Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | simplesocieties's commentslogin

Progress is being made on the multiplayer front (Epic games is getting Fortnite to work on Linux) but the issue isn't really a software one, it's a mismatch of goals:

- Linux users don't want companies to spy on them or harvest their data without consent

- Multiplayer game companies don't want cheaters to sabotage the community and cause a collapse in trust and paying customers

This mismatch cannot be solved with software.


Google's work culture is very amoebic. Teams operate like small startups each with their own complete full stack dev and business team that reports metrics back to upper management. You get a lot of innovation from this but a consequence from is that you get these very siloed and competitive teams each rushing to "make a name" for themselves rather than envisioning a product that slots in nicely with the rest of the ecosystem.

And if the LLMs are as powerful as the very same providers claim it will be trivial to write code/configurations that bypass lock in.

Monopolies are a plague on healthy markets.

Everybody has a responsibility to uphold rule of law in any democracy. I'm tired of the narrative that U.S. companies are helpless entities that can only seek profit at the expense of everybody else. Ok then, if it was profitable to wipe out the entire planet with a nuclear war (Vault-tech) would you be fine with a company doing so?

No, that's literally how it works. Companies are amoral and the companies that compete the hardest within the bounds of the law (or outside of it when corruption is allowed) will win over time. They have an advantage and it's why you see most companies are that way. Any of them that did not take those advantages lost.

Universal claims require universal evidence, of which you didn't present.

- Volkswagen didn't win with Dieselgate. ($30b+ in fines).

- BP didn't win with Deepwater Horizon (65x their yearly net income paid in fines and settlements)

- Enron, Theranos, Bernie Madoff, FTX, Fyre Festival, Lehman Brothers, etc.

There is a MASSIVE graveyard of companies that flagrantly broke the law and didn't "Win" over time. Just because you can name a couple of companies that broke the law and still exists today speaks to survivorship bias, not a universal conclusion. Even Silicon Valley Bank, which didn't break laws but played "fast and loose" with customer funds did in fact, not get out ahead of other banks.


> compete the hardest within the bounds of the law (or outside of it when corruption is allowed) will win over time.

You misread I think.


> compete the hardest within the bounds of the law

Silicon Valley Bank. As I already said.

> or outside of it when corruption is allowed

Survivorship bias: You point out one example where corruption was allowed and a company got ahead, I can point out 100 more companies that did not benefit at all from illegal activity.


within the bounds of the law is not illegal sir

Need some universal evidence on that philosophical statement

Whilst I agree with the idea and sentiment, what do you suggest as a mechanism to enforce such responsibility? How do we handle companies that do not act responsibly?

We throw the leadership in jail? They either knew or they were negligent.

If I, personally, were to ignore international trade bans, I'd almost certainly go to prison. We can't send companies to prison, and companies are designed to spread responsibility, so we send the ones who have symbolic responsibility to prison instead, alongside anyone who can be shown to have engaged in individually incriminating behavior. If you're steering the ship, you are responsible for what the ship does and what happens to it.


Change the wording of the law so companies that sacrifice long term value for short term gain can be sued for securities fraud. Make the law so "fiduciary responsibility" means over a long term time horizon. Judges are already making best effort rulings on if they think a company's actions were positive or negative for shareholder value in current security fraud cases, so this change would not add additional subjectivity.

Fines and jail.

Therapy /s

It's not really "Just a narrative", AFAIK it's based on two rulings: 'Dodge v. Ford Motor Co.' and 'eBay Domestic Holdings, Inc. v. Newmark.' One legally enshrined answer to this is Benefit Corporations AKA B Corps. I'm not saying they're without their own flaws but they are a step in the right direction.

If you read dodge v ford, it doesn’t say you must maximize profits but you can’t defraud your investors. The profit maximization myth needs to die and maybe less people will act like they should try it

This is often repeated on HN, but it's a popular myth. [1] Executives have a fiduciary dury to act in the best interests of the company, but "maximize profits" is not something enshrined by law or legal precedent.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2015/04/16/what-are-co...


When I registered my single-member LLC I had to come up with the by-laws and in the template I used it said I "have a fiduciary duty to maximize the benefits to the owners of the company" or something like that. I think that is based on some US Law.

Ever since then I have tried my best to abide by my fiduciary duty to myself. :-)


But it is "just a narrative". Example from this year: Warner Brother's shareholders voted against an excessive pay package for David Zaslov, CEO. For you "corporations have to maximize profits for shareholders" nitwits, that's the shareholders voting against pay package to save the corporation money and add to the profits of the company.

The board gave him his pay package.

