuance though, since the vast majority of pub owners are actually on a wet lease then the pub itself doesn't get all of the margin, the breweries normally take 20-25% of that margin.

So an example from a recent wholesale catalogue, 1 30L keg which you can probably sell 58 pints out of will cost around £150 so that gets your cost price of around £2.58 / plus VAT and beer duty and you're up to cost price of over £3.00 / pint

So margins are variable but as you can see if you want to sell at around the average price around the country which is £4 / pint then you're not talking about a massive margin.

The reason why food is a popular option for bar owners is that the breweries don't take any of the margin so the owner takes all the profit from food sales, plus in many ways, the food is extra income from people that would be taking up the space to drink too.


Yeah, I was thinking the same. A large proportion of uk pubs are leased by the likes of Star (Heineken), Punch, Enterprise etc, and they really do screw their landlords on alcohol ties. Free houses basically procure alcohol at 1/2 the price. Food GP is much better in these pubs as a result.


This is a fair point — I have never been involved with, nor really patronised, tied houses, so I know less about the economics of them. The alcohol is still far more profitable than the food regardless; it's just that in a tied house a significant chunk of that profit is being taken by the pub company.


Strange. In the USA, many restaurants barely break even on food and make up their profit on alcohol drinks. They live and die by their liquor license. Is it because they go for pricier drinks in the states?


A lot has to do with alcohol prices outside pubs, i.e. supermarkets and shops, as well as taxation levels.


I work in post 16 education. The number of young adults who have never had a drink is crazy high. A lot of them just don't drink, don't go out much and haven't ever been to a pub.

Covid. Lock down. Being fucking skint. Not having access to a car or bus service (remember the old days when a mate would drive 7 or 8 of you and your mates to a local for a skin full? Doesn't happen any more)


As a young adult I just don't see drink as much fun to be quite honest.


" There isn't sufficient margin in drink to float a pub. The margin is in food (and to an extent, dispensed soft drinks)."

Lol. Try a simple experiment. 1) Pour me a beer. 2) Make me a steak dinner. Task: Find out which takes an entire cooking staff, dish washers, grills, linens, produce, deep freezers, meat bills, gas bills, .... OH! Medium rare please.


Note “landlord” doesn’t mean the same thing it does in the US, it means the person who actively operates the pub.


Do they not own the land and building?


Not any more, the majority are owned by the brewery groups and leased to the landlords.

If you see an independent pub in the UK it will be labelled as a 'Free House' that means it is independent of a brewery and can sell any beers it likes.


Even pubs that are free of tie don't necessarily own the land/building, they'll lease it from a property company (usually one specialising the hospitality).


I would imagine that’s raised prices by a lot then


Traditionally they did but it’s not required. It’s like if you called property managers landlords whether or not they actually are one.


Not necessarily. A pub landlord and a property landlord are completely separate concepts. Of course the same person might be both.


> The margin is in food

Interesting, I've always been told than margin was in alcohol (esp. in high end restaurants).


Restaurants and pubs, despite recent convergence, are in different markets. Restaurants rely on turnover, pubs on repeated orders.


Repeated orders are turnover. Same thing.


My local pub does the best burgers I've ever eaten. Absolutely phenomenal. Stone baked pizzas as well.

I'd go there for food with my partner, say a Sunday lunch, but I'd never go there just to drink. I can't think of anything more boring.


High powered vehicles don't have a tendency to cause anything.

Driver input causes sudden acceleration. Having access to more power is not an inherently dangerous thing. Poor driving ability is a dangerous thing - though I agree that more power can compound that danger.

I drive a 480bhp 1800kg car. It takes active involvement from me in multiple steps to "take off" or 'suddenly' accelerate, and when it does so, the whole car is configured to _increase_ its stability as its speed increases.

That said, if I were to aggressively accelerate when the road conditions are in excess of what the stability aids (and my fallible human skillset) can counter - which from experience is a high bar for modern DSC (oil, ice) - then I would crash and power would be a contributory factor. But from experience I can say that a small front wheel drive car will have 'let go' far sooner under those same conditions.

High-powered cars, by virtue of their expense, tend to have more comprehensive and capable driver assistance features both tech and mech (you're not going to find a limited slip differential on a budget super mini car)

Under-powered cars have trouble effectively matching carriageway and motorway speed in the short slip roads that are common in the UK. A 1 litre, >80bhp car is fine for city/town and village driving. It is not an appropriate vehicle for motorway or NSL carriageway driving. Anything that has no ability to out-accelerate a HGV maintaining cruise speed to join a motorway has no business being on the motorway.


> Poor driving ability is a dangerous thing - though I agree that more power can compound that danger.

That’s exactly what he meant.


> 4. Scaffolding being put up or taken down. Incredibly noisy, actually has to be done fairly regularly, many companies illegally do this at the weekend in the early morning as it's a part time job for them

It's incredibly unlikely that a scaffolder operating in the city, during the weekend, is a part-timer. What you are seeing is the side effect of too much work, too little time, and the natural progression of staging.

Work on one "lift" (one floor height) of scaffolding progresses during the week. The "scaffs" come in on Saturday to raise to the next lift, ready for work to resume on Monday. Your crews are out doing smaller jobs during the week but all come in for a shift on Saturday to knock out a lift on a big site together.

And this isn't illegal. The local authority is responsible for setting guidelines, and those guidelines are used to inform enforcement notices that can prohibit a site's activities between hours _retrospectively if they're found to be excessive_. Excessive is a high bar for an enforcement agent standing 100ft below a scaffolder with a decibel meter trying to hear his impact gun over the drum of a bus rolling past.

The core guidelines are unlimited noisy work 8am to 1pm on Saturday. Work to be "avoided" on Sunday.


Outside any major construction site in Tokyo, you will find a noise meter. I assume it is required by law and penalties are steep. The basis for my assumptions? Each time that I saw an enormous lorry approach a work site, the whole "welcoming" crew was very tense. Literally, the driver attempts to coach the lorry with the bare minimum amount of sound -- no revving the engine or changing gears. Also, I rarely heard the "back up beeps" because they will surround the truck with people in yellow safety vests. Plus, one or more people might be spraying tyres to reduce dust. It is quite a ballet to watch!


>It was also used to shut down businesses, anyone could say they had covid, report it on the NHS phone app and then that would trigger all those people in the vicinity to have to isolate

I had significant misgivings about the app and it's efficacy. It is those misgivings that mean I don't believe this is an accurate representation.

Firstly, and perhaps most importantly, a positive case report on the app had to be backed by a PCR result, which required a code provided on a positive PCR test. A bad actor as you describe would have only one shot at a malicious shut down (and would actually need to be Covid+ to do it).

Secondly, the exposure limit was... generous. Proximity and duration had to be sufficient to form a close contact that would then be advised to self isolate and seek a test. People walking past a bad actor loitering outside a shopping centre would not meet this criteria. The shop keeper would...

...but shop keepers, retail staff et al by and large did not have the app. Employers were actively preventing their employees from downloading the application to prevent having to close for staff shortages while they were advised to isolate.

Ignoring all of this, you get into the crux of the app with the "check ins". All venues were meant to enforce the "check in" procedure - in actuality, it was pretty much only restaurants that did so. Even if you "checked in" to a venue, _you had no ability to check out_ so that if a positive case was reported on the same day you happened to be at a venue, even hours apart, you would be flagged. This meant that every positive venue ping had to be reviewed by a person, who would be tasked with reviewing which of the contacts in the venue should be contact traced. The criteria for doing so was opaque - and without the knowledge of what time people left vs arrived - and the actual device:device exposure being invisible to the contract tracer - we can only surmise that an element of inference and good old fashioned guess work was at play. And as was publicised at the time - the contract tracers found themselves with very little work to do.

>Should I also mention the Prime Minister was telling everyone to get onto Zoom for their meetings and then later on a zero click zero day exploit in Zoom surface which conveniently had given GCHQ enough time to hoover up data off plenty of systems. LOL

The Prime Minister has repeatedly demonstrated himself to be fundamentally incapable of understanding even the most basic aspects of his job, let alone technology. Hanlon's Razor comes to mind here.


> Firstly, and perhaps most importantly, a positive case report on the app had to be backed by a PCR result, which required a code provided on a positive PCR test. A bad actor as you describe would have only one shot at a malicious shut down (and would actually need to be Covid+ to do it).

All they had to do was do a test, type in the code and say it was positive, this is my point about the NHS app could have also required a photo of the positive test result but it didnt! I was poking around with it, and you could trigger the mobile app into telling you to self isolate simply by having one or two of the leading question symptoms, it was that "cautious".

So if earlier that day I spent my time around loads of people like in a shopping centre, on a military base, in a police station, I could get those people to self isolate by being in their vicinity and the app doing the rest, if they had that app, but the US Military bases here in the UK were doing their own US testing and where it was only a suspicion, they got US personnel to do an NHS test in order to keep the brits happy and the NHS happy. In actual fact Covid was ripping through some RAF USAF bases and the US mil were soiling their pants at how many active personnel were going down, what a way to take out the most powerful military on this planet!

Now it just so happened, you could also reset the app without any problem so you could rinse and repeat the next day!

> ...but shop keepers, retail staff et al by and large did not have the app. Employers were actively preventing their employees from downloading the application to prevent having to close for staff shortages while they were advised to isolate.

That would have been illegal in the UK, cant comment on how bad the US is.

> Hanlon's Razor

Yeah, if you are caught with your hands in the till put it down to Hanlon's Razor and say you found some money on the floor and you were putting it back! LOL

Looking at this globally, its fcuked the Just In Time global business sectors as we have seen with shortages et al and continue to see.


anecdotally, I was approached for a lead role with Lego pre-pandemic.

Very high expectations for role/responsibilities and technical prowess. Very low remuneration on offer. And that was before rates and salaries shot through the roof post-pandemic.

Unless that's changed, and given the seeming lack of remote roles, I will be shocked if they meet this goal without most all new hires being junior outsourced/offshore resource.


LEGO is a bit used to paying skilled modelers lower than average because "you're being paid to play with LEGO" - perhaps they expect this would extend to software development.


Probably more to do with the salary expectations in Denmark.

Most of Europe is for a multitude of reasons still expecting to treat software as a cost centre.

The expectation of an IC making as much as a Director of <insert corporate department> is unthinkable to HR, even though the market worldwide is shifting exactly in that direction.


Don't know about Denmark, but I can confirm for Germany. I think the main reason is that in contrast to e.g. the US, software people don't innovate that much, the economy is not geared toward companies that have unlimited potential, and where having good software developers is a difference in billions if not trillions. Therefore they are valued a lot less. Would love to hear what you think the reasons are.


I work for a German company from an Anglo country that pays software engineers well, so they have to pay market rates here.

I was embarrassed to find out I was being paid more than my more senior colleague from Germany, not even taking tax into account yet.

He could double his net total comp simply by moving here and doing the same role as he does now.


The reason is huge taxes. Earning 90k eur in Copenhagen nets you just 47k!!!


You'd have to be pretty senior in Copenhagen to earn 90,000 euros, no? As in, staff/principal engineer level?


Not really. Senior developer (C#).


Lack of remote roles will definitely be a problem for them.

They WANT people in the office. They just opened up nla new Copenhagen office and opened up their corporate headquarters in Billund. They are also the largest real-estate holder (or, their owners Kirkbi is) in Billund - They pretty much own the entire city.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: