I can cope short-medium term on minimum spending etc, medium-long if I do something basic - I was thinking of doing something more physical like you mentioned, network installing (cabling etc) which I quite like doing but don't do it often. I know I couldn't get enough work to compete against what I get now, but maybe its enough.
The problem with "cloud computing" it doesn't break enough for people to care, so contracting work has been killed off by this. Probably costs more long term as well for the small business, small long term hidden costs etc.
This might feel a bit gross, but hear me out. AI is going to drive a lot of consolidation, but it's also going to help facilitate starting a ton of new businesses. It's clear big companies are going to need less help maintaining their automations so fewer jobs for people who do that. But there are tons of situations where more automations were always desirable but never economically feasible.
Imagine knowing that there's a product that could bring in $500k/year but would take 2 people 3 years to make it, well, it was always going to be a chicken-and-egg problem. Now it might be possible for 1 person and several GPUs / high subscriptions to build that business in 6mo.
It's scary for sure to try and make something from scratch. But I think actually owning some kind of small business is going to be the best defense against getting laid off from a big company. People in tech for sure have challenges as they're really good at doing the thing vs seeing how the thing is used, but it's absolutely possible to learn the more product-management-ey and business-ey skills.
Using AI to work on my own, to escape AI and working on my own due to remote working, doesn't feel like a solution I can work. If “just use AI” was viable for my mindset then I'd stay where I am in a safe salaried job rather than a more risky start-up, and use AI here.
> … to build that business in [time]…
One of the things I know that I am not cut out to be, is a businessman. I would not want to work for a start-up run by me!
> but it's absolutely possible to learn the more product-management-ey and business-ey skills
Again, if I'm going to learn skills that I would really rather not learn, then getting behind AI and staying here would be the safer option.
> This might feel a bit gross
Yup!
I do see your point, but it is not a solution that I think could work for me.
To me the best parallel I can think of is the industrial revolution. The best (economic) position to be in during that time was to somehow figure out a way to be involved in steam engines. Building or maintaining them, putting one to work in your business, finding a business that you could change with one, etc. Some people chose not to and that's fine, but a lot of basic assumptions about the way people lived got turned on their head whether they liked it or not. People didn't effectively boycott the steam engine even if there were some short periods of success with the Luddites. It's easy for us to be completely dispassionate about this from 200 years in the future.
I think the same flavor of advice holds today. It's totally fine to not like it or not want to participate in it, maybe even boycott it. But you're signing up for a more difficult life. It might well be more rewarding too, we won't know for a long time.
You'll probably need to find an Amish or Amish-like community to join or start your own. It takes enormous money to get into commercial farming but artisinal market gardening is an option with as little as 1/2 acre. You'll want to go as far down the value chain as possible because then even if AI ends up being deployed somehow into a domain you're in, you're at least going to be able to sustain yourself with your own labor. Homesteading is a good way to think about it. Work to minimize what you need from "the grid" in terms of energy, food, etc. One good generic metric is how much you have to spend in a month/year tells you how dependent you are on society. Buying solar panels can help both literally and figuratively. Having a really well insulated home. Getting a very efficient EV you can charge from your solar panels, but even better if you can bike or at least use an e-bike. If you can drive your monthly expenses below $1k it's relatively easy to sustain yourself with low leverage work. You might want to consider moving to somewhere less expensive where you can have more land (for food, solar, water, etc), and lower payments / own it outright.
Obviously I can't tell you that the future will play out the way I'm describing here. This is just my best guess. I have been thinking about it for a while after I was asked a question by a friend "how will all this play out?" months ago. History tells us how people are likely to deploy an invention across society, not because the society is the same but because human nature is.
The industrial revolution wasn't based upon, to quote Brent Hecht, a Director of Applied Science at Microsoft, “the greatest theft of labor in human history”.
> The best (economic) position to be in during that time was
I'm not looking for an economic solution, I know drinking from the well and staying where I am is the best option for me financially, but only until the point it gets too much, and I jump off a bridge. I can't take those extra financial resources with me.
> But you're signing up for a more difficult life.
I'm well aware of that, as I think I've said plainly above for a time at least, maybe for the foreseeable future, I'll probably be earning about half per hour than my current salary roughly equates to (pre-tax, it is a touch better when you factor in where tax bands fall) and will have fewer other benefits (the most important of which is probably what the current company contributes towards my pension pot).
One extra thing that you don't seem to be considering at all is that the need for developers, like designers and a number of other jobs, has a good chance of falling considerably. That will either put a lot out of work, or reduce the salaries over time as supply/demand rebalances, or both. This in the medium/long term may change that “about half” ratio somewhat. Even as AI costs rise (as I expect them to when those providing all that investment capital start wanting to see returns) choices between how much to invest in people and how much to invest in token chewing may often not go the way people want.
> It might well be more rewarding too, we won't know for a long time.
I'm not looking for rewarding. I'm looking for “my mental health will improve, or at least decline less rapidly”. AI is only one of my issues with dev work these days, again as mentioned above, and if any one of them (or my attitude to it) changes significantly the others will still be issues.
WRT “we won't know for a long time” - are you suggesting that while we don't know either way, we should all go one way instead of the other?
> Amish or Amish-like community
That is going off at the deep end… There is a vast difference between not directly using it myself and not touching anything that it has ever touched.
Hey man, do whatever you want! I'm just some guy giving out free analysis of how the world is on the internet.
> The industrial revolution wasn't based upon, to quote Brent Hecht, a Director of Applied Science at Microsoft, “the greatest theft of labor in human history”.
It's probably true but I suspect we're past the point of putting the genie back in the bottle. People are free to try though! I don't love it myself, but I don't see an overwhelming enough majority of people against it.
> One extra thing that you don't seem to be considering at all is that the need for developers, like designers and a number of other jobs, has a good chance of falling considerably.
I hear what you're saying here, and that's part of the reason I argue for going as far down the value chain as possible. If you own land and can do some farming to feed yourself and generate your own power with solar and don't need to buy much fuel then you're not immune to the wider economy, but you're pretty well insulated from it. If you could survive for 3mo without a salary that's great but you're still pretty fragile to a temporary disruption. But if you could survive 3 years without a salary? Now you have some real breathing space.
> WRT “we won't know for a long time” - are you suggesting that while we don't know either way, we should all go one way instead of the other?
Not even close, I'm just saying that when a big societal change happens it takes society a long time to digest it and for a new kind of order to emerge.
200 years on from the steam engine and 100 years on from electrification and 90% or more of the people in the developed world have opted-in to that system. Enough so that we have words for those who didn't because they're so different. Is that good or bad? It's kind of irrelevant for the discussion. What matters is if you think the impact will be as big. If so, you need to think big thoughts about how it plays out. If not? You just make some minor tactical adjustments and get on with life.
> That is going off at the deep end… There is a vast difference between not directly using it myself and not touching anything that it has ever touched.
How do you plan to accurately predict how far the deployment will go and how you will avoid it? This isn't a "gotcha" question, I'm honestly looking for answers myself. Manual labor will avoid immediate encroachment for sure, but people are working on robots too, of all shapes and sizes. I'm struggling to think of some industry that I can confidently predict will be largely immune to automation.
I suppose the unionized trades will probably fend automation off for a while because the environments are so dynamic. A plumber or electrician won't immediately become obsolete as not every detail of every house in the world is mapped and the cost of doing so isn't obviously amortizable. But even there as the costs of mapping go down so do the moats shrink. Would some company give away below-cost robot lawn mowing service to get better data? It's possible.
I'd love to hear your thoughts on the industries that seem less vulnerable to AI-ification.
Our school gets them to hand them in and pick them up at the end of the day. We appreciate contact later on as plans change, buses are late, its kind of rural.
(these are secondary+ kids though).
What is the main problem, is the schools depending on access to phones (and computers in part) to do their homework. I don't mind a PC/Laptop if they provide the account - but what we're hitting on is the requirement for MFA, and with MS this means you're stuck with their "Authenticator", which hard requires GSF, which requires a google account to download (I know I can get around some of these). Google accounts require a phone number... etc etc. Terrible, ive refused - we get homework on paper, and books to actually read.
Not all, but so many do. We eat meat, work on brain rotting tech, pollute the environment, use way too much fossil energy, manufacture need for useless crap.
In comparison, cheating a VC out of a couple million is mild.
Yes, many do. But whether you do it, is your choice.
Claiming there isn't one and you have to do it for survival, sounds just like coping mechanism for a choice to get rich, no matter what.
Also no one has to work on brain rotting tech. They might have to, if they want to sustain their standard of living - but not for survival. And they made a choice at some point in their life to go for that money and not choose something else.
As for meat for instance, also that is a choice. I choose to eat meat and have no moral problems with it - if the meat had a life as an animal outside before and was not just a object in a meat factory.
Vendor lock in is always a thing really, you don't always get choice in SaaS providers and how they auth. Could of course choose another SaaS provider but then that starts reducing the pool, assuming you have alternatives.
Not sure what to do next.
I can cope short-medium term on minimum spending etc, medium-long if I do something basic - I was thinking of doing something more physical like you mentioned, network installing (cabling etc) which I quite like doing but don't do it often. I know I couldn't get enough work to compete against what I get now, but maybe its enough.
The problem with "cloud computing" it doesn't break enough for people to care, so contracting work has been killed off by this. Probably costs more long term as well for the small business, small long term hidden costs etc.
reply