Corporations are not always obligated to maximize profits. They just say this to justify unpopular things they do. They ignore it when it reduces the pay of people in the C-suite.

https://deadline.com/2026/06/david-zaslav-2025-pay-rejected-...


This is Adam Smith's invisible hand - not only that self-interest leads to community interest, but that normal people are "forced" to do evil by the logic of the markets.

Getting approval from the Commerce Department seems exactly like upholding the rule of law to me.

If somehow we were stupid enough to make it legal, then yeah, I guess I can't fault the company for blowing us all up. We would deserve it.

We're a nation of laws. Elections matter.


Laws are not sufficient for a society to survive. There have to be shared norms and morals layered on top. If we are a nation only of laws, we are doomed to extinction.

What specific norms and morals do you have in mind? Usually when I hear language like that, someone is handing out religious pamphlets. Society can definitely survive without religious pamphlets.

I was thinking of the John Adams quote. In context, he was saying we couldn't make a set of laws sufficiently detailed to constrain fundamentally selfish or violently angry people into correct behavior without removing all freedom. People have to try to be better than laws force them to be or it doesn't work.

"We have no Government armed with Power capable of contending with human Passions unbridled by morality and Religion. Avarice, Ambition, Revenge or Gallantry, would break the strongest Cords of our Constitution as a Whale goes through a Net. Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious People. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other."

Edit: People like to take that last bit out of context and argue it means the US is only for Christians. That is not my point at all As an analogy, relying ona detailed software development process to produce good software independent of the ability or intent of your team is hopeless. That process would have to be so detailed as to be the software you are trying to produce. You have best practices that aren't binding and some hard red lines to mark things that are clearly never ok.


I don't get this line of thinking. What is the point of profit. Why do we pursue it? And what good is it if the society in which it is useful no longer exists or cannot function to let you benefit from such profit?

There is something really wrong with all these "extrapolate a single part of society to the max because law allows it". Systems don't work this way, every single system requires balance and that balance does not depend on law. Law was created so we could strive to achieve balance in the system. It's imperfect but somehow we think the imperfection is intentional. It's backwards.


> What is the point of profit. Why do we pursue it?

What is the point of income? Why do you demand it? Why don't you just come work for me for free?


>We're a nation of laws

It's the people who protect the law, not the law that protects the people. If your entire country consists of sniveling profiteers who use laws as an excuse to abdicate their own judgement you don't have a nation and you don't have laws.

The company can do it because the law said so, the CEO can do it because the company said so I can do so because someone else said to etc. Responsibility isn't a game of musical chairs


>Elections matter.

The last thirty years is proof that it doesn't. At least at a policy level. It does matter for containing discontent.


I cannot condone this blithe abdication of responsibility. Even agreeing with xenocide?! I hope you wouldn’t be pushing the button when it actually came time to launch.

You conveniently left out the “done legally” part

> requiring location verification for advanced AI chips

Does.... does anyone in Congress even bother to consult with tech experts anymore? Once the chip is in your competitors hands it's over. No amount of tracking/verification etc. will stop it.

> “If you can use a private key that exists on a particular chip, and you can sign a message with that cryptographic key, and then that message is received by a so-called landmark server, then you can send a couple of those messages and time those messages. A lot of modern chips come with trusted execution environments that support a hardware root of trust where you can sign these messages,” says Kristian Rönn, CEO and cofounder of Lucid Computing. “You get a radius of where the chip has to be.”

This is such a stupid idea. Whoever owns the network can just throttle these messages to be extremely slow, throwing off the data completely, or just not giving the cards network access at all. Just because you throw in "public-private key cryptography", "hardware root of trust", and "trusted execution environment" into your proposal doesn't make it sound.


In the case where the network is throttling the messages or not allowing network access at all, the chip's firmware can simply refuse to activate the chip.

Now, that's not to say that this can't be gamed at all. The HFT people know very well that free space radio links are faster than fiber. You could easily just make the datacenter operators put a starlink dish on the roof though, and you can't beat the speed of light.

Now there could be ambiguous situations, such as a country where their only internet connection comes through a banned country. In that case, again, force them to put a starlink on the roof.

You can also require random on-site inspections. In order to have 10,000 GPUs in a datacenter, you'd have to declare them to the government. Not only would they have to report their position regularly, but when the inspectors showed up where they were declared to be, the inspectors would have to find them there. If they didn't, the control organization would just deactivate them. There would be some phone home interval grace period, maybe a day or two, and after that, the GPUs would just stop working until they were re-verified.


> In the case where the network is throttling the messages or not allowing network access at all, the chip's firmware can simply refuse to activate the chip.

