Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | shmoe's commentslogin

It is odd that Apple doesn't chip in here... they've originated so much decent stuff in the OSS space. Seems like a huge missed opportunity.


Apple are hostile to everything CopyLeft.

Why would they "chip in" here?


Well, they will get more people buying MacBooks, though they won't really use their services.


What makes Apple valuable is precisely its full vertical integration. Nobody else does it at that scale except maybe Sony for consoles and Microsoft but both don't have the same usage coverage and thus integration.

It wouldn't be economically rational for Apple to bring down its own moat.


Apple isn't Sony. They make an arm and a leg on their hardware.

When they switched to x86, it didn't take long for them to release Boot Camp, so they could take Windows users' money, too.


They also make an arm and a leg on services, which is why its not in their interest to make it so you cant use them.


It's not like users will just stop using the services. Rather Linux users will start considering MacBook as a potential laptop to buy.

How could that possibly disrupt their Software/Services infra?


Of course they will. Why would you pay for icloud storage you cant use?


That statement is true for the users that both bought and didn't buy a Macbook (with Linux support). The difference is, the one who bought has paid money for the Macbook.

I am not an Apple user. Do you _have_ to pay for iCloud if you buy the laptop? I don't think so.


Windows dual boot meant millions of potential switchers, if not for anything else, as a list item to tell them "you could still dual boot".

Asahi-on-Mac would bring in irrelevant numbers for a company of Apple's size.


They could also dual boot windows for Arm. Just like before. Assuming Apple did the boot camp thing again


People whom want Linux on Macs obviously already don't want to be put into Apple's ecosystem.


I don't have numbers on that but I bet purchase of brand new MacOS compatible devices is 99% or more from people who already have at least one or more other Apple devices.

Sure they are probably thousands if not millions of (in the positive sense) nerds and geeks posting on HN about buying a Mac first hand, not second hand, solely to put Linux on it but even then would be a drop in the ocean compared to the remained sales.

Still if you have numbers on that I'd love to be wrong about it.


They don't care about people buying MacBooks. They want you in their ecosystem buying i-everything.


Folks are much better supporting Linux and BSD OEMs than buying Apple than then trying to run Linux on their devices.


I do wonder if the margin on Mac isn’t that high vs the price and the services (iCloud etc) make up for that.

Amazon do the same with the fire.


We know that the Mac has fine margins.


From what I can tell from the project team, Apple aren’t being hostile. Just not contributing resource


The decision to not contribute when you have infinite resources is a hostile action on itself.


I would like to have a great laptop running Linux but the hardware options are just not there.

So I end up with a MacBook with macOS. Some may refuse to do that but I expect that's only a tiny missed opportunity.


Can you make 3 examples of things they originated? I'm honestly asking.


WebKit, clang, the llvm backend for arm64


webkit is a fork from KDE, so "initiated" is doing a lot of heavy lifting there.

llvm also existed from before although apple supported the development.

I was curious if apple had actually started any FOSS project.


Swift comes to mind, and this website has more https://opensource.apple.com/projects/ (it lists WebKit, but I guess they count WebKit after it split from KHTML, I’d agree with you there)

Also, Bonjour originated at Apple and it is cross-platform, although Avahi probably is more popular

CUPS is associated with Apple as well, but it seems that it also did not originate there


I was going to say swift, but I figured someone would undercount that because it is so overly relevant as an iOS/Mac development language even though it really is a pretty good portable language. But man... undercounting webkit and clang+llvm is a new level of ignorance..


It is ignorance to call them apple projects when they really aren't. The copyright notice of webkit is full of emails like @kde.org… wonder why it's not entirely @apple.com?


The majority of the advancements done to make the standards compliant browser with great js performance were done at Apple. Going by the copyright notice as the the source of a vast majority of the dev in the 2000s seems pretty special.


They asked about ‘originated’ in particular.


Clang and the arm64 backend did literally originate at Apple. Not sure what you want me to tell you.


That's the first thing I saw in the copyright file

Copyright: 2003-2017 University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.


Do you think it was made at Urbana because it uses the uiuc license? I suppose you think everything that uses the mit license originated in cambridge


Apologies, I focused on LLVM as a whole. You are right about clang (and I didn’t know about the arm64 backend)


Actually the arm64 backend is a grey area. I knew some guys that worked on it in secret at Apple. They definitely created and Developed it at Apple and dropped it on the community after the iPhone 5s launched, replacing the existing aarch64 backend.

I’m not 100% certain if they started with any bits of the previous aarch64 backend or not though.


Last I heard from CUPS they fired the only guy who was working on it?

last thing i found https://mjtsai.com/blog/2025/03/26/apples-dormant-cups/


In both cases you're undercounting apples investment just to make a really dense point on HN.

1) khtml was a really minimal renderer in KDE before apple pumped tens of millions into turning it into the first really modern web2.0 browser, you really can not underestimate the amount of money jobs was willing to pump to make that thing what it became by the time the iphone launched.

2) llvm was essentially apple's bet on a grad student hire and him and his lab's academic project. I knew and worked with several of those former uiuc guys. llvm and clang as we know them today were heavily built at apple.

Also, you are totally (and purposefully probably) misquoting me. I said __clang__ and the __llvm arm64 backend__ were done by apple, and they were almost entirely from scratch from the start at Apple.


I believe the word "originated" has a very precise meaning.


A meaning which seems definitely lost on you for two of my three examples.


Don’t get baited into discussing with a troll (who’s not discussing to gain a shared understanding)


You’re right


Going back a few years, they open source’d their media streaming server, DSS: https://github.com/macosforge/dss


One of my favorites is also ALAC.


Surely this is missing "/s"


Even SC4S, splunk's docker appliance for turnkey syslog uses rsyslogd.

Edit: being pedantic -- it's syslog-ng actually.


And the number of k8s envs that log stdout through them into.... more rsyslog, it's truly everywhere. Plus all the sidecar containers deployed that shuffle app logs, lots of syslog there, its so lightweight and simple and reliable. I watch all the gyrations people go through to achieve the same result, and it's always changing, hurts my brain thinking how much time they waste


I miss the entire WC series... alot. I wish we could get something like that again today.


Chris Roberts is still doing his thing. Elite:Dangerous is still getting updates and there's also Star Citizen/Squadron 42, both of which could either turn out to be epoch-defining or fusterclucks of truly epic proportions.


The latter.


Aggregation. Correlation.


Imagine saying this with a serious face...


He didn't get any spam.. the early, great days of TWiT! RIP.


Was a fairly big fan of his takes until then. RIP. He'll always have a place in computing history.


A very important part of computing media history... and a mixed bag.


Meh, none of that includes the conspiracy bullshit. I liked Jon, but I didn't like where he went in the last decade or so.


Hamachi is what I always bring up when explaining tailscale :P


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: