yeah, but you and i can't do much about what some institution is doing on a daily basis. we can, however, do a lot more about what we're doing on a daily basis -- i.e. not engaging with or spreading speculative bullshit / FUD.
there's enough bullshit for people to deal with in the world. why add to it?
How do syntax errors dissuade you from the proposal? Is not design separate from implementation? Is it not true that a well-designed specification, proposal, etc. can be poorly implemented?
If you got a job offer that was riddled with spelling mistakes and had the wrong name, would that inspire confidence in your future place of work? It's not a huge stretch of the imagination that small, obvious issues could mean larger, more complex issues lurking.
I'd say "riddled with spelling mistakes" is a bit strong in our example (I realise you weren't claiming that about the site).
I got it out early to get some feedback. The 404 spec link is a bad one (since fixed) but the typo in the DNS record is forgivable I think – very impressed anyone spotted that.
Why not set this up yourself in a virtual lab and demonstrate the scenarios you just listed? Put two victim hosts on the network, and then with a third attacker host,
perform your MITM attack.
Thanks for suggestion! I did do several fire drills in the past, where I would change keys and wait for people to reach out. At the beginning of the semester, almost nobody would; by the end, over 80 % of the class would reach out prior to connecting to our shared infrastructure. But I thought that having a real-world smoking gun would be even better motivation to think about it. Sort of "don't be this poor guy" kind of thing. I've also been thinking about actually MitM-ing them myself, and probably will, but I am not sure how far I want to go :).
Not a good comparison, imo. Being a chess player isn’t a 9-to-5 value-creating profession that e.g. being a 3D animator is. Ai will be to white collar jobs what automation was for blue collar jobs.