A dumb pinging chip has 0 ways to detect network throttling. Especially when it doesn't have admin rights to said network. Also MANY use cases for these GPUs require air-gapped environments to meet compliance requirements. This wouldn't work.

> You can also require random on-site inspections. In order to have 10,000 GPUs in a datacenter, you'd have to declare them to the government.

....So the companies in Shenzhen and Guangzhou need to declare them to the U.S. government or the Chinese government? Who's gonna deactivate them then? The issue being discussed in the article has nothing to do with companies that are within U.S. jurisdiction, it's about companies/individuals outside U.S. jurisdiction.


You can use the network sort of like a GPS. If you have two nodes that can ping each other in a certain time, you multiply that by the speed of light (in the appropriate medium), and that gives you an upper bound on the distance between those nodes. You can draw circles around each beacon node and where they intersect is the possible region that the chip could be living.

If packets are being consistently delayed, the circles get big and the possible region that the chip could be in gets big. If the chip can get a few fast pings in here and there it still works ok though.

It may not be possible to provide chips like this to a truly airgapped datacenter. You could have some special piece of hardware that proxies only the pings, but that is not a true airgap.

The companies in Shenzen and Guangzhou would declare with the U.S. government, or some international organization. Obviously the Chinese government doesn't have to let inspectors into their country, but if they don't, when the GPU goes to get it's cryptographic unlock code for the day, it's not going to arrive and the GPU won't work.


> You can use the network sort of like a GPS. If you have two nodes that can ping each other in a certain time, you multiply that by the speed of light (in the appropriate medium), and that gives you an upper bound on the distance between those nodes. You can draw circles around each beacon node and where they intersect is the possible region that the chip could be living.

You are again assuming good faith actors. How is it going to work when you have a datacenter buried 300m underground surrounded with concrete? How will the signal leave? Better yet, how will you guarantee these GPS chips will stay on the GPU at all? Anyone with a soldering iron and enough know-how will be able to remove them.

> The companies in Shenzen and Guangzhou would declare with the U.S. government,

That's the problem. They won't. Many companies are now moving even their manufacturing out of China not only because of rising labour costs, but getting a judge to fairly arbitrate a dispute is impossible, let alone brokering a "pinky promise" with sensitive technology.

> Obviously the Chinese government doesn't have to let inspectors into their country, but if they don't, when the GPU goes to get it's cryptographic unlock code for the day, it's not going to arrive and the GPU won't work.

I highly recommend reading about CUDA, and how GPUs work then re-evaluate this idea. The issue at hand isn't just that NVIDIA chips are being obtained for use in inference and training, but when you obtain them at 20% supply scale you can unveil manufacturing patterns, secrets etc. that wouldn't be noticeable with only 1 or 2 chips.


You're missing the point. GPS measures distance by seeing how long radio waves take to go from a set of satellites to a receiver. You can do something similar with network packets and timing how long they take to arrive from a set of hosts on the network. If the datacenter is buried under 300m of concrete, then you need a 300m fiber that connects to the internet.

There wouldn't be separate "GPS chips." The ping checking and requirement for a cryptographic unlock code would be part of the GPU die. Of course nothing like this can be completely foolproof but you can make it hard. A soldering iron certainly is not going to help.

I wrote my first CUDA kernel 19 years ago, so I'm familiar. I'm not sure what you mean by the last sentence though.


People (rightly so) complain about the wastefulness of datacenters and AI mostly due to the pollution, and "projects" like this one not only do not justify that pollution, but worsen it.

We have GPUI, we have web components, we have Clay UI. No one needs another C UI library.


> No one needs another C UI library.

Well, actually they do, but the LLM wouldn't know why. You gotta have used all these to figure it out, and then spend months wondering upon a better design, researching old experiments by random people in archived repos for inspiration. LLMs are useful only for that last part, quickly comprehending a strange repo you found from 15 years ago.


SO’s demise was two conflicting user bases who wanted mutually exclusive things: the questioners a space to learn and grow without judgement, and the point collectors a glorified FAQ for programming and social media network.

The operators of the platform never grappled with the reality that these two users want opposing things, and LLMs were just the final nail in the coffin.


You’re right, if not for the countless innovations and designs NASA made SpaceX wouldn’t exist, therefore it owes its profits back to the taxpayers that funded its success.



I think at this point it was established that Epstein thought Elon is too lame and awkward to take him to the island


“Local pedo didn’t get an invite to his favorite pedo club, therefore he can’t possibly be a pedo.”


You've 0 proof


Plenty of proof. I just provided 1 proof.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: