Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | sarchertech's commentslogin

90% of people in rural areas aren’t farmers (or live in a farming household), so even if farmers are wealthy it doesn’t have much impact on the rural vs urban income/wealth disparity.

The median farming household wealth is about $1.5 million. That includes their house, retirement savings etc…

I don’t know the exact breakdown but ignore retirement savings. Say a farm family liquidates the whole $1.5 million. They aren’t likely to get the exact market from all of the equipment. Especially if they do it fast. So say they get $1.2 million. Taxes vary dramatically depending on the situation but say they come out with $1 million after taxes.

They now have no job. No income. Maybe the farmer can find a job as a farm manager. Maybe he has to work at the local Walmart for $40k a year.

They can only take out about $40k of that million each year if they want it to last and keep up with inflation.

So better than the median rural family. But across the entire country we’re talking firmly median income. The notion that “farmers tend to be very rich” is wrong. Unless you have a different idea of what very rich means.

The reason farmers look wealthy on paper at all is because our economy can find “more productive” uses for that land than farming. Because our economy doesn’t price in the national security and environmental benefits of domestic food production.


They haven’t built a new army base since WW2. But when they do build new military bases, they build them where they can get cheap land.

Theres also plenty of military bases near Los Angeles.


> Theres also plenty of military bases near Los Angeles.

Well yeah, everyone knows that's where you steal the jet fighter...


That’s not really the case though. Especially in the general case. Just look at the cotton gin. No one was designing little mechanical hands to pick through cotton.

Frequently automation happens only after someone realizes that to automate the process, the process has to be completely reinvented.

I’d say that the majority of successful automation doesn’t follow an iterative path starting from build anything that does exactly what a human does because human physiology isn’t easily replicated with rotational motion.


paradigm shifts usually reveal the limitations and what needs to be done, ie horeseless carriages needing asphalt was obvious from the start

with current gen frontiers, the limitations seem to be requiring a human in the loop, which is quite ironic


Horsed carriages run much smoother on asphalt too.

yes but cars increased the incentive of the large investment required to pave roads

Well you’ve got about 2,500 miles to go east of San Fransisco before you hit a border.

Dozens of different journals over several months implies there was concurrency.

> Their view is even more skewed in that they've worked in relatively small teams, to my knowledge.

They’ve both worked on AAA games before.


Casey has had massive impact on the AAA space, no doubt. But I think most of that comes through RAD Tools which was a relatively very small team of incredibly smart, high impact people. Blow has made some contributions on AAA titles but I think most of his career has been spent on smaller indie titles.

I’m not trying to discredit them, I’m just saying that it’s not like they’re AAA veterans who have shipped many titles from start to end, in that particular space.


Jon worked on Oddworld: Munch's Oddysee, Deus Ex: Invisible War, and Thief: Deadly Shadows.

Before that he founded a 14 person game studio in the pre dotcom era. Back then that was a decent sized team.

Casey worked on Dungeon Siege.

They were also very involved in the AAA community. And after 3 AAA games the vast majority of high impact devs would have moved into leadership roles or started their own studios.


The point I was trying to communicate was that most of their career was spent operating in an environment different than what some of us operate in today. I wasn't going after the _calibre_ of games they worked on but rather the environment; team size, investor/business expectations, scale of production, etc. Having worked in games myself around this era, I've experienced first-hand how different working on a title like Oddworld or Dungeon Siege is compared to a Cyberpunk or Assassin's Creed.

> Having worked in games myself around this era, I've experienced first-hand how different working on a title like Oddworld or Dungeon Siege is compared to a Cyberpunk or Assassin's Creed.

Cyberpunk was released 20 years after Dungeon Siege, so I don’t know what you mean this era.

Also Thief Deadly shadows had close to the same size dev team as Assassin’s Creed and a similar budget.

If you’re trying to make the claim that he doesn’t have much experience in modern $500 million dollar games. Then sure because they didn’t make $500 million games 20 years ago when either one was working in AAA gams.


I worked in games from 2006 to 2014 on titles that I imagine are similar in scale & production to Oddworld or Dungeon Siege to something more like an EA or Rockstar flagship title towards the end of my career in the industry. On the latter end of my career we had dedicated build/release teams, dedicated mocap technicians, networking/multiplayer teams, international/distributed teams, finer-grained tools teams, dedicated DLC teams, etc. We had interns, we had to prepare for more media appearances, etc. It was a completely different environment. Again, I'm not trying to disparage the games they worked on, my point was the environment in which they were created.

I admittedly don't know firsthand what Thief or Dungeon Siege were like but you can see the difference on Mobygames; these both have ~250-300 credited in total versus Assassin's Creed (and "only" the 2007 version) which has ~900 — it only goes up from there. This is not a rock solid comparison but it's probably a decent proxy to describe the scale of production. You could maybe argue that a title like Assassin's Creed had a bloated team, but as an IC that's not really in my control.

But in more concrete terms what I mean is that in the Dungeon Siege/Oddword environment, sure I could have maybe said to my team — I'm going to rewrite "x" because it's not efficient enough, and then go heads down for a while and try to solve this problem. I didn't have that same luxury at the other end of the spectrum. On a smaller team I could maybe say — hey, I think we should drop C++/OOP because of "reasons", and have a somewhat realistic chance of persuading the team. This was unlikely to be taken seriously at your EA/R* type company.

Beyond the games industry I'm not going to be taken seriously suggesting to my big tech employer to rewrite everything in Rust instead of Java because OO is evil or it's non-performant or whatever. As far as polymorphism and clean code go, I sometimes find value in leveraging these if they make sense. I may anticipate some persistence-layer migration in the future or feel defensive about the next few intern project and want to try and have some sort of guardrails to limit their blast-radius. Virtual functions are non-performant, Jon or Casey may argue, and they'd be right in their respective domain — but it's not really applicable in mine; even if I were to theoretically drive _my_ service latency down to zero, my end-user would notice no difference as most of the latency is spent on downstream services. Etc, etc.


Assassins creed had a budget of $15-$20 million. The thief game I mentioned was $12 million. That’s roughly the same scale. Theres also a 5 year difference so inflation makes them even closer.

$20 million is roughly 200 person years, so a 900 vs 300 is likely largely due to crediting differences.

A quick glance shows that assassins creed has extensive individual credits for translators, recording staff, and actors across multiple languages.

While thief deadly shadows largely only lists translation companies.

Assassins creed also list far more worldwide publishing staff that would have had little direct impact on development.

> Jon or Casey may argue, and they'd be right in their respective domain — but it's not really applicable in mine; even if I were to theoretically drive _my_ service latency down to zero, my end-user would notice no difference as most of the latency is spent on downstream services. Etc, etc.

I don’t know that I’ve heard Jon talk about this, but Casey has multiple talks on it and Casey would tell you that if you’re aware of the performance trade offs of the decisions you’re making then whatever decision you make is probably fine.


With respect to their resumes, you're saying neither has worked on a AAA game or a AAA-game-sized-team in 20+ years?

Yeah roughly. Very few high impact engineers are going to stick around working at an IC level in a giant AAA studio for 20 years.

As a contractor though, yeah? At least in Jonathan's case?

Sure but I’ve worked as a contractor myself and I’ve worked with hundreds of them. In most cases there isn’t much of a meaningful difference in their experience.

Not in the AAA studios I've worked in. Contracting was a very different experience.

I think the majority of the improvements come from 3 places.

1. Hardware advancements mean that you can get the same results with less optimized code (this is what allowed 3rd party engines with GC scripting languages to become popular)

2. The proliferation of learning resources and open source code.

3. The budgets and size of indie studios as well as total time spent on the games. Seriously look at some of the games these days that get labeled indie.

Warcraft 1 (my first RTS) had just 4 programmers. And only one of them was on the project the whole time. And the entire project was only 14 months.


> having nobody but Blizzard able to make something that complex ...

> Warcraft 1 had just 4 programmers

This to me sounds like the market for games has changed, such that larger projects are now more viable. Smaller projects with a handful of people may still be viable, but look tiny in comparison.

One of my favourite games of that era, Thief, also had a very small team.


Hold it right there, taffer!

Warcraft 1 was one of my favourite games from my childhood. Probably took me 14 months to beat that one level I always got stuck on.

>Warcraft 1 (my first RTS) had just 4 programmers. And only one of them was on the project the whole time. And the entire project was only 14 months. <

Nice but this isnt even the half of the story: According to ChatGPT, the whole team was "32 people in professional roles", so 8x times of number of programmers. And that ratio even became extremer in the last decades.


Yeah if you include, the manual illustrators, sound people, pr and marketing people, sales, and all the other roles that weren’t involved with day to day development or who didn’t directly impact the dev process.

If you look at one of the games the OP mentioned. The scouring. It has 1 primary programmer, I can’t find how many artists (except to say there are multiple outsourced artists). But it’s been in development for 5 years. So far more programmer years than WC1.


> prioritize each other's well-being over our selfish egos

The desire to sleep around is obviously a desire to feed your own selfish ego.

This is where I have a problem when people try to defend this. If you’re honest that you like to sleep around and you found a partner that likes to sleep around, fine.

But the I have evolved beyond the quaint social mores of the unenlightened bit is silly.


Yeah, I edited because I realized it could come across more confrontational than I intended.

That being said, it is - whether we like it or not - an observed biological mechanism that humans, like a lot of other species, like to sleep around and that they are attracted to new sexual partners after being with the same one for a long time. [0]

Once we accept that, the question becomes one of management. Do we use our free will to override these urges to fit social norms better or or do we instead trust each other to uncouple the biology from the emotional bond? Different couples might come to different conclusions at different times, but they are both not without risks and both require thoughtful compromise and communication.

The superiority is not towards people in monogamous relationships - that's how ours is structured right now too! It is towards people that use language like "cuck", that implies somebody's worth is defined by their monogamy, language that brings all sorts of weird vibes of male ownership of female bodies and a lessening of men who do not subscribe to such views.

There's nothing wrong with either monogamy or ethical non-monogamy, just do what works for you and your partner and don't be a dick about it!

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coolidge_effect


>Yeah, I edited because I realized it could come across more confrontational than I intended.

I appreciate that.

>Do we use our free will to override these urges to fit social norms bette

I don’t find that argument very convincing. Using free will to override urges is just describing existing in society.

I have the urge to eat everything I see, to sleep with nearly every woman I see, to fight men I disagree with, to kick my dog when he misbehaves, to take things that aren’t mine, to sleep till noon, to cut in line, to drive 100 mph when I’m late, and countless other urges.

The cultural norms that tell us to resist those urges have evolved just like our biological urges. They make civilization possible.

If you could snap your fingers and remove the cultural norms that favor monogamy. All the data we have from societies that don’t have this norm, from studies of dating apps, from other animals says the mostly likely result is that a small percentage of men have a large number of partners. The likely result of that is a much less stable society, which is probably why socially enforced monogamy has become the norm so frequently.


> I have the urge to eat everything I see, to sleep with nearly every woman I see, to fight men I disagree with, to kick my dog when he misbehaves, to take things that aren’t mine, to sleep till noon, to cut in line, to drive 100 mph when I’m late, and countless other urges.

I don't think all of those are the same. I don't think we should be telling you how much to eat or who to sleep with, and I don't think those are comparable to actions that endanger or hurt other humans or animals.

> All the data we have from societies that don’t have this norm, from studies of dating apps, from other animals says the mostly likely result is that a small percentage of men have a large number of partners.

If women were to choose this arrangement out of their own volition, then why shouldn't they be allowed to? If they'd rather be the second partner to an especially appealing man than first partner to some schlub, why should we force them to settle? For the crappy man's sake? How about he work on himself and become better at attracting mates? We already design everything around mediocre dudes, why should society be providing them with women that apparently would rather be with somebody else?

> The likely result of that is a much less stable society

We do all sorts of things that result in a much less stable society. Think of income inequality, racism, gun ownership in the US, lack of mental health support, legal alcohol etc etc. Usually, though, some dudes benefit and so the instability is a price we all must pay. But if it increases the agency of women? Nah, that'd be a bridge too far.


Sorry I don’t buy the argument that a moral framework should be built around allowing for satisfying individual biological urges.

I don't believe that is a fair characterisation. It is built around human agency, particularly female agency, one that has historically been oppressed.

There is new data center project 30 miles outside my city that plans to build a 1000MW natural gas power plant and a 500MW biomass plant that will take millions of acres of forest to sustain (to quite the developer it will burn 350-500 truckloads of logs per day).

If this is an example of the kind of buildout we want to streamline, I say no thanks.


One of the perverse things about our current permitting regime is that it's often easier for a company to build a private natural gas power plant connected to their data center than it is for the local utility to build a new wind or solar farm. The former can often be done without any kind of discretionary permit at all, whereas the latter goes through a public process in which residents can complain and sue to block the project.

And both are much easier than getting permits for a high voltage transmission line to another region of the country where it might make more sense to build a wind or solar farm.


My town just found out about the forest service’s intent to do some major logging and the truck traffic is way out of spec to the existing roads to the trees.

The scale the data centers want to operate at maybe way out of spec. to the existing infrastructure.

https://www.iberkshires.com/story/84456/Town-Residents-Conce...


so from the article, 200 truck trips over 5 years.

we're honestly screwed as a country, funny to see.


This an ancient road when it turns to dirt that’s VT. The Massachusetts is paved but as the town head of DPW is worried about the weight of the trucks. This road happens to not meet the town standards for construction of new development.

The road might see 200 cars a day. The physics for a logging trucks are beyond the roads capabilities. They may come in spurts. There are no stop signs and none are needed.


How manny times does the snow plow go down that road in the same 5yr period? What's the axle group loading for a snow plow? The same federal maximum as the log truck you say?

The prevalence of dirt roads in VT is an intentional policy decision.


The snow plow is seasonal traffic and not nearly as long or heavy as a million trees. The biggest connecting road has a commercial limit of 2.5 tons.

The snow plow as two axles


I have no sympathy for a bunch of retired New Yorkers who wouldn't pony up for some asphalt because it didn't fit the "rustic theme" they envisioned for their state.

Not asking for sympathy asking for money for road usage.

Didn't describe that population at all. EMT, Nurses, college professors, generational farmers, trades people. The main point is why should the town be burdened with the cost. The road satisfies the community needs. Vermont gave up on their side of the road when the commercial roads were developed 3/4 of mile over. The forest service should budget for the impact on the local roads.


>Didn't describe that population at all. EMT, Nurses, college professors, generational farmers, trades people.

Sure sounds like a service economy that feeds upon retirement and tourism money to me....(I know what they look like, I grew up in one)

>The main point is why should the town be burdened with the cost. The road satisfies the community needs. Vermont gave up on their side of the road when the commercial roads were developed 3/4 of mile over. The forest service should budget for the impact on the local roads.

I don't care exactly who winds up holding the bag but when you drive from literally anywhere bordering Vermont into Vermont it's pretty clear what the level of investment in transportation infrastructure is. And this infighting over how some petty amount of truck traffic is gonna destroy a dirt road is exactly what's downhill of that under-investment.


Sounds to me like you are blaming service workers for existing in an economy beyond their control, to justify some in anger.

Biomass is almost certainly a better form of energy production than whatever your existing energy mix is and it is being villanized, nice.

The majority of our power comes from 2 nuclear plants nearby, 8 hydro dams, and renewables. We also have one of the largest pumped storage hydro facilities a few miles away.

A biomass plant harvesting existing timber would only be better if the alternative were building a new coal plant.

This isn’t replacing anything though. We don’t need an extra 1.5GW, so if this project doesn’t go through the alternative will be that we continue moving towards more solar and wind.


Sounds like Tennessee Valley Authority, in which case 50% of your energy mix is fossil fuels and 0% of the biomass plant is fossil fuel and the incremental effect is potentially negative on atmospheric carbon.

It’s 46% and it’s irrelevant if it’s not replacing any existing power generation.

There is more excess data center power demand than there is capability to build plants over the next 10 years, so if this plant isn’t built the likely result is 1 less data center and not releasing carbon from 5.5 million tons of timber per year.


Better how?

More sustainable/co2 neutral/renewable.

Farmed trees are often promoted as being a great fuel, but they do very, very little for enhancing biodiversity.

The UK's largest CO₂ emitter is an ex-coal now-biomass powerplant: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drax_Power_Station


> Farmed trees are often promoted as being a great fuel, but they do very, very little for enhancing biodiversity.

Wind turbines and hydroelectric dams don't do much for enhancing biodiversity either, which is fine because their purpose is to generate electricity.

> The UK's largest CO₂ emitter is an ex-coal now-biomass powerplant

Only by counting burning biomass as emitting new CO2 while not counting the CO2 it removed from the air from being grown.


That only counts if you grow the trees explicitly for power generation. Burning trees that already existed (as is the plan for the plant I mentioned) is like burning coal, which also removed CO2 from the air in the past.

Trees are part of the active carbon cycle. They grow while taking in CO2, then die and rot while releasing it again. Burning them does the same thing as the second one, which was going to happen on its own.

Coal isn't part of the active carbon cycle. It would stay locked in the ground indefinitely if you didn't dig it up.

Moreover, that plant appears to be getting biomass as compressed pellets from sawmill scrap wood and sawdust, i.e. it's the refuse from trees that were already being logged to make lumber. If they didn't burn it then it would go into a landfill to rot and release the carbon anyway.


That’s not the plant I’m referring to plans to do. They’re planning to bring in 350-500 logging trucks per day.

Sure they will get sawmill scraps if they can, but if built this will be by far the largest biomass reactor in the country. When I did the math there’s not enough available scrap in the entire country to power this thing.

They’ve explicitly stated that they need 5.5 million tons of timber from the surround 250 miles of forest annually.

>Burning them does the same thing as the second one, which was going to happen on its own.

Over 50-100 years for short lived species. And much longer for longer lived species.

So yes better than coal but over the lifetime of anyone alive today it’s essentially the same thing, so it’s only really better than coal if you are looking 100 years into the future and if you stop doing cutting down existing trees at some point.


> When I did the math there’s not enough available scrap in the entire country to power this thing.

Which tracks since it's in England and they're getting pellets from the US, Canada and Europe.

> Over 50-100 years for short lived species. And much longer for longer lived species.

But who is logging old growth trees for biomass?

In if someone is cutting down a tree in a first world country it's generally either because the tree was grown intending to cut it down and they immediately start growing new trees there, or because it's going to be cut down regardless of what you do with the tree because they're removing it in order to make some other use of the land.

Moreover, you can always find that one asshat doing something ridiculous, but the world also generates a lot of scrap wood or cuts down a lot of trees just to clear the land. Burning them to generate electricity is never going to be large proportion of world power generation, but doing it to the extent that the trees were just going to rot anyway seems pretty hard to object to.


The plant that I was talking about when starting this thread plans on harvesting 5.5 million tons of timber per year.

That’s not all that much unused wood scrap, so if you’re building a large biomass plant you’re going to end up harvesting timber.

> In if someone is cutting down a tree in a first world country it's generally either because the tree was grown intending to cut it down and they immediately start growing new trees there, or because it's going to be cut down regardless of what you do with the tree because they're removing it in order to make some other use of the land.

In Europe maybe. In the US and Canada it’s very common to harvest timber from naturally grown forests (vs managed plantations) that are being cut primarily for the timber.


> Also, an affair is only blackmail material in a society of prudes.

You don’t have to be a prude to think cheating on a spouse is condemnable.

In general, it also doesn’t really matter what society thinks. You can just threaten to reveal the affair to the spouse. And even in the case the spouse doesn’t really care it’s fodder they can potentially use in a divorce to get a better deal.

One thing worth pointing out is that in this case in addition to the affair with the Chinese spy he was allegedly having an affair with a subordinate, which is always problematic.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: